No Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim DLC for PS3?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
It’s not looking good for PS3 owners anxiously awaiting the release of Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Bethesda has reported via their blog that the issues they have encountered may be too much to overcome. Don’t give up on them quite yet, they’re still tinkering. :cool:
 
They have issues on the everything. Every one of their PC releases has had a load of bugs and barely worked, and was full of random bugs and crash to desktop issues years after release. Hardly surprising that a "non standard parts" system is too hard for them (even though this isn't anywhere near their first game on it...).
 
Oh and I think you mean "It’s not looking good for PS3 owners anxiously awaiting the release of Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim's Dawngaurd DLC". Not Skyrim itself. :D
 
oh man i thought it said pc and ps3 got scared and mad there for a sec

sucks for ps3 owners though good thing pc gaming fo life!! :)


really though sucks for ps3 owners :(
 
I keep getting feeling that for complex and demanding games, the PS3 is inferior to the 360. At least that's what it seems like with Bethseda trying to get patches out to the PS3.
 
They have issues on the everything. Every one of their PC releases has had a load of bugs and barely worked, and was full of random bugs and crash to desktop issues years after release. Hardly surprising that a "non standard parts" system is too hard for them (even though this isn't anywhere near their first game on it...).

I've had one crash to the desktop in Skyrim, I don't remember any in either Fallout. Now I will admit I did just get Skyrim recently , so maybe they worked out some of the the bugs and I was already patched. But I'm just saying I haven't experienced what you're describing.
 
I keep getting feeling that for complex and demanding games, the PS3 is inferior to the 360. At least that's what it seems like with Bethseda trying to get patches out to the PS3.

I'd say the problem lies with Bethesda as plenty of other developers have been able to release ports on the PS3 that are as good or better than the X360 counterpart. Shadows of the Damned comes to mind. That said, Sony really needs to start thinking about making it easier to code for their consoles/handhelds as they're infamous for making developer's lives more difficult than necessary and that's been going on for a lot longer than the PS3 has existed.
 
What is way more bigger issue is that they signed a stupid distribution agreement for central and eastern Europe - so i can't buy the DLC for Skyrim even when i have PC & Steam and even if i want.
 
It's a disgrace and there's no excuse.

Even by Bethesda's standards...let THAT sink in...their games have been abysmal buggy train wrecks on the PS3. Think about the "normal" glitches on PC and such and amplify those problems by a thousand or so and you get the picture of what PS3 gamers have been forced to endure if they make the mistake of buying a Bethesda developed title on that system.



http://www.ign.com/articles/2012/08/31/skyrim-dlc-on-playstation-3-may-never-happen

“Earlier in the month, we provided an update on Dawnguard's status for PS3.

“It's been a few weeks, and we wanted to make sure everyone knows where we're at with Dawnguard. Skyrim is a massive and dynamic game that requires a lot of resources, and things get much more complex when you're talking about sizable content like Dawnguard. We have tried a number of things, but none of them solve the issue enough to make Dawnguard good for everyone. The PS3 is a powerful system, and we're working hard to deliver the content you guys want. Dawnguard is obviously not the only DLC we’ve been working on either, so the issues of adding content get even more complicated. This is not a problem we’re positive we can solve, but we are working together with Sony to try to bring you this content.

“We wish we had a more definitive answer right now. We understand the frustration when the same content is not available on all platforms. When we have an update, we will certainly let you know. We deeply appreciate all the time and support you have given us, and we’ll keep doing our best to return that.”

This is nonsense.

Six years later and they still can't develop on the PS3 worth a damn. That's on them. That's their fault.

No one else has had this much trouble with programming for the PS3 by a mile.
 
They have issues on the everything. Every one of their PC releases has had a load of bugs and barely worked, and was full of random bugs and crash to desktop issues years after release. Hardly surprising that a "non standard parts" system is too hard for them (even though this isn't anywhere near their first game on it...).

They always release buggy software and, considering how many times they've reused Oblivion's game engine with a few tweaks and updates, there's really no excuse for it. :( I'm not at all surprised that their programmers don't have any idea how to get their content working on Sony's console.
 
