Physics card next month from BFG?

prtzlboy said:
A: it's expensive as hell
and
B: games are coming out less frequently and with less quality

Seriously think -- look at the pc games section of a store compared to the console section -- it's shrinking. Extra expensive hardware is not going to make better games, it will only make crappy games look better.
This is your proof that PC gaming is dying? That's the worst process of reasoning I've ever seen dude.

Games come out faster on consols because that's how consols make their money. Not the system, but the games themselves. So they have to pump them out quickly, even at the cost of quality. If you'll look at your local walmart shelves you'll find 1 good game per ten shitty ones. While there are certainly flops in the PC gaming shelves, those companies can't afford to spend 1-2 years on a game and have it flop out completely, so they're more concerned about quality than companies churning out "Zelda IXXXXIV: Link goes Postal."

Also, the technology for the console games changes FAR more slowly that the technology for the home PC. In the recent years, PC developers have found that immersive = sales, so they have to have more content than "Mario Brothers 425: Luigi bakes a pie," 12 levels of floury goodness!

My point is, come to the table with proof or stop making doomsday predictions.
 
Apallohadas said:
"Zelda IXXXXIV: Link goes Postal."
"Mario Brothers 425: Luigi bakes a pie," 12 levels of floury goodness!

Bring it ON!
 
GeForceX said:
But I'm a pro-gamer and I run at 800 x 600 with no fancy stuff. :(

It's a waste. Why don't they work on something more better... like saving the Earth from corruption? It's all for the money, I tell ya!

-J.


A Pro gamer that runs at 800x600...

So...does that mean you dont have a job? :D

Anyway, I can't believe peeps are still arguing this. It works, we have seen it work in person and there is no argument that it does not work.

And do you really think BFG is going to market something that sucks?
 
prtzlboy said:
Graphics cards came before multi-core cpu's and are an already established technology.

it's a price thing.

$300 for a physics card, that's just crazy. The $300 you pay for a graphics card gives you a quantum friggin leap in the gaming experience.

And, if you even care for the difference, a $50 sound card can give you a much better experience with things like EAX.

A: it's expensive as hell


Did you even stop to think that people who already have $700 vid and $300 sound cards would refuse to buy one because of your pointless baseless argument?
 
it's not about the people who have the dough, it's about the people who don't. I've got a decent rig and I don't mind spending some cash to stay up to date and make my games look and sound better.

And, I guess computer gaming is dying for ME. It will never be DEAD, of course. There will always be good games. That's why I'm on the forum :) It's just that I've seen entire genres die off on the pc and it bothers me. Space sims a la Freespace? And it isn't totally because of the cost, I know. I suppose that's my subjective opinion and I'll leave it at that. I shouldn't even have mentioned it.

I'm also not saying an add-in physics card won't make games better, I'm just questioning the implementation. I think the best direction would be more integration, not more add-in cards. Maybe a less expensive solution could be added to motherboards or video cards. Like I said, though, maybe it WILL blow my mind, and then, sure, I'll get one.

I never thought I'd get people so angry about wanting to spend $300. I think hardware physics processing is good, and I get pretty excited thinking about how much fun I could have blowing shit up :D , but I just don't think another actively cooled add-in card blows up my skirt like it does some people. Hell, maybe it'll be like a math co-processor, and eventually get integrated into the cpu itself. That's the kind of thing I'd like to see.

I know a lot of people already who are wondering just how they're even going to squeeze another card into their box!
 
Eh, if its good and has some good games that support it I will buy it, otherwise I'll just stick to what I currently have.
 
didn't sli seem like a waste? this is just the technology process...and i'm sure prices will drop. just look at regular parts. a 60gb hard drive used to cost like 150 bucks not too long ago.
 
I see and hear a lot of gamers taking shots at the ppu. But, and i'm generalizing here, they all want the latest core this and the best gpu that so they can play games with all those amazing graphics. I say, wait for the technology and game development to merge together as they did with the GPU and games. As soon as a big tittle game comes out that utilizes the ppu to produce all of the amazing, realistic glory of some action FPS game, all of the latest-and-greates tech junkies are going to swarm all over the lates-and-greatest ppu.
 
