nForce4 & SLI article

It was a great teaser. Pretty much let us know that nf4 is really close, and it WILL have SLI. I am glad that SLI is really the only major change. I would hate for a completely different chipset to come out that makes us all wait for 6 months of debugging before its available/useable. I think its great that people finally know for sure what the nf4 is going to offer, which was covered well. Now they can finally decide if they should wait or not. If they aren't going to use SLI, there isnt much of a point for them. A great follow up would be to cover how long of a wait till enthusiast-quality PCI-E gfx cards to take the place of the AGP ones like BFG 6800 GT or Gainward Golden Sample.
 
the absents of soundstorm will be a let down for many, would they had included it would have made the nforce4 the board to have amongst nforce fans
 
knowing that there has been a big stir around the net about the NF4's lack of sound storm support, you would think they would have made some mention of the sound system of the board. I wish there would have been a section covering that aspect of it in the article.
other than that its about like all the others ive read so far, seems like a fantastic new addition to the amd 64 line of motherboards.

It will most likely be the next board I buy somtime in the spring after income tax when i can afford to get 2 6800 gt's and 2 3gb/sec sata HDD's and a 939 processor.

I think by then maybe there will be a killer board out by ASUS or ABIT or MSI that will have all the inevitable bugs worked out. And who knows, maybe the next generation Nvidia graphics card will be comming out by then and drive the price of the 6800 gt's down to a respectible $200 range.

I cant wait to see someone put 2 6800 Ultra extremes and a fx 55 on a vapochill and see if 2 graphics cards can keep up with the cpu power. The article from Madshrimps yesterday (http://www.madshrimps.be/?action=getarticle&articID=231) seemd to say that they should put the vapochill on the graphics card and not the processor.
Ive always wondered why Asetek hasnt had a chiller for the graphics cards. I know it can be done, ive seen it in thier forums. You know that would make things jump if you had another head for the graphics card along with the cpu running on the same compressor. Hell i would sell my wifes car and buy one of those lol.
 
The market for the Vapochill/Prometia very limited, when you consider that the coolers are hideously expensive. Even fewer people would be buying them to cool their graphics cards, and to release a product specifically to do that would be commercial suicide. Even modifiying existing systems to cool both the CPU and Graphics Card can be extremely complicated and even more expensive.

The people that are going to stick a Phase Change cooling system on a GPU are going to buy a seperate unit to do it, but then theres not that many people going to do that, are there.

I don't see why they don't manufacture mounting kits to do it though, the mounting systems themselves aren't very complicated, and very easy to replicate anyway.
 
Gahhhhhh no Soundstorm!

I can't believe that nVidia hasn't realized how important of a feature this is for many people. Maybe they could implement it as an optional part of the high end model, like maybe have a lower end regular model and then an upper end Deluxe model with Soundstorm.
 
It has No SoundStorm1 or 2 ... all it is a glorified nf3 it is evolutionary not revolutionary as the nf2 was i am shocked nv didnt improve or even add there SS processer to the nf4 that would really define it to the a64 user base cause to this day my choice for a socket a board was HEAVILY INFLUENCED BY THE SS APU its not hard to call the nf2 the definiative chipset for socket A and the nf4 just another chipset


p.s.
(idk if this is over stepping but here it goes) nforcershq has a online petition to save the apu http://www.petitiononline.com/NVAPU/petition.html if you want the apu back feel free to sign it mabe nv will listen
 
Yeah, I think this is sorta a refresh of what NF3 should have been. SLI is interesting but yet to be seen.
 
I still don't get what the big deal about Soundstorm is. Granted I skipped a generation and never got to tinker with it on an AthlonXP platform but regardless... Is there some big advantage to it over regular sound card solutions for the HTPC market that I don't know about or is it simply a matter of value? :confused:
 
Impulse said:
I still don't get what the big deal about Soundstorm is. Granted I skipped a generation and never got to tinker with it on an AthlonXP platform but regardless... Is there some big advantage to it over regular sound card solutions for the HTPC market that I don't know about or is it simply a matter of value? :confused:

Different people like it for different things but basically for me, it's an integrated hardware acclerated 5.1 digital/analog sound chip that outputs sound nearly as good as an Audigy. And it's a lot cheaper than an Audigy, saves PCI slots, and does real time digital encoding.
 
