Orthos vs. Supreme Commander, which proves stability?

Camaroz06

Gawd
Joined
Jan 26, 2007
Messages
642
Ok,
For all that think Orthos run for any long amount of time proves a system is stable take this into consideration. I have my overclock at 3.5ghz and it is orthos stable for 24 hours and I have run 3dmark after the orthos run too. I go to play Supcom lastnight and load up a 8 player supreme AI map and play to see just how stable it is. Game crashes 4 times, granted its about an hour into the match and there are a lot of units. O kept upping the voltage but it seemed to crash still, I also ran orthos again (blend pri 9) and it didnt crash. So where do you guys think the problem is? When I looked at the error report for Supcom it mentioned direct X so I am thinking it has something to do with the video card. Another thing that makes me think its the video card is when I try to go for 3.6ghz orthos runs and superpi runs but 3dmark will not run. So does anyone have any ideas? Maybe the info is having trouble going through the PCI bus? who knows.

Thanks,
Eddie
 
yeah, i would go by the real world results. Why would you want something that is stable "on paper" but not in the real world.

Driver issue maybe? I really dont know
 
When I had it at 3.4ghz Supcom never crashed, it seems when I go past 3.4ish there starts to be other insabilities, mostly with the video card I think. Is that normal? It would seem to me if you just keep upping the FSB eventually something else if left alone has to become the weak link.
 
The problem with using a game as a test for stability is that there are a lot more variables at play, like video driver issues or audio driver issues. Orthos tests the CPU and memory but doesn't really test anything else. Best test for your problem is dropping back to stock and see if SupComm still crashes - then you'll know where the issue is.
 
Ok,
For all that think Orthos run for any long amount of time proves a system is stable take this into consideration. I have my overclock at 3.5ghz and it is orthos stable for 24 hours and I have run 3dmark after the orthos run too. I go to play Supcom lastnight and load up a 8 player supreme AI map and play to see just how stable it is. Game crashes 4 times, granted its about an hour into the match and there are a lot of units. O kept upping the voltage but it seemed to crash still, I also ran orthos again (blend pri 9) and it didnt crash. So where do you guys think the problem is? When I looked at the error report for Supcom it mentioned direct X so I am thinking it has something to do with the video card. Another thing that makes me think its the video card is when I try to go for 3.6ghz orthos runs and superpi runs but 3dmark will not run. So does anyone have any ideas? Maybe the info is having trouble going through the PCI bus? who knows.

Thanks,
Eddie

Crashing to desktop in Supreme Commander while playing 8 player maps is not a stability problem it's a problem in the 1.0 version of the game, even THQ have said that. ;) It should probably be fixable with a patch by now... Anyway try to underclock your CPU and then play an 8 player map in Supreme Commander, you'll find that after approximately one hour you'll crash there too...
 
Yeah that sounds like a software issue. If you're 24 hours orthos stable you can pretty much rest easy that you have a stable rig on your hands.

Although, you might try OCCT as well?
 
I tried to do some OCCT testing for RAM and CPU, I put it on high priority. Damn thing ran my computer hard I couldnt do any web surfing at the same time. Test failed about 1 houe 20mins into testing...not due to hardware but due to my girlfriend asking me to turn off the computer since the fans are so loud :) . Oh well better to have a happy girlfriend! Ill do more testing this week sometime.
 
Darth Bobo is right. This is a known issue with SupCom and doesn't have a tie in with your computer's stability.

Special Note: 8-Player Games: A known issue exists for Update 3220, where
some 8-player games experience crashes during gameplay. Initial testing indicates a
memory allocation issue. However, stats indicate that 8-player games are
approximately .5% of all games being played, so our decision was to release the
update with this known issue.
 
Back
Top