Please critique my quiet, mid-range, overclocking build

beacon

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 11, 2005
Messages
265
Budget

I have a soft budget of $1000 or less. +/- $100 is no biggie.

Components Requirement

Case
PSU
Mobo
CPU
HSF
GPU HSF
RAM
HDD
DVD-R
GPU

I have a legit copy of Windows Vista Ultimate. Monitor/keyboard/speakers/etc are a non-issue as well.

What computer will be used for?

Going to be for general use at home office, but also for some gaming -> WoW, SC2/DIII when it comes out.
Don't plan to play graphics intensive games, but I want to keep the option open in the future.

Going to be running 2x22" LCDs.

Features

Don't need RAID, a single HD would be fine. I don't keep a lot of files, 500gb is more than enough
Don't need SLI - I like/prefer monolithic.

Computer must be quiet -- computer loudness is a huge turnoff. I'll be replacing the GPU HSF with aftermarket.

I would like to air overclock this rig to the best stable speed. I don't really need to and I haven't overclocked since my AMD 1800+ box, but I would be doing this for hobby if nothing else.


Proposed parts bought online

Case: Antec P182 - $150 less $50 MIR - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811129025&Tpk=p182

PSU: Corsair 750W - $120 less $20 MIR - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139006&Tpk=corsair+750w

Mobo: Asus P5Q - $130 - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131295

CPU: Intel Q6600 - $170 with coupon - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115018

HSF: Thermalright Ultra 120X - $60 - http://www.buy.com/retail/product.asp?sku=205121074&listingid=20983864&dcaid=17902

GPU HSF: Thermalright HR-03GT - $45 - http://www.directron.com/hr03gt.html

RAM: G.Skill 4Gb DDR 1000 (PC2 8000) - $85 - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...AFC-hardOCP&cm_mmc=AFC-hardOCP-_-NA-_-NA-_-NA

HDD: Seagate Barracuda 500Gb - $75 - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148136&Tpk=seagate+500

DVD-R: Random 20x DVD +/- R - $25 - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827151171

GPU: Powercolor 4870 - $260 less $30 MIR - http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1333675&highlight=powercolor

Random: Fans, thermal paste, etc. - $25

TOTAL: $1145 less 100 MIR




Any and all critiques would be highly appreciated!

Thanks!
 
A 4870 is too powerful. Newegg recently had an ECS 8800GT with aftermarket cooling for $110 or so, but it seems to be gone now. There's an ECS 9600GT with aftermarket cooling for a little over $100.

You would also be well served by one of the 4850 cards with aftermarket cooling. Or you can swap the cooler if you really want to.
 
Yeah, my 7800GT ran WoW maxed out no problem at 1280x1024. Granted you will be running a higher resolution but I would think a 4850 would be a better choice to still get high end graphics without coughing up more $$$ than you need to. Save some money there. I'd also go with an E8400 myself for that build, if cool and quiet is what you want. The E8400 is a 45nm part whereas the Q6600 is a 65mn part. The E8400 is also very overclockable. Unless that is you have some application that would benefit from a quad.

You may want to add super quiet aftermarket fans if the Antec ones don't satisfy your desire for silence.
 
Thanks guys for the comments. I appreciate it. At this point I don't think I need more than a 4850 for what I will be doing now and in the future.

Also, what are the real differences between the 65nm and 45nm processors?

Super quiet aftermarket fans -> Yate Loons?
 
I second the recommendation of getting different case fans. Some (relatively) cheap replacements to look for are the Yate Loon D12SL-12 case fans... check out Jab-Tech or Petra's Tech Shop for them.

DDR2 1000 RAM is overkill for the Q6600. You could stick with a cheaper DDR2 800 kit, like the ones from A-DATA or G.Skill. Some figures:

enginurd said:
Stated FSB/4 = Actual FSB
Multiplier x Actual FSB = CPU Speed
1:1 Ratio: 2 x Actual FSB = RAM Speed
1:1 Ratio: FSB = 1/2 RAM speed

Q6600:
Multi x Actual FSB, Stated FSB, RAM Speed = Clock Speed
9 x 266Mhz, 1066Mhz, DDR2 533 RAM = 2.4Ghz <== Stock Speeds
9 x 333Mhz, 1333Mhz, DDR2 667 RAM = 3.0Ghz <== Good OC
9 x 400Mhz, 1600Mhz, DDR2 800 RAM = 3.6Ghz <== Excellent OC, About the Max

The Xigmatek HDT-S1283 would work just as well as, yet cost less than, the TRUE 120 (and, unlike the TRUE 120, it also comes with a fan). Pair it with the retention bracket that makes mounting it easier. You won't need any additional thermal compound, as both the TRUE 120 and the Xigmatek HDT-S1283 comes with their own tubes of TIM.

Get the 640GB Western Digital hard drive instead of the Seagate 500GB drive. It uses two 320GB platters that makes it perform much faster and quieter.

Don't get the P5Q; the location of its 24-pin main connector makes wire management (and proper cooling) a huge PITA. Consider the P5Q Pro, P5Q-E, or the Gigabyte GA-EP45-DS3R instead.

If you're staying with AMD/ATI, the VisionTek brand is the only one that offers a limited lifetime warranty. (On the NVIDIA side, EVGA, BFG, and XFX are the ones to look for.) The HD4850 or the GeForce 8800GT would be better options for your immediate needs; I suggest waiting until Diablo 3 and StarCraft 2 arrives before getting a video card good enough for both (though, considering what Blizzard has done in the past, those two cards should be more than enough).
 
looks like you did your homework!

i would choose a higher cfm fan for the TRUE since its fins are closer together so more cfm = better cooling in terms of the thermalright.

other than that, looks very good!
 
I agree, get the Xigmatek for much less money. If you already got the TRUE120X, pickup a Scythe S-Flex fan for it (you don't want the cpu fan failing without warning, and these FDB fans are long lasting compared to sleeve bearing fans -- and much more expensive, but you only need one, lol).
 
Thanks folks, I haven't pulled the trigger on anything - yet! I wanted to get some expert advice before I did so :p
 
Would 700+ W be overkill for this machine? I don't plan on running SLI/Xfire... but I would like the possibility to run a 4870X2 or other powerful monolithic in the future. Would an efficient 500W do?

Thanks!
 
Would 700+ W be overkill for this machine? I don't plan on running SLI/Xfire... but I would like the possibility to run a 4870X2 or other powerful monolithic in the future. Would an efficient 500W do?

Thanks!

For extra headroom the Corsair unit is priced pretty decently here http://www.provantage.com/corsair-cmpsu-750tx~7CSMC05E.htm, it's nice to take care of these things now and so you don't have to buy unnecessary component upgrades in the future if you're already thinking about upgrading sometime in the future.
 
Back
Top