Powering/booting problem: PSU or mobo?

zorobabel

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
193
Hi folks.
I finally upgraded my computer, and got a i5-2500k, ECS P67H2-A3 and 2x4GB PNY optima 1333.
I kept the rest:
PSU: Antec Neo HE 500W, made by Seasonic AFAIK; bought it in 5/2007, and it has seen a lot of use.
Graphic card: GF 7800 GTX 256 MB
Harddrives, sound card, low power sata cards (no hardware raid cards).

The problem first occured yesterday trying to add a third harddrive: instead of loading windows I got a blinking cursor in the top left corner. I was OC-ing to 4.0ghz, so I returned multi to stock and eventually booted again, but with only 2 HDDs. I only had a PCI sata/pata card installed, beside the GPU.
Today, still at stock clocks I plugged in 4 HDDs (3 are 7200rpm), plus a Creative XFI Xtreme music, and a second PCI-e sata card, and a DVD burner just for kicks, trying to determine wether my PSU was too weak, and as I feared - it didn't boot, bios not loaded. Also the bios time was reset but not the rest of the settings.
I unplugged most of the stuff and now I'm writting this.
At this point I'm inclined to believe that the PSU is not enough, but I'm puzzled, is the i5-2500k suck a pig? I would expect it to run without issue as long as I have a single video card (and I have no intention of going dual GPU, ever).
The PSU has been rock solid until now, but it did power an AMD x2 4600+ Windsor 65W, ECS 6100 mATX card, and 2x1GB DDR2 800. These may be lower power components, but I also had all of the above components, 2 opticals, an extra 1-2 HDDs on ocasion, webcam, fans etc. And I never had an issue.
So what do you think, PSU or mobo?
 
PSU. It is rather old and is based on an old design.
 
Agree with Danny. The NeoHE is, IIRC, based on one of Seasonic's older and lesser platforms. And a budget design running for very long and extended periods of time would almost certainly have suffered from capacitor deterioration (based on your use, roughly 20 to 25 percent). This means that the "500W" NeoHE might not be able to deliver even 400W after such prolonged usage.
 
Thanks guys!
Would you agree that a new 600W PSU (a quality one of course) would suffice for another 4-5 years with this setup, and a newer GPU at some point?
 
Thanks guys!
Would you agree that a new 600W PSU (a quality one of course) would suffice for another 4-5 years with this setup, and a newer GPU at some point?

Depends on which 650W but probably.
 
edit: It looks like I spoke too soon, the chirping is back and it's 1-2 seconds and not 3-5, and I'm sure it's not coming fom the PSU, but from the board or one of the cards. The changes were: I removed the radeon, plugged in a PCI sata card and plugged in the sata connectors for the hard drives. It may be a motherboard issue after all. /edit.

Thank you for posting.
I did some more testing this evening. I found out that when being close to the no post limit, the system would boot very slow and load windows even slower, all while the PSU made a very faint chirp/beep every 3-5 seconds. I pulled out the multimeter and measured 5.00v or 4.99v when there was HDD activity and 12.24v to 12.24v depending on CPU load. Very stable voltages, I think the PSU would stop cooperating before catching fire. It has 23A on 3.3V, 17A on 5V, and 38A on it's 3 combined 12v rails.

To make matters worse, I discovered I have at least 2 problems: one is the PSU and another one is my PCI-e SATA card with a J-micron chipset. This ECS P67H2-A3 board will not post with this particular SATA card installed in any of the PCI-e slots: the system speaker would indicate a memory problem. I do not have another PCI-e x1 card to test with.

I then proceded to take my wife's computer apart and brought a radeon x1650pro and an Enermax EG565P-VE (24P) to the party.
Now the Enermax PSU is even older than the Antec, circa 2005, but until now I didn't realize it is heavier and beefier. It has 32A on each of the 3.3v and 5v lines and 34A on it's 2 combined 12v rails.
I am writting this with the Enermax, both GPUs, the Creative XFi, 2 fans, 4 HDDs, and an optical unit installed, it all seems OK for now. The multimeter reads 5.19v to 5.20v for 5V, pretty stable, and the 12v is 12.16 idle and 12.10 with the CPU loaded, a bit more variation than with the Antec.

Now my thoughts... I guess 12V doesn't matter as much as people make it out to be, at least when you don't have enough 3.3v and 5v to go with it. When I bought the Antec I specifically looked for a lot of amps on 12V, it looks like I was wrong. Or maybe this ECS mobo handles power diferently. Or maybe the Enermax doesn't have a circuitry as sophisticated as the Antec, and is not that well protected from overload.
Please post if you noticed anything in this story, or your own thoughts about this.

edit: It looks like I spoke too soon, the chirping is back and it's 1-2 seconds and not 3-5, and I'm sure it's not coming fom the PSU, but from the board or one of the cards. The changes were: I removed the radeon, plugged in a PCI sata card and plugged in the sata connectors for the hard drives. It may be a motherboard issue after all.
 
Last edited:
It's scary to use older psu with lower efficiency, unlike PSU of today. Don't jeopardize your new rig on your older PSU.
 
It looks like the slight beeping/chirping and slow boot and load times were caused by a WD10EADS being plugged in the SATA ports. I had nothing but trouble with this one, but it didn't affect booting on the previous board.
 
Back
Top