Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
With the world’s problems solved, U.S. Senators have now turned to important issues like the Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act. Who cares about losing your job or your home, the real “silent killer” is electric cars…in crosswalks. The added bonus is that tax dollars will be used to conduct this “study.”

The Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act of 2009 requires the Secretary of Transportation to conduct a study on how to protect the blind and others from being injured or killed by vehicles using hybrid, electric, and other silent engine technologies.
 
"Dude, my prius is so good for the environment, I'm helping save the world."
"yeah, but how many blind people have you killed since you got it?"
"3". :eek:

I don't see how there's enough of these cars on the road already for this to be a problem? I suppose maybe in San Francisco w/ their fart sniffing smuggies, but couldn't they just do something on a local level? I just don't see this being a big enough problem to warrant federal resources.
 
It's more of the same bullshit. Can't use coal power because it's to dirty, can't use nuclear because it's scary and will cause everyone to have 3 eyes. Can't use wind because stupid birds fly into the blades and get killed, can't use tidal, because the fish and whales are to dumb to go around the devices. Wait, we have clean coal now, but we'll tax and regulate it so heavily it's not feasible.

Now we want to get rid of gas powered cars because they are bad for the environment and we need electric cars, but they kill blind people. I guess we'll all just have to walk while our elected officials ride in peasant powered rickshaws.
 
Well, regardless of how we end up getting our energy, the fundamental problem is just that there's too damn many people. Honestly, I really don't think there's any way in hell we can sustain the lifestyle we have in the quantity (world population) without having a huge impact on the planet. The energy has to come from somewhere, and we use a shit ton of it. No matter how you go about it, it's going to have an impact one way or another.
 
Follow these simple rules:

Drivers: Pay attention to pedestrians.

Pedestrians: Pay attention to drivers. (if blind, get a seeing-eye dog)

Problem solved.
 
Heh, to scratch wounds, I was right about a post made a long time ago that turned into a huge flame war
 
Follow these simple rules:

Drivers: Pay attention to pedestrians.

Pedestrians: Pay attention to drivers. (if blind, get a seeing-eye dog)

Problem solved.

That has too much common sense for the general population and government of the USA.
 
If people would take off their iPods and LISTEN, they could hear the electric vehicles. Even if the engine is quiet, they still have plenty of tire and other noises. When I walk around, I can easily hear them.
 
Cars have been quiet for years. Most of the noise you hear is wind and tire noise anyway. I mean really if the car is five feet away you might hear a lifter tapping if your lucky. This is full of fail.
 
The government tries to do the right thing and take care of something before it's a problem, and you still complain? What's with the bitchin'?
 
Survival of the fittest, bitches.

Shift to serious... this is absolutely ridiculous. We should all be focused on what's really important right now: Swine Flu. Or better yet, the question if Swine Flu is an offensive term.

When will people smarten up and figure out when there's an onslaught of garbage news like there has been in the past few days the corporate-owned media is drawing your attention away from a real story? News is not news, nor has it been for a long time, it's advertising.
 
Have you ever been next to an electric car? They are seriously silent in a parking lot, with only a small squeak of a tire when they turn. I almost got hit by one while I was working, and I've got great sight.
 
With every piece of computer hardware in the world reviewed, technology site editors have begun covering issues like politics.

Yeah, something tells me you don't have a great handle on how policy making or appropriations work, Steve. This isn't a several month long witch hunt for steroids in baseball, it's a minor bill that could be very helpful for many people.
 
Holy freakin' crap...

The Prius (or any hybrid, or even pure electric vehicle,) is *NOT SILENT*!!

Our Subaru Forester makes less noise coming down the hill to our house than our Prius does. The Prius just makes a *DIFFERENT* kind of noise. Yes, it's a noise that people don't notice because they're not used to that sound meaning "car", but it is sound. Just because it doesn't go "VROOM VROOM" doesn't mean it's silent.

I'm definitely writing my congresspeople (All three of which are enviro-nuts, by the way, I believe all three drive Priuses (Prii?) in D.C.)
 
