No AGP with this new Generation?

alienz

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 14, 2002
Messages
250
Well according to the link on the front page to CoolTechZone
Nvidia said it won't offer an AGP version unless there is demand.

Ok there is demand, I am not going to purchase any of their cards, or ATI's, unless the card is AGP. There is no reason for me to upgrade my motherboard right now. 3.2C on a i875 board. We are not talking about the time the jump was made from PCI to AGP.

So exactly how can we go about showing Nvidia and ATI that there is definite demand for AGP parts, and to stop being stupid? Or even better perhaps they could do what MSI was showing off and offer both connections allowing for us to actually use the card for more than a year.

Any ideas? One of those stupid online petitions? Anyone have contact info?
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
I hope they dont make one. People need to advance and move on in life. Let AGP die. (im not saying its bad, or that we max out the bandwidth) Just let it die. We have something new. So move on.

I can see people staying with the same platform forever because they still make AGP cards.

I hope All the sockets change soon for no reason, we get another new type of ram, and everything converts to PCIe.

Why is it hard for people to spend a little money?

Just because something is new, does not mean people she move to it. AGP hasn't even reached its limit yet, so why should a consumer waste money on something he doesn't need? It doesn't make any marketing sense. While you are forcing people to move onto PCI-E, there is no point (unless you plan SLI*.) Imagine if Nvidia refuses to come out with an AGP card. ATI then capitalizes on this mistake, and *BAM* ATI has a huge part of the market share.

Take for example hybrid cars and possible hydrogen engines. Just because the technology is good and better does not mean people should be forced to move on. If John Doe wants to ride his hummer, fine. That doesn't mean he should be left with no choice to go with a hybrid because some people value it over other types.

In short, Nvidia would be incredibly stupid to not come out with an AGP card.

*which is a very small part of the market anyway
 
I'm pro PCI-E, but I do think they should give consumers a choice.

They could just say, "If you need to upgrade, get a 6800U", but if people want to upgrade to 7800GTX, they should be able to.

Personally, if I had an AGP mobo and wanted the 7800GTX, I'd just buy the mobo and card. $150 for a mobo isn't that much when you are talking about a $600 video card. That's just me though.

Maybe they are too lazy to modify the drivers.. but maybe also they found it didn't work as well as in a PCI-E. I call laziness though.
 
That bridge chip they have is pretty seemless. There is virtually no difference between AGP and PCIe.

As for the AGP thing...get over it already. Next thing you know people are going to be saying "Save Socket A." There is NO WAY Nvidia will let ATI have the only high end card in AGP, especially when the answer is as simple as throwing on their bridge chip.
 
Yeah,...well,...you know, I seem to remember a company called 3DFX that decided we the consumer didn't care for nor want 32 bit color capabilities in our grafics card either,...by the way...what ever happened to them anyway?....
 
"Save Socket A"? Socket A had reached it's limits. AGP has not. I'm sorry if you have oodles of cash to just throw away. I on the other hand see a platform that has no reason to fade already.

But as another poster said, Albatron and or some other company will release an AGP version.

kirbyrj said:
That bridge chip they have is pretty seemless. There is virtually no difference between AGP and PCIe.

As for the AGP thing...get over it already. Next thing you know people are going to be saying "Save Socket A." There is NO WAY Nvidia will let ATI have the only high end card in AGP, especially when the answer is as simple as throwing on their bridge chip.
 
Right I agree with that. In another 18months you'll have a more mature dual core solution, maybe more apps that would make use of multi-threading, giving reason to scrap the old boards and CPU's.

I just want to know how best to go about making sure there are 7800 and R520 AGP parts.

JohnAddisonUK said:
I agree AGP has not reached its limits but it's time has come, I think that there should be 7800 AGP cards but this should be the last generation to support it.
 
Well of course AGP has not reached its limit but that dosent mean anything. The PCI express is overall better, more flexable, and more room to grow over time. Also I beleive it can deliver more power to the cards via the slot, vice what AGP can. Its not about the performance AGP can deliver, its about all the other things. Also I do not beleive that the AGP protocol can support 2 AGP slots, so no SLI. ANd sure its a Nitch in the Market, however, we are moving that way.

It just makes more sence to move eveything to PCIe. AGP is last generation, plain and simple. Not because it sucks, but because something better (not neccessary faster) has come along.
 
I hope they come out with AGP nforce 4 boards before agp geforce 7's. This really sucks thay the mobo companies have been screwing us agp owners over from getting a good upgrade. Sure nforce 3 is good, but I want nforce 4!
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Also I beleive it can deliver more power to the cards via the slot, vice what AGP can.

This is a good enough reason to move away from AGP.
 
Well it seems to me, everyone isnt thinking about the technology aspect behind this. They are thinking about their financial situation and not being able to afford the transition to PCIe.... Too bad so sad.
 
It seems no one takes into consideration that bandwidth isn't the only limiting factor of AGP, and that PCI Express is a part of a whole updated platform that supports newer technologies of all different types, not just video.
 
