NVIDIA Hosts Vulkan Developer’s Day

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Vulkan is the new generation, open-standard API for high-efficiency access to graphics and compute on modern GPUs. This ground-up design, previously referred to as the Next Generation OpenGL Initiative, gives applications explicit control over GPU acceleration for maximized performance and predictability. Vulkan eliminates expensive driver operations, which means less CPU overhead and no more unexpected frame rate hiccups.

A key advantage of Vulkan over OpenGL is the ability to generate work for the GPU across many CPU threads, making Vulkan particularly useful for developers who find themselves CPU-bound, which can occur in diverse application domains, including games, computer-aided design and mobile apps. Vulkan expands the family of Khronos 3D APIs by complementing OpenGL and OpenGL ES, two standards that between them provide access to billions of GPUs today. Going forward, NVIDIA will be working hard within Khronos to ensure Vulkan evolves to meet industry needs. The developers day brought key engineers from NVIDIA’s development partners together with NVIDIA driver experts.
 
Go Vulkan!! Go Vulkan!! The only team I've rooted for in years.
 
No mention of advantages over DX12.
Cross platform is one but anything else?
 
No mention of advantages over DX12.
Cross platform is one but anything else?

hmmmm, I'm going to say none. There were really no advantages of Opengl over DX11, so I bet the same applies to Vulkan vs DX12
 
hmmmm, I'm going to say none. There were really no advantages of Opengl over DX11, so I bet the same applies to Vulkan vs DX12

This is the dumbest thing I've ever read. Why would you pull such an idiotic statement out of your ass with zero research?
 
One advantage I can think of: no Windows 10 requirement .
 
No mention of advantages over DX12.
Cross platform is one but anything else?

It's good enough reason.

is2t3.jpg
 
One advantage I can think of: no Windows 10 requirement .

I guess we'll see where Vulkan goes. For now it looks like Windows 10 is doing extremely well with PC gamers if Valve's Steam Survey is accurate. And Windows 10 is also on the Xbox.
 
One advantage I can think of: no Windows 10 requirement .

This is where I'm headed but want to know if it will have enough features to get the developers excited vs DX12.
 
No mention of advantages over DX12.
Cross platform is one but anything else?

Doesn't require Windows 10. Works on 7, 8, 10, Linux, OSX, Android.

Isn't proprietary and paywalled.
 
Doesn't require Windows 10. Works on 7, 8, 10, Linux, OSX, Android.

Isn't proprietary and paywalled.

"Works on Linux" except when it doesn't. The current plans are Vulkan won't even be support on AMD 290 and 390 cards:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=AMDGPU-Vulkan-Driver-Only

And AMD still start off with a closed source driver for this for people that care about open source:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-gpu-xdc15&num=1

AMD's Linux support history has been dreadful at best when compared to Nvidia, Vulkan won't change this.
 
"Works on Linux" except when it doesn't. The current plans are Vulkan won't even be support on AMD 290 and 390 cards:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=AMDGPU-Vulkan-Driver-Only

And AMD still start off with a closed source driver for this for people that care about open source:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-gpu-xdc15&num=1

AMD's Linux support history has been dreadful at best when compared to Nvidia, Vulkan won't change this.

His source for those quotes is questionable. It's been stated that it will work with all GCN GPUs.
http://www.phoronix.com/forums/foru...ng-vulkan-support-to-older-amd-gcn-gpus/page6
 
^ It'll be AMD's job to get on the ball with Vulkan support, because Nvidia sure is embracing it.
 
"Works on Linux" except when it doesn't. The current plans are Vulkan won't even be support on AMD 290 and 390 cards:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=AMDGPU-Vulkan-Driver-Only

And AMD still start off with a closed source driver for this for people that care about open source:

http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-gpu-xdc15&num=1

AMD's Linux support history has been dreadful at best when compared to Nvidia, Vulkan won't change this.

Cross platform APIs can be of great benefit but they aren't silver bullets that achieve write once, run everywhere single base executable objects. I doubt that last year's number one console game, Black Ops III, will anytime soon see an Android version. Or even a desktop Linux version due to its low market share.

Now for more smaller, more casual games especially for indie developers, then Vulkan could be extremely beneficial. I think this where Vulkan, will see its initial impact. If that goes well then it could trickle up.
 