The SS is the only onboard hardware accellerated soundchip in existensed on the x86 platform, is it not? That is something to think about.
 
The Vapochill line for CPU cooling is complimented by the Waterchill line for Chip and GPU. I own a Vapo and my next investment (after replacing the broken computer inside the Vapo) will be a Waterchill for GPU and Chip. The additional cooling of the GPU and Chip is super but what Im really after is the lower sound-volume from the water coling.
 
I suspect the loss of SoundStorm has everything to do with the memory controller being moved into the CPU core. The audio processor would naturally want to be integrated into the memory controller to pre-empt everything else on the system.
 
I'm just trying to invision the kind of 2 loop watercooling system I'll need to cool this beast with 2 video cards...... ummm at least 2 loops, maybe 3 since the video cards are starting to run hotter than the procs...
 
Zoner said:
I suspect the loss of SoundStorm has everything to do with the memory controller being moved into the CPU core. The audio processor would naturally want to be integrated into the memory controller to pre-empt everything else on the system.

I don't know, I talked to an nVidia product design rep from their audio division and he told me that SoundStorm was not included in the nForce3 motherboards because the demand for it wasn't that high. Which...doesn't make any sense to me, but maybe they felt they just got a lukewarm response when they included it.
 
well it all comes down to numbers. And we all know that those of us in the KNow about computers usually build our own. Now i would think that we probly account for like 5% of total PC sales in general. SO if we all stood up and stomped our foot at Nvidia, it still would not make one bit of difference because we only represent 5% of the market. You have to think that the people that buy boards in mass are the companies that cater to the housewife that has nothing better to do than chat on yahoo or email pictures of her kids to her mother. Thats where the biggest base of computer users lie. Thats what has made Dell so popular. The other segment of the markets are business's that dont give a rats ass about sound anyway. All they want is something cheap that their workers can use to get thier excel spreadsheets done and word documents typed. They REALLY dont want anyone to have any kind of high performance video capabilities or sound capabilities, hell they would be playing doom 3 all day instead of crunching numbers like a good little robot.

so its just a matter or numbers and market share. they have em we dont. SO i guess well all be doing the same thing. Buying an audigy 2 with our new platform.
 
Regarding "jimowens" comments:
That's simply not true for this type of board. These NF4 boards are not going to be the main boards crap companies are choosing to put into their computers when trying to save money and make a buck. They'll be using ECS and low-end MSI boards, or custom in-house boards. NF4 boards are more angled towards enthusiasts, so we're much more than 5% of the target market.
 
Most people on all these tech forums keep saying if you're a l33t gamer with a big ass rig you'd have an Audigy 2 in some flavour for your sound anyways.
 
the big deal with SS is it DOES real-time Dolby Digital encoding I am not aware of anything on the market today that does that in tearms of pc hardware

look at this review where is goes head to head with the Audigy 2 Firingsquad

the SS apu raised the bar for pc sound its sad to see it go but if a nf4 board where to turn up with it i would buy it in a heartbeat
 
I was hyped about the Nforce4 and waited forever to upgrade, but because it does not have Sound Storm I will not be buying a Nforce4!

"What was Nvidia thinking?" seems to be a common question posted all over the internet at the lack of Sound Storm.

I was willing to pay extra and wait for SLI even though it is only 8x PCIexpress. Nvidia said they didn't want to add extra cost to the board because of a Dolby Digital license, but they think there is a market for SLI's extra cost? Ya probably because you have to buy another Nvidia graphics card....

If I'm willing to pay extra for SLI I sure as hell am willing to pay for the added cost of Sound Storm!