I'm reading a lot of arguments from people who are saying that $300 is too much for something that just makes it look pretty. Try thinking about it as a Mustang convertible instead of a computer, why do people buy the V-8 Mustang instead of the V-6? They both go fast and are limited by the roads speed limits, but the V-8 is much more expensive. People buy the V-8 because the additional cost is worth the more pleasurable experience.

Same thing applies with the ppu, if it enhances game play, even if it's purely visual, some people will buy it. The amount of people who buy it will depend on the number of games that supports it, the cost of the ppu, and the amount of personal enjoyment it will bring to the player.

Personally I probably won't buy it because I don't care that much about graphics in games. I might be swayed to buy it if other programs start using it as well. I would really like to a see a distributed computing project like folding@home or World Community Grid (I run WCG, sorry team #33) start developing for the ppu. If a ppu could dramatically improve the speed at which results are computed then to some the $300 card may be more worthwhile to invest in.
 
MovieMan80 said:
I'm reading a lot of arguments from people who are saying that $300 is too much for something that just makes it look pretty. Try thinking about it as a Mustang convertible instead of a computer, why do people buy the V-8 Mustang instead of the V-6? They both go fast and are limited by the roads speed limits, but the V-8 is much more expensive. People buy the V-8 because the additional cost is worth the more pleasurable experience.

Same thing applies with the ppu, if it enhances game play, even if it's purely visual, some people will buy it. The amount of people who buy it will depend on the number of games that supports it, the cost of the ppu, and the amount of personal enjoyment it will bring to the player.

Personally I probably won't buy it because I don't care that much about graphics in games. I might be swayed to buy it if other programs start using it as well. I would really like to a see a distributed computing project like folding@home or World Community Grid (I run WCG, sorry team #33) start developing for the ppu. If a ppu could dramatically improve the speed at which results are computed then to some the $300 card may be more worthwhile to invest in.

I think rather than most of the arguements being about not wanting to pay $300 for a PPU because it makes things "look pretty," its mostly people not wanting to pay $300 for a PPU that currently has no function and doesn't have any killer-app to back it up as of now. It also doesn't have very large companies backing it's existence, so I think that most people are just hesitant to pay so much for something that might end up falling by the wayside.
 
quadnad said:
I think rather than most of the arguements being about not wanting to pay $300 for a PPU because it makes things "look pretty," its mostly people not wanting to pay $300 for a PPU that currently has no function and doesn't have any killer-app to back it up as of now.
You're right, I'm not going to buy a PPU today because it isn't out yet. Ageia has said they will release the cards once the games come out, which are supposedly right around the corner (I'm thinking mainly of Ghost Recon here).
quadnad said:
It also doesn't have very large companies backing it's existence, so I think that most people are just hesitant to pay so much for something that might end up falling by the wayside.
ASUS and BFG are producing the hardware. I would call them both big companies. Epic (and their Unreal engine), Ubisoft, Sega, Atari, and other game companies are also on the list of Ageia supporters, and I would call them big companies as well.
 
jebo_4jc said:
ASUS and BFG are producing the hardware. I would call them both big companies. Epic (and their Unreal engine), Ubisoft, Sega, Atari, and other game companies are also on the list of Ageia supporters, and I would call them big companies as well.

I have to be totally honest here, I don't really feel that BFG and ASUS creating cards is enough to make me feel that my $300 PPU is well spent, or backed properly. They are both decent companies, no doubt, but somehow I don't think that if sales for the PPU did poorly that they'd stay behind the product. As for those other "supporters," they're merely companies producing games with the ability to utilize the PPU, and I haven't seen anything from them suggesting that it is well worth the cash. I want a demo dammit (c'mon Epic...they've always been into touting the unreal tech)! Also, remember that things like ATi's trueform and other technologies appear and disappear from games almost as quickly as they arrive, so I don't feel that game companies are much of a backing. They provide no direct financial support, so this all hinges on the PPU's use in these games, and whether it is enough to justify the cash for gamers.