My Electric car will be outfitted with a PA speaker, and it will be playing LOUDLY....

The sound of flying cars on The Jetsons!!!!! :eek::rolleyes::p

Safety Act that motherfucker.
 
Clearly we can't be trusted to look both ways before crossing, anymore. :rolleyes:

So you also expect blind people to "look" both ways?

Follow these simple rules:

Drivers: Pay attention to pedestrians.

Pedestrians: Pay attention to drivers. (if blind, get a seeing-eye dog)

Problem solved.

This leaves out one group, those who are visually impaired but not blind. They do not qualify for a seeing-eye dog but might still need to use their hearing to complement their vision when e.g. crossing a road.

Cars have been quiet for years. Most of the noise you hear is wind and tire noise anyway. I mean really if the car is five feet away you might hear a lifter tapping if your lucky. This is full of fail.

It depends on where the crossing is. In the city where cars travel slower and frequently brake and accelerate, the engine noise is more dominant. On a main road this is replaced by mostly tire and wind noise.

This doesn't seem to be about banning hybrid vehicles like some of you think. it's just a study to find ways to prevent the blind from getting killed when crossing the road. Obviously if you're not blind it's a "waste of money", but sometimes you have to accept that some of your money has to go towards improving the situation for a minority. Or maybe most of you want to do like the nazis and kill everyone who's blind, deaf etc. at birth or before?
 
I guess I'm lucky.. only blind in my left eye, deaf in my right ear! :p

Seriously though, I think this bill is a good idea now, precisely because we are only at the infancy of the technology.. It shouldn't be too difficult to figure out a way to add some kind of distinctive, yet not overly annoying, sound to these types of vehicles.

It's a hell of a lot better to do this now, instead of 15 years from now when there are millions of these on the road, then having to retrofit all of them.
 
Just let people turn their stereos up real loud, I can hear those guys with the overkill subwoofer cars almost a minute before they even pass by. More importantly, when I read "Pedestrian safety enhancement act" I heard the Combine Overwatch voice from HL2 in my head saying it... does that make me paranoid, a nerd, or is it just a sign of the times?
 
it's going to be a really big embarrassment when their study (even though all this information is already the fuck out there), finds that hybrids don't hit people as a percentage of cars that they make up than every other car out there.

This is retarded, I'm fucking tired of all these ADA type regulations that get passed, blind people need to have those yellow bumps whenever there's no clear curb (the actual rules I'm unsure of), as a result the city of San Francisco has spent untold amounts of money putting them in, even in areas where people don't walk much less blind! CostCo? Whole fucking store surrounded by them! Ramp that comes out of a parking garage... yup blind bumps! (You really need to think about that last one for a second!)
 
I would rather see R&D on a portable device that melts atomizes car that drives way to close to me when I ride my bike.
 
I'm all for deaf and blind people having pedestrian assistance. so that "someone has their back", so to speak.
 
I would rather see R&D on a portable device that melts atomizes car that drives way to close to me when I ride my bike.

need more pro-bicycle movement in general for the roadways. Bicycle lanes mandatory for major streets. Would think you could get anywhere on a bike, but i cant even make the 20 miles from college to my home due to a poorly bicycle conscious city and river in between.
 
Let's face it,if you're in the path of an oncoming car,regardless of the noise it makes,you're probably going to be roadkill before you react.You only need one safety device to prevent this - it's called a brain.
 
need more pro-bicycle movement in general for the roadways. Bicycle lanes mandatory for major streets. Would think you could get anywhere on a bike, but i cant even make the 20 miles from college to my home due to a poorly bicycle conscious city and river in between.

Bikes aren't realistic. Want to put some bike lanes on a highway with cars going 60-70mph? I know you said "streets," but still. They put those bike lanes near my house, and the bicyclists only interfere with the traffic. Not only does it slow you down, but you have to watch out for them constantly. If you go in the city, it's even worse. If you want to bicycle, either do it through a park, on a mountain, on side streets, or at the gym. If you can't afford a car or some other form of transportation, well I feel for you, but I don't think we need to legislate special lanes for the fraction of people who use bikes for purposes outside of recreation. The same goes for this whole thing with the blind. Why do the blind get their own laws? How about a law for the elderly that requires all crosswalks have a minimum of five minutes to cross?