I wanted Sound Storm so I could hardware encode all sources to Dolby Digital for my HTPC wide screen gaming rig. I will now wait for VIA's dual PCIexpress solution because it is going to be dual 16X for graphics cards over Nvidia's 8x. I might even switch altogether and get 2 ATI PCIexpress graphics cards aswell for the VIA chipset dual PCIexpress graphics solution.

If a Dolby Digital license is so expensive then maybe they should look at a DTS solution instead. That would be just as good if not better. And while Nvidia is at developing SoundStorm2 (after the backlash from a lack of SoundStorm on the Nforce4 you know they will) they need to fix the damn EAX problems everyone bitched about on the Nforce2 that got NO support!

It is sad that I have NO other options to hardware encode Dolby Digital from any source on an Athlon64 system. I guess I'll have to settle with an Audigy2ZS, but I think I will even wait on that and see if Creative Labs develops a sound card for the PCIexpress bus that can handle hardware encoding of Dolby Digital and DTS from any source where the PCI bus was so limited....

Like I said I will no longer be buying a Nvidia Nforce4 SLI board and 2 6800ultras now that there is no SoundStorm2. I will instead buy a Via chipset board and 2 ATI PCIexpress Graphics cards and use the onboard sound untill Creative Labs wakes up and makes a product that will do the same thing as SoundStorm using the increased bandwidth of the PCIexpress bus...

Nvidia what were you thinking?!?!?!?
 
Numan said:
Most people on all these tech forums keep saying if you're a l33t gamer with a big ass rig you'd have an Audigy 2 in some flavour for your sound anyways.

Not really, if your rig was really 1337 you would use the digital out and hook your 1337 rig to a real home theater audio amplifier that has better DACs and S/N than any computer sound card could ever have and you wouldn't have to worry about game support and compatibility for drivers either...

And if I spend the cash on a dual PCIexpress graphics motherboard I might aswell NOT buy an PCI bus Audigy2 ZS incase Creative Labs makes a sound card that uses the bandwidth of the PCIexpress bus and makes a sound card that can do the same thing that the Nforce2 SoundStorm and encode Dolby Digital and DTS on the fly with little CPU hit...

Nvidia what were you thinking?!?!?!?!

I'm not a graphics card company specific fan at all, but just wait untill the benchmarks come out for HalfLife2 that use the newer drivers for dual PCIexpress solutions that favor ATI PCIexpress graphics cards and you will see that Nvidia may have already lost this round with the enthusiast market now that they have limited the Nforce4 to 8X SLI for Nvidia cards ONLY with no SoundStorm2...

Other chipsets will have dual 16X PCIexpress graphics cards, HiDef audio, and not restrict dual graphics card brands... We shall see if this is indeed true in the very near future.
 
I smell red... :rolleyes:

What do you need on-the-fly Dolby encoding for? I don't get it... Are you a video profesional that's creating content all day? Source material that wasn't originally intended for Dolby Digital isn't really gonna benefit from being up-converted from two channels or whatever...
 
now those are responses ImJacksAmygdala!! howled at a few remarks but loved you overall tone. stick it 2 em! :D ...you're so right on the hardware setup through the home theatre. it's gotta B! I do hope you're wrong on the nf4 getting outclassed ...
 
Impulse said:
I smell red... :rolleyes:

What do you need on-the-fly Dolby encoding for? I don't get it... Are you a video profesional that's creating content all day? Source material that wasn't originally intended for Dolby Digital isn't really gonna benefit from being up-converted from two channels or whatever...
You're missing the point. The real-time DD encoding could be applied to SURROUND streams. Meaning you could do 5.1 gaming using HT speakers without having to run oodles of cables.

Anyway, nForce2 got an amazing number of design wins in the retail market; a LOT of the HPaq Athlon boards with "GeForce4MX Graphics" are in fact nForce2 boards.

