Process of new build...

gregnash

2[H]4U
Joined
Jun 8, 2005
Messages
2,164
So I am in the process of saving up for a new build and have pretty much decided that I will be going with this generation of technology (ie. LGA775 or AM2+) instead of purchasing the latest and greatest when I build. This is more of a cost savings exercise as gaming and computers are really no longer my life rather I would like to spend time with my wife, dogs and new photography hobby.

However, that is not to say that I don't game anymore on my computer. This will probably be my last build for a number of years (if you look at my current rig you can see what I mean) and I would like something that is not going to show its' age in 6 months (I know a hard pill to swallow).
So here is what I use/do that will be transferring over to the next build.
Monitor: Westinghouse NW2210 (1680x1050 native and what I use)
Games: WAR, WoW and some Titan Quest
Software: Photoshop CS2

So I am pretty decided on what mobo/cpu I will be getting and dont really see the benefit for me of getting an SLI/Crossfire setup (unless it will help with photo processing). With that said I want to keep my prices to not exceed $180 for the card.

What would you recommend with the above items in mind? I was thinking about a 4850 but was thinking if I saved the some money and got say a 9600GSO instead that would give me a bit more to spend on more ram, better cpu etc.
 
for 180 range. I would suggest the 4870 512mb. Id wait for about 2 weeks and I can bet that the card will be in the range. It will be worth it trust me.
 
Ok but from what I can see on the egg, the cheapest one is really around $200 which is really more than I want to spend. I would rather spend the money on a nice mobo/cpu combo that will last me seeing as the graphics technology will change much faster than the cpu/mobo tech.

Here's a quick example.. I found this chart from Tom's and on the side it advertises the 9600GSO for $80. Now I thought I had read somewhere that the 9600GSO was just a revamp 8800GT with a newer core and was comparable (somewhat) to the 4850. So really if that is true why spend the current $140-$200 on a 4850/4870 when I can get CLOSE performance in something that is near half the cost?
 
O
Here's a quick example.. I found this chart from Tom's and on the side it advertises the 9600GSO for $80. Now I thought I had read somewhere that the 9600GSO was just a revamp 8800GT with a newer core and was comparable (somewhat) to the 4850. So really if that is true why spend the current $140-$200 on a 4850/4870 when I can get CLOSE performance in something that is near half the cost?

The problem is that isn't true: The 9600GSO is the old 8800GS renamed to attract more custromer. Even with the extra VRAM on the 9600GSO (768MB), the performance is roughly equal to the 9600GT. You're thinking of the 9800GT which is pretty much the 8800GT in terms of performance with lower energy usage. The 9800GT is somewhat comparable to the HD4850 but the price difference between the two is pretty small ($20 to $25).
 
So for my needs though (saying that I wan to be able to play WAR maxed) which of these should I get? Is the extra $50 (after MIR) for the 4850 gonna give me that much of a difference?

I say for the extra $30 (before MIR), get the HD4850. Since you want max settings at 1680x1050 with WAR, ever extra bit of performance helps and the HD4850 certainly has that extra bit of performance.
 
4850 that small performance will smoothen out any lil hick ups on the way when played at max.
 
The 4850 is roughly equal to a 9800GTX+, which is significantly faster than the 9800GT. The 9800GT is roughly equal to a 4830.

Currently I see on newegg the 4850 starts at $135 and the 9800GTX+ starts at $140.
 
Back
Top