Patent Troll Targets Minecraft

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Uniloc sounds like something you would find on a lowjack setup, but in fact, it is a well-known patent troll who is now targeting Mojang, the creator of Minecraft, for patent infringement. ‘Notch’ Persson, the owner of Mojang is determined to fight the suit with all resources at his disposal.

But it might need to improve its own game, as the filing misspells its target as "Mindcraft", and developer Markus "Notch" Persson has already vowed not to give in.
 
I want to patent the while, repeat, and for loops. I'll make billions :)
 
Would anyone mind if Patent trolls (including Apple) were to be systematically and ruthlessly assassinated?
 
It was in beta for how long? And they are saying something only now? Not saying the suit has any merit, just what trolls do, I guess.
 
This happened because the other ones paid up!

Rule: Never pay ransoms! Instead, pay double to have them taken out!
 
...by or through making, using, offering for sale, selling and/or importing Android based applications for use on cellular phones and/or tablet devices that require communication with a server to perform a license check to prevent the unauthorized use of said application...

So basically Uniloc patented a process that was common on games and possibly other software by the late-90's (verifying a serial key with a remote server for online play) and some idiot at the patent office let them have it.
 
So basically Uniloc patented a process that was common on games and possibly other software by the late-90's (verifying a serial key with a remote server for online play) and some idiot at the patent office let them have it.

It should be possible to take a case against the Patent Office; otherwise it should be shut down as it is open to corruption etc.:eek:
 
From the article:

"Filed in 2001 and awarded in 2005, Uniloc's patent describes a system for "preventing unauthorized access to electronic data" which involves communication between a portable device and a license registration authority. Uniloc claims that this patent gives it rights to software that verifies licensing on the Android operating system."

Doesn't this apply to a lot of Android software, and possibly Apple's iOS software, as well?

This patent, like with many other software patents, are too broad in their definition. And, I'm sure Mojang isn't the only company that uses a server for a license check on the Android platform.

It's absolutely ridiculous what these patent trolls do.

Notch gave a statement not too long ago: http://notch.tumblr.com/post/27751395263/on-patents

He is right on this:
[quote}But there is no way in hell you can convince me that it’s beneficial for society to not share ideas. Ideas are free. They improve on old things, make them better, and this results in all of society being better. Sharing ideas is how we improve.[/quote]
If we fail to share and cooperate, how will we ever benefit not only ourselves but others as well? I've always believed in the fact that through cooperation and sharing of ideas that we can improve the society we live in, and the technology that helps us-- everything from electronics to medicine.

Locking down ideas to patents and asking monetary compensation for them, and suing others just to keep your ideas, whether beneficial or not, to yourself is not just trolling, but downright greedy and underhanded.

I hope some day we move to an open patent system or do away with patents on ideas. In an open patent system, in my head, one would be given to the original idea or work, but allow it to be openly AND freely used by others, especially if it is beneficial to other people.
 
Wasn't minecraft based off that Infiniminer game? If anyone could actually sue them it would be them, but they haven't. also infiniminer would also probably be liable...:eek:
 
A copy protection system.....why do I have a feeling there is a ton of prior art that can invalidate this patent going back about 30 years?
 
In an open patent system, in my head, one would be given to the original idea or work, but allow it to be openly AND freely used by others, especially if it is beneficial to other people.

Greed > Helping Others

It'd never work. Corporations won't dump money into R&D if they can't get more money out of it. Individuals would be less inclined to develop ideas because larger entities would simply swoop in and make all the profit off of it.

What's needed is reform. Better checks and balances (full prior art check). Less time for patents to expire. I think Sonny Bono got certain creations up to 100 years ... that's insane.
 
There will be a special hell prepared for such trolls.

Hmm. The hell of being cut to pieces, or the hell of the upside down sinners are a couple of good choices.

You know, the Chinese have a lot of hells.
 
Wouldnt anything that has a login that communicates with another system fall under this?
 
A copy protection system.....why do I have a feeling there is a ton of prior art that can invalidate this patent going back about 30 years?

Because you haven't studied the patent or read the claims. Very good, very expensive lawyers have been unable to defeat this patent on invalidity grounds previously. I'm not saying it's impossible, but I bet the parties reach a settlement.
 
I hope not. I for one never really like MineCraft... nor the creator. Seemed a bit arrogant to me. But I hope he wins this, and beats the living shit out of this patent troll, so they go into bankruptcy. Furthermore, I hope the company... some how the lawsuit gets entangled into the owners and lawyers involved, getting them barred and go into bankrupt as well for harboring and trying to enforce stupid ass patents such as this.
 
Because you haven't studied the patent or read the claims. Very good, very expensive lawyers have been unable to defeat this patent on invalidity grounds previously. I'm not saying it's impossible, but I bet the parties reach a settlement.

Many will pay the cost of the settlement, as a preference to paying the cost in the case.

Myself, I would not have granted the patent in the first place as it seems to general. It seems to general in the sense that all communications networks require some kind of pass-code authentication log-on process in order to access some kind of account.

As the Judge, therefore, I would look for something specifically different between the two systems, in the patent challenge, however small, and then dismiss the case on that, and then order the patent owner to pay costs in the case.

Yes, stupidity, or ignorance, is a form of corruption. To avoid corruption, one needs to increase ones attention to detail. In the case of a patent, you should go down to the level of detail used in the definition for it, and then reflect the same on the competing system. If there any differences at that LOD, then they are not the same. The ability to prove where that necessary LOD lies, is the key.
 
I will patent the process of subpena-ing companies/people (same thing now, right?) for patent litigation. Then, I will have all the monies in the world.
 
Back
Top