Protect Yourself Against Android Malware Apps

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How do you protect yourself from the recent wave of Android malware apps? People seem to like Lookout. It is free and they have a handy list of currently affect apps. What are you guys using for protection?

Update: We originally reported that Google removed the apps from devices, but we recently learned that the remote removal system has not yet been engaged for these applications because they are under active investigation.

We’ve deployed an over-the-air update that protects Lookout users from all known instances of DroidDream.
 
I can't really say I have a full fledged droid phone. It's an LG Optimus M. I do use lookout though and it works great. It's got other uses also (I sometimes misplace my phone or son gets hold of it)
 
Last I checked apps in Android are sandboxed from each other meaning Lookout can't actually remove a malicious app unless it has root access. So the point of this app is what? Kill battery life? Suck up memory and waste CPU cycles? Give you a false sense of security?
 
This is a giant waste of time, Android already takes these things into consideration. You really should take a second to see what the program you're installing has access to before you install it, though. Viruses or "malware" that affect the actual system are totally bogus, Android is just like a unix system, things need root access to make system changes.

And getting an iPhone most certainly will not solve any kind of problem, it will actually make more problems :), like say, making a phone call.
 
... by getting an iPhone.

lol zing

Last I checked apps in Android are sandboxed from each other meaning Lookout can't actually remove a malicious app unless it has root access. So the point of this app is what? Kill battery life? Suck up memory and waste CPU cycles? Give you a false sense of security?

that's what I was thining... unless it simply detects it and lets the user know about it so they can take appropriate action
 
Last I checked apps in Android are sandboxed from each other meaning Lookout can't actually remove a malicious app unless it has root access. So the point of this app is what? Kill battery life? Suck up memory and waste CPU cycles? Give you a false sense of security?

That's why there are no uninstaller apps, file browser apps etc. Either that or you don't understand what a trojan is.
 
This is a giant waste of time, Android already takes these things into consideration. You really should take a second to see what the program you're installing has access to before you install it, though. Viruses or "malware" that affect the actual system are totally bogus, Android is just like a unix system, things need root access to make system changes.

And getting an iPhone most certainly will not solve any kind of problem, it will actually make more problems :), like say, making a phone call.

"It's unix like, therefore indestructable"

http://blog.fortinet.com/android-droiddream-uses-two-vulnerabilities/
 
Last I checked apps in Android are sandboxed from each other meaning Lookout can't actually remove a malicious app unless it has root access. So the point of this app is what? Kill battery life? Suck up memory and waste CPU cycles? Give you a false sense of security?

I have not researched the subject. It may be that Lookout can not 'remove' another malicious app, or not, however the simple ability to identify suspicious behavior and provide warnings about such activity is valuable to me.

Further, Lookout has the ability to locate my phone, remotely -even if it is, say, in your lost or stolen vehicle, on your teenage malcontent, or for whatever reason.

Lookout also has a back up and restore (to the cloud) function, should my phone not be able to be recovered once lost or stolen, or should lightning strike it, or my nephew get his hands on it and decide to play with it, I can restore to my new phone.

Are those also features that waste clock cycles?
 
That's why there are no uninstaller apps, file browser apps etc. Either that or you don't understand what a trojan is.

File manager apps can modify files on the SD card and can only view the file system files. You would have to make the file system RW before the File manager can do anything. Some file managers like ES File Explorer can do that for you but again they require root access. Even clicking on the apk file to uninstall through the file manager would require user interaction. So while Lookout may be able to scan everything it can't do shit on its own.

The uninstaller apps do not uninstall anything unless they have root access such as Titanium Backup. Those so-called "uninstallers" on the market do nothing but call the actual Android uninstaller and put a pretty picture on the front of it and it still requires user interaction to confirm the uninstall in some form.

I have not researched the subject. It may be that Lookout can not 'remove' another malicious app, or not, however the simple ability to identify suspicious behavior and provide warnings about such activity is valuable to me.

Further, Lookout has the ability to locate my phone, remotely -even if it is, say, in your lost or stolen vehicle, on your teenage malcontent, or for whatever reason.