I doubt that last year's number one console game, Black Ops III, will anytime soon see an Android version. Or even a desktop Linux version due to its low market share.

Perfectly fine by me.

if you ask me, the less "Call of Modern Battlefield: Online" junk, the better :p

Just because something sells a lot, doesn't mean it's good. Most of the people shopping for these games are Teenagers, and teenagers aren't necessarily know for their excellent taste :p


I mean, they are the ones who keep buying Kanye, Miley Cyrus and that kind of junk :p
 
Zarathustra[H];1042094183 said:
Perfectly fine by me.

if you ask me, the less "Call of Modern Battlefield: Online" junk, the better :p

Just because something sells a lot, doesn't mean it's good. Most of the people shopping for these games are Teenagers, and teenagers aren't necessarily know for their excellent taste :p


I mean, they are the ones who keep buying Kanye, Miley Cyrus and that kind of junk :p

Whatever those teenagers lack in taste, they make up for with money to spend on games, at least their parents'. If one wants desktop Linux to be a viable alternative to Windows for gaming, desktop Linux needs AAA like the Call of Duty franchise.
 
Whatever those teenagers lack in taste, they make up for with money to spend on games, at least their parents'. If one wants desktop Linux to be a viable alternative to Windows for gaming, desktop Linux needs AAA like the Call of Duty franchise.

QFT
 
Now for more smaller, more casual games especially for indie developers, then Vulkan could be extremely beneficial. I think this where Vulkan, will see its initial impact. If that goes well then it could trickle up.

One would think that a small studio won't have the resources to code close to the metal. I think you got this backwards.

I am also very sceptical of the other predictions in this post. Your love for windows is probably clouding your judgement.
 
One would think that a small studio won't have the resources to code close to the metal. I think you got this backwards.

I am also very sceptical of the other predictions in this post. Your love for windows is probably clouding your judgement.

Isn't coding close to metal cheaper?
 
One would think that a small studio won't have the resources to code close to the metal. I think you got this backwards.

I am also very sceptical of the other predictions in this post. Your love for windows is probably clouding your judgement.

I thought the one of the major points of Vulkan was to ease cross platform development? Wouldn't smaller developers with unproven titles have more of a desire to get their games on as many platforms as possible and isn't that a key promise of Vulkan?
 
Isn't coding close to metal cheaper?

Cheaper how?

Now granted, I'm not a programmer, but I would have thought it would be the opposite.

If anyone could explain this to me, I'd be curious.

I was under the impression that API's exist to be huge time savers, so the programmer doesn't have to repeat the functions they perform in their code every time they write it.

Because of this, I would have imagined that the closer to metal you get, the more complex, by necessity, your code gets, and the more complex it gets, the more coding hours need to go in to it, making it more expensive...
 
I'd expect the engine (unity, unreal, etc..) to "give it to them for free" once it all gets baked in.

but that's just conjecture on my part.
 
Isn't coding close to metal cheaper?

cheaper in what way.

Now I don't deal with 3d programming but if its similar to other kind of programming a lowlevel languagge is more expensive in human time resource, coding the software because you have do do everything self ( like assembly coding).
However in a high level language you can do alot of stuff coding wise in a few steps however you can tweak it as much.

soo for a developer with limited resource/time a lowlevel programming language is not optimal for the design phase.
 
This is the dumbest thing I've ever read. Why would you pull such an idiotic statement out of your ass with zero research?

Allow me to elaborate. Since you provided ZERO evidence on the contrary.

Other than cross platform and open source (sort of), there is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING that Vulkan offers that DX12 doesn't.

In fact DX12 offers something that vulkan doesn't. Its available now. There are no DX12 games yet but at least it has a head start.

The cross platform part mainly covers linux, android and windows (nintendo NX is rumored to use it). No Apple (big loss), no xbox (becuase, why?), no WiiU (who cares), and as of yet no PS4.

And since both are very similar, like their predecessors, then my statement may not seem as idiotic as you think.
 
I guess we'll see where Vulkan goes. For now it looks like Windows 10 is doing extremely well with PC gamers if Valve's Steam Survey is accurate. And Windows 10 is also on the Xbox.

