questions about new hard drives

modulus

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 20, 2010
Messages
360
So I recently picked up a couple 1TB seagate 7200rpm drives. I'm definitely a novice so bear with me. I did some tests to make sure they were good and have a few questions.

My first question is about SMART data that drives provide. My read error rate and seek error rate for both drives makes me think something is up. After spending time searching for stuff online about it I read lots of "anything non 0 means its bad and return it" and i read some "numbers are reported differently for different manufacturers so as long as the SMART data doesn't say it's failing its fine. I ran some badblocks read/write tests with 4 passes on each drive and found 0 bad blocks on either drive. Also, I managed to produce a graph of the drives' read/write performance, but I have no idea what they mean or what normal numbers are.

sdbSMART.png

Hard drive 1 SMART data


sdbbenchmark.png

Hard drive 1 Benchmark data


sdcSMART.png

Hard drive 2 SMART data


sdcbenchmark.png

Hard drive 2 Benchmark data


So how does this all look? Do I need to be concerned? Should I return these drives? Thanks for the help
 
Anyone got anything? Is there another thread that would be better for this?
 
Quickest way, is the ReallocatedSectorCount "value == 0" Value can
be LOW and the drive okay UNLESS it increases more than a certain
amount weekly, but greater than 0 and you do not want unbacked up
data on it at all.
 
Numbers will vary between manufacturers, or even firmwares. I see the smart data as historical data, if they change little over the months, then one day see a spike in a value, it might cause concern, but your benchmarks look fine.

Most manufactures offer free tools to test drives, although most will be windows apps. If you need to send a drive in for RMA, they don't care about smart data, they care about their own scan tools.
 
196-201 are listed as N/A so i'm guessing maybe these drives don't report them?

These images are just from the default disk utility the comes standard with ubuntu.

Thank you everyone for your help. I think I will monitor the levels over time and as long as they're stable I think I should be fine. Thanks.
 
Maybe I am crazy, but I buy a new hard drive, I format it. Copy shit to it, and back that up to another drive.

If something happens, I get it rma'd and slap in the replacement drive, format and copy data back from a backup.

I am not so sure I would want to spend that much time analyzing all of that that the OP pasted. I mean holy shit..
:confused:
 
Maybe I am crazy, but I buy a new hard drive, I format it. Copy shit to it, and back that up to another drive.

If something happens, I get it rma'd and slap in the replacement drive, format and copy data back from a backup.

I am not so sure I would want to spend that much time analyzing all of that that the OP pasted. I mean holy shit..
:confused:

That's what I do, and the only reason it sucks is because I always have to buy my drives in pairs out of paranoia. I have too much to lose to trust my data to a single point of failure.

Nothing wrong with doing a quick check, though. I check the S.M.A.R.T. status every now and then just for peace of mind, even though I have everything backed up and I know a failure could potentially happen at any time.
 
Back
Top