Oracle Claims Google 'Directly Copied' Java in Android

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Now we know why all those Street View cars were circling Oracle…they were stealing code! :p

Oracle has amended its lawsuit against Google to overtly accuse the company of stealing code for Android. The initially vague complaint was changed Wednesday to charge Google with having "directly copied" several parts of code outright. About a third of the Java APIs used by developers are also "derivative" of ones Oracle uses, the updated suit read.
 
dear giant companies, stop complaining about other giant companies and do something for the american society that gave you the opportunity to be giant companies.

thanks.
 
True story: I used to work in an office building in Austin, TX that housed offices for both Google and Oracle. I guess someone at Oracle left a thumb drive lying around, or maybe they failed to secure their network properly.
 
I knew the Oracle buyout of Sun Microsystems would be the start of crap like this. I'm tired of the buyouts and the lawsuits. I'd like to see some of these people work for a living.
 
Dear Oracle, Until you can learn to not roll out your updates so it becomes like Pokemon (Gotta catch them all!), shut up. Sincerely, Microsoft Windows Control Panel (Programs and Features Dept.).
 
um ok. google stole a bunch of java coding to use in an open source operating system. big effing deal.
 
Can someone explain why Oracle even still has a case? Java is open source, I can download the entire java and hotspot source code right now and copy it and it should be perfectly legal!
 
Oracle has bloody ruined OpenOffice.org, to the point that the Document Foundation and Go-OO have basically forked the product (LibreOffice). Oracle is not open source friendly and I worry for everything that came into their possession with the Sun takeover. I'm no big fan of Google as they're starting to go back on their "Do No Evil" motto, but Oracle has already shown a blatant obstructionism and endeavor to control what they can and ruin what's out of their control.
 
Can someone explain why Oracle even still has a case? Java is open source, I can download the entire java and hotspot source code right now and copy it and it should be perfectly legal!

You clearly lack understanding of the matter and open source licensing.
 
Can someone explain why Oracle even still has a case? Java is open source, I can download the entire java and hotspot source code right now and copy it and it should be perfectly legal!

Despite it being open source, the license to use it (as well as most other open source project licenses) do often stipulate terms of usage, such as using the code without modification and/or directly crediting the original source provider. Google has done neither in this case, and Oracle's sticking point is that Google's JVM implementation (Dalvik) is not 100% compatible with Oracle's JAVA, and therefore runs afoul of the JAVA license, thereby infringing on Oracle's copyright/patents/etc.

I'm with you though, open source means open source. As in, "Hey look, source! Let's see what I can do with it!"
 
You clearly lack understanding of the matter and open source licensing.

Aren't they both GPL making this okay? Isn't that the point of open source?

There is a picture of the code comparison over at:

http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/oracl...e-comparison/41025?tag=content;selector-blogs

While they are certainly very similar, they are different, and this is GPL we are talking about. This will have big implications if they rule in favor of Oracle. They certainly have a big uphill battle on this one.
 
Aren't they both GPL making this okay? Isn't that the point of open source?

Sun/Whoracle did not license java's source and IP under GPL. The code licensed under something called the java research license; I'm not sure what the IP is licensed under, but it only authorizes 3rd party implementations that are 100% complete implementations of the java spec. Davlik is not 100% equivalent to Whoracle's; in particular it doesn't have any of the stuff only needed for server apps.

http://java.net/jrl.csp
 
Oracle/Sun Microsystems ...c++/c/perl/fortran are all holding on line 1. They want their money or they are going to sue. Apparently, there's code in Java Libraries that's awfully close to C++'s libraries!
 
Sun/Whoracle did not license java's source and IP under GPL. The code licensed under something called the java research license; I'm not sure what the IP is licensed under, but it only authorizes 3rd party implementations that are 100% complete implementations of the java spec. Davlik is not 100% equivalent to Whoracle's; in particular it doesn't have any of the stuff only needed for server apps.

http://java.net/jrl.csp

Uh, that isn't the only license available. Also, you don't need to implement the entire thing. A subset is perfectly valid.

Sun actually did release it under GPL, btw. Look up OpenJDK: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenJDK#Release_of_the_class_library
 
Dear Oracle, Until you can learn to not roll out your updates so it becomes like Pokemon (Gotta catch them all!), shut up. Sincerely, Microsoft Windows Control Panel (Programs and Features Dept.).

Hopefully Google forgot to steal this part.

***unchecks the "Check for updates automatically" button***

***Answers "Never" to the additional prompt about checking for updates***

***Continues to receive Java update prompts***
 
Can someone explain why Oracle even still has a case? Java is open source, I can download the entire java and hotspot source code right now and copy it and it should be perfectly legal!

Because while a lot of it is open, it still has to prove itself as compatible via a variety of tests and checks before it's considered valid. Android is not completely compatible with Java. All of this was done to prevent an issue like Sun had with Microsoft in the 90s. So far, the defense that Google has that i've seen is that their requirement is invalid
 
Dear Oracle, Until you can learn to not roll out your updates so it becomes like Pokemon (Gotta catch them all!), shut up. Sincerely, Microsoft Windows Control Panel (Programs and Features Dept.).

I see you have administered an oracle database.

I have no love for Oracle, but I also hate java. If oracle can kill java, at least the glass will be half full.
 
i dont get it, how can you "copy" Java?

Easy. You go to Starbucks, buy a small latte, take it home, put it in the replicator. Woala, Copied.


Oracle=Symantec=SCO
Buy stuff, make it worse or kill it off because they were in your field of business and you can't compete.
 
i meant like did they make a compiler that copied Java code or just implemented apps with Java
 
Google has done neither in this case, and Oracle's sticking point is that Google's JVM implementation (Dalvik) is not 100% compatible with Oracle's JAVA, and therefore runs afoul of the JAVA license, thereby infringing on Oracle's copyright/patents/etc.
Maybe they forgot to use the right includes. :p
 
What I find most appalling is that Oracle would sue google about their efforts to add java support to the Android platform. One of the main selling points of java is that it runs everywhere and to do this with android seems somewhat suicidal to me.
 
Davlik is not 100% equivalent to Whoracle's; in particular it doesn't have any of the stuff only needed for server apps.

http://java.net/jrl.csp

Which makes perfect sense for Android.. Who needs server stuff and other bloat in a handheld device with a simple ARM core and 512MB RAM?

Would they have preferred it if Android came with a complete Java implementation, making even the original iPhone 3G feel blazing fast by comparison?

It seems copyright and patent laws and the patent trolling that comes with them are the biggest bottlenecks to technological evolution.
 
While I love Android and generally support Google, I couldn't help but think long before this lawsuit came about that Google is doing to Java what Microsoft did to it in the 90s. Change it just enough to make it incompatible, then claim credit for the work.
 
While I love Android and generally support Google, I couldn't help but think long before this lawsuit came about that Google is doing to Java what Microsoft did to it in the 90s. Change it just enough to make it incompatible, then claim credit for the work.

Google wrote the VM. The API implementation I think actually comes from Apache. Wherever they got it, though, you can be sure if you check out the source you'll see the appropriate copyright notices for everything that came from an external source (all of which is located in a folder named "external")
 
Back
Top