PlayStation Move = Wii HD

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The crew at Gizmodo spent some time with the PlayStation Move and came away with the opinion that it is basically a Wii HD.

I had high hopes for PlayStation Move since its announcement. Having played around with various titles for about an hour today, I have to say: if Sony's technology is better, it isn't showing in its first-gen software. Frankly, I'm not sure that it ever will.
 
Copying what someone else has already done isn't a way to attract new customers.
Sony just made a more accurate wiimote, really.

Microsoft at least took the concept and did something new and fresh with it... It's a unique (and IMO, much better) implementation of body-as-controller movements.

Microsoft's has the chances to attract new customers. Especially when dad can enjoy MW2, and junior can play his little kiddy games, and mom can do yoga, they get the best of both worlds.

I had long wondered who would top the Wii's innovation. Sony failed, seems like Microsoft has the best shot at it to me. The question remaining is how Nintendo will top it with Wii 2 (my guess is they won't- they got lucky with the Wii).
 
I think there hasn't been any ground breaking app for move as yet. until they do it just be a wii clone with higher quality. now will sell some yes. will they make back their r&d cost. maybe. will it be as successful as wii. nope. most people who look @ this as buy already have wii. if they do why and they going to spend another 80( 105 if they don't have the eye as yet) to get a wii on ps3. microsoft gets a double up with voice control + no need for controller. as long and kinect is priced right they be selling alot.
 
Copying what someone else has already done isn't a way to attract new customers.
Sony just made a more accurate wiimote, really.

Microsoft at least took the concept and did something new and fresh with it... It's a unique (and IMO, much better) implementation of body-as-controller movements.

To ordinary people who don't understand the technology, arm flailing is arm flailing; the difference is in two cases you hold stuff and flail your arms, the other case, a camera watches you flail your arms.

The concept is still the same, the execution is different.

I stand by what I've said all week - most people who want motion controlled gaming already own a Wii. Those who don't will be hard pressed to buy a 360 or Ps3 console plus the expense of Kinect or Move, as opposed to spending less money by just buying a Wii. If you don't already own a Wii and you own a 360 or Ps3, then Kinect or Move may be a deal and/or appealing to you.

Personally, I'll be glad when the fad is over because I grew sick of it over a year ago. :eek:
 
Kinect is appealing simply because I don't need a remote or anything anymore, or to screw with batteries...
Only time I'd need the controllers would be to play a FPS game or something.
 
Personally, I'll be glad when the fad is over because I grew sick of it over a year ago. :eek:

I'd agree the Wii was a fad. Kinect takes the awkwardness out of it, IMO. If it's priced right, I could see myself using that a whole lot. Instead of pointing a dorky white controller at the TV, I speak or wave my hands... It's a much better implementation IMO.
 
...and that article is a waste of time and the person who wrote it is an idiot.

By the same token you could say "well a 360 is just a better Xbox" or "a Ps3 is just a better Ps2". Let's all hook up our Colecovision systems again, who needs millions of polygons, 5.1 surround and 1080p? I'm fine with my 10 pixels and bleeps and bloops :rolleyes:
 
...and that article is a waste of time and the person who wrote it is an idiot.

By the same token you could say "well a 360 is just a better Xbox" or "a Ps3 is just a better Ps2". Let's all hook up our Colecovision systems again, who needs millions of polygons, 5.1 surround and 1080p? I'm fine with my 10 pixels and bleeps and bloops :rolleyes:

That's not really what he was getting at... He was getting at what advantage (to consumers) would such a device have? A wand in your hand has already been done with the Wii, and was a quickly worn novelty.
 
As I see it, there are advantages to the Wii and Sony set up in that they have buttons and triggers which can enhance game play. Then again, I can't see why a game developer couldn't have a player hold onto a controller (standard or specialized) while using the Kinect on the X-Box to accomplish the same thing.

In the end, I think the Kinect is a more interesting product as it involves the whole body. Running in place to simulate running in a game vs a joystick on a hand held controller, Kicking a ball, anything that takes more input than where your hands are located. 3d positioning, Skeletal tracking, facial recognition, voice recognition... Sony's Move website mentions how they want the whole body involved in games. A boxing game was used as an example, though really it relies on the player moving his hands rather than his whole body. Not quite as limited as the Wii, but not much better. It seems to me that Kinect allows more on this front.

Gaming aside, I think the Kinect brings a really compelling option for people that don't game. The fitness program demoed really would appeal to an entire family and people that wouldn't otherwise buy a console at all. Whole body tracking opens up a new world.

The Wii will still be the lowest cost motion controls, but in the long run the kinect will be cheaper than the Move. At least if you want full features and more than one player.
 
I'd agree the Wii was a fad. Kinect takes the awkwardness out of it, IMO. If it's priced right, I could see myself using that a whole lot. Instead of pointing a dorky white controller at the TV, I speak or wave my hands... It's a much better implementation IMO.

I haven't seen much for Kinect that is much different than what they've had for the Wii for awhile now. Granted, I haven't sat and watched every E3 video or showpiece that's been released so far, so there may be stuff on the radar that I haven't seen yet. That being said - the biggest hurdle IMHO for Kinect (to me) is the price tag. $150 for the base unit and $60 for Kinectimals (the 1 game that I would buy for our household, especially my daughter) is a steep buy.

