P45 Mobo Recommendations

Deeky

Gawd
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
982
I'm looking to step up from my P35 mobo (GA-P35-DS3R) to something with Crossfire potential, or at least dedicated PhysX card potential (which I've heard is possible on Intel boards - is this actually the case?) ... I have no interest in stepping up to i7 yet, I'm running a Q9550 and the upgrade investment simply does not justify the gains in my opinion. Definite improvement, but a little too parallel considering I'd need a new board, ram and processor.

I posted a thread similar to this a week or two ago, but I was a quite vague with my requirements. I've since done some research and I'm a little more focused.

Any recommendations with regard to P45 mobos? I'm not interested in DDR3, so X48 is out. X38 maybe. I'd consider X38 for the dual x16, but that's about the only real bonus (though somewhat important, I suppose). P45 seems like the sweet spot. Not too pricey, PCI 2.0, Xfire potential, overclockable/stable, more PCI-e slots overall. Layout is important as that's one of the key reasons I'm looking to leave my current board (besides offering zero upgrade potential). The recent addition of a PCI-e 1.0 sound card to my rig has really made a mess. Only one PCI slot capable of accommodating the card and the placement is terrible. I'm concerned for my hardware.

I've enjoyed my Gigabyte board, I'd definitely buy one of their products again (EP45-UD3P maybe?). ASUS of course. I'd be willing to look at any brand, assuming the mobo is considered solid. Recommendations?

EDIT: RAID is not necessary. I purchased the DS3R thinking I'd eventually pursue a RAID setup, but that's never going to happen. I'm quite happy with hotswappable drives in AHCI.
 
Last edited:
I have a Gigabyte EP45-UD3P, and it's pretty nice. So far I have even gotten a nice overclock out of my CPU. But one problem, one of the Gigabit LANs burned out on the board so only one left is working. This sucks, but I don't know if it will happen to other people. Just buy a one or two year warranty on the board, it's not that expensive, and then you will be able to RMA it if any problems arise.
 
Cool, thanks for that. I just remembered/rediscovered that many X48 boards include DDR2 support, so I guess that opens a door. Still, I think X38 would be the better choice for me beyond P45. X48 would be good if I intended to make the leap to DDR3 at some point ... but in that case, I'd simply go LGA 1366. X38 is short listed for dual x16, though I do realize DDR2 somewhat hobbles the potential.
 
Last edited:
I have a Gigabyte EP45-UD3P, and it's pretty nice. So far I have even gotten a nice overclock out of my CPU. But one problem, one of the Gigabit LANs burned out on the board so only one left is working. This sucks, but I don't know if it will happen to other people. Just buy a one or two year warranty on the board, it's not that expensive, and then you will be able to RMA it if any problems arise.


Well, Gigabyte does have a three year warranty, but it is from the date of board manufacture, not date of purchase. My board also has one of the two lan ports that used to go out every so often. It would die for a week, than it would just start working again. :confused:
 
Don't get an x38 motherboard if you plan on overclocking a 45nm quadcore. The most I was able to get out of mine was 3.7ghz until I switched to a UD3P and hit 4.2 easy. I know not all X38's suffer from the FSB wall, but it seems too hit and miss. Only downside I see to the P45 is if you are xf'ing high end cards. The x8/x8 limitation may have an impact on peak gaming performance.
 
If you're looking for a P45 mATX, the DFI Lanparty Jr. is a good choice to OC a Q9550. I have my Q9550 at 4.0 at 471 x 8.5. And the reviews for the Lanparty Jr. is generally good.
 
Thanks for the input. The UD3P looks solid if not for the ridiculous placement of the PCI-e 1.0 slots, one of which I hope to use for an Auzentech sound card. With a two slot GPU in the top x16, there's only one other slot on board for the card and that would be the second x16, which I want for Xfire or a dedicated PhysX. The Asus P5Q Turbo is much better in this regard. I won't be shooting for a record breaking overclock, just something north of modest but well shy of insane.

I'll skip x38. If I do decide to beyond P45 it would be to Asus Rampage Forumla territory, which is likely more board than I need but the x16/x16 is nice for a pair of DX11 cards and the layout is awesome. Double the price, though. Same coin as a modest i7 board. :rolleyes:
 
UD3P has three PCI-E 1x slots... I'm looking at mine right now. There are two PCI-E 1x slots above the top-most PCI-E 16x slot.
 
+1 on the UD3P.

I got my DS3L about a month before the UD3 series was released and regretted not waiting to get one. I've had zero luck with my DS3L being able to get it to run at 400mhz bus speeds. 7*400 doesn't work (tried vcore upto 1.4v and MCH upto 1.26v with little luck) and yet 9*358 works with a small voltage boost (1.30 vcore and 1.2v MCH).
 
UD3P has three PCI-E 1x slots... I'm looking at mine right now. There are two PCI-E 1x slots above the top-most PCI-E 16x slot.

Yup, but the one below the first x16 slot will be covered by a double-wide GFX card. The other two south of the northbridge, any card longer than an X-fi Titanium will be blocked by the DIMMS. Smart design on Creative's part, too bad Auzen and ASUS make better sound cards (just too damn long). EDIT: Actually, I might be wrong. There might be enough room in the PCI-e slots above the GPU. The card is 6.25 inches. Can anyone with the mobo confirm? Does anyone run a Forte with this board? That card is even longer, almost 7 inches.

Hard to deny it. The UD3P is hands down the easiest thing to recommend, it would seem. What about the P5Q Deluxe? It seems to be well loved.
 
Last edited:
Well, Gigabyte does have a three year warranty, but it is from the date of board manufacture, not date of purchase.