And retail is where the money is. We enthusiasts don't mean jack to companies except for marketing, and there isn't much attention paid to motherboards anyway.
 
Mr. Jones said:
When do you guys think the new boards will come out to buy?

I saw on the inquirer that the regular and Ultra versions should be available in november, and the SLI version should be available before Christmas
 
MindBuster said:
Just BUHUU'ing over no Soundstorm :(

Would it come as a Soundstorm2 PCI-E card maybe :confused:

ive talked with some people "in the know" soundstorm is dead at least for the time bening i wonder if sound card makers are paying attention to this and one of might give us a ddice card :)
 
MindBuster said:
Just BUHUU'ing over no Soundstorm :(

Would it come as a Soundstorm2 PCI-E card maybe :confused:

I would buy a Nvidia PCIexpress SoundStorm2 sound card in a heartbeat. Although I doubt Nvidia has the foresight to actually make such a product nor do they have the balls to go against Creative Labs. That alone might be the real reason SS was dropped...

But who knows... ATI has all sorts of home theater related products for video so maybe Nvidia would get the hint and try to get in the market using SoundStorm PCIexpress sound cards. The PCIexpress bus has the bandwidth to do it now... It would be nice and I'm sure gamers would go for it based on brand name alone...
 
MindBuster said:
Just BUHUU'ing over no Soundstorm :(

Would it come as a Soundstorm2 PCI-E card maybe :confused:
they took SS off because of the licensing agreement with dolby and it was costing them to much.
 
Ya but a PCIexpress SoundStorm sound card would cover the cost of the Dolby Digital license or atleast be more cost effective than a motherboard audio solution in terms of sales.

I don't think Creative labs would like that too much though.
 
re: Tempest remarks

Even though the top line boards are targeted towards us few people that know what were doing, in the broader sense, Nvidia doesnt make Boards, they only make chips, and to appeal to the broadest market they have to make it as cheap as possible. Yes HP is not gonna put a MSI SLI board into a HPshitpack desktop, but they sure might put a stripped down version of NF4 in one. ANd since this is only a single chip solution, for nividia to maximize thier dollars they will make them like they do the graphics chips. they will make them all the same and the good ones go in SLI boards and the crappy ones go to compaq and HP.

just my uninformed opinion, but probly has some truth to it.
 
For the Sound Storm non-believers, please tell us one audio solution on the market that is capable of DDICE with SPDIF Optical outputs? Sorry, but you can't.

The ONLY one is Nvidia's Sound Storm...

The reason is that the PCI bus does not have enough bandwidth to do so. For that reason no PCI solution is capable of what Sound Storm can do with such a small foot print.

DDICE (Dolby ® Digital real-time Interactive Content Encoder) is critical for several enthusiast markets. The same markets that can afforde Nvidia's top of the line graphics cards or even the more extreme dual SLI PCIexpress graphics solutions. The HTPC theater crowd, SFF HTPC crowd, and the Wide Screen PC Gaming super 1337 crowd all use home theater audio equipment that has better DACs and S/N than any computer sound card could achieve. On that high end equipment any noise from the source is just that much more horrible.

Sound Storm is the only solution available that has digital SPDIF optical outputs for low noise that can hook up to HT audio amplifiers and the DDICE is the only solution for real-time hardware DD encoding applied to surround streams that allows you to do 5.1 gaming and movies using high quality home theater THX certified speakers with little overhead on the CPU. (DTS would even be better)

It is possible that a PCIexpress card could be made that could use the bandwidth required for DDICE, but currently no solution exists except for Nvidias Sound Storm on a dated motherboard using a dated CPU socket.

This effectively leaves many enthusiasts that are willing to shell out the extra cash required for the dolby license totally alienated in the market.

Many in this crowd want the Cool n Quiet AMD64 CPU, but skipped the Nforce3 because of the lack of SoundStorm. Instead opting to wait for Nforce4 hoping Nvidia would see the light. Nope they didn't so I guess we are SOL and now we can only hope other chipset makers will add HD audio that is DDICE capable on the AMD64 platform, preferably one that offers dual 16X PCIexpress graphics cards.