With new technology always comes new challenges, but part of the solution is to give up the old and take advantage of the present. Sure, in the age before "silent" cars the blind didn't have much of a problem, but there are other ways to solve our dilemma. Want to make some money? Design a radar device to alert of large objects in motion, or design a device that picks up on the electrical frequencies of the car that subsequently signals the blind. Some ideas may be possible, others may not. At the same time, don't try to legislate or force things just because they once were ideal but are now impractical.
 
In under a years time (two in the same week), on the same 100 yard length of street downtown, three people with working eyes and supposedly working eyes have walked right out in front of slow moving buses and been hit.

Sadly they've all survived.

Is it that hard to turn your head or your entire self, and look before jumping out? We don't have many fatties with this being Sweden so they have no excuse to be that lazy. Next time this happens I'm going to film it while pointing and laughing and put it on youtube and comfort the bus driver (yaknow, tell him his bus will be alright, it wasn't his fault) rather than take care of the suicidal idiot who's lying knocked out on the tarmac.
 
Working in a car park, I can tell you guys that these scare the shit out of me.

I rely very heavily upon being able to hear cars, and in amongst all the "regular" cars, you just don't hear the hybrids.

Some car parks have surfaces that don't create tyre noise at all, so these are 100% silent.

I've never come close to being hit by one, but they do startle you quite a lot when they just "appear" from nowhere.

Sure I'm in the habit of looking over my shoulder, because noone can drive for shit, (#1 rule in a car park, I don't care if you're schumachar, I assume you can't drive), but there are just times when you have to rely upon hearing cars too.

My solution is to fit them with spokey dokies. :D No study is needed, anyone with half a brain and no $ vested interest $ in research $$$$$$ would know you just need to add noise to these vehicles.
 
This will be a nuisance and not save a single life.

Most people who get hit by cars get hit in traffic, not by some sneaky lone vehicle all by itself. The reason is simple: In times of high traffic, it's impossible to rely on your hearing to detect a single car coming with all the ambient noise anyway. You have to rely on your vision. This is why the blind cannot safely navigate around cities without a doggy to help.

People can't even manage to avoid getting run over with the roads filled with plenty noisy vehicles. It wouldn't be any better with roads filled with electric cars with noisemakers on them.

Just another solution in search of a problem.
 
So they add some kind of noise to the quiet cars and get rid of one of the potential reasons to buy them.

Or they come up with some retarded new traffic law that will slow things down, lengthen commutes, and burn more energy by forcing cars to be on the road for a longer period of time to make the same trip.

How about this: each member of Congress just pisses off for a while. Go away. The world will not stop spinning without weekly legislation dictating its rotation.
 
Lots of inconsiderate inconsiderate idiots here. Because you're fine with seeing cars and avoiding them everyone else should be or are stupid?

Fuckwits.

Some people can't see terribly well and partly rely on their hearing. Maybe partially sighted people should stay in their homes so you dont waste your 5 dollars taxpayer money? All blind ppl should get a dog? I mean, fuck considering whether a seeing eye dog is suitable for all blind people, just make an idiotic statement.

This isnt about putting a "hot water"sign on top of a tap. This is about a potential issue which may affect a suprisingly large portion of the population and dealing with it BEFORE it becomes a real problem.
 
It's a proposed bill. People propose lots of bills. It might be passed, it might not, but it's moronic to be debating it on a hardware site.

Just to fit in, I'll just respond like 90% of you:

"I don't know anything about this and I'm not blind but we can't afford this shit man why isn't the Senate solving swine flu or something important man oh man our government sucks we should all move to nowhere because they're all so socialist."

Wow. What an enriching debate.
 
Back
Top