I don't understand what you mean "by date of board manufacture". The box says 3 years warranty in US and Canada.
 
What about the P5Q Deluxe? It seems to be well loved.
The P5Q Deluxe is a good board, although it tends to be overpriced. That's why I recommend the P5Q Pro Turbo instead. It cuts down on unnecessary features while keeping the important ones, and costs quite a bit less.
 
Arg. I'm so hung up on the x8/x8. I intend to jump to DX11 in the future, planning on a single card SLI/Xfire solution (waiting for the Nvidia offering to appear, for comparison). I had hoped to use the second x16 slot for a dedicated PhysX card, if only because my 285 GTX is too beefy to collect dust on a shelf or wallow in a server box. I'm worried I'll be hamstrung by the lack of lanes. At the same time, x38/48 boards seem crazy expensive at the moment ... I've also got an eye on the ASUS Rampage Formula or the P5E Deluxe.
 
Last edited:
i am just fucking around but i still want guys to know that there are viable options out there besides gb and asus, including dfi, evga and biostar.

http://www.ewiz.com/detail.php?name...c9fecd22579bc56eb5dcd479d46dad4cf8e9d45f9c8c1


16 lane pcie slots for you.

Gotcha. Yeah, each motherboard should be evaluated relative to the others and ultimately should be selected based on the user's needs/preferences. GB and ASUS are certainly not the only motherboard companies.
 
GA-EP45-UD3P is the best p45 board period board overclock well even with the power saving features love the pci setup makes my case look really clean keeping everything so low , cant fir a Forte sound card so I went with the titanium fatality which is great sounding and great looking at same time
 
GA-EP45-UD3P is the best p45 board period board overclock well even with the power saving features love the pci setup makes my case look really clean keeping everything so low , cant fir a Forte sound card so I went with the titanium fatality which is great sounding and great looking at same time

One of my favorite P45 boards as well. Highly recommended everywhere.
 
GA-EP45-UD3P is the best p45 board period board overclock well even with the power saving features love the pci setup makes my case look really clean keeping everything so low , cant fir a Forte sound card so I went with the titanium fatality which is great sounding and great looking at same time

This, end of story.
 
Alright all you UD3P lovers. You win. But I have one last question:

If I want to run something like a x1 sound card in the second PCI x16 slot, is there a way to configure it so the first slot remains x16 and does not switch to x8?

If not, I may have to go with the UD3R. I'm not sure if the UD3P will work for me, layout wise (actually, not sure if the UD3R is much better).
 
Last edited:
Alright all you UD3P lovers. You win. But I have one last question:

If I want to run something like a x1 sound card in the second PCI x16 slot, is there a way to configure it so the first slot remains x16 and does not switch to x8?

If not, I may have to go with the UD3L. I'm not sure if the UD3P will work for me, layout wise.

How many x1 cards do you have?
 
UD3R is is, then.

Actually, what's the dif between the UD3R and the UD3L? Just the stock cooling? No RAID? It has a better layout for my needs. At the very least there will be guaranteed room for my Auzentech.

I only have one x1 card, but it might not fit in the two slots above the GFX card (too long, might hit the DIMMS) and the other x1 slot will be blocked by a double-wide 285.
 
Last edited:
UD3R is is, then.

Actually, what's the dif between the UD3R and the UD3L? Just the stock cooling? No RAID? It has a better layout for my needs. At the very least there will be guaranteed room for my Auzentech.

I only have one x1 card, but it might not fit in the two slots above the GFX card (too long, might hit the DIMMS) and the other x1 slot will be blocked by a double-wide 285.

How long is your auzentech card?
 
How long is your auzentech card?

6.25 inches. UD3L is definitely smaller than the R, no chance of the card fitting north of the GFX card. The R has a shot. I think I'll take a chance on the UD3R, there are a few notable differences between the L and the R. If my calculations are correct, the card should fit without hitting the first DIMM.

If anyone can confirm, I'd really appreciate it.
 
Last edited:
6.25 inches. UD3L is definitely smaller than the R, no chance of the card fitting north of the GFX card. The R has a shot. I think I'll take a chance on the UD3R, there are a few notable differences between the L and the R. If my calculations are correct, the card should fit without hitting the first DIMM.

If anyone can confirm, I'd really appreciate it.

Your card should fit in the top x1 slots on either the UD3R or the UD3P.
 
ASUS P5Q Pro Turbo or Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3P is what I recommend.

For what its worth... i built a batch of 6, P5Q Pro Turbo boards last week (standard build no overclocking), and two had to be sent back on RMA to distributor, the other 4 were no longer compatible with 4GB of Corsair memory that i have used sucessfully on these boards before, (exact model memory is listed on the QVL on Asus website, but now no longer compatible).. i ended up having to go with some kingston value ram to get the remaining 4 boards to work this time.

I would avoid the Pro Turbo, as their recent builds, have had way to many issues, and given me nothing but headaches.. Go with the Gigabyte one instead, i replaced the other two boards with Gigabyte equivalent P45 chipset board, and they worked fine with all memory i gave it, and no RMA required.

The older P5Q Pro, was far more reliable then the Pro Turbo, if you get lucky and can still find it since its been discontinued.
 
Your card should fit in the top x1 slots on either the UD3R or the UD3P.

Thanks, Sixty. I did some additional posting on the Head-fi boards and a member confirmed that his ASUS Essence STX fits in the top x1 slot without hitting the DIMM, with about "3mm to spare." According to reviews, the STX is 168mm or just over 6.6 inches long. So yeah, between your confirmation and that info, it looks like I'll have room to spare going with the DS3P/R.

Cheers for the info, interested.
 
Back
Top