Questions regarding laptop purchase

runev

n00b
Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Messages
26
Hi,

Yesterday my faithful HP DV2222EA took it's last breath when i tried to boot it up at school. The motherboard is fried and my insurance ran out 4 days ago. So I've been using quite some time trying to find a new notebook to buy. Primarily I'll be using
it in my studies, which these days involves hours at end using both Eclipse, Visual Studio and Adobe Photoshop. Gaming is cool, but I've got my 360 and PS3 for that.

What I am looking for however is a powerful budget PC of sorts which price shouldn't exceed far beyond USD $1650 (EUR 1250). Prices here in Norway seem to be quite a bit higher that in for example the US, so I'll have to take that into consideration. Size and maximum supported resolution is two of my primary concerns; the computer should be from 15.4" to 16.4" in size and support a minimum of WXGA+ (1440x900). And yeah, battery life time isn't that important since I'll pretty much always have the power connected.

So here's the deal. The HP HDX16-1000EO costs about 1650 USD in Norway incl. VAT. This seems, to me atleast, to be a reasonable price and plenty of fun specification for the money you're spending, atleast compare to some of the alternatives. It the WUXGA+ display that first got my attention, since playing around in 1080p on a laptop must be amazing when you're used to a 14.1" with a WXGA (1280x860) display. I'm also used to 2GB of RAM which Vista seems to eat up quite fast, thus 4GB+ is what I'm looking for. Storage space isn't that important, as I've got several external drives laying around if I need them.



So, the questions;

1. How is Windows 7 on memory support? I know all about Vista 32bit's >4GB issues, but I'm not up to date on how this works in Windows 7. Will it work the same way with both a 32bit and 64bit version, which inherit the
memory issues from Vista 32bit? I'm curious since the laptop I'm currently considering supports a maximum of 8GB.

2. A follow up question from question 1. The HDX16 comes with a Intel Core 2 Duo P8400 2.26 GHz CPU and supports up to 8GB of RAM. It also ships with a 64bit version of Vista. Is this only to support the whole 8GB of possible
memory? I thought a Core 2 Duo CPU was 32bit, so am I wrong or right? However checking intel.com i saw that it 'supports Intel® EM64T', what ever that might mean. Could use some clarification here.

3. Is there any site where it's easy to dig up benchmarking results on notebook and laptops as a unit, and not just its components (which seems to be the only option at for example Futuremark's site)?

4. The HDX16 comes with a 5400 RPM drive. Slow. How do you think installing a new WD 7200 RPM drive would affect both performance and heat development. Just trying to find out if it's worth the extra USD $120 such a drive costs.

5. The NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT. I'm just curious, but would it be correct to say that the GT edition is the little brother of the GS edition?




If you disagree strongly with me in my prefered choice so far, the HP HDX16 that is, then please suggest other laptops for me. Just try to keep it below 1650 USD, and remember that the price I'll have to pay for a CPU advertised on newegg.com has 25% added to it's price. Anyway, here's a few others I've dug up which are within my budget;

  • Asus G50VT, Intel Core 2 DUO P8400 2.26 GHz, 4GB RAM (8GB Max), NVIDIA GeForce 9800M GS GDDR3 512 MB, 15.4" WSXGA+ (1680x1050)
  • Asus V1V, Intel Core 2 Duo P8400 1.8 GHz, 2 GB RAM (4GB Max), ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3650 512 MB, 15.4" WXGA+ (1440x900)
  • Asus B50A, Intel Core 2 DUO T5850 2.16GHz, 4GB RAM (8GB Max), Intel GMA X4500HD, 15.4" WXGA+ (1440x900)
  • Lenovo ThinkPad R500, Intel Core 2 Duo P8400 2.26 GHz, 2GB RAM (4GB Max), ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3470 128MB, 15.4" WSXGA+ (1690x1050)

Wow, that evolved to quite the wall of text. If you read it all, then thank you!

Thanks in advance for any help and advice :)
 
Last edited:
5. The NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT. I'm just curious, but would it be correct to say that the GT edition is the little brother of the GS edition?
it's worse than the 9500 GT 128bit.