With the lack of SoundStorm2 the Nforce4 product line does not distinguish itself from the rest of the pack except for SLI, but even now there are other 16X dual PCIexpress graphics card chipsets on the way.

Kinda sucks, I was really hoping I didn't have to wait any longer and I could build in November with the Nforce4 in time for HL2, I guess I'll just wait a little longer and see if a PCIexpress sound card comes out that can do what SoundStorm did.

If you want to see exactly why the lack of SS2 on the nforce4 is such a big deal take a look at these threads. It goes into the details of why SS was so different from any other available solution and why we may never see it again from Nvidia even in a stand alone sound card.

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=459434&perpage=20&pagenumber=1

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=460339&highlight=nforce4

I hope those links work... If not check out the AVS forums and do a search on the subject.

You can also see some great replies from people on this subject at The Tech Report here..

http://techreport.com/ja.zz?comments=7246

http://techreport.com/ja.zz?comments=7485

If you read all of the user replies you will finally understand why enthusiasts wanted SoundStorm2 so badly and why NO other solution exists currently on the market.

So what are our options now and in the near future? Will a SS type solution become available as a PCIexpress card?

Those seem to be the two biggest questions currently. I don't care who makes it as long as it is possible on a AMD64/dual DRR/dual PCIexpress graphics platform. The only way I will now buy a Nforce4 is if Nvidia's SLI is better than VIA's dual PCIexpress graphics card solution and a SoundStorm type PCIexpress stand alone sound card comes out. Otherwise I will continue to save my pennies.
 
WHEW!
It looks like someone has written an Opinion piece for the local newspaper before!
:p











runs away........
 
Well, that's not quite true (about bus limitations keeping DICE to integrated solutions and PCIe)...people could always put RAM on the actual sound cards.

But they don't anymore.
 
ImJacksAmygdala said:
For the Sound Storm non-believers, please tell us one audio solution on the market that is capable of DDICE with SPDIF Optical outputs? Sorry, but you can't.

The ONLY one is Nvidia's Sound Storm...

The reason is that the PCI bus does not have enough bandwidth to do so. For that reason no PCI solution is capable of what Sound Storm can do with such a small foot print.

DDICE (Dolby ® Digital real-time Interactive Content Encoder) is critical for several enthusiast markets. The same markets that can afforde Nvidia's top of the line graphics cards or even the more extreme dual SLI PCIexpress graphics solutions. The HTPC theater crowd, SFF HTPC crowd, and the Wide Screen PC Gaming super 1337 crowd all use home theater audio equipment that has better DACs and S/N than any computer sound card could achieve. On that high end equipment any noise from the source is just that much more horrible.

Sound Storm is the only solution available that has digital SPDIF optical outputs for low noise that can hook up to HT audio amplifiers and the DDICE is the only solution for real-time hardware DD encoding applied to surround streams that allows you to do 5.1 gaming and movies using high quality home theater THX certified speakers with little overhead on the CPU. (DTS would even be better)

It is possible that a PCIexpress card could be made that could use the bandwidth required for DDICE, but currently no solution exists except for Nvidias Sound Storm on a dated motherboard using a dated CPU socket.

This effectively leaves many enthusiasts that are willing to shell out the extra cash required for the dolby license totally alienated in the market.

Many in this crowd want the Cool n Quiet AMD64 CPU, but skipped the Nforce3 because of the lack of SoundStorm. Instead opting to wait for Nforce4 hoping Nvidia would see the light. Nope they didn't so I guess we are SOL and now we can only hope other chipset makers will add HD audio that is DDICE capable on the AMD64 platform, preferably one that offers dual 16X PCIexpress graphics cards.

With the lack of SoundStorm2 the Nforce4 product line does not distinguish itself from the rest of the pack except for SLI, but even now there are other 16X dual PCIexpress graphics card chipsets on the way.

