NVIDIA Class Action Settlement Screws Users?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Wall Street Journal has a lengthy article posted that breaks down the NVIDIA faulty-chip class action lawsuit settlement. According to the article, people that owned a high end laptop with a defective NVIDIA chip are only entitled to a cheapy Compaq laptop as a replacement. Thanks to Trackr for the link.

Then, the lawyers negotiated on what replacement computer would be provided for those unrepairable H-Ps. It turned out to be a relatively low-end Compaq computer then selling at Best Buy for $330.
 
Seventeen firms and nobody caught the mistake in the settlement. Very sloppy.
 
Seventeen firms and nobody caught the mistake in the settlement. Very sloppy.

lawyers in those cases don't care about the end person, all the care about is how much they will get. normally 1/2 the money goes to the lawyer, the other 1/2 to the 30,000 people involved in the suit. Since they had so many firms it is probably 3/4 money goes to lawyers and the other 1/4 can only be used to afford cheap low end computers.
 
Seventeen firms and nobody caught the mistake in the settlement. Very sloppy.

Had the mistake been in their check, you can bet they would have landed on it like a Sumo wrestler.

Although a lot of times in a settlement all you get is a crappy coupon. Even though the settlement was for millions.
 
yeah i was sorta salty about this. I have a high end one with the nvidia chip. Luckily mine has only exhibited the occasional black screen issue.

that said i didn't even bother sending it in. i'm just gonna do a reflow and fix the cooling.
 
Had the mistake been in their check, you can bet they would have landed on it like a Sumo wrestler.

Although a lot of times in a settlement all you get is a crappy coupon. Even though the settlement was for millions.

yup, HP got sued for a lot for shit they do with their toner, if you had any of the printers and got ripped off for thousands because of it you for a nice coupon for $2 - $5 off your next toner purpose. :rolleyes:
 
I had a friend who had a bad GPU in his laptop. So after two years of ownership with only one of the two very expensive GPUs in his laptop working, and being out of a computer for two weeks while he got his laptop replaced, he finally got his laptop to the condition it should have been in when he got it.

And of course, Dell/Nvidia replaced the GPUs at a fraction of the production cost that they were when the laptop was new.

Pretty shady business plan. And too bad it had to get sued out of them.
 
And people wonder why Nvidia's market share is going down.
Well, if you looked at the data, the decline was caused almost entirely by the huge drop in integrated graphics sales by nvidia. LGA 775/478/479 is dead, so very few sales on the Intel side and nvidia hasn't made a new AMD chipset with IGP in a while.

Anyways, this is just HP customers, right? I read details of it on a link from /. and it was because HP couldn't/wouldn't fix some affected laptops. Apple, Dell, Toshiba, etc users aren't getting a cheapie $300 HP laptop. ;)
 
I'm still waiting on my replacement from this class action settlement. I was so pissed that I went from a 17'' high end HP and am getting this POS in return, but since it was totally dead I guess something is better than nothing.
 
can someone post the exact specs of the $330 compaq they're talking about ?

is the cpu faster than the ones in the busted old laptops?
 
Yep. My cousin got screwed in this deal. Had a $1,500 laptop and the GPU went bad. Now he's getting a cheapy Compaq. He had two options but unfortunately the better of the two was the Compaq.
 
I have an HP laptop but made sure it used AMD for graphics - smart choice.
 
can someone post the exact specs of the $330 compaq they're talking about ?

is the cpu faster than the ones in the busted old laptops?


Display

•15.6" diagonal High-Definition HP BrightView LED Display
•1366 x 768 Resolution

Processor

•AMD-V Series V140 single core processor
•2.30GHz

Graphics

•ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4250 Graphics

Memory

•2GB DDR3 System Memory (2 DIMM)

Battery

•Up to 4.15 Hours of Battery Life
•47WHr 6-cell Lithium-Ion Battery

Hard drive

•250GB Serial ATA (SATA) 5400RPM

Optical drive

•SuperMulti 8X DVD±R/RW with Double Layer Support

Expansion

•3 x USB 2.0 ports
•1 x VGA
•1 x RJ-45
•Headphone jack
•Microphone

Video

•No webcam

Audio

•Internal stereo speakers

Wireless

•802.11 b/g/n WLAN

Ethernet

•10/100 Fast Ethernet LAN

Input

•101-key compatible with full-size keyboard
•Touchpad

Enclosure

•Color - Black

Size (H x W x D)

•14.72" x 9.70" x 1.29"/1.49"

Weight

•5.6 pounds
 
The lawyers should have received the crappy laptops and the consumers should have received the monetary settlement.

