OCing and Gaming - Q6600 or E8500?

kompulsive

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 11, 2008
Messages
355
The title pretty much says it all. I plan to run the processor with 2x2GB PC2 8800 RAM and a Radeon 4870 512MB card. Would the E8500 be the better overclocker or will I be able to get the Q6600 into the 4GHz+ area? Also, how much of an issue is the Duo vs. Quad going to be? If the Q6600 can OC just as well as the E8500, I would just as soon have the two extra cores for when I do things like video and audio editing. However, my primary activity is going to be gaming.
 
go with q6600 for future proof. dual core will be phased out soon.
 
If you're going to get a Q6600 then get one while you can, the guys at my local shop tell me that they're starting to have a hard time getting 65nm CPUs.
 
...what? You serious? I was planning on ordering everything from NewEgg in a month or so. Is Intel phasing the Q6600 out or something?
 
...what? You serious? I was planning on ordering everything from NewEgg in a month or so. Is Intel phasing the Q6600 out or something?

Q6600 will be off the shelves by late Q2 next year.

Ordering them now is getting a little harder as they aren't as readily available as they used to be. This happens with all of Intel's chips.
 
Supply and demand. The demand is crazy high on them Q66's. Not to mention they are beginning to throttle production down
 
I guess my question now is, should I really go with the Q6600? Is something better going to take it's place in the same price range soon? I don't see a point in ordering a processor just to have it be replaced by something better a week later.
 
I guess my question now is, should I really go with the Q6600? Is something better going to take it's place in the same price range soon? I don't see a point in ordering a processor just to have it be replaced by something better a week later.

having owned a Q6600 now for 7 months---- I've never once thought "I should've gotten a Core 2 Duo....."


From a multi-tasking/game perspective.... here's some insight....
I've got a E8400 Wolfdale on my work machine and 8GB of DDR2 on it vs. my Q6600 w/ 4GB of DDR2 on my home machine and my Q6600 runs circles around my work rig for multi tasking.

Gaming wise I'm pulling in over 30+ FPS in today's games (Far Cry 2, Crysis Warhead, Fallout 3 etc) and have no issues with my quad core. I think people who don't like the "basted and pasted" Q6600 because it's simply two Core 2's slapped together----mind you it's a hell of a chip.
 
The title pretty much says it all. I plan to run the processor with 2x2GB PC2 8800 RAM and a Radeon 4870 512MB card. Would the E8500 be the better overclocker or will I be able to get the Q6600 into the 4GHz+ area? Also, how much of an issue is the Duo vs. Quad going to be? If the Q6600 can OC just as well as the E8500, I would just as soon have the two extra cores for when I do things like video and audio editing. However, my primary activity is going to be gaming.

The E8500 would more than likely out clock the Q6600...getting a Q6600 to 4.0 is going to require some serious volts and some serious cooling....and the right board.

That being said, I would go with the quad.
If its in your budget, get a 45Nm quad instead of the 65Nm
They run cooler with less volts.
 
I guess my question now is, should I really go with the Q6600? Is something better going to take it's place in the same price range soon? I don't see a point in ordering a processor just to have it be replaced by something better a week later.

The Q8200 and other budget 45nm quads will take its place. However, the 8MB cache is a good thing, vs the smaller cache on the new 45nm quads, plus if you OC the Q6600 to 3.6GHz it's still a fantastic processor. able to keep up with low end Core i7s at stock speeds ( i didn't say beat or equal, I said keep up.) ;).

The 45nm quads with 12MB cache are also great too. You can wait for those to drop down in price, which will likely happen between Q1 and Q2 next year. The Core architecture relies heavily on large caches to "hide" the latencies associated with FSB versus an integrated mem controller, hence the great boost against AMD64 platforms.

The Q6600 is a great chip despite it lacking some of the new instructions from the new 45nm wolfdale/penryn chips. I see the cache becoming more and more important, so I'd pick up a Q6600 over a Q8200 for now.

P.S., the Q6600 is also great, because it is a 800FSB (effective) CPU and comes with a multiplier of 9. you would only need to do 400FSB to do 3.6GHz whereas on the Q8200 the multiplier is lower and more difficult to OC.
 
I guess my question now is, should I really go with the Q6600? Is something better going to take it's place in the same price range soon? I don't see a point in ordering a processor just to have it be replaced by something better a week later.