But hey, I'm still excited to see what Ageia comes up with, as I think it has a lot of potential. I just want the thing to be released dammit :mad:
 
A PPU could actually save me a lot of $$$ when it comes to delaying my next upgrade cycle. I took a chance with the Monster 3D (Voodoo1) card a long time ago. So I'll bet on this as well. Yeah eventually the tech will get incorporated into Vid cards, just as hardware 3D acelleration did eons ago.. But All I will need for my next upgrade would be the PPU and an ATI X1600 agp and I'd be set for a while... New Proc + Mobo + Ram + Vid card = a lot more than Vid Card + PPU....
 
I have a general question here. Many of the features of GPUs are coded functions in the silicon. So when DX10 comes out with new features, my 7800GTXs won't be able to perform them.

Sound cards have been programable for a little while. (I think this started with the SB Live! but I'm not sure.) I won't pretend to understand the differences but some new processing routines can be coded into drivers or firmware.

Does anyone know if Ageia's PPU is going to have commands/features/processes coded into the chip or programable? This could have a huge impact on the need to upgrade it regularly. I apologize in advance if this is a stoopid question or if my assumptions are incorrect.
Z
 
Someone else said it, but this whole $300 price point for something completely new bugs me somethin' awful. Honestly, it scares the sh1t out of me. :eek: :eek: :eek:
 
You guys arent looking far enough ahead. This isnt simply moving processing tasks around, this is a setup for significant developments in the long-term. Hardware unification anyone?
 
There would have to be a slew of really unique software to make me want a ppu. Look at WoW, although I dont play it, you would have a hard time telling WoW players they NEED a ppu. The market is widely controlled by games where a ppu is useless. People playing competitve e-sports games wouldnt want a ppu either, unless it figured into gameplay in a manner that required its use. Simply being there for flash is not enough, when serious players turn flash OFF to compete.

I see this as being limited to a few flight sims and destructible enviroments in fps games. Sure, the capacity to do more is there, but the designers already HAVE the capacity to do more, and are still churning out the same old crap, over and over, just making it prettier and faster. A ppu is just another prettier/faster bump.

I would rather see gameplay innovation. thanks.
 
FYI- Best Buy has the PPU listed for release on 3-28-06 at $299.99 Store manager showed me the inventory screen this afternoon. I doubt benchmarks will sway me to switch to the 7900 tomorrow, so I think I will spend the money on the PPU instead.
 
Diseaseboy said:
FYI- Best Buy has the PPU listed for release on 3-28-06 at $299.99 Store manager showed me the inventory screen this afternoon. I doubt benchmarks will sway me to switch to the 7900 tomorrow, so I think I will spend the money on the PPU instead.

1. Probably only listed in stores then? I checked on line...nothing.

2. Of course you'll wait to see if it gets some favorable reviews, right?

I thought theses guys had hardware ready, but were waiting for a killer app to support this card. I'm not aware of anythign that's gonna blow my boxers in the next month. Anyone?
 
Dang, $299 seems a bit steep, I was hoping for something in the $150-$200 range.
 
Naldo said:
Dang, $299 seems a bit steep, I was hoping for something in the $150-$200 range.

Give it 6 months and it will drop to that price point.
Another year it will be $50 and the newest lastest one's will cost that much.
 
Diseaseboy said:
FYI- Best Buy has the PPU listed for release on 3-28-06 at $299.99 Store manager showed me the inventory screen this afternoon. I doubt benchmarks will sway me to switch to the 7900 tomorrow, so I think I will spend the money on the PPU instead.

Why? What games even support it?
 
Zyme said:
I have a general question here. Many of the features of GPUs are coded functions in the silicon. So when DX10 comes out with new features, my 7800GTXs won't be able to perform them.

Sound cards have been programable for a little while. (I think this started with the SB Live! but I'm not sure.) I won't pretend to understand the differences but some new processing routines can be coded into drivers or firmware.