PS3 has a major lack of ram
my guess Dawnguard needs more ram for what ever and the PS3 just doesnt have it
 
I've had one crash to the desktop in Skyrim, I don't remember any in either Fallout. Now I will admit I did just get Skyrim recently , so maybe they worked out some of the the bugs and I was already patched. But I'm just saying I haven't experienced what you're describing.

There is a pile of bugs in skyrim, some gamebreaking. Whole quests dont work because of bugs and glitches. Worst example was the quest in the tower with the sleeping people, the guy just wouldn't move up the stairs after triggering the next step to go open the door. So the whole quest would be impossible after that. Even with lots of patching it still happens (it's due to bad pathing I think, nothing complicated), but it's kind of anoying as it's one of the daedric item quests. It's definately a game i'm glad to have the console for, so I can "fix" lots of things as I go along, like quest characters never spawning, or missing items. Oblivion had to rely on community patches for this after Bethesda gave up, and still isn't perfect.

Bethesda games on average crash more than any other PC game i've ever played (so it's hard to blame it on system/hardware issues. Fallout had the memory leak style problem for a long time where it would gradually get worse and worse performance over a few hours. With that game it would crash to desktop (even as vanilla) during loading mostly. If it didn't then then it would randomly after a long session. Same for New Vegas. Skyrim crashes less than the others but it still does.

However fun their games are, Bethesda just seem like lazy programmers who can't get stuff right. Or just throw a load of stuff together and hope it works. When it does, it's fine, when it doesn't they have 0 clue what to do. :(
 
They always release buggy software and, considering how many times they've reused Oblivion's game engine with a few tweaks and updates, there's really no excuse for it. :( I'm not at all surprised that their programmers don't have any idea how to get their content working on Sony's console.

Erm... Morrowind's Game Engine...
 
PS3 has a major lack of ram
my guess Dawnguard needs more ram for what ever and the PS3 just doesnt have it

Isn't it only like 256 MB or something really tiny like that? I remember hearing two console nerds at work arguing about it a long time ago when they were both new consoles.
 
Isn't it only like 256 MB or something really tiny like that? I remember hearing two console nerds at work arguing about it a long time ago when they were both new consoles.

not even its like 16MB oh an that is shared over all the Cell cores ...
 
Isn't it only like 256 MB or something really tiny like that? I remember hearing two console nerds at work arguing about it a long time ago when they were both new consoles.

256mb cpu ram and 256mb vram, the xbox has 512 total system ram which is split between the two, so pretty much the same.
 
ah right its 256 but each core needs its own space in ram so you end up with like 32MB per core
and if you have read from another cores part of ram you run in all kinda fun issues
 
ah right its 256 but each core needs its own space in ram so you end up with like 32MB per core
and if you have read from another cores part of ram you run in all kinda fun issues

Does an i3 use less ram than an i7? Can I half my ram usage my turning off hyperthreading? Probably works like any other processor, where the cores can access any ram/the same ram, I assume it has caches?
 
Does an i3 use less ram than an i7? Can I half my ram usage my turning off hyperthreading? Probably works like any other processor, where the cores can access any ram/the same ram, I assume it has caches?

Sony has some of your cashes if you bought a PS3. :p And Microsoft has a little piece of your soul (if it hasn't already been spoken for) if you bought a 360...even more of it if you allow them to capture your likeness with Kinect. That thing is like a spirit vaccum.
 
Does an i3 use less ram than an i7? Can I half my ram usage my turning off hyperthreading? Probably works like any other processor, where the cores can access any ram/the same ram, I assume it has caches?

Cell is not the same as i86
and no Cell has no cache...
 
I'd say the problem lies with Bethesda as plenty of other developers have been able to release ports on the PS3 that are as good or better than the X360 counterpart. Shadows of the Damned comes to mind. That said, Sony really needs to start thinking about making it easier to code for their consoles/handhelds as they're infamous for making developer's lives more difficult than necessary and that's been going on for a lot longer than the PS3 has existed.

