I realize this question has been beaten to death and then some, but...
I have an E8400, P5Q Pro, and Antec 300 (all I think you need for HSF rec.) and I'm looking at these three HSF, Xigmatek S-1283, Zerotherm NV120, and Noctua NH-U12P. First question, is the xigmatek's fan worth using? I see a lot of people have it replaced, but is it because they are noisy or don't move air, or both? If I have to replace the fan, the xigmatek will cost about the same as the Noctua (including the mounting bracket), so I think I would rather have that. The NV120 would be cheaper than both though (assuming I have to buy a nice fan for s-1283). [H]ardOCP seemed to show it performed almost as good as the NH-U12F, but I don't see a lot of people using it. Any reason why? Thanks.
I have an E8400, P5Q Pro, and Antec 300 (all I think you need for HSF rec.) and I'm looking at these three HSF, Xigmatek S-1283, Zerotherm NV120, and Noctua NH-U12P. First question, is the xigmatek's fan worth using? I see a lot of people have it replaced, but is it because they are noisy or don't move air, or both? If I have to replace the fan, the xigmatek will cost about the same as the Noctua (including the mounting bracket), so I think I would rather have that. The NV120 would be cheaper than both though (assuming I have to buy a nice fan for s-1283). [H]ardOCP seemed to show it performed almost as good as the NH-U12F, but I don't see a lot of people using it. Any reason why? Thanks.