Photo editing: Upgrade or start from scratch?

Joined
Dec 22, 2010
Messages
18
1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Photoshop CS5, other photo editing/RAW conversion software (CaptureOne); would like to move to video editing capability if that doesn't blow budget... need to learn it but might never really get around to using it.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
Preferably no more than $1k for a new build; less for upgrade. I'm within striking distance of a Micro Center.

3) Which country do you live in? If the U.S, please tell us the state and city if possible.

Atlanta GA

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. The word "Everything" is not a valid answer. Please list out all the parts you'll need.
Mobo/CPU/RAM/cooler(s) for sure... everything else, depends on your advice

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
1. Lian Li PC-V-1000A Plus case (currently houses an Asus A8N32SLI Deluxe with AMD Athlon 64 x2 4800+)
2. WD1500LHFS VelociRaptor boot drive
3. Four (+ one spare) WD7501AALS 750GB Caviar Black data drives, currently in RAID 1+0 because this mobo's RAID is limited to 2TB; would probably go back to RAID 5 with new onboard mobo RAID, unless you guys think I'm really getting a performance boost from the striping; I'm frequently writing big files (20 to 50 GB+) when I save. I need all three: speed, capacity, reliability.
4. Rosewill RV2-700 power supply (this is what the corner shop had in stock when the old Thermaltake died)
5. Lite-On SHW-160P6S-05 DVD burner
6. Mitsumi FA404M floppy
7. Gigabyte nVidia GeForce 6200 (probably replace with onboard graphics of new CPU for now?)
8. All peripherals (monitor, keyboard, mouse, scanner, printers, card readers, etc.)

6) Will you be overclocking?
No

7) 7) What is the max resolution of your monitor? What size is it?
20" 1600x1200

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
ASAP

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? USB 3.0? SATA 6Gb/s? eSATA? Onboard video? etc.
RAID
Firewire & eSATA (for external backup drives)
You tell me - I want to use it for a long time. (Have used current build since 2006)

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? If so, what OS? Is it 32bit or 64bit?
Windows 7 Professional 64-bit


Thanks for any and all advice!
 
Keep the case, the RAID drives, and the peripherals, but it's time to upgrade everything else.

$250 - Intel Core i7 2600
$135 - MSI P67A-G45 (B3)
$80 - Two sets of G.Skill Ripjaws X F3-10666CL9D-8GBXL 2x4GB DDR3 1333 (at $40 each set)
$180 - Crucial m4 128GB SSD (you'll need an adapter)
$185 - XFX HD 6870 1GB
$70 - Antec NEO ECO 620C 620W PSU
=====
$906 - Subtotal (including 2.5" bracket, but not including shipping, taxes, or rebates)

This is more of a complete build designed towards your eventual goal of video editing. Some video editing programs are designed to use Nvidia's CUDA technology, so you may have to decide whether or not the added cost of an Nvidia card, like the GTX 560, is worth it for your needs.

The SSD replaces the VelociRaptor as your primary drive, and it's noticeably faster as well. Again, you'll reuse your Caviar Black drives for storage.

I chose between NewEgg and Micro Center based on which part is cheaper. You should be able to obtain a few discounts from buying everything from Micro Center, but you need to call ahead and see what specials your local store has. (You may also want to ask them whether or not they price-match.)

I omitted the optical drive in the above list, but I recommend buying a new one just to be on the safe side. Any SATA DVD burner that costs less than $25 (for a barebones OEM model) will work.
 
Thanks. Could I get away with no video card for the time being until I get going with video? And do I really need a new PSU?
 
If you want to use the onboard video (which is actually embedded in each Sandy Bridge processor), then you need to find a H67 or Z68 board with IEEE 1394a support. Here are a couple of alternatives:

$90 - MSI H67MA-E45 (H67)
$150 - MSI Z68MA-ED55 (Z68)

The Z68 board has more features geared towards power users but is generally more expensive than the P67 board.

It is recommended that you go with a new power supply for this build. All power supplies degrade in efficiency and power output over time, and even faster/further when constantly pushed through high levels of use. Additionally, many power supplies, including the Rosewill series, are poorly made and can't handle their maximum rated power loads.
 
If you want to get away with no video card for now, you'll need a Z68 motherboard if you want to run with on board video.

The PSU you have is crap, as is with all Rosewill PSUs. I wouldn't trust it with any of my components. That being said, the Antec is a quality PSU.

I'd rather see you go with the GTX 560 Ti instead of the Non Ti version, but that's just me and ONLY if you plan on using the CUDA technology otherwise go with that 6870.

edit
tiraides beat me to it. Everything he said +1
 
The PSU you have is crap, as is with all Rosewill PSUs. I wouldn't trust it with any of my components.
While the Rosewill PSU that the OP have is indeed crap (700W for $60 before rebates or sales? Red Flag right there), not all of Rosewill PSUs are crap. There are some decent quality Rosewill PSUs out there.
 
