Opinions needed for WHS Rig

Cbl12886

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
357
I am planning on using my old desktop (specifications in sig) for a media server and for backups using WHS. I would like it to run a raid 3 or 5 setup with 1TB drives. I was thinking of using a raid controller with a new case or a stand alone nas. I would like the most economical solution without getting crappy components. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,
Blake
 
RAID 3? Really? Stick to 1, 10, 5 (although not recommended), or 6.

Desktop will work fine although is probably not something you will want to encode video with. I would suggest not running RAID 5 (see the RAID reliability primer) and instead use either RAID 6 or use WHS duplication (which will save you from needing a RAID card).

What capacity are you looking to hit initially, how long do you want the service life to be, and what is your expected storage growth rate?

Also, if you can, sell that GPU and get something lower end, like a 7200 or something. For the most part, all a GPU in a WHS does is consume power.
 
I am planning on using my old desktop (specifications in sig) for a media server and for backups using WHS. I would like it to run a raid 3 or 5 setup with 1TB drives.
WHS doesn't do RAID easily or natively and the newer WHS versions are a whole new ballgame.

If you're planning on using WHS I'd suggest doing a little research on the various versions.
 
unless this is going to double as an HTPC, i agree, spend $20 on an ultra cheap low power video card. you will only need it for viewing the console/desktop. also 2tb drives are cheaper in cost per gigabyte and consume less power per gigabyte. if you havnt already bought hard drives, and are planning on more then 1TB, go with 2TB drives. it will also lets you cram more storage in the case before you run out of space for drives. although if you are looking for RAID5/6 or something, you would still need the same number of physical drives.

are you planning on the current WHS or waiting till whenever vail comes out?
 
RAID works just fine with WHSv1 and even better with Vail(GPT support).

How much total space are we talking? RAID IMO is too much work for less than 8TB.
 
The most I can afford is 4x1TB. I will be storing mainly television shows, movies(I don't plan or having a gigantic movie collection), pictures, and pc backups. I plan on using the latest version of WHS.
 
Well dont buy a cheap RAID card, thats a waste of money.
Your better off just using WHS as it was intended.
 
Ok, ill probably just get two 1TB drives, new case, and WHS then call it a day. Thanks!
 
Ok, ill probably just get two 1TB drives, new case, and WHS then call it a day. Thanks!

I would still recommend looking at the new and old versions of WHS to see which suits your situation better.

There are many that won't be moving to the new version because of it's "improvements" and your questions indicate you have no idea how WHS works.

It's nothing against you and I may be wayyy off base but if you're not familiar with the current/future WHS do yourself a favor and read a little about it.

This thread gives an overview.
 
Can I use Server 2008 R2 to stream media? I don't think you can but I might as well ask since I have a free copy.
 
It depends on what/ how you want to stream, but yes, you can. R2 is Windows and thus has a multitude of streaming options.
 
Ideally I would like to be able to use media center for all clients and my xbox.
 
Back
Top