Next level in passively cooled card?

Ronco

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Oct 6, 2005
Messages
1,308
I'm looking to upgrade the 6600GT SLI set-up composed of two Gigabyte fanless cards. I was quite miffed that the performance increase is generally about 25% over a single card so I think I won't bother with SLI this time around. I'm not a monster gamer but I like speedy gear. Budget is not a problem but what I don't like is wasting money for performance I don't use. The gaming PC will be slightly changed and it'll probably end up beng the only Windows desktop in my currently changing set-up... and I'd like whatever's on it to last about 18 months in a comfortable state to run then-current software.

Aftermarket upgrades? I do not as a rule like futzing with gear. Putting together a PC for me is generally speaking an occasionally necessary chore rather than a pleasure, and the same goes for bolting complicated aftermarket cooling kits on. So I would like to buy something off the shelf. Any recommendations would be appreciated.
 
bLaCktIGErs91 said:
Yep. There are also some silent x1600xt's floating out there, which I think are slightly superior to 7600gs speed wise, but I think I hear nvidia f4nbo1s coming to call me a liar.
I don't know if a 7600gs would really make you happy or not, because roughly speaking,
7600gs = 2x6600GT
ASUS had their silent line of cards (x1600xt, even a 7800GT), but I don't know where to get one
 
Here's a review of the 7600GS and X1600XT: http://www.motherboards.org/reviews/hardware/1597_6.html

Doom 3: EVGA 7600GS wins 6/6, Asus X1600XT wins 0/6
Quake 4: EVGA 7600GS wins 5/6, Asus X1600XT wins 1/6
Far Cry: EVGA 7600GS wins 2/6, Asus X1600XT wins 4/6
FEAR: EVGA 7600GS wins 0/6, Asus X1600XT wins 6/6
CoD2: EVGA 7600GS wins 3/6, Asus X1600XT wins 3/6

The EVGA 7600GS comes at reference speed and passive cooling, like the Asus X1600XT card tested. The results are different for the factory overclocked XFX 7600GS, which is also passively cooled: Quake 4 switches to 6/6 wins, Far Cry flips to 4/6 wins, FEAR changes to 3/6 wins, and CoD 2 becomes 6/6 wins. And further limiting the results to playable resolutions and AA settings would also give a different picture (15fps isn't playable for FPS games). There's no question that the XFX 7600GS is generally faster than a X1600XT, but results are pretty even between a stock speed 7600GS and X1600XT.

This is the XFX 7600GS mb.org tested: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814150146 Not bad for $147 shipped.
 
What do you want SLI? 7900GT+Zalman VF-900 is slient and probally not more than 100$ :p
 
So generally speaking, would you say in going fanless as stock, I can't really expect more than the logical upgrade for a 6600GT (that's pretty much where the 7600GS / X1600XT lies in the current field of video adapters, isn't it)?

Taking a diferent tack, what would I need to do to get a higher-end card silenced (not quiet, silent)? Just want to weigh up the pros and cons.
 
Ronco said:
So generally speaking, would you say in going fanless as stock, I can't really expect more than the logical upgrade for a 6600GT (that's pretty much where the 7600GS / X1600XT lies in the current field of video adapters, isn't it)?

Taking a diferent tack, what would I need to do to get a higher-end card silenced (not quiet, silent)? Just want to weigh up the pros and cons.
NV Silencers and ATI Silencers do a damned good job of silencing a card.

Do something like a 7800GT with one of those, can be had for about $250.
 
trek554 said:
the 7600gs runs hot as hell. http://hardwarezone.com/articles/view.php?id=1856&cid=3&pg=9 "With such high temperatures recorded even in the cool confines of our air-conditioned labs, end-users who have a badly ventilated casing should have second thoughts before getting one of these cards."
That's the second or third time you posted that. :rolleyes:

The cores can run much higher than the core temperatures he measured before throttling (125C or 130C). Even if the temperature in a closed case is 20C higher than what he tested, it's still well within specs. His warning is based on poor reasoning.
 
pxc said:
That's the second or third time you posted that. :rolleyes:

The cores can run much higher than the core temperatures he measured before throttling (125C or 130C). Even if the temperature in a closed case is 20C higher than what he tested, it's still well within specs. His warning is based on poor reasoning.
not everybody reads every thread. its still the hottest running card i have ever seen tested. some people might appreciate the information. :D
 
trek554 said:
not everybody reads every thread. its still the hottest running card i have ever seen tested. some people might appreciate the misinformation spammed into every thread.
fixed