Thanks guys. So for now I could maybe just go with:

$250 - Intel Core i7 2600
$150 - MSI Z68MA-ED55 (Z68)
$80 - Two sets of G.Skill Ripjaws X F3-10666CL9D-8GBXL 2x4GB DDR3 1333 (at $40 each set)
$70 - Antec NEO ECO 620C 620W PSU
TOTAL: $550

...?

There still seems to be a consensus on the photo processing boards that while an SSD speeds up boot time and some processes noticeably, for actual photo processing it provides little benefit. I can always add one down the road when they get really cheap, or I just decide I want another boost.

Will I need a CPU cooler, or is the stock unit sufficient if I'm not OC'ing?
 
That list looks fine. No need for a 3rd party HSF unless you live in a very warm/hot place where you can't run the AC all the time.
 
Heh... well I do live in Atlanta, and my wife likes to leave the windows open a lot. It will sometimes be in the 85 degree range in the room.

Here's another question that will confirm my level of ignorance: My Asus is a full size ATX board, right? Can I replace it in that case with a micro ATX board?

Also just to make sure I understand... it looks like that MSI Z68 board has four SATA 3Gb/s ports and two SATA 6Gb/s ports. I can run onboard RAID off the four, and have two boot drives on the other two?

My current Asus has a goofy SIL3132 (if I recall correctly) arrangement that requires a driver load to boot off its fifth SATA port... a huge PITA sometimes.
 
Here's a good third-party CPU cooler that won't break the bank:

$30 - Cooler Master Hyper 212 Plus

Your case should be able to fit microATX boards just as well as full ATX boards. (For confirmation, your Asus board is an ATX motherboard.) However, with microATX boards, you generally have a smaller working area (for components) and comparatively fewer features than their "equivalent" ATX counterparts.

Yes, you could run RAID off the four SATA 3Gb/s ports of the MSI Z68MA-ED55.
 
Get the Z68MA-ED55. You can easily afford it; it's only $15 more than the P67A-G45.
 
What's the difference in the 2600 and the 2600k? Should I care?

Also what's the argument for the 2600 or 2600k over the I5-2500k? Worth the extra $100? Are the onboard graphics capabilities any better on the former as opposed to the latter?

Should I maybe get the Z68A in lieu of the MA, since there's room for it?

Thanks for all the help, I really appreciate it.
 
Last edited:
What's the difference in the 2600 and the 2600k? Should I care?
The main difference is that you can overclock the 2600K whereas you can't with the 2600. In addition, the 2600K has a faster onboard video but lacks Intel TXT or Intel VT-d support unlike the 2600. The main difference between the 2600K and the 2500K is that the 2600K has Hyper-Threading support or HT whereas the 2500K does not.
Also what's the argument for the 2600 or 2600k over the I5-2500k? Worth the extra $100? Are the onboard graphics capabilities any better on the former as opposed to the latter?
Your Capture One software as welll as video editing usage are heavily multi-threaded. As such, the HT feature of the 2600K will provide a decent increase in performance in those applications that justifies the extra $70 to $100 over the 2500K.
Should I maybe get the Z68A in lieu of the MA, since there's room for it?
What Z68A are you talking about?
 
It's really overkill for your needs but if you feel like spending money, go for it.
 
Great. So then how does this look?

$170 Z68A-GD65 (B3) LGA 1155 Z68 ATX Intel Motherboard (plus $20 MIR)
$280 Intel Core i7 2600K LGA 1155 Boxed Processor
$24 Cooler Master Hyper 212 Plus Universal CPU Cooler
$96 G.SKILL Ripjaws X Series 8GB (2 x 4GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1333 (PC3 10666) Desktop Memory Model F3-10666CL9D-8GBXL (two at $48)
$70 Antec NEO ECO 620C 620W Continuous Power ATX12V v2.3 / EPS12V 80 PLUS Certified Active PFC Power Supply (plus $20 MIR)

Total $640 less $40 in MIR, plus some tax & maybe some shipping
 
Whoops, it appears there is a (B3) version of that mobo, which is what Micro Center has for $170, and a (G3) version, which Newegg is offering for $190. Newegg is showing the (B3) version as discontinued.

What does this mean?
 
Answer: This says: "...the new MSI "G3" motherboard comes with all the features of the last iteration, with an updated BIOS interface, and new to Intel platforms, PCI Express Generation 3, which is set to add future functionality for upcoming "Ivy bridge" 22 nm CPUs and future videocards from NVIDIA and AMD."
 
My old optical drive won't work with that board, right? Because it has no IDE ports? Will the optical drive eat one of the SATA ports?
 