While yes PCIe has benefits over AGP, does the G70 need anything that PCIe offers? No. It needs a bridge chip. If you want SLI then obviously you'll need to go PCIe. But the performance of this chip I don't see the need to do so.

Like everyone on [H] I have no problems spending money on my rig. But I would like to have the option for an AGP card. I like my setup, maybe I just want to upgrade my 9700Pro. Maybe I want to spend $600 on Nvidia's latest card so I can tell my friends this is what they should get.
 
I'm sure their lower level cards will be AGP like the 7600GT or 7200. It's pointless to make the high end AGP when either the slot and or the CPU will be a bottleneck.
 
I want them to NOT make an agp 7800 card, because really you should upgrade to PCI-express anyways and it would waste resorces on thier part to make a card that supports it, as for me I am still using agp but the card I have now will be my last agp card, my next system will be pci express, socket 939 most probably.
 
thespymaster said:
Yeah,...well,...you know, I seem to remember a company called 3DFX that decided we the consumer did care for nor want 32 bit color capabilities in our grafics card either,...what ever happened to them anyway?....


I think they were bought by Nvidia. LOL
 
thespymaster said:
Yeah,...well,...you know, I seem to remember a company called 3DFX that decided we the consumer did care for nor want 32 bit color capabilities in our grafics card either,...what ever happened to them anyway?....
NVidia bought them in either 1999 or 2000.
 
sculelos said:
I want them to NOT make an agp 7800 card, because really you should upgrade to PCI-express anyways and it would waste resorces on thier part to make a card that supports it, as for me I am still using agp but the card I have now will be my last agp card, my next system will be pci express, socket 939 most probably.

It's not a "waste of resources" if there's a market for it. When they released the HSI bridge, they said that it would allow the design of AGP boards from PCIe chips (and vice versa) with minimal effort - I'm not an electrical engineer but I'd think that the hardest part would be adding the connector & traces for the extra power. It's not like anyone has to design any new silcon to push one of these cards out.

Minimal design effort involving COTS parts + large base of relatively-fast AGP system = profitable market for AGP 'next-gen' cards.
 
I dont see how you guys can say agp is gone when all your pci-e boards still have pci slots on them. Best way to get an agp version would be to get the [H] and other hardware sites to call for them. "Whens the agp version going to be released?" "uh... were working on it...?"
 
kirbyrj said:
Originally Posted by USMC2Hard4U
Also I beleive it can deliver more power to the cards via the slot, vice what AGP can.

This is a good enough reason to move away from AGP.

Don't the higher end PCI-E boards use molex connectors on the card still?

-wil
 
It makes sense to make an AGP part for this generation. The last two years haven't exactly given us the largest of CPU performance gains so the older platforms with agp are still very competitive. We are still in the middle of many transitions. When the cards that 3dmark 07 requires comes out and or Longhorn, make that the start of PCI-E only.
 
i guess some people just want to let AGP die ... damn that sucks i think we should give it another year or so for AGP to fade away... shit sata 2 hasnt even taken full advantage either lol...
 
Which is silly, cause they are practically the same at this point, rofl. 1000-1200 dollars for SLI, rofl. Only reason to. Otherwise, that is it. AGP and PCI-E are practically interchangeable at this point.
 
With the millions of computers on the planet that currently have AGP,...nVidia and ATi both would be idiots not to continue to support AGP. Yeah WE, the hardcore community might, and do upgrade frequently however, the rest of the world doesn't upgrade that often and genereally only when they find that their current hardware doesn't cut it. So,...while we are willing to change platforms every 6 months or so,...the rest of the world isn't and that is lost revenue if they don't supply them with a viable upgrade option.
 
I don't understand the mentality of wanting to kill off AGP, what's the reason behind it? It doesn't affect PCI-e owners at all, if they make both AGP and PCI-e configurations how in the hell would PCI-e owners lose anything? If AGP doesn't perform as well as PCI-e then it still doesn't affect them since they'll be using the faster PCI-e. Someone please educate me on the consequences of not rushing to kill AGP, because the only real reason I can think of right now is that PCI-e owners wanting to promote elitism "I have a PCI-e slot and you don't so I get to use this card, haha sucker!"

:confused: :confused: :confused:
 
I got the money for it, but I will spend it logically, if my current s754 system can keep up in all the latest games, even on a 9800 pro (waiting for this gen... :mad: ) I was gonna make this AGP upgrade my last hurrah, and then I will hit up PCI-E in like a year from now.
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
NVidia bought them in either 1999 or 2000.

EXACTLY....And when 3dfx realized what we did want,...it was too late,...they got cut down in the crossfire,...that's what you get when you think you know instead of covering all of your bases....upgrade to PCIe, yes someday but for them not to continue AGP support for a few years would be suicide...


:eek:
 
If you're bitching about the 7800GTX not being AGP, be quiet.

If you can afford a $600 videocard, I'm quite sure you can afford a $100 motherboard.
 
