raid 5 for media storage questions

wagsrules

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 18, 2006
Messages
1,063
Hey guys. I am helping my brother set up a raid for his media files. He currently has 2 1tb drives. One is about full and the second is half full. He wants to do a raid 5 and start with 3 drives so he would get another 1 tb drive. I don't know alot about raid 5 and don't know if it is the best option or not. I know with raid 5 you loose the storage capacity of 1 of the drives. He wants to use the onboard amd raid. This computer will be used for storage and media playback on his tv.

If he goes with raid 5, can we set up the raid without formating the drives? Or would they have to be wiped? Or would raid 1 be a better option? Also, can you add additional drives to a raid 5 without having to rebuild it?

Basically he wants the best setup to protect all of videos without spending a alot of money.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
 
I would instead get a 2TB WDC green for $119 (internal or external for $10 more) and backup the other two drives. A 3 drive raid5 is not good for performance and also raid is not a backup. It only prevents data loss due to a hard drive failure. It does not prevent accidental deletion, file system corruption, virus wiping out all files...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136514&cm_re=2TB-_-22-136-514-_-Product

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136471&cm_re=2TB-_-22-136-471-_-Product
 
Last edited:
No you cannot set up the RAID without formatting the drives. They will be wiped. No you cannot add drives to a RAID 5 array without having to rebuild it.

Also, it is not a good idea to use the onboard raid controller as it'll greatly impact the performance of the PC. Especially if your bro is using Windows.

As drescherjm said, RAID is not backup or protection. It just guarantees uptime. It doesn't protect against accidental or malicious deletion, corruption, infection, modification, misplacement, etc of files. RAID 5 and RAID 1 only gurantees uptime in the event of a single hard drive failure. Thats it.

So if your bro is looking for BACKUP or protection of files, his best bet would be the following:
- External hard drive with a copy of all the critical data
- NAS
- File server

And no adding a 3rd drive to the PC itself and keeping a copy of the data there is not backup since it's still vulnerable to all of the factors/actions mentioned above. A backup is seperate from the PC itself and only connects to the PC when necessary.
 
Thanks. That answered the questions I had about raid 5. I kind of figured that the onboard raid controller was not the way to go. He just wants to use raid 5 so that his data will not be lost with a harddrive failure. I understand about backup and all that. You guys were very helpful.
 
Just note: if you got an Intel ICHxR RAID controller, you can do most of the stuff you want.

You can have a single disk with Windows, and transform that single disk to a RAID0 array or RAID5 array while keeping all data that was on the original disk. Intel controller can also migrate from level 0 to level 5 or other, and do other things generally reserved to hardware RAID.

If you enable write-back, the RAID5 write speeds are actually quite decent (70MB/s; single disk performance) - a lot better than 5 - 10MB/s speeds from most other onboard RAID5 vendors. Know that write-back could put the filesystem in jeopardy, so if you go this route a GOOD backup becomes mandatory. But i wouldn't discount this option; as it provides a lot of flexibility and might come for free if you motherboard has the ICHxR southbridge.
 
wagsrules

Take a look at DATOptic SPM393 hardware raid5 controller - driver-less raid controller

I bough one just to try it out - What a surprise, it takes about 45sec to built 8TB RAID5 (5x 2.0TB) and so easy to use, and move data about 235MB/sec

- Connect to SATA port onboard
- Turn on system
- 8.0TB is there
- It even offer email notification, SMART...

But one thing this controller wont do - on line expansion, meaning you start out as 3x drives and then add more drives to it later and expand the existing volume

Well, I hope DATOptic will change the firmware and implement that function later, that would be fantastic.
I'm thinking about write a test report of this raid controller, if there is a requested

Otherwise look at these raid controller:

High Point Tech:
- 2300 series for hardware assist raid controller
- 2600 series for full hardware raid
Search in newegg.com with Areca search term

****
 
Last edited:
Back
Top