Tech wise, Kinect > the rest. From what I've seen though, there ain't much difference one to the other on the game front...most of the stuff I've seen is standard fare run of the mill party/family type Wii game stuff and I've already gotten my fill of that. The dancing stuff, the Adventure game...not interested in either of those. Who knows, it may sell out for months at a time and surprise me - I just know in my case, it's not going to be a purchase unless something just ridiculously cool comes out for it, or the price gets halved and the games drop down to around the Move game MSRP of $39.99.
 
Gaming aside, I think the Kinect brings a really compelling option for people that don't game. The fitness program demoed really would appeal to an entire family and people that wouldn't otherwise buy a console at all. Whole body tracking opens up a new world.
I'm really looking forward to watching movies on a 360 with Kinect. No more remotes FTW.
If I can also watch OU/Texas/Florida play football live with the new ESPN, I could even ditch my cable company.

Point being that Kinect is so much more than the games.

I haven't seen much for Kinect that is much different than what they've had for the Wii for awhile now. Granted, I haven't sat and watched every E3 video or showpiece that's been released so far, so there may be stuff on the radar that I haven't seen yet. That being said - the biggest hurdle IMHO for Kinect (to me) is the price tag. $150 for the base unit and $60 for Kinectimals (the 1 game that I would buy for our household, especially my daughter) is a steep buy.
Well, no official price yet. I think, with that $150 leak by Gamestop... Microsoft had enough ears out there to know $150 might be too high. I'd expect it to be set at $99 or something.

And wait a few months and that $60 game would be $40... No different than any other 360 game. Pre-order or immediate launch people get screwed on price.
There's even some pre-order specials netting you a $50 game nowadays usually.

I'd suggest you watching demos. Yes, this does all the same cheesy novelty Wii stuff, but also a whole lot more. I love it... Can't wait for November to roll around.
 
I still don't see the appeal of Kinect or how it's that much better than using the already available Xbox Live Vision camera (TotemBall anyone?)
 
I think Kinect will REALLY shine if they allow hybrid controls. Take that Star wars demo they showed at the end of the keynote for instance. - make a light saber control with a stick (or even 2) or dpad(s) on the lightsaber handle, and you've got a way to move, turn and look so you aren't on rails, and a light saber to swing around. Since you'll probably have BOTH hands on the lightsaber handle you should be able to move your avatar and look around while swinging away with the saber.....

That would kick MUCHO ass.
 
I don't know man. Every time I see a video of that Kinect thing it looks like it has severe latency issues. Having to do everything nearly a second early kinda ruins the experience.
 
To ordinary people who don't understand the technology, arm flailing is arm flailing; the difference is in two cases you hold stuff and flail your arms, the other case, a camera watches you flail your arms.

The concept is still the same, the execution is different.

I stand by what I've said all week - most people who want motion controlled gaming already own a Wii. Those who don't will be hard pressed to buy a 360 or Ps3 console plus the expense of Kinect or Move, as opposed to spending less money by just buying a Wii. If you don't already own a Wii and you own a 360 or Ps3, then Kinect or Move may be a deal and/or appealing to you.

Personally, I'll be glad when the fad is over because I grew sick of it over a year ago. :eek:

I definitely agree with you.

If my kids were older, I'd be more interested since it would have the added benefit of allowing me to embarrass the heck out of them when gaming while they have friends over.

Since they're less than 3, I'll just stick with a controller.
 
I definitely agree with you.

If my kids were older, I'd be more interested since it would have the added benefit of allowing me to embarrass the heck out of them when gaming while they have friends over.

Since they're less than 3, I'll just stick with a controller.

I'd still go for it, you can do it in 12 years, and it shall have that retro charm.
 
Wii is a fad? I must admit I haven't looked at the numbers the last 2 or 3 months but wasn't the wii still on top at least back in April or so? If you consider its total units and games sold, and I am guessing still pretty good current numbers, I guess computers, sex, and eating are just a fad also by comparison.

now before you start calling me a fanboy get you facts right. I am a PC fanboy. Don't really care for any of the game systems.
 
The Wii is a fad never gets old, some companies would signup for such a fad.
Those new technologies have to get it right from the start. There is no second change for the people at Sony and Microsoft. Nintendo owns the segment for the casual gamer there is a marketing idea behind it, beyond what the others try to do , which is trying to get a piece of the pie in a way which i have my doubts about.

The best way to find out how well they do is a year after they launched. The defining moment is when they show you games that aren't an afterthought like the many Wii titles we have seen already.
 
The Wii is a fad never gets old, some companies would signup for such a fad.
Those new technologies have to get it right from the start. There is no second change for the people at Sony and Microsoft. Nintendo owns the segment for the casual gamer there is a marketing idea behind it, beyond what the others try to do , which is trying to get a piece of the pie in a way which i have my doubts about.

The best way to find out how well they do is a year after they launched. The defining moment is when they show you games that aren't an afterthought like the many Wii titles we have seen already.

Which, honestly, from what I've seen: Microsoft has been doing well.
Sony's games seem to be cheap mashups, which also reminds me of the Wii... Microsoft seems to have some quality originals. But then again, that might just be the demo world and after release comes the flood of crappy products.

I do agree though, it'll all come down to games.
 
Back
Top