The longer you plan to wait between upgrades the better the Q is now. If you grab an E now and upgrade within a year to an i7 that's be fine. A year from now you will want a quad that's fairly certain. A Q6600 at 3.5Ghz or so is going be to be an adequate cpu for awhile
 
Actually, Its 1066

Beat me to it. But as for getting to 4ghz on a q6600, dont plan on it. I have one of the better chips around. Most people are reporting hitting a wall around 3.3ghz on the chips being purchased in the last few months. My 6600 has a vid of 1.2(quite low) and it takes me 1.6v to get stable at 4ghz, and thats on watercooling. It runs 24/7 at 3.6ghz with 1.4v though. You might want to just pony up the extra 100 bucks and get a q9550 instead.
 
I'd definately go with a Quad core at this point. A quadcore at 3.2ghz or a dualcore at 4ghz wont make a difference in todays games. Either chip will maintain a rock solid framerate with a decent videocard. However, looking at some of the new benchmarks with Far Cry 2 being an example, it becomes very quickly apparent how a quadcore will dominate in the future. The dualcore simply cant keep up.

In my opinion, todays games will run as well on either chip, however looking at new games coming, a quadcore will make a big difference down the road.
 
I'd definately go with a Quad core at this point. A quadcore at 3.2ghz or a dualcore at 4ghz wont make a difference in todays games. Either chip will maintain a rock solid framerate with a decent videocard. However, looking at some of the new benchmarks with Far Cry 2 being an example, it becomes very quickly apparent how a quadcore will dominate in the future. The dualcore simply cant keep up.

In my opinion, todays games will run as well on either chip, however looking at new games coming, a quadcore will make a big difference down the road.

Well worded. My thoughts exactly and yet as we always say you cannot future your machine.
 
Yeah, a quad is the way to go at this point. The Q6600 with a nice OC will still pull it's weight for next couple years. I'd snag one now, before they get sucked up and become unavailable.
 
Yeah, a quad is the way to go at this point. The Q6600 with a nice OC will still pull it's weight for next couple years. I'd snag one now, before they get sucked up and become unavailable.

Yeah I think come Christmas time the prices might actually be a bit higher than now. The Q9550 is a temptation if $300 is in your cpu budget
 
Hmmm...I might be able to afford the Q9550. How much of an increase in performance (overclocking/gaming) will if I go with the Q9550 instead of the Q6600? Is it worth the extra money to get the Q9550? What Q9550 stepping should I keep an eye out for?
 
In term of actual performance over the Q6600, the Q9550 is roughly 10 to 15% faster at stock speeds. In terms of overclocking, you can theoretically hit 4Ghz with the Q9550. The Q9550 is $320 whereas the Q6600 is $190. So for an extra $130 over the Q6600 you get about a 10 to 15% performance increase, lower energy usage and slightly higher possibility of hitting 4Ghz. Figure out for yourself if that's worth the extra $130 or if there's any other part(s) of your system that could use the extra $130
 
go for the E8500. i saw improvemnt across the boards when I upgraded from a Q6600 to a E8500.

Games load faster, extracting files faster, and converting divx to dvd went from 40 minutes to 15minutes.
 
go for the E8500. i saw improvemnt across the boards when I upgraded from a Q6600 to a E8500.

Games load faster, extracting files faster, and converting divx to dvd went from 40 minutes to 15minutes.

If it was taking you 40 minutes to convert a movie on a Q6600 you were doing something wrong. In fact the Q6600, or any quad-core, will beat the ever living piss out of a dual-core in video conversion.
 
In term of actual performance over the Q6600, the Q9550 is roughly 10 to 15% faster at stock speeds. In terms of overclocking, you can theoretically hit 4Ghz with the Q9550. The Q9550 is $320 whereas the Q6600 is $190. So for an extra $130 over the Q6600 you get about a 10 to 15% performance increase, lower energy usage and slightly higher possibility of hitting 4Ghz. Figure out for yourself if that's worth the extra $130 or if there's any other part(s) of your system that could use the extra $130

And if you're trying to future proof the Q9550 is a better candidate. A 4Ghz Q9550 is still going to be a good cpu this time next year, heck in two years its probably going to be fair. Look how good some guys are doing who got the first Q6600's now
 
If it was taking you 40 minutes to convert a movie on a Q6600 you were doing something wrong. In fact the Q6600, or any quad-core, will beat the ever living piss out of a dual-core in video conversion.

Very true.
 
Well, I found out the answer to that question. Can I RMA the processor back to NewEgg if I don't get the E0 stepping?
 
Newegg seems to be shipping a lot of E0's but as always kinda luck of the draw
 
Back
Top