Nvidia vs Ati -- aspect ratio scaling

jingra

n00b
Joined
Jun 23, 2006
Messages
19
I've been looking at the monitor threads for weeks now in anticipation of buying a new monitor. However, it seems several of the LCD's I am looking at don't do scaling of an input signal that is not equal to the native resolution of the monitor (ie, taking a 1024x768 signal and scaling it up while maintaining the correct aspect ratio). So I would like to ask the community about using the video card to scale the image. I have read about and am familiar with the fact that Nvidia used to be able to do this reliably, but with the 158.xx and 162.xx driver series for XP they have dropped the ball. If I am wrong, please let me know. I am curious about ATI also. Can you let those cards do the image scaling?

Thanks,
J
 
Most nvidia cards can do fixed aspect ratio scaling. I don't know about the new ATI HD 2x00 series, but the previous cards didn't support it.

My 7600GT does fixed aspect ratio scaling perfectly, like the GF6 series and older cards did.

This is on the 158 drivers:
fixedaspectvs2.png
 
When I bought my 8800GTS I was looking forward to this feature that ATI seemed to be lacking.

....but instead I find it is broken now and does not work. :(

From the release notes: (page 12 of 48)

GeForce 8800 GTX/GTS: Flat‐panel scaling doesnʹt work with widescreen
monitors. [309707]

http://us.download.nvidia.com/Windows/158.22/158.22_ForceWare_Release_Notes.pdf

So much for my Soldier of Fortune 2 not being stretched. I am looking forward to the next driver release and keeping my fingers crossed.
 
They're up to 163.14 for 32bit Vista and XP now, and 163.11 for 64bit Vista. Make sure your drivers are current. It may be fixed, it may not, I don't know as I don't have a widescreen monitor and don't make use of the feature, but the 158.22's are (I think) over a month old now and have been replaced several times over.

I don't believe ATI supports it at all, though.
 
It has been fixed since the 160.03's. There is a box under "manage custom resolutions" that is labeled Treat as HDTV. It is checked by default. Uncheck it, and flat panel scaling will appear.

All NVidia cards do this. ATI cards do not - they rely upon the monitor to do it. Some people think that it is the ATI driver doing it, but it is just allowing the option to show up if you already have the ability to do it in your monitor.

This is one feature I refuse to give up, and it is the bane of ATI cards for me.
 
Back
Top