You claim you have no bias and yet everything you post reads like a Microsoft late night infomercial. :p
 
You claim you have no bias and yet everything you post reads like a Microsoft late night infomercial. :p

Anything that not negative of Windows or Microsoft will be considered by you as an infomercial. In any case no one here or anywhere else knows the future of Vulkan or how it will turn out and the same would be true of DX12 which is much further along. It seems to hold a lot of promise and I think that's great. I just don't think that it's success will be because of some great or grand market force trying to be "free of Windows 10" or Windows in general. That's never really been much of a market force in the desktop space.

If it proves to be reliable, efficient, performant, better than DX 12 in ways beyond not being Windows based and really does simplify cross platform development then that would seem to be a formula for great success.
 
This is the dumbest thing I've ever read. Why would you pull such an idiotic statement out of your ass with zero research?
You're right as a developer there are distant cost disadvantages to not using DirectX API's and documentation over openGL+the countless other api's you'd need to make a game let alone the custom tools you'll need to develop. Then again most game developers don't build their own game engines but just buy one.
 
Read about this a few days ago and about Nvidia's stand on Vulkan.

https://developer.nvidia.com/engaging-voyage-vulkan

Seems the consensus states that Nvidia isn't fully supporting Vulkan but kinda half-heartedly so. Seems they still are pushing OGL.

Vulkan’s strengths lie in the explicit control and multi-threading capabilities that by design allow us to push more commands to the GPU in less CPU time and have finer-grained cost control. OpenGL, however, continues to provide easier to use access to the hardware. This is especially important for applications that are not CPU-limited. Current NVIDIA technologies such as “bindless”, NV_command_list, and the “AZDO” techniques for core OpenGL, can achieve excellent single-thread performance
 
Looks to me as though they are considering situations that dont need what Vulkan provides and gives devs an easier time.
As well as supporting Vulkan when CPU is pushed harder.
What would you do in their position?
 
Isn't coding close to metal cheaper?

Usually - no.

Coding "to the metal" usually involves micro-optimizations which are hardware/architecture specific. This in turn translates into more development time, which means more cost.
Using a higher level API like OpenGL or DirectX is much simpler in comparison, all the "nitty gritty/low-level" functions are abstracted away and you are left with things such as "init()" which will work for 99% of the hardware but may be sub-optimal in terms of performance on a specific set of hardware.

Granted, this is a pretty basic explanation, but it does hold.
 
Anything that not negative of Windows or Microsoft will be considered by you as an infomercial.

Moi? I haven't criticized Microsoft in a long time so you have me confused with someone else. I don't brown-nose them either though.
 
Looks to me as though they are considering situations that dont need what Vulkan provides and gives devs an easier time.
As well as supporting Vulkan when CPU is pushed harder.
What would you do in their position?

I was just relaying the thoughts of other with far greater knowledge and they related that Nvidia was not fully supporting Vulkan based on the quote I posted. These guys are and tend to be Nvidia supporters so I do not believe they are speaking anything other than heartfelt truth.
 
I was just relaying the thoughts of other with far greater knowledge and they related that Nvidia was not fully supporting Vulkan based on the quote I posted. These guys are and tend to be Nvidia supporters so I do not believe they are speaking anything other than heartfelt truth.

You gave your own opinion of it.
 
Isn't coding close to metal cheaper?

As was said above, usually no. It involves either additional training for the graphics programmer(s), who then become a bigger asset to the company and usually involve increased remuneration medium term. Or hiring very specialized programmers which cost more.

Why do it? You get something new for the publisher/marketing department to promote and consumers to talk about.

Read about this a few days ago and about Nvidia's stand on Vulkan.

https://developer.nvidia.com/engaging-voyage-vulkan

Seems the consensus states that Nvidia isn't fully supporting Vulkan but kinda half-heartedly so. Seems they still are pushing OGL.

In addition to my response above, these specialized programmers coding closer to hardware level also become very intimately aware of GPU strengths and weaknesses. Something I would imagine nvidia is not to fond of as was seen when Oxide stumbled across such a weakness/limitation in their hardware handling of Async code.

AMD is probably also cautious about it, but their company philosophy is very different from nvidia. Interesting read about an open GPU university project based on AMD GPUs: http://fudzilla.com/news/processors/39734-open-source-gpgpu-is-the-cat-s-whiskers
 
If Nvidia is doing this then I guess AMD submitting Mantle to the Khronos group and renaming it Vulkan worked as intended.
 
Back
Top