Old Raptor vs. New Seagate?

eltnsx

n00b
Joined
Oct 7, 2008
Messages
3
I'm building a new rig, and I can either wipe and use a ~3-4 year old Raptor as my primary drive, or this

what do you guys think?

edit:
1) 74 gig version of the Raptor
2) I do a lot of computational work, so in order of importance to me:
  • Performance
  • Reliability (if a week-long simulation ends due to a drive failure, im screwed)
 
Unfortunately, my adviser is a cheap-ass, I have the following available to me:

1) 1x 3-4 year old 74 gig raptor
2) 2x 3-4 year old 80 gig IDE Seagate Barracudas
3) New drive in my previous post
4) Random external drives

I've thought of going raid with the 2 Seagates, is there any way to setup a computer such that files are periodically backed up onto an external drive?

Thanks,
 
An older drive has a greater chance of failing than a newer drive. With that in mind, I recommend the cheaper, larger (capacity), (faster) Seagate 640GB HDD. You should also use an external drive for backups, but I don't know if the (external drive's) built-in software will enable scheduled backups.
 
So to confirm, the Seagate will outperform the Raptor?

In transfer speeds (Read/Write). However, the Raptor has better seek times than the Seagate. So the Raptor will find the files/space faster but be slower in transfering them than the Seagate. But the seek time thing is pretty minute. I'd go with the Seagate.
 
Back
Top