NVIDIA Developing x86 CPU?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to Michael Hara, NVIDIA’s senior vice president of investor relations and communications, the company is considering making a x86 processor in the next two or three years.

If you look at the high-end of the PC market I think it’s going to stay fairly discrete, because that seems to be the best of all worlds...A highly integrated system-on-chip is going to make sense in the MID [editor note: mobile intelligent device] and netbook markets...Two or three years down the road I think it’s going to make sense...We won’t talk much more about what we think about that timeframe, but there’s no question it’s on our minds.
 
I hate to say it but charlie has been right about them.
 
Wonder what Intel is going to require of them to even get a license for x86. This isn't going to be pretty either way.
 
I think this has more to do with licensing a core than nvidia developing one. See the recent TSMC/Intel deal for embedding Atom into other products. A Tegra with a future Atom core would be awesome.
 
Gotta toot my horn here. I've been saying that the only battle that will matter is the one between Intel and Nvidia as they converge in technologies. Well, time to heat it up. I've been hearing rumors of some secret blackops project that Nvidia has been working on, maybe this is it.
 
This is a MUST move for NVIDIA. They cannot survive the long haul without an X86 CPU IMO. SOC is the future. And a GPU simply can't do it all.
 
i wonder when its time to release a new chip, will they just rename the old chip and change the ghz on the cover box
 
Well, I'm not a programmer or chip designer, but it does make sense in this way:
I don't think Jen-Hsun has ever said that the CPU itself is going away; only that its role will be greatly diminished.

If you're NVIDIA and you want a system with a minimalist CPU that's still x86 compatible, you might be better off designing it in-house.
You're then in a position to market a core system (CPU, chipset,GPU) that makes use of your strategy.

The biggest hurdle in that scenario: NVIDIA will have to figure a way to make CUDA a widely-used language, or they will have to abandon it and concentrate on OpenCL.
Trying to push the use both languages seems counterproductive, unless there's a way to combine the two seamlessly.
Again, I'm not a programmer, but it's my understanding that OpenCL is a lower-level language than CUDA.
If there was a way to make CUDA a superset of OpenCL, you might gain the advantage of both and make it easier to utilize both to take advantage of NVIDIA's GPU strengths.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if we start hearing another rumor about Nvidia buying Via or a merger with AMD in the next couple years.
 
Is this the can of whoop-ass they're going to open on Intel? Considering maybe making an x86 cpu in 2 - 3 years? If not maybe someone can clear up exactly what that "can of whoop-ass" remark was referring too.
 
I just wonder what they can offer against Intel or AMD. Intel is still ripping through all in their path and AMD has the value lineup covered. Both of them are far ahead in CPU space.
 
How exciting would it be for us all to have a viable third party competitor.

That's a new era for hardware enthusiasts.
 
I expected AMD/ATI to have this market cornered by now with in house CPU/chipset/GPU but maybee this will end up falling on Nvidia.
 
hrmm, wonder which x86 licence holder they are going to buy out.. :)
 
Maybe they shouldn't have been burning bridges, continually talking smack about competitors, constantly bullying & pissing off OEM's, renaming old chips as new, plus denying the chip substrate problems the last couple of years, etc...They might have been in a better position to sweet talk Intel into a x86 license deal or at least keep the lawsuits to a minimum. Karma's a b*tch isn't it!
 
I would like to know how HOT that cpu is gonna be.

Well, considering that they can't magically add more transistors just because they're putting in a CPU and a GPU, I'm gonna say it's probably just about the same temperature as any other chip of similar technical specifications.
 
I think it's more likely a cpu architecture and not an actual cpu it's self . More than likely something to compete with the Larabee.
 
1) What happened to the x86 CPU being "antiquated" and falling in favor of the GPGPU?
2) Good luck getting an x86 license from Intel after all the crap you've given them!
 
I wouldn't be surprised if we start hearing another rumor about Nvidia buying Via or a merger with AMD in the next couple years.

Rumors of Nvidia merging with AMD would make me laugh. Rumors of Nvidia buying Via would make me interested.
 
Via would be your best bet on a buy out.

The problem with that is I don't think any of the x86 licenses are transferable in a sale or merger. I think Intel locked up those legal holes a long time ago with Via...Also me thinks Nvidia would have jumped on that bandwagon a couple years ago if it was doable...
 
Bring on the competition.

If it is as quick and affordable as Intel/AMD, and actually works well, it could mean more price cuts.
 
I say they're going to get bought by Intel during this economic downturn. Call me crazy. I don't like it, but it may happen. Or I'm just talking out of my anus.
 
I'm not very informed on this but why can't Nvidia develop x86 CPUs without Intel's consent?

Also if that is the case, how is AMD able to develop them?
 
Gotta toot my horn here. I've been saying that the only battle that will matter is the one between Intel and Nvidia as they converge in technologies. Well, time to heat it up. I've been hearing rumors of some secret blackops project that Nvidia has been working on, maybe this is it.

So you're saying CPUs and GPUs will eventually be one thing? I thought CPU and GPU technology were much different from eachother.
 
I'm not very informed on this but why can't Nvidia develop x86 CPUs without Intel's consent?

Also if that is the case, how is AMD able to develop them?

They both (Intel/AMD) hold patents to the x86 architecture that would make it impossible for Nvidia to create a CPU without getting a license from one or both. I'm not sure but I think Intel, IBM, etc hold most of the patents and AMD basically traded their x64 technology for some of Intel's licensed technology. That is way over simplifying it but that's about the jist of it...
 
I'm not very informed on this but why can't Nvidia develop x86 CPUs without Intel's consent?

