NSA: Our System Too Complex To Stop It From Deleting Data

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The National Security Agency, facing lawsuits over its surveillance programs, says that the system is too complex to stop it from deleting data that can be used against the agency in court. :rolleyes:

The government's explanation raises more concerns, said Cindy Cohn, EFF's legal director. "To me, it demonstrates that once the government has custody of this information even they can't keep track of it anymore even for purposes of what they don't want to destroy," she said in an interview.
 
What I find even more concerning is that Cindy Cohn thinks what they said is actually true.
Buffoons and corruption everywhere.
 
Elf-You-Sit-on-a-Throne-of-Lies.png
 
Technically what they say probably is true. I know at least their collection systems in the past operated under several general principles. They recorded data to sift through searching for a database of keywords, traffic that contained those keywords moved onto the next phase, any traffic that didn't would get discarded/deleted. Then the traffic that went through would go through another process of analysis and more data would be discarded/deleted. So while they collect a large amount of data, they actually only eventually look at a very small subset of all that data and they don't tend to keep the rest of it simply because the amount of storage that would take would be astronomical.
 
By the NSAs logic, if I were to write a computer virus that was only meant to infect my friend as a joke on my local network, but if that virus were to escape my network and infect hundreds of millions of PCs, I shouldn't be liable because now its out of my control....?


and if I were arrested and ordered by a court to retain evidence from that virus, but the virus I created was programmed to regularly delete the evidence (and to safeguard against me changing this behavior), I somehow wouldn't be liable for what I created...?
 
I can see it. It could be a real bitch actually.

First off we already know the EFF screwed up sort of when on the one hand screamed for the NSA to delete the data and then decide to file a law suite claiming it was illegally collected so now it became evidence and had to be retained. But that's ok, we have Judges to figure this out and the Judge said "NSA, Stop destroying data", then a week later he said, ahh, OK, you can dump it.

To get a better understanding you have to know what the 702 program data under discussion is all about. This is the Prism Program, Prism is the repository of data that has been provided to the NSA under National Security Letter, Court Order, or Warrant, from Providers and Phone Carriers like Google and Verizon. This is not the meta-data program data BUT, it is almost certain that this data is mixed in the same data bases as the stuff collected from foreign sources because Prism is used to support the Analyst's work so it makes sense that it would all be data-based together.

Now from the FISA Court's perspective, just signing off on a warrant is not a Judgement of guilt, it's an OK to request information, so the people involved are still innocent and their privacy must still be protected from people who have access to Prism but are not working the issue that involves the protected person. So something has to be "shielded", marked, or whatever but there has to be discriminators or encryption options that safeguard the persons identity from those who don't have a need to know it. There was also a FISA Court requirement to destroy US Person's data after five years from the time of when it was acquired.

Yea, depending on how this thing was set up, I wouldn't want to have to write the search algorithms that have to select some of this stuff for destruction and not other stuff.
 
By the NSAs logic, if I were to write a computer virus that was only meant to infect my friend as a joke on my local network, but if that virus were to escape my network and infect hundreds of millions of PCs, I shouldn't be liable because now its out of my control....?


and if I were arrested and ordered by a court to retain evidence from that virus, but the virus I created was programmed to regularly delete the evidence (and to safeguard against me changing this behavior), I somehow wouldn't be liable for what I created...?

Correct.
 
By the NSAs logic, if I were to write a computer virus that was only meant to infect my friend as a joke on my local network, but if that virus were to escape my network and infect hundreds of millions of PCs, I shouldn't be liable because now its out of my control....?


and if I were arrested and ordered by a court to retain evidence from that virus, but the virus I created was programmed to regularly delete the evidence (and to safeguard against me changing this behavior), I somehow wouldn't be liable for what I created...?

No. What they are saying is that there are a number of programs that all collect data. It isn't just one overarching program. They would have to devise a way to implement storage in all of the programs. In addition the amount of data they are collecting is so vast there is no reasonable way for them to store all of it, which is what the EFF asked. And finally some of the data is classified and can't be released to public. So in reality, it was an unreasonable request in the first place. The judge seemed to agree since the order was reversed.
 
They probably can't keep all that data because they need to make room for new surveillance data.:D
 
Ahh Ghost6303, they are not worried about liability, President Bush gave them a get out of jail free card with his War powers Letter, the one Obama has left in effect. They are not going to jail so you should give up on that concept.

But they do have to go through all the moves required of them by courts and judges. Keep the data, destroy the data, keep some of the data, destroy this other data. So even if they know they are not going to jail over anything in the Prism database they still have one Court that said they have to destroy the data after 5 years and another court that says they have to keep it for the EFF's lawsuit, this Judge was supposed to make a decision and he can't make up his mind from one week to the next.
 
"The amount of data they are collecting is so vast there is no reasonable way for them to store all of it." Which points out one major reason I laugh every time someone thinks the NSA is out trying to watch everyone jerk off to porn, or really cares what YOU are doing. It is about collecting the data so that specifics can be targeted if needed. I'm still a firm believer that it all comes down to the tool vs. the user debate, guns don't kill people, people do, these NSA programs are tools for people to use, whether or not a person abuses the system isn't the programs fault.
 