You think Bethesda is the only company who has claimed that the PS3 is hard as balls to work on? Gabe Newell has talked about how problematic the PS3 was to work on. The problem is that the PS3 has an architecture that is very different then Xbox 360 and PS3. It's not that they can't, it's that they don't see it cost effective.

This has been going on since the PS2. But back then developers were more willing to throw more effort onto the PS2, cause it held the majority of the market. Something like well over 70% of market share, compared to GameCube and Xbox. Unlike right now where the Wii, PS3, and Xbox 360 own a nearly even 33% share of console sales. That makes it really easy for developers to avoid a console that may not pay off to develop DLC's.

Sorry but 7 SPE cores was a stupid idea on Sony's part.
 
You think Bethesda is the only company who has claimed that the PS3 is hard as balls to work on? Gabe Newell has talked about how problematic the PS3 was to work on. The problem is that the PS3 has an architecture that is very different then Xbox 360 and PS3. It's not that they can't, it's that they don't see it cost effective.

This has been going on since the PS2. But back then developers were more willing to throw more effort onto the PS2, cause it held the majority of the market. Something like well over 70% of market share, compared to GameCube and Xbox. Unlike right now where the Wii, PS3, and Xbox 360 own a nearly even 33% share of console sales. That makes it really easy for developers to avoid a console that may not pay off to develop DLC's.

Sorry but 7 SPE cores was a stupid idea on Sony's part.


Those SPE cores, are frickin awesome when used correctly. The first party stuff on PS3 is unmatched. There is NOTHING on the Xbox that can touch Uncharted , Killzone or Infamous in graphical fidelity. The problems arise when third party devs want to do cross platform. Obsidian wouldnt have an issue if the consoles werent so old too. I dont think you realize how much shoehorning is going on to make these games work on very old hardware and modern PCs at the same time.
 
Man people never believe me when I tell them Killzone 2 is one of the best looking games I've ever seen. The smoke effects in that game is still pretty unmatched.

That said, I remember when the Sony boss was bragging about how difficult the PS3 was to program, claiming it would add to the longevity. Yeah okay buddy!
 
the PS3 has some power but its hard to get at
the cores all have to working in sync
the issue is when one core needs to work on data another core has
for some things like folding its great but for games not so much
 
"PS3, the weakest HD console out right now having problems with Skyrim, a memory resource heavy game, New at 11PM, stay tuned too CNN for more info"

Is this a damn surprise? The PS3 has so little available ram that simply playing for 40-50 hours generates a save file that's too big for the PS3 to handle, eventually Bethdethsa had to take apart the save file and treat it like they do skyrim itself, have it load in blocks instead of loading the whole thing. The only thing it would always load is completed/current quests and current carried equipment.

This fixed the problem, but now there is dawnguard, and from what I have seen of it, is a -LOT- more texture heavy then launch skyrim was. They got it working on 360 because they made the cells -EXTREAMLY- small, which while traveling several hundred meters will be causing old cells to swap out with new ones like mad, and loading less of them at the same time.

But, yeah, I hope, god I hope, this is -FINALLY- the fucking wake up call for PS3 owners to finally realized their "Holy grail" of a system is a -SYSTEM-, and like any other system, has limitations. And yes, it has far, far, far greater limitations then the 360 does.

And again, before I have any PS3 fans etc jump down my throat, the only systems I own is a PS3 and Wii, the only reason I bought both was because PS3 and Wii is the only systems I can get certain games, mostly everything on 360 with the exception of Gears/Halo I can get on PC.
 
Why would anyone buy an elder scrolls game for a console anyway? Is your TV that much better than your monitor (the resolution isn't, but field of view matters)? Is your computer stuck with a 2005 GPU (a 2005 CPU might well be enough)?

I could be shocked and maybe Bethesda debugged Skyrim (and maybe Oblivion) better than what is fixed with the unofficial patches with the PC, but I can't imagine playing Eldar scrolls games with the console UI (or the various leveling patches for Oblivion). The game itself (Skyrim) might be good enough to be the most played game of 2011 after being released late November, but the mods make it worth playing well through 2012.
 
