Powerline ethernet options

ShepsCrook

[H]F Junkie
2FA
Joined
Feb 16, 2003
Messages
9,544
I'm looking for some powerline ethernet options. I have an HTPC that has been on wireless, but while watching some large HD/DTS movies with XBMC, the media pauses while it buffers. Sometimes every few minutes and needless to say, it's really very annoying.

So I'm curious what powerline ethernet adapters people have used.

I don't want to run a 100' dedicated CAT6 line to the HTPC.
 
There is lots of heresay about powerline devices out there. No matter what you can't trust the reviews because the devices depend on wiring in your house that varys extremely on the age, size, wiring method, distance and number of circuits.

General rule of thumb if your entire house is wired with romex:

If the devices are rated for 500mbps and both devices are on the same circuit, you will most likely see the 90-100mbit.

If they aren't on the same circuit you will see less, typically 40-50mbit.

If your house is wired with anything but romex, the performance will really start to degrade fast.

Your best option may be to explore a higher speed (and signal) wireless link, coax-to-ethernet adapters (MoCa or HPNA), or just run CAT5.
 
Well, the house is a year old, 2200sq ft. I was trying to avoid running CAT6.
40-50 would be enough for HD streaming from a server.
 
A "mixed" approach may also be better for you. Run CAT6 to a room that is closer to the room you have the HTPC in and use wifi there. (or powerline adapters if said "new" room is on same circuit)
 
The problem is that the way the house is designed, where my current network setup is, running CAT6 means drilling a hole from the closet where it's all stored, into an over the garage attic, then down into the garage (running along the garage wall), then down into the crawl space. At which point, if I go that far, I may as well take it to the wall the HTPC is on and put in a jack.

I have the tools and the ability to do this, I was just trying to avoid doing that much work. (Being lazy with it I guess.)

I guess I may as well see if it will work for me vs asking and having excuses as to why I can't or don't want to run CAT6. If the powerline adapters don't work for me, then I'll just have to upgrade the wireless or run CAT6. Upgrading the wireless wouldn't be bad, but would be the most expensive route.

I'm looking at the Netgear Powerline AV500 model for $50
http://www.netgear.com/home/products/powerline-and-coax/high-performance/XAVB5001.aspx
netgear-powerline-av-500---xavb5001-1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Another point, if the wiring are the same zone. I am no electrician to explain this, but certain combinations of locations didn't work in my apartment. I assume different outlets were on different breakers therefore different circuits?? Does anyone know how to test this?

I would advise buying locally with return policy, if it didn't work just return the adapters.
 
Well, I tested the Netgear AV500 adapters, and sadly, they did not do the trick. I might tinker with them again, but another day. They did give decent speeds, but were no better than the wireless, if not worse than my wireless.
 
Remove any extension cords if any, wall plugs are OK. I had a extension cord and after removing it the speed jumped.

From my past testing, power has better ping than wireless.
 
I did powerline and it works pretty good.

But I also upgraded to wireless AC and it works better. While Power line can go faster at times every now and then it cuts out, its rare but it happens, and the slight speed benefit isn't as beneficial as the stability I have with AC.

If cost is a factor though power line is the cheaper option.
 
Me...I'd HTFU and run the Cat6 cable. Ether over Power sounds great...but seldom lives up to old fashioned cabling. Especially in any house or building not built in the last ten years to current electrical code with brand new (or damn close) appliances.
 
PL networking blows it out the ass, its awful in reality.

Why not just upgrade your wireless to a nice hi-gain antenna or use a real good wifi product like Ubiquiti products.

You are going to spend the same on PL networking when you can just upgrade to much much better wireless equipment and thank yourself for it. 2200sq feet is not a challenge at all for higher end wireless equipment.
 
Sure, but I just got those PL adapters together for $40. I doubt I'll get any wireless equipment for that price.

I was trying to keep it cheap and less time consuming than running 100' of CAT6. I'd run the CAT6 since I already have the cables over upgrading my wireless.
 
Sure, but I just got those PL adapters together for $40. I doubt I'll get any wireless equipment for that price.

I was trying to keep it cheap and less time consuming than running 100' of CAT6. I'd run the CAT6 since I already have the cables over upgrading my wireless.

If you already spent the dough try them. Maybe we cynics will be surprised.

But if I was you, I'd keep the CAT6 and a powerdrill with spade bit handy.
 
I did cable work for time warner for a while, so I've got 2' long wood screw bits and rock/cinder block bits with an 18v hammer drill.
 
I was in a similar situation as you. My house is around 2200 sq ft also. We done some remodeling a few years back and made the garage attached to my home into a huge living room.

My modem is on the opposite/farthest end of my house (where the majority of our PCs are). Wireless connection was crap, I bought 2 or 3 different wireless routers, bought 4 of those big 7-9db antennas, went through about 3 different pci/usb wireless options, tried setting up an AP/signal repeater, and none of that gave me the speed I was wanting. The repeater did boost my wireless signal to 3 bars, but it was still piss poor slow.
I tried the powerline kits next. Couldn't get a signal at all using the power plugs in the living room, I figured it was because I have 2 different breaker boxes, maybe those parts are on different circuits completely. I'm currently using the powerline kit, but I had to plug it into a different room, and run the cable to my living room. Speed is great, but the wire running along the baseboards is crap. Next time I tear into my house to do some work, I'll be running CAT6 lines everywhere I can.

Long story short, just run the CAT6. I think you'll be happier lol.
 
you could also do some testing to see if any rooms closer to the HTPC (like directly upstairs) work well with the powerline adapters and put a WAP there via the adapters.
 
Your best option may be to explore a higher speed (and signal) wireless link, coax-to-ethernet adapters (MoCa or HPNA), or just run CAT5.

OP, I didn't see a response to the MoCa suggestion. MoCa beats both powerline and wifi but those of us who suggest it always seem to get ignored. Do you have coax runs to the rooms in question?
 
Back
Top