Lookout also has a back up and restore (to the cloud) function, should my phone not be able to be recovered once lost or stolen, or should lightning strike it, or my nephew get his hands on it and decide to play with it, I can restore to my new phone.

Are those also features that waste clock cycles?

So how would Lookout have saved you from these apps? Oh wait it wouldn't have. They didn't update the application to detect these apps until AFTER Android Police had contacted Google and announced their findings. Too little too late. In fact it would have been faster to read the news, since it went viral pretty quickly, and then removed the applications manually. So yes waste of clock cycles and memory.

Contacts, Calendar, E-mail, and WiFi information is already backed up automatically with Google. So if my phone actually died and I had to upgrade to a different device it would be pretty painless. So there again a waste of clock cycles and memory as it is duplicating functionality. HTC phones have their own Backup system as well. Plus you can always do a Nandroid backup of your device. Not to mention there are a ton of complaints in the app reviews about the backup function of Lookout not working correctly or taking forever. ;)

If I lose my device, I lose my device. That's what insurance is for. There are other apps out there for $.99 that do the same thing with lost/stolen phones. No subscription required. By the way what good does Lookout do if they turn the phone off or do a factory reset? ;)

So what did we learn today class? Lookout is a piece of software that can't actually remove malware on its own, duplicates already existing functionality, and in the end gives the end user nothing but a false sense of security. :eek:
 
In case you didn't, let me break it down for you:

"Android is just like a unix system, things need root access to make system changes.

I did not say it was indestructible.

Also, DroidDream is easily stopped by making a dummy file, so it doesn't seem like a huge threat. It installs a root shell on the device in question, if the exploit "exploid" runs successfully, which it didn't in the case of the article you linked to.

Even with the root shell there, it can't be accessed remotely, which would be ideal in the case of exploiting the victim's phone, and is pretty much meaningless, as I'm pretty sure you can't SSH into a phone over a mobile network due to port restrictions and things like that. You would also have to have an ssh server installed to do so.

So the only thing I've gathered from this is that you would have to have some incredible, drawn out plan in which case everything would have to work for someone to actually get remote root access into a victim's phone.

Not very realistic.
 
If I lose my device, I lose my device. That's what insurance is for. There are other apps out there for $.99 that do the same thing with lost/stolen phones. No subscription required. By the way what good does Lookout do if they turn the phone off or do a factory reset? ;)

So what did we learn today class? Lookout is a piece of software that can't actually remove malware on its own, duplicates already existing functionality, and in the end gives the end user nothing but a false sense of security. :eek:

Just for the record, the free version of Lookout (no sub required) will allow you to locate your phone... It also turns on the GPS if it's turned off, there's other apps that can do that but there's not a lot of them. AFAIK the location part of Lookout is actually pretty sleek, I've been meaning to try it out since many of the other location apps I've seen recommended in the past seem to be in indefinite closed betas or are now paid services (Mobile Defense, WaveSecure, etc.).

Also, some of the other apps on the market for phone location will only report the location thru text & e-mail messages or whatever and don't have a web interface w/mapping, which I think is convenient. I'm not sure why you wouldn't want the option of using such a service... It beats the heck out of paying $100 for a lost phone. I've never lost my phone, heck I never even misplace it at home, but I still like having this option available to me.

I do pay for my insurance from Sprint, and I'll probably compare Lookout to the location app they just launched that's free as part of the service... But if I like Lookout enough I may downgrade my insurance from the full $7 TEP (which includes free repairs for defects as well as complete replacement w/the $100 deductible) to only the $4 charge for replacement in case of accident/theft. $3 a month is not much, but it's $3... Also the price of a Lookout sub (more if you subscribe to Lookout for a full year).

Personally I don't care for most of Lookout's other features either, I agree that the backup features are redundant and unnecessary... You don't have to use them if you install Lookout tho. There is one other feature that I think is highly valuable though, and that's remote wipe in case of theft or a lost device... Like I said, I haven't tested it yet, but Lookout says it'll go well beyond the wiping of contacts/texts that most apps advertise and it'll actually wipe accounts from your device amongst a lot of other sensitive stuff. If it actually works that's well worth $30 a year for a lot of people.

