Planned Wireless Internet Network Threatens GPS

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A new ultra-fast wireless internet network is threatening to overpower GPS signals around the country. Oh no! How will anyone blindly drive off a cliff or into a pond without GPS?

The problem stems from a recent government decision to let a Virginia company called LightSquared build a nationwide broadband network using airwaves next to those used for GPS. Manufacturers of GPS equipment warn that strong signals from the planned network could jam existing navigation systems.
 
Why doesn't the government swap them spectrum somewhere? I'm sure there is something else that could be used.
 
Um, considering the military uses gps heavily, although I know its not the same access as civilians, I don't see them doing this.
 
hmm sounds like a scare tactic to me. I mean if this was really the case, would light squared even attempt such a bandwidth. I highly doubt it will make planes crash or drive your car off a cliff.
 
Im not a big Bill Clinton fan, but dont take away one of the best things he did for us. Bill made damn sure he was able to shower us with his high quality signal.
 
What is wrong with the FCC, First BPL now this.

They sit there and conduct their little spectrum auctions and seem to do little else.
So when they get a bug up their collective butts to actually regulate something they create a disaster.
 
Um, considering the military uses gps heavily, although I know its not the same access as civilians, I don't see them doing this.

Yep. If this is a real issue then the DOD and FAA will put the smack down on it.

My take on it? Consumer gps units might just suck in this scenario and the vendors are shitting themselves over the potential liability.
 
I hate my Garmin GPS - makes me drive in circles when I try to reach Microcenter
 
Sounds like a bunch of bullshit from our current telecoms afraid to lose their chokehold on market ownership.
 
Good news everybody! Now the FBI wont be able to put GPS tracking devices on your car.
 
Sounds like a bunch of bullshit from our current telecoms afraid to lose their chokehold on market ownership.

WTF are you talking about? We're talking about the GPS companies, not the telecoms. Completely unrelated. :rolleyes:
 
Yep. If this is a real issue then the DOD and FAA will put the smack down on it.

My take on it? Consumer gps units might just suck in this scenario and the vendors are shitting themselves over the potential liability.

Yes, that's exactly it. The GPS makers actually admit it, they used substandard quality filters, so even if Lightsquared stays COMPLETELY within the frequencies that it bought, paid for, and owns - the GPS makers are saying 'Our substandard filters, that we saved 30 cents per unit by using, intrude on Lightsquared's frequencies, so therefore they shouldn't be allowed to use what they own.' This only applies to standalone GPS devices though, cell phone GPS devices already used the normal filters that actually do their job correctly.
 
Fears... Uhm, was any testing done to confirm there would actually be a problem? It shouldn't be too hard to do.
 
AT&T Navigator and VZ Navigator mean anything to you?

Right, but it is my understanding that those services are based off the cell towers, not the GPS satellites. If this is the case, then it would actually be in their benefit for GPS to go offline, since only their phones would have navigation.
 
Well golly... maybe you should not have sold that particular spectrum frequency to this company, eh FCC?
 
Right, but it is my understanding that those services are based off the cell towers, not the GPS satellites. If this is the case, then it would actually be in their benefit for GPS to go offline, since only their phones would have navigation.

It's assisted GPS. It uses both cell tower and GPS satellite. The phones without GPS chips uses the cell tower fetches the GPS information if I understand it, but ultimately it's GPS driven. Trouble is if you're out of range, you wouldn't be able to get updated information unless you actually have a GPS chip in your phone.
 
Yes, that's exactly it. The GPS makers actually admit it, they used substandard quality filters, so even if Lightsquared stays COMPLETELY within the frequencies that it bought, paid for, and owns - the GPS makers are saying 'Our substandard filters, that we saved 30 cents per unit by using, intrude on Lightsquared's frequencies, so therefore they shouldn't be allowed to use what they own.' This only applies to standalone GPS devices though, cell phone GPS devices already used the normal filters that actually do their job correctly.

Well golly... maybe you should not have sold that particular spectrum frequency to this company, eh FCC?
Please see Ualdayan's post quoted above. If his info is accurate, the GPS manufacturers should be on the hook for selling substandard equipment. Doesn't seem like something the FCC or Lightsquared should be concerned with. Only through real field testing will we know for sure if this is a real problem. If the cell phones are using the proper filters and they pass testing then the project should be a go and the device manufacturers should be fucked. It will suck for consumers and manufacturers alike but hey, that's what you get when you cut corners.
 
It's assisted GPS. It uses both cell tower and GPS satellite. The phones without GPS chips uses the cell tower fetches the GPS information if I understand it, but ultimately it's GPS driven. Trouble is if you're out of range, you wouldn't be able to get updated information unless you actually have a GPS chip in your phone.

Ok, that makes more sense. Hopefully this will pay off in the long run if we really do get fast, reliable WiFi nationwide. :)
 
shit, this is like the only thing the FCC SHOULD be fucking doing is to make sure shit like this doesn't happen.
 
The GPS signal strength measured at the surface of the Earth is about –160dBw (1 x 10–16 watts), which is roughly equivalent to viewing a 25-watt light bulb from a distance of 10,000 miles.

It doesn't take much to tweak a GPS signal if you have a cosite/cochannel RF signal messing with it.

Why doesn't the government swap them spectrum somewhere? I'm sure there is something else that could be used.

Heh, pull out the NTIA Redbook and let em know where. It's not as easy as it sounds.
 
shit, this is like the only thing the FCC SHOULD be fucking doing is to make sure shit like this doesn't happen.

A whole lot of GPS devices out there should be recalled and repaired. Repaired is prolly not the correct word, since they were manufactured with that defect intentionally to save money in the short term, hoping that neighboring slices of spectrum were not sold.

This most likely will not affect the FAA or military. By the time this service actually goes live in enough places to matter, the gps manufacturers will have had time to quietly recall and fix the naval/aviation and military grade receivers. Of course they will still be left with class action suits over the consumer grade crap they sell at BB and the like.
 
A whole lot of GPS devices out there should be recalled and repaired. Repaired is prolly not the correct word, since they were manufactured with that defect intentionally to save money in the short term, hoping that neighboring slices of spectrum were not sold.

This most likely will not affect the FAA or military. By the time this service actually goes live in enough places to matter, the gps manufacturers will have had time to quietly recall and fix the naval/aviation and military grade receivers. Of course they will still be left with class action suits over the consumer grade crap they sell at BB and the like.

I would hope that the military grade crap has the proper filter to begin with. They can charge out the ass to the military. It's the consumers that they like to cut corners with.
 
.. oh, and with what was discussed above. I'm all for the FCC allowing them to go ahead. Screw the GPS companies if they failed to add the right equipment.
 
Back
Top