Does anyone know if Ageia's PPU is going to have commands/features/processes coded into the chip or programable? This could have a huge impact on the need to upgrade it regularly. I apologize in advance if this is a stoopid question or if my assumptions are incorrect.
Z

It will be programmable. In the intervierws I have read so far, they always say that the hardware can do anything that they might need it to do currently, and that what they plan to spend their time on after the HW release is growing the functionality of the drivers. For example, I think I recall hearing them say that at launch it will only support rigid body motion, but that's because that is what is primarily being used by game developers currently. In order to have volumetric or particle-based processing, they just have to code that into the drivers. And they have said that they will do so when the demand is there from the content designers after they get used to what it can do now.

prtzyboy said:
And, I guess computer gaming is dying for ME. It will never be DEAD, of course. There will always be good games. That's why I'm on the forum It's just that I've seen entire genres die off on the pc and it bothers me. Space sims a la Freespace? And it isn't totally because of the cost, I know. I suppose that's my subjective opinion and I'll leave it at that. I shouldn't even have mentioned it.

I'm also not saying an add-in physics card won't make games better, I'm just questioning the implementation. I think the best direction would be more integration, not more add-in cards. Maybe a less expensive solution could be added to motherboards or video cards. Like I said, though, maybe it WILL blow my mind, and then, sure, I'll get one.

I never thought I'd get people so angry about wanting to spend $300. I think hardware physics processing is good, and I get pretty excited thinking about how much fun I could have blowing shit up , but I just don't think another actively cooled add-in card blows up my skirt like it does some people. Hell, maybe it'll be like a math co-processor, and eventually get integrated into the cpu itself. That's the kind of thing I'd like to see.

I know a lot of people already who are wondering just how they're even going to squeeze another card into their box!

In terms of genres dying, all things run in cycles. They were big back in the day, thinned out then came back again, and are thinning out again. They will be back. Same thing happened with RPGs, Baldur's Gate was the first one in the current "cycle" of RPGs....before that there was nothing. But if you go back far enough, you can find when they were popular before that.

As far as add in vs. integration goes, that's something that will take time to happen. Everything that is commonly integrated into motherboards now, started out as an ad in board. Sound, lan, usb/firewire, sata, IDE, PS/2, serial/parallel...even the math co-processor you mention was at one point an add in. If, over time, the demand, market, and technology are right, motherboard integration may well happen. But before that can happen, the motherboard manufacturers need to be convinced that it will be worthwhile.

 
uzor said:
Anything that uses the PhysX SDK. You can find that list here:
http://www.ageia.com/physxInAction/games.html


OK... Maybe I should have included the adjective "good" and the qualifier "out now" to my initial question.

I am definately interested in looking at how Ghost Recon looks with it, but it isn't out till mid May (for the PC). Obviously Unreal is something i would pick it up for, but again, not even close to release.

Don't get me wrong though, I want Ageia to succeed but I just don't see it happening without a Killer App and Unreal is the only one that looks promising. So, I see no point acquiring the card until then (unless Ghost Recon turns out to be an aweosme game)
 
Flight Sim 10 won't use the PPU, according to the development team. I brought it up to them, and they looked into using it, but it just didn't have anything that they could use......
 
You know, i'm really starting to get sick of Ageia and their partners fucking with our heads and wallets.

November,December, Christmas, Febuary, March, Spring, $100, $200, $300 WHEN WILL IT END.
 
I got an invitation to buy one early. I signed up and haven't recieved the authentication email yet, but, I'm not sure I can afford it since I just bought $600 worth of cell phone stuff, and next month looks like tax time, may have to pay out there too. (Wasn't there supposed to be tax decreases? Mine keep going up!!@!)
 
BBA said:
I got an invitation to buy one early. I signed up and haven't recieved the authentication email yet, but, I'm not sure I can afford it since I just bought $600 worth of cell phone stuff, and next month looks like tax time, may have to pay out there too. (Wasn't there supposed to be tax decreases? Mine keep going up!!@!)

Nice. I have the money but no one's selling and you can get the card but dont have the money, quite a quandry.

Might I inquire how they went about offering you?
 
Back
Top