Finally, the people behind Lookout also put out an app called Plan B, which might appeal more to people like you who worry about background processes, etc. Plan B is an app you push unto your device after it's lost, using the new market feature to install apps from any PC, and it then provides location services... Hence the name.

Companies like HTC are starting to offer similar services but in many cases they're not really any better... HTC's Sense.com stuff has been blamed for high battery drain on newer devices, and they haven't retro-actively implemented it on most of their devices either (probably won't).
 
Finally, the people behind Lookout also put out an app called Plan B, which might appeal more to people like you who worry about background processes, etc. Plan B is an app you push unto your device after it's lost, using the new market feature to install apps from any PC, and it then provides location services... Hence the name.

Now that I like. That is a much better solution to finding a lost/stolen phone.
 
File manager apps can modify files on the SD card and can only view the file system files. You would have to make the file system RW before the File manager can do anything. Some file managers like ES File Explorer can do that for you but again they require root access. Even clicking on the apk file to uninstall through the file manager would require user interaction. So while Lookout may be able to scan everything it can't do shit on its own.

The uninstaller apps do not uninstall anything unless they have root access such as Titanium Backup. Those so-called "uninstallers" on the market do nothing but call the actual Android uninstaller and put a pretty picture on the front of it and it still requires user interaction to confirm the uninstall in some form.



So how would Lookout have saved you from these apps? Oh wait it wouldn't have. They didn't update the application to detect these apps until AFTER Android Police had contacted Google and announced their findings. Too little too late. In fact it would have been faster to read the news, since it went viral pretty quickly, and then removed the applications manually. So yes waste of clock cycles and memory.

Contacts, Calendar, E-mail, and WiFi information is already backed up automatically with Google. So if my phone actually died and I had to upgrade to a different device it would be pretty painless. So there again a waste of clock cycles and memory as it is duplicating functionality. HTC phones have their own Backup system as well. Plus you can always do a Nandroid backup of your device. Not to mention there are a ton of complaints in the app reviews about the backup function of Lookout not working correctly or taking forever. ;)

If I lose my device, I lose my device. That's what insurance is for. There are other apps out there for $.99 that do the same thing with lost/stolen phones. No subscription required. By the way what good does Lookout do if they turn the phone off or do a factory reset? ;)

So what did we learn today class? Lookout is a piece of software that can't actually remove malware on its own, duplicates already existing functionality, and in the end gives the end user nothing but a false sense of security. :eek:


So you agree that lookout now can warn people who dont follow news closely that they have infected apps on their device? Further I would like to see your source that lookout needed to be updated.

So if your phone is in your car and your car is stolen oh well that is what insurance is for?

So you sign up for a website to use lookout. It is free. There is now a pay option - so what.

Proclaiming other options for specific feature is an agreement that those features are of use.

Google does not back up everything on my phone. Just specific items.

So you dont like the app. Fine. Your like and dislike are not criteria or even of importance to how I, and others, decide what is of value or use for ourselves.

You have expressed your opinion, I have expressed mine.
 
BTW, if anyone has any other suggestions for location and remote-wipe apps I'd love to hear them... Two of the ones I heard mentioned the most when I bought my EVO seem to have fallen by the wayside, Mobile Defense is still in closed beta and WaveSecure got bought out by McAfee and made into a paid app/service, I don't mind paying but I'd rather avoid McAfee even if Intel bought 'em. I think I remember reading about one called Prey as well but I haven't looked into it, and I believe that stuff like Where'sMyDroid doesn't provide a web interface or advanced wipe functions (I could be mistaken).
 
I just don't download strange, hacker type .apks from the web.

And the few apps that I have (Angry Birds didn't show in the market for me for a few days, only AB Seasons), I download on my PC so I can scan them before moving them to my sdcard for install.
 