Also if that is the case, how is AMD able to develop them?
AMD has a license and pays Intel royalties for various technologies. IIRC, AMD's license is up for renegotiation next January, or continues as-is if no new license is negotiated when the current one expires (unless one party breaks it... not good for that party :p).

nvidia can make an x86 processor without a license, but 1) it would be costly and time consuming to make clean implementations (non-infringing) and to validate the design and compatibility (certainly not within 2-3 years) and 2) the performance and power consumption of such a new core would unlikely be competitive with anything on the market by the time it is released. I still think that nvidia will license an Atom core now that TSMC and Intel have an agreement to make that available.
 
So why did Intel give AMD the rights to make CPUs? That just gave Intel more competition. Same with Nvidia- it would give Intel more competition if they let Nvidia make CPUs.

Also, if IBM holds the patent as well, why can't IBM give permission to Nvidia?
 
So why did Intel give AMD the rights to make CPUs? That just gave Intel more competition. Same with Nvidia- it would give Intel more competition if they let Nvidia make CPUs.

Also, if IBM holds the patent as well, why can't IBM give permission to Nvidia?

AMD gets rights since it keeps the monopoly guys off of their back......and Intel gets $$ from each AMD CPU sold :p
 
So why did Intel give AMD the rights to make CPUs?
...
Also, if IBM holds the patent as well, why can't IBM give permission to Nvidia?
It's a long story, but the pre-litigation part can be summarized:

Intel supplies CPUs to IBM for the IBM PC. IBM wants a second source so that it doesn't rely exclusively on Intel for parts. Intel licenses a few other companies to produce its chips, including Harris Semiconductor, AMD and later NEC and even IBM itself. The license with AMD included a cross-license clause to share technology between the two companies, which allowed AMD to license certain future Intel IP in exchange for AMD IP.

The fall out happened because AMD was not allowed the 386 core and decided to make its own reverse engineered clone using 286 and earlier IP. AMD sued, was eventually granted use technology it was currently using in exchange for paying royalties to Intel. The royalties were ordered because it was determined by the court that AMD had not fulfilled its end of the cross license agreement.

Since then, Intel and AMD have had cross-license agreements. The terms heavily favor Intel and Intel still receives undisclosed royalties based on several factors including how much production is outsourced (of which there is a cap on how much AMD can outsource).

To answer your second question, the x86 licenses Intel granted can not be assigned or transferred. Nothing really stops another company from trying to enter the x86 market with their own designs other than the near total certainty of failure after wasting millions or billions. :p
 
The problem with that is I don't think any of the x86 licenses are transferable in a sale or merger. I think Intel locked up those legal holes a long time ago with Via...Also me thinks Nvidia would have jumped on that bandwagon a couple years ago if it was doable...

if they buy Via but leave it together as a company, they can make use of it. If they buy via and fold the company but take the tech then the license becomes void. At least thats what i get.

Either way, love them or hate them, if this is true it could be an interesting 3rd party entry.

Honestly though i see them focusing on the atom's market more than enthusiast however. Though if they do they would then have the technology to work on ultraportable, rather cheap, portable gaming systems.
 
It's a long story, but the pre-litigation part can be summarized:

Intel supplies CPUs to IBM for the IBM PC. IBM wants a second source so that it doesn't rely exclusively on Intel for parts. Intel licenses a few other companies to produce its chips, including Harris Semiconductor, AMD and later NEC and even IBM itself. The license with AMD included a cross-license clause to share technology between the two companies, which allowed AMD to license certain future Intel IP in exchange for AMD IP.

The fall out happened because AMD was not allowed the 386 core and decided to make its own reverse engineered clone using 286 and earlier IP. AMD sued, was eventually granted use technology it was currently using in exchange for paying royalties to Intel. The royalties were ordered because it was determined by the court that AMD had not fulfilled its end of the cross license agreement.

Since then, Intel and AMD have had cross-license agreements. The terms heavily favor Intel and Intel still receives undisclosed royalties based on several factors including how much production is outsourced (of which there is a cap on how much AMD can outsource).

To answer your second question, the x86 licenses Intel granted can not be assigned or transferred. Nothing really stops another company from trying to enter the x86 market with their own designs other than the near total certainty of failure after wasting millions or billions. :p

AMD licensed out their x86-64 extensions to Intel correct? Without them, their CPUs aren't 64-bit compatible. So at least its not a TOTAL one-sided relationship.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X86-64
 
AMD licensed out their x86-64 extensions to Intel correct? Without them, their CPUs aren't 64-bit compatible. So at least its not a TOTAL one-sided relationship.
That's still an open question. Intel's first stab at it seems to have come from the documentation, which was free to all, and was missing a couple of system managment instructions AMD had added back later. X86-64 isn't really licensed in the same way that the broad term "x86 license" is used (which covers implementations and patented technology use). You can't patent an instruction set. There's also no reason that Intel would have turned down anything it could have got under the cross-license agreement. It's possible that Intel has a completely separate implementation of x86-64 from AMD's implementation.

X86-64 is mostly a dumb extension of the same old existing 32-bit instruction set to handle 64-bit integer registers and 40-bit memory addressing. The biggest change really was adding 8 additional registers accessible in 64-bit mode. It's not a new ISA, it's just IA32 extended to 64-bits.

I'm glad MS put its foot down to force Intel to adopt AMD's version of X86-64, but it's hardly a huge achievement. Intel had evaluated the same thing years earlier and discarded it. The real benefit was that low cost servers could accesss more memory directly. It's had little overall effect on the desktop, although I and other geeks appreciate it. It's little more than FANtasy (unsourced from a certain Intel-hating UK web site) that AMD can somehow stop Intel from using x86-64.
 
Back
Top