Onboards RAID

CeEstMoi

n00b
Joined
Mar 2, 2014
Messages
2
Hi @ll,

in 2007 I'd tried to use the onboard RAID (only with AMD's boards) and was disappointed... at least I used Win-software-RAID instead.
Now I'd like to setup 5 similar "lowcost" streamserver with at least 5TB space

Therefor:
- anybody experience with chipsets improvements?
- which would be the best for RAID5?
- any benchmarks available RAID5?
- RAID5 vs. RAID10? (does AMD support only 2+2 disks? would appreciate 3+3)
- any idea, which disks have "better solution"?
- if I have to use with card - which will fit to the mainboards? (former the PCIe-cards didn't run on most boards - only graphic-cards were supplied)
- or better run software-RAID instead?

I didn't found much reviews on this. Maybe you'vo got some hints...

regards
Ce
 
What OS will you be running?

ZFS for Linux or Windows Server 2012 (R2) Storage Spaces are both good software options. But Storage Spaces sucks at parity.

I tend to like the software RAID due to their flexibility and portability over the on board stuff.

With that said I haven't had any real issues with modern on board RAID...
 
as I'm a greenhorn in Linux, quite sure I'll run it on WIN7 64bit maybe prof.

can't believe, that there is a turbo an nobody press the button...
 
I set up raid1 on a AMD APU system last year.
Last I recall AMD uses Promise as their onboard controller.

Unlike Intel in which you can do raid ready and then set it up with AMD you need to set it up before you install a OS, least that was my understanding at the time.

You can set up raid 10 but that's it, 4 disk max

If you bought 4 3TB drives you could have 6TB of space and it would be snappy.
 
Typically, an Intel board supports their "Matrix Raid" which is software raid but configured in the BIOS before hand to configure the Port for RAID. Most people use a fast disk to boot like a SSD, then stripe their Disks in Raid1 for speed or do Raid 0 mirroring for the paranoid. Some baords support Raid 5 with 3disks and more. There are boards with 6 or 8 sata ports so a lot of combinations can be had.

Steps are rather simple, put the blank disk pair (lets just say) in the right ports. Download Intel's MAtrix raid software and run it to setup your raid config. That same software will manage the raid and find its status. Remember, your raid data needs backup as well. Typically, one would get 3 new disks of the same type. Put 2 in raid and keep the 3rd one standalone to do backups of your raid volume. If you run out of space, get a USB2 drive and spill into that. The nice thing about it is, if one disk (in the RAID array) fails after a few years, you have exactly the same disk that was olding your backup. You empty that into a 4TB drive and re-use that drive to re-build the raid and then restore from the backup. Chances are you cannot find exactly the same model of that disk anymore!. Again more paranoid people might get another disk to make 2 spares. Why ?. Your data is more valuable, trust me. I keep 3 volumes on different drives and cycle them every 6 months. There is no longer any optical media useful enough for archiving. Many of my CDRs and DVD-R are getting serious oxidation on the edges with corruption. Some are unreadable after 15 years.....:confused:
 
According to the Optical Storage Technology Association (OSTA), "manufacturers claim life spans ranging from 30 to 100 years for DVD, DVD-R and DVD+R discs and up to 30 years for DVD-RW, DVD+RW and DVD-RAM"

Blu-ray

The recordable media used in red laser disc technology like DVD's and CD's is an organic dye that is very sensitive to light. Blu-ray disks, however, use a combination of silicon and copper which is bonded during the burning process, this alloy is much more resilient than the organic dye. Manufacturers claim a life span from 100 up to 150 years for Blu-ray disks
 
I personally lost too many operating system installs with software raids over the years and just ended up going with a hardware raid controller. I've had a few raid cards since I started and have had my adaptec 5805 the longest. allows up to 8 SAS or SATA drives and will do just about every raid option out there. haven't lost a single byte of information since going hardware raid. it's the only way in my eye now.
 
Software raid seems like a good way to have issues.
Intel's RST is a firmware raid, a bit more robust.

Been running a pair of RE drives on Intel RST raid1 for 6+ years, not a single issue yet.
Intel's software can be glitchy though and usually has more induced problems then solved problems
judging by their release notes when a new package is offered.

If you have the coin though hardware raid is the best of course, long as your card works and the company keeps up with drivers, firmware, bios, etc.
 
That doesn't change the fact that you can migrate software raid compared to Intel rst.
 
you can do the same with hardware raid too. if I wanna change my board and chip out I just swap my raid card and drives onto the new board and fire it up, works like a charm.
 
Back
Top