Then you would have seen action on this!
 
Display

•15.6" diagonal High-Definition HP BrightView LED Display
•1366 x 768 Resolution

Processor

•AMD-V Series V140 single core processor
•2.30GHz

Graphics

•ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4250 Graphics

Memory

•2GB DDR3 System Memory (2 DIMM)

Battery

•Up to 4.15 Hours of Battery Life
•47WHr 6-cell Lithium-Ion Battery

Hard drive

•250GB Serial ATA (SATA) 5400RPM

Optical drive

•SuperMulti 8X DVD±R/RW with Double Layer Support

Expansion

•3 x USB 2.0 ports
•1 x VGA
•1 x RJ-45
•Headphone jack
•Microphone

Video

•No webcam

Audio

•Internal stereo speakers

Wireless

•802.11 b/g/n WLAN

Ethernet

•10/100 Fast Ethernet LAN

Input

•101-key compatible with full-size keyboard
•Touchpad

Enclosure

•Color - Black

Size (H x W x D)

•14.72" x 9.70" x 1.29"/1.49"

Weight

•5.6 pounds

Seriously? It has their competitor's IGP. :p
 
I am a member of the class that filed a claim.

In 2006 I bought a Dell E1705 that came with an Nvidia 7900GS chip. The laptop actually worked fine for well over 2 and almost 3 years. Around the beginning of 2009 the laptop did what many before it had done. The video card started producing severe artifacts as a result of heat damage. With the unit being out of warranty and a replacement part selling for $400 I just set it aside and moved on.

Fast forward to mid June/July 2010. I get the standard class action card in the mail with instruction to fill out a web form and submit proof of purchase. I did this. Around February 2011 a box shows up at my door with instructions to mail my laptop and AC adapter to Dell our of warranty support. Inside there was a form for me to describe the problem I was having. I found the form odd because I expected they would already know why they were sending the box but I filled the form out anyway. I shipped it the following day.

I don't hear a thing for well over month until I get an automated call from a Dell auto caller that says my laptop had been recieved and that they determined that my LCD panel was cracked and need replacement at a cost of $299. They wanted me to call in and authorize the repair. My first call was to a lady. I had to explain why the laptop was sent in and that the LCD was fine when it was shipped. I instructed her to tell the technician to replace the video card as settlement allows and send it back to me. This goes on for a month. I have to field 3 more calls with the 3rd service rep finally confirming the video card had been replaced but the LCD was cracked and needed repair. Telling her the same thing I asked that the laptop be sent back. A week later I get an email from another rep asking for me to authorize the LCD repair and after 11 replies I finally get him to agree to ship the laptop back to me.

Some of the emails: http://imgur.com/a/3nGZU

A week and a half later I get the unit back. The LCD screen is NOT cracked and the video card had been replaced. I sent the unit in running Suse 11.2 and got it back running an expired copy of Windows 7 Ultimate beta with only the wireless driver installed. The unit had been crammed into a plastic bag with the original padded bag torn in half and stuffed below the laptop. The AC adapter which I had taken care to wrap properly and rubber band together had been shoved into the box. The box itself wasn't even properly sealed with tape.

I will never buy another Dell product again nor will I suggest their products to friends.
 
ASUS G1S was affected by the faulty GPU. I had to send mine in for RMA twice. The third time, ASUS gave me the run around on my extended warranty. ASUS was not mentioned in the lawsuit at all. So while others actually got offered something, I got offered nothing. My ASUS G1S now runs with a GPU that if I even push it a bit, it'll overheat (not cause of dust or cooling) and the screen will fuzz out.
 
The lawyers should have received the crappy laptops and the consumers should have received the monetary settlement.

Then you would have seen action on this!
LOL, the lawyers got $15 million and the settlement for class members is $10 million.
 
LOL, the lawyers got $15 million and the settlement for class members is $10 million.

But how could It be? How the heck do lawyers get such a big part of the steak? This makes no fucking sense to me, because:
a) Lawyers are the only ones that get paid wether they do their job ok or not.
b) Makes no sense to pay them more than what you will win.
 
I have a Gateway P171x-fx with an nVidia m8800GTS. I wasn't even included in the lawsuit, but my machine's GPU failed twice. The second time was just two weeks outside of the 3 yr warranty and I got nothing. I baked my GPU; everything's better now.

To hear that those that did get in on the lawsuit got shafted this way leads me to be very supportive of AMD in my next builds and future recommendations.
 
I have a Gateway P171x-fx with an nVidia m8800GTS. I wasn't even included in the lawsuit, but my machine's GPU failed twice. The second time was just two weeks outside of the 3 yr warranty and I got nothing. I baked my GPU; everything's better now.

