HardOCP News
[H] News
- Joined
- Dec 31, 1969
- Messages
- 0
Our nForce4 & SLI article is posted, just wanted to know your thoughts on the nF4 & SLI
http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=Njc3
http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=Njc3
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Impulse said:I still don't get what the big deal about Soundstorm is. Granted I skipped a generation and never got to tinker with it on an AthlonXP platform but regardless... Is there some big advantage to it over regular sound card solutions for the HTPC market that I don't know about or is it simply a matter of value?![]()
Zoner said:I suspect the loss of SoundStorm has everything to do with the memory controller being moved into the CPU core. The audio processor would naturally want to be integrated into the memory controller to pre-empt everything else on the system.
Numan said:Most people on all these tech forums keep saying if you're a l33t gamer with a big ass rig you'd have an Audigy 2 in some flavour for your sound anyways.
You're missing the point. The real-time DD encoding could be applied to SURROUND streams. Meaning you could do 5.1 gaming using HT speakers without having to run oodles of cables.Impulse said:I smell red...![]()
What do you need on-the-fly Dolby encoding for? I don't get it... Are you a video profesional that's creating content all day? Source material that wasn't originally intended for Dolby Digital isn't really gonna benefit from being up-converted from two channels or whatever...
Mr. Jones said:When do you guys think the new boards will come out to buy?
MindBuster said:Just BUHUU'ing over no Soundstorm![]()
Would it come as a Soundstorm2 PCI-E card maybe![]()
MindBuster said:Just BUHUU'ing over no Soundstorm![]()
Would it come as a Soundstorm2 PCI-E card maybe![]()
they took SS off because of the licensing agreement with dolby and it was costing them to much.MindBuster said:Just BUHUU'ing over no Soundstorm![]()
Would it come as a Soundstorm2 PCI-E card maybe![]()
Fuck 'em.ImJacksAmygdala said:I don't think Creative labs would like that too much though.
thankyou your post says it allImJacksAmygdala said:For the Sound Storm non-believers, please tell us one audio solution on the market that is capable of DDICE with SPDIF Optical outputs? Sorry, but you can't.
The ONLY one is Nvidia's Sound Storm...
The reason is that the PCI bus does not have enough bandwidth to do so. For that reason no PCI solution is capable of what Sound Storm can do with such a small foot print.
DDICE (Dolby ® Digital real-time Interactive Content Encoder) is critical for several enthusiast markets. The same markets that can afforde Nvidia's top of the line graphics cards or even the more extreme dual SLI PCIexpress graphics solutions. The HTPC theater crowd, SFF HTPC crowd, and the Wide Screen PC Gaming super 1337 crowd all use home theater audio equipment that has better DACs and S/N than any computer sound card could achieve. On that high end equipment any noise from the source is just that much more horrible.
Sound Storm is the only solution available that has digital SPDIF optical outputs for low noise that can hook up to HT audio amplifiers and the DDICE is the only solution for real-time hardware DD encoding applied to surround streams that allows you to do 5.1 gaming and movies using high quality home theater THX certified speakers with little overhead on the CPU. (DTS would even be better)
It is possible that a PCIexpress card could be made that could use the bandwidth required for DDICE, but currently no solution exists except for Nvidias Sound Storm on a dated motherboard using a dated CPU socket.
This effectively leaves many enthusiasts that are willing to shell out the extra cash required for the dolby license totally alienated in the market.
Many in this crowd want the Cool n Quiet AMD64 CPU, but skipped the Nforce3 because of the lack of SoundStorm. Instead opting to wait for Nforce4 hoping Nvidia would see the light. Nope they didn't so I guess we are SOL and now we can only hope other chipset makers will add HD audio that is DDICE capable on the AMD64 platform, preferably one that offers dual 16X PCIexpress graphics cards.
With the lack of SoundStorm2 the Nforce4 product line does not distinguish itself from the rest of the pack except for SLI, but even now there are other 16X dual PCIexpress graphics card chipsets on the way.
Kinda sucks, I was really hoping I didn't have to wait any longer and I could build in November with the Nforce4 in time for HL2, I guess I'll just wait a little longer and see if a PCIexpress sound card comes out that can do what SoundStorm did.
If you want to see exactly why the lack of SS2 on the nforce4 is such a big deal take a look at these threads. It goes into the details of why SS was so different from any other available solution and why we may never see it again from Nvidia even in a stand alone sound card.
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=459434&perpage=20&pagenumber=1
http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=460339&highlight=nforce4
I hope those links work... If not check out the AVS forums and do a search on the subject.
You can also see some great replies from people on this subject at The Tech Report here..
http://techreport.com/ja.zz?comments=7246
http://techreport.com/ja.zz?comments=7485
If you read all of the user replies you will finally understand why enthusiasts wanted SoundStorm2 so badly and why NO other solution exists currently on the market.
So what are our options now and in the near future? Will a SS type solution become available as a PCIexpress card?
Those seem to be the two biggest questions currently. I don't care who makes it as long as it is possible on a AMD64/dual DRR/dual PCIexpress graphics platform. The only way I will now buy a Nforce4 is if Nvidia's SLI is better than VIA's dual PCIexpress graphics card solution and a SoundStorm type PCIexpress stand alone sound card comes out. Otherwise I will continue to save my pennies.