Psystar Countersues Apple on Antitrust Grounds

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Mac clone maker Psystar officially responded to Apple's copyright infringement lawsuit by countersuing for anticompetitive business practices. Say what you will about these guys, they may not be very smart but they got balls.

As expected, the 54-page complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, charges Apple with restraint of trade, unfair competition, and other violations of antitrust law. Miami-based Psystar, owned by Rudy Pedraza, requests that the court find Apple's end-user license agreements (EULA) void and seeks unspecified compensatory and punitive damages.
 
I seriously hope this doesn't succeed.

Purely because I don't want Apple to even have a remote chance of breaking out of the niche market and becoming the new Microsoft. Not with the iPhone NDA, apps store, itunes DRM, ipods locked into itunes, and plenty of other practices that I just plain don't like.
 
Interesting how the tables are turning. These guys have big balls, but I hope they get it right.
 
I seriously hope this doesn't succeed.

Purely because I don't want Apple to even have a remote chance of breaking out of the niche market and becoming the new Microsoft. Not with the iPhone NDA, apps store, itunes DRM, ipods locked into itunes, and plenty of other practices that I just plain don't like.

Would never happen. Apple as a company has no chance of having an OS that works on ANY hardware without issues. If they were forced by the courts to make their OS available on all machines and not just apple hardware the world would be full of people complaining about the latest "Blow Leopard" not working on their $299 dell desktop and how much Apple sucks. If MS only had to support software that they had manufactured themselves or one video card model instead of ANY video card model their OS would probably be a lot more stable in most people's perspective. I realize it's a flawed view for a person to take but that's how people look at it.
 
This won't take long...

A little upstart, with probably minimal resources, going up against a company with some 8 billion in the bank and a fleet of 100 attorneys.

The term "I think I can I think I can I think I can I think I can" ain't gonna work here fella's :)
 
My instinct for wanting to underdog to win is saying yes. My instict that is responsible for my hate of all things Apple says yes. My instinct that doesnt like companies like phystar says no.

2 to 1. I will do a dance if they win.
 
Does anyone else get a niggly feeling that this was Psystar's actual goal from the start? They certainly must have expected Apple to sue them, and maybe an antitrust lawsuit has a little more to stand on as a counter-suit than right out of the blue?
 
Ha ha */Nelson*

I'm pretty sure I called that when they first sued PsyStar (I'd have to go back to look at those comments for that news article).

Apple is very anti-competitive and it's about time they got taken down a notch much like Microsoft was years ago.
 
Does anyone else get a niggly feeling that this was Psystar's actual goal from the start? They certainly must have expected Apple to sue them, and maybe an antitrust lawsuit has a little more to stand on as a counter-suit than right out of the blue?

I had the same exact feeling too.
 
they may not be very smart
I don't think that can be substantiated....

Does anyone else get a niggly feeling that this was Psystar's actual goal from the start? They certainly must have expected Apple to sue them, and maybe an antitrust lawsuit has a little more to stand on as a counter-suit than right out of the blue?
I think so too.
 
On one hand, I have wanted to use Mac OS X myself, but on the other hand, I am not about to throw my high performance PC stuff out the door and buy more expensive and less performing apple products just to use their OS while at the same time losing my ability to use the games I like.

I think Apple should either support other hardware or not sue companies that allow me this kind of choice. I think it would boost Apple's OS sales and over all profit if they allowed me to buy their software and run on standard PC hardware. The fact is apple simply does not want to invest what it would take to make compatibility with hardware work. Because of this, they should stay in their little niche market hole until they are ready to compete with the rest of the world.

I hope the counter suit works, I am tired of seeing MS being the only company sued.
 
Back
Top