Does an i3 use less ram than an i7? Can I half my ram usage my turning off hyperthreading? Probably works like any other processor, where the cores can access any ram/the same ram, I assume it has caches?

Yes, on PCs each CPU core requires some small amount of RAM for system purposes, for example I made a server 2012 VM with 1 core and memory demand after bootup is 249MB, with 24 cores memory demand is 324MB so around 3MB required per core, so yeah the extra cores probably do necessitate more memory even in the PS3
 
Man people never believe me when I tell them Killzone 2 is one of the best looking games I've ever seen. The smoke effects in that game is still pretty unmatched.

That said, I remember when the Sony boss was bragging about how difficult the PS3 was to program, claiming it would add to the longevity. Yeah okay buddy!

Some "review" site guy was online saying that the PS3 hardware was more powerful then the 360 hardware, in graphics, because the CELL could assist with the GPU

What the total fucking idiot moron doesn't understand is -HOW- the Cell was assisting the GPU in the PS3, he thinks the thing was helping with -RENDERING-, which is the most graphically intensive process in rendering graphics, which the cell does not do. The cell does offloaded physics, which is -THE SAME THING- programmers do with the 360

And yes, he does indeed bring up Killzone 2/3 and Uncharted 3 as "The shining examples", and they look fine, but then he brings up Gears 3, which looks fucking PHENOMINAL in comparison, and he brushes it off with "Ho hum"

I spent a hour and a half talking on his youtube page typing out all these corrections, how the cell is used, all the shortcuts games like Killzone 2/Killzone 3/Uncharted 2/Uncharted 3 take like if a scene is GPU heavy, it can dynamically "Flush" the memory cache, and even change the entire picture resolution on the fly to keep up performance. He deleted all my comments and called himself right regardless.

Hell, Killzone 3 the developers of the game even admitted that when a scene gets graphic heavy, effects like smoke/debris etc they cut the resolution of the textures by half, if it keeps up, they "Blur" effect the screen, -ALL- the textures drop to half resolution, and if that's still not enough the entire game engine dynamically switches on the fly from 720p to 480p in order to keep the game flowing.

Point is, you can't deal with fanboys. Its impossible. Dealing with fanboys is always a measure of exhaustion, cause no matter how much logic you use, it falls on deaf ears

Hell, the Angry Video Game Nerd just did a -FANTASTIC- piece about fanboys, as he himself -WAS- a fanboy even at one time, and even had video evidence to prove it. It was fucking hilarious watching his child like self spewing half facts and half truths out the ass to "Defend" his precious nintendo.

And that's what its like dealing with console fanboys. They don't look at technical specs, they don't look up hardware computation charts etc, they just get fed media bias, and they spew it back out without thinking. Fuck here we are 7 years later and people are still shouting "PS3 MOST POWERFUL CONSOLE EVER!" at its official unveiling, and repeating all the facts SONY spewed out which any logical person -KNOWS- is bullshit
 
Regardless of the quality of the PS3's architecture, (and whether it's Sony's fault of Bethseda's fault), either way the PS3 is holding back Skyrim and what can be done to this game. I'm sure features were stripped because of Sony. And now Bethseda is trying to add features back in like they did with horse combat etc.., or DLC features.

Sucks when multiform reduces things. Most companies bring everything down to the lowest common denominator. Looks like Bethseda is getting tired of it. I know Todd Howard loves the 360 so he wont' leave that behind. But makes me wonder if more is to come.
 
