P4P800 vs. IC7

LstBrunnenG

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Jun 3, 2003
Messages
6,677
In a short time I am going to be in posession of both an Asus P4P800 and an Abit IC7. The P4P800 was my first motherboard, but it fried (twice), so I gave up and bought an IC7. Then last week I decided to RMA the P4P800 (the CPU socket was in flames...I truly doubt that that was my fault).

One will be kept, the other paired up with a 2.4A and sold. So obviously if the P4P800 dies with a Prescott and the Abit doesn't care about the difference, then the Abit is the only choice. Or vice versa.

As I see it:

Pros of IC7:
875P chipset
Firewire

Cons of IC7:
No PAT w/ 4 DIMMs (my current situation)
No onboard LAN (currently using a card)

Pros of P4P800:
Onboard Gigabit Ethernet
Possibility of PAT w/4 DIMMs (haven't tried in a long time)

Cons of P4P800:
No firewire
PAT not a certainty
Possibility of it bursting into flames again

One more thing: the reason I was considering selling the P4P800 to this friend of mine is that it only fried when I was in the case doing something. (And yes, the power was off at the time.) It ran from June-August just fine until I was playing with my fans or something and then from August-March just dandy until I was cleaning up my wiring job. Therefore, logic dictates that if there is no fiddling, there will be a much lower chance of failure. Besides that, he'll be using a different processor, RAM, and case. I don't hear about any other users who have had P4P800s die on them quite so often so it's probably something in my setup that it doesn't like.
 
I had a P4P800 and liked it. Except for the voltage problems it (and just about all others) seemed to have. It really needed a droop mod for stable overclocking. And vdimm was limited to 2.8v so a vdimm mod was needed to push your ram farther. But other than that it was a really fast board. few a few $ more get the P4P800-deluxe as it has firewire.

BTW, PAT is disabled completely on the P4P800 if you go past 200fsb. There are ways around it which work great as I did them myself...but just an FYI.

I sold mine and got an Abit AI7. I can overclock to about the same point, but the voltages are much more stable and vdimm goes all the way to 3.2v. (not to mention it has more fan headers than the P4P did)
 
Back
Top