TMaxx6 said:
If you're bitching about the 7800GTX not being AGP, be quiet.

If you can afford a $600 videocard, I'm quite sure you can afford a $100 motherboard.

Yeah but my current CPU won't run on any PCI-e motherboard, CPU will cost another 500 dollars because it'd be a waste to upgrade but not get something good, and with the new CPU+mobo I'm looking at buying some new DDR2 RAM as well, and on and on and on and on. :(
 
sakurakana1003 said:
I don't understand the mentality of wanting to kill off AGP, what's the reason behind it? It doesn't affect PCI-e owners at all, if they make both AGP and PCI-e configurations how in the hell would PCI-e owners lose anything? If AGP doesn't perform as well as PCI-e then it still doesn't affect them since they'll be using the faster PCI-e. Someone please educate me on the consequences of not rushing to kill AGP, because the only real reason I can think of right now is that PCI-e owners wanting to promote elitism "I have a PCI-e slot and you don't so I get to use this card, haha sucker!"

:confused: :confused: :confused:


Because it costs more to engineer and produce both AGP and PCI-E videocards? If new technology is available, use it. Just because some people whine about not wanting to spend the money for a PCI-E motherboard doesn't mean everyone else shouldn't have PCI-E. If there is a market for it, which there is, it will sell.
 
TMaxx6 said:
Because it costs more to engineer and produce both AGP and PCI-E videocards? If new technology is available, use it. Just because some people whine about not wanting to spend the money for a PCI-E motherboard doesn't mean everyone else shouldn't have PCI-E. If there is a market for it, which there is, it will sell.

It cost more to produce both AGP and PCI-e, true. But you still haven't answered my question: how does it affect PCI-e users in a negative way? The PCI-e technology is available, and it IS being used. That's not what I'm talking about, I'm talking about rushing to kill AGP. I personallyl never said anyone shouldn't have PCI-e, I said everyone SHOULD have PCI-e, but should also have the choice of AGP. There IS market, it IS selling. What does that have anything to do with what I talked about? :confused:


EDIT: I'm in full support of PCI-e, don't misunderstand me. What I don't understand is why some people want AGP to die so badly when it doesn't affect them in any negative ways. (At least based on what I know right now, which is why I asked for education on any potential reasons that I'm not aware of.)
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Well everyone has different agendas

Not everyone has a huge cash supply either. For some people $600 is enough for a card, they cant justtify the other $400 for new cpu and mobo, maybe even more for new ram, psu, etc.

New technology is great, its amazing what comes out. But immediately flushing old tech? What the hell? When AGP came out I didnt see a massive hatred for PCI video cards. Hell you can still find PCI video cards of the 9x00 series.

The point is, what do you gain from a huge cash investment of the new motherboard and cpu combo? Slightly more performance and more future compatability? Soon your gonna want all these new features and buy another motherboard. What happened to that one you just got? Doesnt have that feature eh?

Its pointless to force ahead instantaneously. But lets look at this, the video card manufacturers benefit the most from PCIe. They also make alot of the chipsets for the motherboards that support this. Seems like forcing everyone to upgrade several different pieces of hardware that they have their name on (or in) makes them alot more money.

Where is this huge performance gain? Where will we benefit from all this amazing stuff PCIe has to offer right now? Where? A few more FPS and a grand less in the wallet?

Bleeding edge is always amazing, but not always practical. For me, its a huge pain to find the money to even just pay the bills, let alone spend another grand instead of going for a new middle range video card for around $250. To use that $250 card I have to spend and upgrade and leave behind currently perfectly good hardware that does everything I ask as well as I want, except support a new graphical feature I want?

Killing off old tech happens yes, upgrades are just that, upgrades. Not major overhauls. When you change out your cpu, mobo, ram, and video card, thats a new system right there. That is not an upgrade. Its an upgrade from what you had, but its no uprade of that system.

PCIe, yes many great things to come. Just dont tell me that I *NEED* it to get this performance when my current setup will give me it just the same. We have nothing to fully utilize the newest generation of tech. When we do and something comes around that MUST have it to function, then yes. Its time to crack open the wallet and break the bank. Not before. Rushing ahead for an almost minimal gain with no real reason is as pointless as pissing in the wind.
 
I think PCIe is cheaper or easier to produce or something, that's why it is being pushed hard.
 
thespymaster said:
With the millions of computers on the planet that currently have AGP,...nVidia and ATi both would be idiots not to continue to support AGP. Yeah WE, the hardcore community might, and do upgrade frequently however, the rest of the world doesn't upgrade that often and genereally only when they find that their current hardware doesn't cut it. So,...while we are willing to change platforms every 6 months or so,...the rest of the world isn't and that is lost revenue if they don't supply them with a viable upgrade option.
whats the purpose of upgrading from a 6800GT or Ultra? They still manhandle the current games out there just fine. IMO, this new wave of cards is the perfect time to say goodbye to AGP.
 
Back
Top