Kinda sucks, I was really hoping I didn't have to wait any longer and I could build in November with the Nforce4 in time for HL2, I guess I'll just wait a little longer and see if a PCIexpress sound card comes out that can do what SoundStorm did.

If you want to see exactly why the lack of SS2 on the nforce4 is such a big deal take a look at these threads. It goes into the details of why SS was so different from any other available solution and why we may never see it again from Nvidia even in a stand alone sound card.

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=459434&perpage=20&pagenumber=1

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=460339&highlight=nforce4

I hope those links work... If not check out the AVS forums and do a search on the subject.

You can also see some great replies from people on this subject at The Tech Report here..

http://techreport.com/ja.zz?comments=7246

http://techreport.com/ja.zz?comments=7485

If you read all of the user replies you will finally understand why enthusiasts wanted SoundStorm2 so badly and why NO other solution exists currently on the market.

So what are our options now and in the near future? Will a SS type solution become available as a PCIexpress card?

Those seem to be the two biggest questions currently. I don't care who makes it as long as it is possible on a AMD64/dual DRR/dual PCIexpress graphics platform. The only way I will now buy a Nforce4 is if Nvidia's SLI is better than VIA's dual PCIexpress graphics card solution and a SoundStorm type PCIexpress stand alone sound card comes out. Otherwise I will continue to save my pennies.
thankyou your post says it all

p.s nforcershq has been rallying for the apu since the nf3
http://www.nforcershq.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=39361&start=0
http://www.nforcershq.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=47085&start=75
and the petition for ss incase you missed it
http://www.petitiononline.com/NVAPU/petition.html
 
it apears monday may be a intresting day Drew Henry is going to respond to the public outcry for the SS http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=19218 it may be out of the nf4 but will it make a comeback in a future chipset or even as a stand alone card or is it truely beyond all hope only time will tell
 
I think its just too late for the Nforce4 and I could care less what Drew Henry has to say. I sent a letter to him through the Inq aswell. He will just feed us some bullshit marketing line, but the message is already crystal clear. Nvidia is nerfing the nforce line of chipsets for the OEMs to cut down on costs and increase sales while offering enthusiasts SLI which is a Nvidia brand dual graphics solution ONLY which will also increase Nvidia sales. No thanks, there are other dual graphic card solutions aimed at the enthusiast market.

I'm seriusly considering the K8T890pro if its dual graphics solution is not video card brand specific and allows ATI or any other PCIexpress video card. What happens if we see another FX line in the future?

So where does this leave AMD64 users or other gamers that want to go AMD64?

Well I just hope that Intel's HD Audio (aka Azalia) causes Creative Labs to rethink the competition. Many users will stick with Intels onboard sound solution and Creative Labs will hopefully have no choice but to respond with a sound card that can compete with the feature set including DDlive 5.1 encoding, atleast Tom's Hardware believes that an audio war could be in the making.

http://www6.tomshardware.com/consumer/20040813/index.html

http://www.intel.com/design/chipsets/hdaudio.htm

Despite how many HTPC enthusiasts feel about Creative Labs, I'm more interested in using it more for gaming than for movies. I think Creative could make a more dedicated solution with less of a CPU performance hit for gaming than Intels HD Audio. I plan on using the SPDIF out to a home theater audio amplifier and speakers so I'm not as concerned about the crappy DACs although I think Creative could do a better job than Intel's HD audio. I really think Creative labs has no choice but to repond due to the fact it is Intel pushing this.

http://www.sudhian.com/showdocs.cfm?aid=572

Ironically this competition would finally give AMD64 users a simular solution should Creative Labs repond with a simular sound card that provides DDlive 5.1 encoding. When that happens I will seriously consider the K8T890pro or maybe the Nforce4 SLI chipsets.

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?threadid=459434&perpage=20&pagenumber=1

Anyone hear anything about Audigy3 HD Audio?
 
Back
Top