To hear that those that did get in on the lawsuit got shafted this way leads me to be very supportive of AMD in my next builds and future recommendations.

Last three builds have all been AMD/ATI. I will continue to for the foreseeable future.
 
But how could It be? How the heck do lawyers get such a big part of the steak? This makes no fucking sense to me, because:
a) Lawyers are the only ones that get paid wether they do their job ok or not.
b) Makes no sense to pay them more than what you will win.
Yes, it makes no sense.

http://blogs.wsj.com/deals/2011/03/24/dealpolitik-the-good-the-bad-and-the-ugly-of-class-actions/

Actually it was $13 million to lawyers, $10 million for claims. I posted $15 million above.
 
holy shit. an amd V series single core laptop as a replacement............ wow, the class got jacked.

replacements should be based on equivalent performance.
you don't replace dual core laptops with single core crap.

7900GS for a 4250 integrated graphics that can't even play battlefield 2.
 
at least ppl in the US got something. Ppl in canada got nothing besides the satisfaction of putting a sledgehammer to a laptop...
 
Still waiting on my M1330 to get mailed back (glad I removed the hard drive first according to some guy in this thread saying a new OS was installed...)
 
Wait, would the Precision M90 have fallen under this class action? I've had two of those machines die on me at the office and I'm on my last one.
 
Still waiting for them to send the box and instructions to the correct address. So far they have shipped four boxes to my old address, but can recite my current address when asked.
 
ASUS G1S was affected by the faulty GPU. I had to send mine in for RMA twice. The third time, ASUS gave me the run around on my extended warranty. ASUS was not mentioned in the lawsuit at all. So while others actually got offered something, I got offered nothing. My ASUS G1S now runs with a GPU that if I even push it a bit, it'll overheat (not cause of dust or cooling) and the screen will fuzz out.

Yeah, My G1s was also effected, and needed to be sent in a few times. They gave me the option of getting it replaced with a G50 though, so I jumped right on that. Still cost me about $250 though, OOW.
 
Wait, would the Precision M90 have fallen under this class action? I've had two of those machines die on me at the office and I'm on my last one.
Did it use a G80 series GPU? Look on Dell's site for settlement information
 
I have the Dv2020us that was sent in. It had:

HP Dv2020us - AMD Turion 64 X2 Mobile TL-50@ 1.6GHz with a Passmark score of 771.
Compaq Replacement: AMD-V Series V140 single core processor @ 2.30GHz with a Passmark score of 674.


The spread the between the two is by a 100 points I don't know if I'll notice a difference and/or if this processor supports multi-threading.


But the overall specs are considerably better:

802.11 b/g/n
Larger HDD
2GB RAM (my Dv2020us had 1GB)

I wish the NIC was 10/100/1000 but it'll mainly hooked up via 802.11n

This laptop has been dead for 3 years now. I'm just happy it's no longer a paperweight and it gets the wife off my back about buying her a new laptop. I'm just waiting for the damn thing to arrive. I was sent out March 7th....
 
Yes, it makes no sense.

http://blogs.wsj.com/deals/2011/03/24/dealpolitik-the-good-the-bad-and-the-ugly-of-class-actions/

Actually it was $13 million to lawyers, $10 million for claims. I posted $15 million above.

Good read. Althought I think that the justice system in the US is screwed, plain and simple. The fact that in many many trials its more important to convince the jury rather than showing proof of what you are talking about (IE playing with feeling and not showing what really happened) means that it doesn't matter wether you are guilty or innocent as long as you have a ton of money to get a very good lawyer. And it shouldn't be that way.

As for the class-action, surprising also...
 
What mistake?

How about the fact that the lawsuit amounted to nothing at all to the people affected by it? I'm well aware of how class action suits work, but it's complete bullshit regardless. Companies get a slap on the wrist, lawyers make money, the end. It's not even deterrent and it does nothing whatsoever to the consumers. It should be illegal.
 
Should we open a class action law suit against the lawyers who filed the original class action law suit to nvidia??
 
Still waiting on my M1330 to get mailed back (glad I removed the hard drive first according to some guy in this thread saying a new OS was installed...)

I got mine back the other day. I'm not sure if there was an OS on there since I bought it for my dad and have no idea what state it was in when it they gave it back to me but there's definitely no OS on there now.

Here's the DVD slot though: http://i.imgur.com/VtdSD.jpg
DVDs go in fine. They have trouble ejecting. I'm just going to open this badboy up and fix things back in place.
 
Back
Top