The G50VT makes the most sense, and there is no need for 8GB RAM
 
Seems i miscalculated the price of the G50VT as $2210 is the cheapest i can get it for when buying online. That's $500 over my budget, though I'll see if i can dig up some more cash. Only bad thing is that i feel I'm paying quite a lot for a gaming intensive laptop which will hardly ever be used for gaming.
 
I thought a Core 2 Duo CPU was 32bit, so am I wrong or right

You can run 64 bit OS on pretty much all C2D CPU's as far as I'm aware. EM64T means that the CPU can be used with 64bit OS's.

Have your heard of Sager notebooks? I own one and they make arguably the best notebooks as far as price to performance ratio is concerned. They always incorporate the best hardware in their products but costing about 1/4 less then the more known manufacturers such as alienware or dell. They aren't as pretty (I guess if you care about style over function, you can always get a MAC), but performance to price wise, Sagers are hard to beat.

I just configured a 15.4" Sager 8662 Notebook and here are the main specs:

- WUXGA (1920x1200) Ultra Bright Matte LCD
- Core 2 Duo 2.40 GHz (P8600) - 1066MHz FSB
- 2 x 2GB (4GB) DDR3 1066MHz RAM
- 250GB HDD 7200 RPM (16MB Cache Buffer)
- nVidia GTX 260M 1GB DDR3 Memory
- Windows Vista 64 Home Premium
- 3 year warranty

With these specs the total came out to about $1730 before shipping. You can save about $50 off this price if you use Paypal e-check.

Check out the link below to find out more about this notebook. I've purchased my Sager notebook from them and they are legit.

http://www.pctorque.com/sager-8662-gaming-computers.php
 
Actually the Sager notebooks are not that ugly, but it seems no shops in Norway sells that brand. At least nothing i can find when looking around and googling.

Does anyone know what CPU comes with the G50VT-AK020K model? I'm weighing in more and more against this notebook, even though its a bit pricey. Every product specification I've found only details the CPU as;

Intel® Core™2 Duo Processor T9600/T9400/P8600/P8400/P7350 : 2.8 GHz - 2.0 GHz, 1066MHz, 6/3MB On-Die L2 Cache (Intel Centrino 2)

This doesn't help much though, as in my eyes this means i can get any of 5 CPUs when it arrives. Tried to google the model and check asus.com, with no luck.

Anyone know?
 
1. How is Windows 7 on memory support? I know all about Vista 32bit's >4GB issues, but I'm not up to date on how this works in Windows 7. Will it work the same way with both a 32bit and 64bit version, which inherit the memory issues from Vista 32bit? I'm curious since the laptop I'm currently considering supports a maximum of 8GB.
I'm asssuming that you're talking about the installation issue that Vista Pre Sp1 had right? That problem was fixed with Vista SP1 and no issue of that sort has shown up with Windows 7. As an anecdotal evidence, I've installed Windows 7 Beta with four sticks of RAM without any problem.

2. A follow up question from question 1. The HDX16 comes with a Intel Core 2 Duo P8400 2.26 GHz CPU and supports up to 8GB of RAM. It also ships with a 64bit version of Vista. Is this only to support the whole 8GB of possible memory? I thought a Core 2 Duo CPU was 32bit, so am I wrong or right? However checking intel.com i saw that it 'supports Intel® EM64T', what ever that might mean. Could use some clarification here.
Yes you need a 64bit OS to be able fully use all 8GB of RAM. And yes the C2D CPUs (mobile or desktop) are 64bit capable.

3. Is there any site where it's easy to dig up benchmarking results on notebook and laptops as a unit, and not just its components (which seems to be the only option at for example Futuremark's site)?
Hit up www.notebookreview.com
4. The HDX16 comes with a 5400 RPM drive. Slow. How do you think installing a new WD 7200 RPM drive would affect both performance and heat development. Just trying to find out if it's worth the extra USD $120 such a drive costs.
While the 7200RPM drive would run a bit more hotter and drain the battery life a bit more, the 7200RPM drive is totally worth it those costs.
 
Back
Top