PCI Express Generation 3 (PCI-E or PCIe 3.0) is the new technology for video cards. Fortunately, however, it is backwards compatible with today's PCI-E 2.x cards. Since PCI-E 3.0 cards aren't going to be available (yet alone needed) for at least another six months, the technology is a nice yet unnecessary luxury. (Apparently, future Z68 boards will have PCI-E 3.0 to differentiate themselves even further from P67/H67 boards.)

Yes, you'll need a new SATA optical drive as the newer boards will have no IDE ports. In fact, I mentioned such in my first post in this thread. Fortunately, the Z68A-GD55 has eight SATA ports, with four SATA 3Gb/s and four SATA 6Gb/s ports (two of those ports are from a different SATA controller).
 
OK thanks. What are the chances my existing Win 7 64-bit install will boot in this rig? That would save me a day's work right there...
 
It's a coin toss. For some people, they can transfer the hard drive(s) over with no trouble, but others have had to reinstall Windows 7 onto their new machines.
 
Do I need to leave SATA mode set to IDE, not RAID or AHCI, in order to have any hope of that working?
 
I don't see where I have such an option on the old box. This is a 2006-vintage mobo ...? Does it matter? Does setting AHCI or RAID vs. IDE mode significantly affect performance on a single drive?

RAID questions:

1. My old onboard RAID limits total array size to 2TB. Is there any such limit with these newer boards we're discussing?

2. Do you think I'm getting much of a performance boost with my current RAID 1+0 setup (four 750GB = ~1.4TB RAID) vs. RAID 5 (four 750GB = ~2.1TB RAID)? If not, I'd just as soon have the extra space. I only set it up as RAID 1+0 in the first place because I bought the four drives thinking it might just squeeze in under the array size limit in RAID 5, but it didn't. Subjectively it seemed markedly faster, but that might just as easily have been due to the speed of the new drives vs. the old as opposed to the RAID configuration.

Oh and one more... If I decide to get wild and crazy and press the overclock-o-matic button on that mobo, will the recommended power supply still be up to the task?
 
Last edited:
I don't see where I have such an option on the old box. This is a 2006-vintage mobo ...? Does it matter? Does setting AHCI or RAID vs. IDE mode significantly affect performance on a single drive?
I have and have seen mobos from 2006 have that option. So check your BIOs again for SATA options. Yes it does matter from both a performance standpoint and the success of transfering the OS over standpoint. Your existing Windows 7 install will not work in a new PC if the SATA mode in the new mobo isn't set exactly the same as the SATA mode as the old mobo. Otherwise, you'll have to do a fresh OS reinstall.
1. My old onboard RAID limits total array size to 2TB. Is there any such limit with these newer boards we're discussing?
AFAIK, no. I remember a while back someone doing a 4TB RAID5 array with the ICH10R storage controller. Considering that your mobo choice has the same ICH10R controller, should be fine from a size standpoint.

However there may be a compatibility issue with those Green drives when using them in a RAID 5 array on many current motherboards.
2. Do you think I'm getting much of a performance boost with my current RAID 1+0 setup (four 750GB = ~1.4TB RAID) vs. RAID 5 (four 750GB = ~2.1TB RAID)? If not, I'd just as soon have the extra space. I only set it up as RAID 1+0 in the first place because I bought the four drives thinking it might just squeeze in under the array size limit in RAID 5, but it didn't. Subjectively it seemed markedly faster, but that might just as easily have been due to the speed of the new drives vs. the old as opposed to the RAID configuration.
RAID 1+0 is generally faster than RAID 5. However do note that your current RAID array is not transferrable to the new motherboard. You will have to recreate the RAID array which means all that data will be lost if it hasn't been backed up.
Oh and one more... If I decide to get wild and crazy and press the overclock-o-matic button on that mobo, will the recommended power supply still be up to the task?
It should. Though if you're feeling spendy, then go for the Corsair 650TX V2 650W PSU. Note the V2 in the name.
 
I have and have seen mobos from 2006 have that option. So check your BIOs again for SATA options. Yes it does matter from both a performance standpoint and the success of transfering the OS over standpoint. Your existing Windows 7 install will not work in a new PC if the SATA mode in the new mobo isn't set exactly the same as the SATA mode as the old mobo. Otherwise, you'll have to do a fresh OS reinstall.

Hmmm... what if I were to, say, set for AHCI or RAID mode, initialize the disk using a new Win 7 OS install, then restore a Win 7 backup image to it from the old install?
 
Hmmm... what if I were to, say, set for AHCI or RAID mode, initialize the disk using a new Win 7 OS install, then restore a Win 7 backup image to it from the old install?

Probably wouldn't work since the backup image is of the old install. Remember that the image is an exact copy of the OS as it was at the time of the install.
 
Back
Top