Yes, on PCs each CPU core requires some small amount of RAM for system purposes, for example I made a server 2012 VM with 1 core and memory demand after bootup is 249MB, with 24 cores memory demand is 324MB so around 3MB required per core, so yeah the extra cores probably do necessitate more memory even in the PS3

its more like the SLi texture ram thing with Cell
each cell core needs to set aside its own chuck data in ram
you run in issues when 2 cell cores need the same data all kinds nasty race conditions start showing up and the cores can fight over who has access to that data
 
Some "review" site guy was online saying that the PS3 hardware was more powerful then the 360 hardware, in graphics, because the CELL could assist with the GPU

What the total fucking idiot moron doesn't understand is -HOW- the Cell was assisting the GPU in the PS3, he thinks the thing was helping with -RENDERING-, which is the most graphically intensive process in rendering graphics, which the cell does not do. The cell does offloaded physics, which is -THE SAME THING- programmers do with the 360

And yes, he does indeed bring up Killzone 2/3 and Uncharted 3 as "The shining examples", and they look fine, but then he brings up Gears 3, which looks fucking PHENOMINAL in comparison, and he brushes it off with "Ho hum"

I spent a hour and a half talking on his youtube page typing out all these corrections, how the cell is used, all the shortcuts games like Killzone 2/Killzone 3/Uncharted 2/Uncharted 3 take like if a scene is GPU heavy, it can dynamically "Flush" the memory cache, and even change the entire picture resolution on the fly to keep up performance. He deleted all my comments and called himself right regardless.

Hell, Killzone 3 the developers of the game even admitted that when a scene gets graphic heavy, effects like smoke/debris etc they cut the resolution of the textures by half, if it keeps up, they "Blur" effect the screen, -ALL- the textures drop to half resolution, and if that's still not enough the entire game engine dynamically switches on the fly from 720p to 480p in order to keep the game flowing.

Point is, you can't deal with fanboys. Its impossible. Dealing with fanboys is always a measure of exhaustion, cause no matter how much logic you use, it falls on deaf ears

Hell, the Angry Video Game Nerd just did a -FANTASTIC- piece about fanboys, as he himself -WAS- a fanboy even at one time, and even had video evidence to prove it. It was fucking hilarious watching his child like self spewing half facts and half truths out the ass to "Defend" his precious nintendo.

And that's what its like dealing with console fanboys. They don't look at technical specs, they don't look up hardware computation charts etc, they just get fed media bias, and they spew it back out without thinking. Fuck here we are 7 years later and people are still shouting "PS3 MOST POWERFUL CONSOLE EVER!" at its official unveiling, and repeating all the facts SONY spewed out which any logical person -KNOWS- is bullshit

techicly he is right
Cell COULD be more powerful then even a PC for the right conditions
look at the folding client for it it blows PC folding even GPU folding out of the water
the issue is larger data sets and need to access the same set of data with more then one cell core at a time chokes it
PS3 really needed more like 1GB of ram but it used Rambus XDR crap which costs a ton
 
oh and next gen systems better have at lest 4GB of ram no point not to now ram is so cheap
thats always been the one thing holding back consoles was the VERY small amount ram they had
 
techicly he is right
Cell COULD be more powerful then even a PC for the right conditions
look at the folding client for it it blows PC folding even GPU folding out of the water
the issue is larger data sets and need to access the same set of data with more then one cell core at a time chokes it
PS3 really needed more like 1GB of ram but it used Rambus XDR crap which costs a ton

The only way a PS3 will blow anything out of the water is in applications where ~6 threads can constantly run in under 512k per thread. Try finding a game studio willing to hire (and pay, and deal with his going home...) an old-school DSP or assembler guru who can fit hello_world in under a 1MB. Choking the main CPU doesn't help any either, but the main CPU is pretty wimpy to start with.
 
its more like the SLi texture ram thing with Cell
each cell core needs to set aside its own chuck data in ram
you run in issues when 2 cell cores need the same data all kinds nasty race conditions start showing up and the cores can fight over who has access to that data

In the case of skyrim, its purely memory limitations

Gamebyro engine is indeed a media hog, and the thing is streamlined, its just the sheer amount of stuff it needs to load for a scene is baffling in comparison to other games. Sure you could have it running on Unreal 3.5 and getting 30-40% higher framerates, but you would still be crunching up tons of memory for all those textures etc.