"The amount of data they are collecting is so vast there is no reasonable way for them to store all of it." Which points out one major reason I laugh every time someone thinks the NSA is out trying to watch everyone jerk off to porn, or really cares what YOU are doing. It is about collecting the data so that specifics can be targeted if needed. I'm still a firm believer that it all comes down to the tool vs. the user debate, guns don't kill people, people do, these NSA programs are tools for people to use, whether or not a person abuses the system isn't the programs fault.

In principle yes. But the problem is that because the program is so vast it is easy for someone to abuse its uses. Especially given the penchant for the office of President to abuse their powers. They could essentially start putting in keywords looking for what they deem to be "seditious" behavior and start using the information to attack their opponents. Obama has already been caught doing that numerous times now with other programs. That isn't to say previous presidents weren't also guilty of that, its just been especially visible lately.
 
Anyone watch Enemy of the State? It's eye opening that it came out 15 years ago and to see that basically everything in it is true.
 
I can see it. It could be a real bitch actually.

First off we already know the EFF screwed up sort of when on the one hand screamed for the NSA to delete the data and then decide to file a law suite claiming it was illegally collected so now it became evidence and had to be retained. But that's ok, we have Judges to figure this out and the Judge said "NSA, Stop destroying data", then a week later he said, ahh, OK, you can dump it.

To get a better understanding you have to know what the 702 program data under discussion is all about. This is the Prism Program, Prism is the repository of data that has been provided to the NSA under National Security Letter, Court Order, or Warrant, from Providers and Phone Carriers like Google and Verizon. This is not the meta-data program data BUT, it is almost certain that this data is mixed in the same data bases as the stuff collected from foreign sources because Prism is used to support the Analyst's work so it makes sense that it would all be data-based together.

Now from the FISA Court's perspective, just signing off on a warrant is not a Judgement of guilt, it's an OK to request information, so the people involved are still innocent and their privacy must still be protected from people who have access to Prism but are not working the issue that involves the protected person. So something has to be "shielded", marked, or whatever but there has to be discriminators or encryption options that safeguard the persons identity from those who don't have a need to know it. There was also a FISA Court requirement to destroy US Person's data after five years from the time of when it was acquired.

Yea, depending on how this thing was set up, I wouldn't want to have to write the search algorithms that have to select some of this stuff for destruction and not other stuff.

IT'S ALWAYS SOMEONE ELSE'S FAULT
 
If you want something that is intrusive, invasive, expensive, bloated, bureaucratic, inefficient, and wasteful, then yes, let government set it up and run it. Problem solved.
 
Did anyone else read the thread topic title and honestly not just go sigh and think to themselves "And there it is... finally they just came out and played that card."
 
I believe it, they skim so much data the can't possibly store it all. It's literally impossible, there is not enough computer storage on the planet.
 
By the NSAs logic, if I were to write a computer virus that was only meant to infect my friend as a joke on my local network, but if that virus were to escape my network and infect hundreds of millions of PCs, I shouldn't be liable because now its out of my control....?


and if I were arrested and ordered by a court to retain evidence from that virus, but the virus I created was programmed to regularly delete the evidence (and to safeguard against me changing this behavior), I somehow wouldn't be liable for what I created...?

From my experience, it only really pertains to information that was still there after the judge made the ruling. If you destroy evidence you can possibly be penalized for that, especially if they prove that it was knowingly done. Many companies and organizations have a limit on how long data can be kept, especially with emails, for that reason.

If the NSA was to discard gathered information because they found that it violated a law if they kept it, then one cannot force them to keep the data.

Personally I find that this just screams lack of planning and foresight on the NSA part because if they are incapable of pulling information that needs to be kept from the database and deleting other information, then their system was incompetently designed and should force the people in control of budgets to seriously question letting the NSA do anything involved with computers.
 
7 Billion People in the world.

Over 200 Sovereign Nation States.

More then 25,000 international non-governmental organizations.

The US Population is about 315 Million, the US has membership in about 80 of those 25,000 organizations.

In 2010 world wide sales of computers came to well over 300 Million The most recent highpoint in US PC Sales was 75 Million units in 2010.

This page gives you a list of the world's cell phone usage by Nation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of_mobile_phones_in_use

Do some reading, do some thinking, of course the NSA's data collection is vast, and that is just Computers and Mobile devices. That doesn't even scratch the surface of everything else like RADARs, Satellites, and everything else that emits a signal in the entire Electromagnetic Spectrum.

How is it even now that so many of you can be fooled by this media trick. People who talk about "vast data collection" as if they don't have a worldwide mission.
 
Personally I find that this just screams lack of planning and foresight on the NSA part because if they are incapable of pulling information that needs to be kept from the database and deleting other information, then their system was incompetently designed and should force the people in control of budgets to seriously question letting the NSA do anything involved with computers.

Right, because when you design something for specific purposes and later someone levies new requirements on your system that it was specifically designed not to allow, that's incompetence.
 
Back
Top