So you agree that lookout now can warn people who dont follow news closely that they have infected apps on their device? Further I would like to see your source that lookout needed to be updated.

Right on their own blog. Android Police outed the infection and the apps pulled before the OTA went out.

http://blog.mylookout.com/2011/03/s...-found-in-official-android-market-droiddream/

So if your phone is in your car and your car is stolen oh well that is what insurance is for?

Yep. By the time you discover your car has been jacked it's probably way to late anyways. That car is most likely long gone by then. A buddy of mine had his car stolen a few years back. Police literally told him to just file an insurance claim because it was a lost cause.

However, Plan B could be a good alternative but I'm still not wasting CPU cycles and battery life on something worthless 99% of the time until I absolutely need it. Even if Plan B worked and I recovered my phone and/or car I still wouldn't keep it installed nor would I ever consider Lookout.

Frankly I'd like to see proof Lookout's GPS tracker has actually helped anyone outside of losing their phone in the seat of the couch or in the car.

So you sign up for a website to use lookout. It is free. There is now a pay option - so what.

Granted. I meant to pull the piece about cost but forgot.

Proclaiming other options for specific feature is an agreement that those features are of use.
Google does not back up everything on my phone. Just specific items.

Granting Lookout total access to everything in your phone in the off chance you lose it? Thanks but no thanks. I'll try Plan B and if that fails I'll cut my losses and move on with my life. It's only a phone.

Backing up data is a given for anything and everything. Never did I say backing up is foolish.

What data are you putting on your phone that you don't have backed up already? That's a recipe for disaster. Nothing on my phone isn't backed up either on my computer and server or sitting in my GMail account. That's also what Nandroid is for except with Nandroid I have full control over where my data goes and who can access it.

Scanning a phone for a virus but can't really do anything about it is as worthless as a Fart App. By the way the website confirmed it. The user gets prompted to uninstall the offending app. However, at that point you're already rooted and infected. Lookout can't do shit about that without root access. Not sure how you would fix that except reinstalling the ROM from scratch. By the way Nandroid would have you running again in about 5 minutes. ;)

So you dont like the app. Fine. Your like and dislike are not criteria or even of importance to how I, and others, decide what is of value or use for ourselves.

Yes, I dislike the app because it gives users a false sense of security. Overall Lookout does nothing but suck up battery life, memory and CPU cycles. I wonder how many people had Lookout installed and were still infected by DroidDream. Boy that's a quality app that deserves to be liked. :rolleyes:

Instead of being given a false sense of security how about those dumbasses that installed Screaming Sexy Asian Girls actually learn from this experience? Oh wait they won't. They'll just install Lookout, Symantec, AVG, or some other Android AV that will protect them from DroidDream only to find themselves hacked and rooted again by Screaming Sexy Asian Girls 2 that uses a different exploit.
 
BTW, if anyone has any other suggestions for location and remote-wipe apps I'd love to hear them... Two of the ones I heard mentioned the most when I bought my EVO seem to have fallen by the wayside, Mobile Defense is still in closed beta and WaveSecure got bought out by McAfee and made into a paid app/service, I don't mind paying but I'd rather avoid McAfee even if Intel bought 'em. I think I remember reading about one called Prey as well but I haven't looked into it, and I believe that stuff like Where'sMyDroid doesn't provide a web interface or advanced wipe functions (I could be mistaken).

If you're paying for insurance, you already have one.

www.sprint.com/protection
 
If you're paying for insurance, you already have one.

www.sprint.com/protection

I know this, I mentioned the very same thing in one of my previous posts, thanks though. I was planning to downgrade my insurance from the Total Equipment Protection ($7) to just the theft/loss/accident protection ($4), at which point I think the app is no longer available to me.

Plus the remote wipe functionality in it seems to be particularly rudimentary, I think it just deletes your contacts and maybe text messages but that's it... Frankly those are the last things I'm worried about, I'm more worried about my e-mail and/or calendar ending up on a stranger's hands (along w/billing info, etc.).

My contacts might have birthdays and phone #s but a lot of that is publicly available or not hard to find, and I don't ever text anything of a sensitive nature.