SONY has done a great job with the PS3, at launch the OS took up 310MB active memory, they have got it down to 252MB active memory today, they -COULD- get this down even lower, but people don't realize the things they were screaming about they wanted to have while in game like friends list, mail access etc while playing actually takes up ram.

But fact is, the 360 when running a game only needs 167MB of active memory when running, that's almost a hundred free MB of ram available for game functions. (At launch it needed 229MB of ram when running games) and this shows for texture quality in literally every multiplatform game for PS3/360. Programming for PS3 right now is an industry standard, the "Mystery" of the systems have been solved, they were solved long ago. Now programming for the system is just a resource race -IE- what can we do with the memory limits we have etc etc.

SONY moving to non-proprietary hardware for the PS4, just like the XBOX and 360's before it is a step in the right direction, but they must, must, must get that memory allocation use down when running games. Microsoft got the idea long ago that when running games, you don't need 70% of the OS active, so it dumps it all. PS3 SONY should have not been focusing on all the bells and whistles the 360 has when games are running, they should be trying to streamline the OS as much as possible, and like the 360, after the game is ended, reload the entire thing.

This is why quitting a PS3 game is so, so, so, so quick, and brings you instantly back to the surface layer of the PS3, because it remains loaded in memory. They are focusing too much on minor things, getting back to the OS in 2 seconds should -NOT- be a priority, playing the game itself should be the priority.

Why I am interested outside of general PS3 firmware hacks, people gain access to the core OS and figure out how to streamline it.Hell look at the PSP with the Half Byte Loader, even with the official firmware installed, running HBL with a quick reboot free's up 12MB of activation space, giving you the ability to do things like view youtube etc, something SONY said "Was impossible" etc
 
techicly he is right
Cell COULD be more powerful then even a PC for the right conditions
look at the folding client for it it blows PC folding even GPU folding out of the water
the issue is larger data sets and need to access the same set of data with more then one cell core at a time chokes it
PS3 really needed more like 1GB of ram but it used Rambus XDR crap which costs a ton

A CPU that is faster for one out of a million different types of data tasks is not equivalently a faster CPU. If that's the case we better start calling Bulldozer the faster CPU then Sandy Bridge because it can do 7zip data crunching faster
 
The only way a PS3 will blow anything out of the water is in applications where ~6 threads can constantly run in under 512k per thread. Try finding a game studio willing to hire (and pay, and deal with his going home...) an old-school DSP or assembler guru who can fit hello_world in under a 1MB. Choking the main CPU doesn't help any either, but the main CPU is pretty wimpy to start with.

right again for a game console is stupid but sony thought they have this huge network of cell cpus in every thing in your home.... and that didnt happen

folding is a case were that can happen and it shows but there isnt a lot cases like that with games its hard to get all 7 cores in use with out stepping on each other
 
A CPU that is faster for one out of a million different types of data tasks is not equivalently a faster CPU. If that's the case we better start calling Bulldozer the faster CPU then Sandy Bridge because it can do 7zip data crunching faster

if i was going to build a big data base server then Bulldozer is the go to CPU because it IS faster at that
for a gaming box i7 all the way

sony though they could over come this with pure power but the lack of ram holds it back
 
oh and next gen systems better have at lest 4GB of ram no point not to now ram is so cheap
thats always been the one thing holding back consoles was the VERY small amount ram they had

Ram is cheap, console makers however are literally the cheapest mother fuckers on the planet

Fuck, look at 360, microsoft with launch systems they had to decide if they were going to use 1 cents of shit quality thermal paste per system, or 13 cents of high quality thermal paste per system. Look how that turned out.

Hell, tons of people who have stock first release 360's who have replaced the thermal paste with high end Arctic Silver 5, even with those tiny fucking heatsinks run cooler then the newest 360 Slims. And lets not forget the whole fiasco with Microsoft instead of using cheap high tin solder vs expensive high copper/silver solder, a savings of 22 cents per system, but has cost them untold -BILLIONS- in RMA'd 360's

So like I said, the PS4/XBOX-Next getting 4gigs ram is a fucking pipe dream
 
Back
Top