Also, Sprint's app sends a text message to your device every time you use the web interface to locate it (presumably to avoid abuse), and that kinda defeats the purpose in the case of theft. Some idiot might neglect to turn off my phone if he steals or finds it and takes it, but he'll probably have to take it home to wipe it and bypass my lock code... However if he sees text message coming in stating that I'm trying to locate it he'd likely pull the battery right then and there.
 
Yep. By the time you discover your car has been jacked it's probably way to late anyways. That car is most likely long gone by then. A buddy of mine had his car stolen a few years back. Police literally told him to just file an insurance claim because it was a lost cause.

Actually, a lot of people who pay for a LoJack service on their car have successfully recovered their vehicles with the help of their local police department (which LocJack works with in the case of an emergency)... Just saying. I actually pay for LoJack on my car because it pretty much pays for itself, I think the discount that my insurance company gives me for having it is actually more than LoJack's yearly fee.

I'm not saying these services would be anywhere near as reliable, obviously in the case of phone theft the police is never gonna get involved, but still... They're useful. Whether you chose something like Lookout or Plan B or something else is another matter. I agree all the extra fluff isn't really necessary or particularly useful, with the exception of remote wipe functions which go hand in hand with location services.

You could argue that if Android security is strong enough then most thiefs would just wipe your phone rather than deal with a lock screen password, I think Lookout even has the ability to wipe your SD card though... And that's something that would survive a phone wipe (filled with personal photos, some app data, documents, etc.).

Anyway, I know people that have successfully recovered lost phones w/services like these... If you leave it at a restaurant or something like that they could neglect to find it where you've left it when you go back (if you even remember to), this solves that.
 
BTW, if anyone has any other suggestions for location and remote-wipe apps I'd love to hear them... Two of the ones I heard mentioned the most when I bought my EVO seem to have fallen by the wayside, Mobile Defense is still in closed beta and WaveSecure got bought out by McAfee and made into a paid app/service, I don't mind paying but I'd rather avoid McAfee even if Intel bought 'em. I think I remember reading about one called Prey as well but I haven't looked into it, and I believe that stuff like Where'sMyDroid doesn't provide a web interface or advanced wipe functions (I could be mistaken).

Looking at the lookout webpage, it does have remote wipe and shutdown in the paid version.
 
Looking at the lookout webpage, it does have remote wipe and shutdown in the paid version.

I know this, those are the only features worth using in the app imo... I was just wondering if anyone has any alternatives. I understand people blasting Lookout for it's pseudo security features (it's more of a sys info functionality than actual protection), but I've been saying it has other redeeming features, such as that. However if there's an app out there that's focused solely on location and remote wipe, I'd probably opt for that instead (provided the price is right, Lookout isn't too bad at $30 a year, should be half that tho).
 
I've tried the lookout phone locator. Worked pretty darn good. Got within 10ft of the phone, which happened to be laying in the grass near the car.
Lookout also has a scream function. This will allow you to make your phone scream and strobe. I tried it, for a test, and worked great.
Lock and Wipe I haven't used, yet. Don't want to use them for any testing purposes.

And straight from lookout website:
Lookout checks every app you install and automatically updates when new dangerous apps are discovered

Now, I may have a false sense of security, but at least I have something. I do check everything I think about installing, but a little bit extra is worth it.

I was also able to find my wife one day with lookout. She hates me now.
 
Lol I've never been married and I could've told you that was a bad idea... Unless you suspected she was cheating or something, then she had it coming. :p

I've been meaning to do a complete wipe prior to flashing a new ROM, I'm tempted to try out the wipe features then... Although I'm thinking it'd be best to set up some dummy accounts on the phone for this, wouldn't want something to go wrong and my calendar/email get screwed.
 
Well, after reading all of this I may be looking into some AV software. I haven't used any since I got the EVO. And maybe I wont need it if I'm careful about what apps I install.
 
If you generally install market apps only AND you pay attention to the permissions, you should generally be pretty well protected...
 
Back
Top