Obviously if XFX managed to overclock the core by 100MHz with passive cooling, it just *might* have been designed to run passively to begin with. :rolleyes: And further, don't you think the Asus EAX1600XT (no fan) card will run much hotter than the one tested in your favorite link? In case you missed it, the OP asked about passively cooled cards.
 
pxc said:
fixed

Obviously if XFX managed to overclock the core by 100MHz with passive cooling, it just *might* have been designed to run passively to begin with. :rolleyes: And further, don't you think the Asus EAX1600XT (no fan) card will run much hotter than the one tested in your favorite link? In case you missed it, the OP asked about passively cooled cards.
dont change my quote. some people care about heat just as much as noise. i am not spamming but you are being an asshole.
 
trek554 said:
dont change my quote. some people care about heat just as much as noise. i am not spamming but you are being an asshole.
I guess it's OK to not read the threads and just spam the same poorly reasoned warning over and over if you want to. :rolleyes:
 
pxc said:
I guess it's OK to not read the threads and just spam the same poorly reasoned warning over and over if you want to. :rolleyes:
what is your problem? anytime someone asks about the 7600gs i let them know that they may run into heat issues. i didnt suggest anything else. i post the link to prove where i got the info. hardwarezone is a very good site ran by the guy from anandtech. just because you dont agree doesnt give you the right to change my quote and be condescending.
 
If you read further into the article you'll notice that he says:
It is with these considerations in mind that we feel that overclockers should take extra care with this card, even if we got decent core clock speeds using the passive cooler (though the DDR2 memory was its undoing). However, those who need a silent rig would find the GeForce 7600 GS very appropriate and its decent performance overall should endear it to the lower-middle range crowd.
It's all a nonsense argument. Words typed to fill space. If you bung a gaming card into a PC and don't attend to case ventilation you're a dunce. If you take a passively cooled card and overclock it you add a fan. No-brainer, really, isn't it? The 6600GT was a hot little bugger too, but you could get passively cooled ones and many people used them at stock speeds without problems.

As a general trend the more powerful a card gets the hotter you can reasonably expect it to run. You just gotta deal with it.
 
Well, heat is an issue but it's not like the PC is overclocked or I have masses of PCI cards or other stuff which could block decent cooling. Two fanless 6600GT's run fine in there (although it would get pretty warm in there after a games session), so I'm sure one of whatever runs pretty hot can without major issues unless it's furnace-hot.

I have seen the Thermaltake coolers but my question was pretty much the same as the guy who posted the link... what (unoverclocked) cards they would safely support for rock solid operation.
 
Unless you go to at least a 7800GT or equivalent an upgrade is kinda pointless. I think the 25% performance improvement you've reported must be specific to particular game titles, because SLI'd 6600GTs can get you better than that. You should be getting from 6800GT to 6800 Ultra performance levels, dependent upon the individual game of course, and I suspect you're looking at benchmarks rather than improvement to image quality capabilities.

SLI is all about image quality. Maintaining framerates whilst using higher graphics settings. 'Performance' and 'speed' are only really relevent to that consideration. And a 7600GS won't get you 'better' than what you've got already. A 7800GT or better would. And you're getting into territory where passively cooled cards aren't really provided there!


I suspect your best approach would be to look for quiet solutions, rather than silent solutions. I've a rig right beside me which includes 11 fans all up. And you can hardly hear the thing at all unless you take the case side panel off. It's perfectly possible to get them comfortably quiet.
 
Thanks for the advice. I live in a very quiet place, have a heavy audio interest, and I use headphones which are open and also speakers at low volumes. Therefore, any extraneous noise is an issue. There are heavily silenced PSUs inside the PC's and one 12cm exhaust for all PC's. I've also found that the stock CPU cooler at load is at the very least comparable to other "quiet" fans so I've switched back to stocks. The result, combined with passively cooled cards is a system I can live with. I'm leery about adding another fan. I have inserted a 6600GT with a fan before and found it added unacceptable levels of noise.
 
I always doubt whether a hot running card like 7600 w/ a passive heat sink will really work? I mean, is that heat sink really enough?

Also, say you don't overclock, would they eventually come out a heat sink ver. of 7900 GTX?
 
if the part glued to the GPU is the heat sink, what is the top part sticking out?
 
It's another heatsink. It's the same arrangement as my 6600GT's but the heatpipe portion pivots.

124657288_e8793648da_o.jpg
124657287_4c082121ca_o.jpg
124657289_fc07dcea59_o.jpg


On my cards, the heatpipe suspends the rear-mounted sink. The rear sink 'floats' over the back of the card. On the Asus, that's now arranged so that the second heatsink can be mounted in a variety of ways.

I wish that wasn't vapourware. I haven't seen it anywhere for sale either. It seems like exactly what I want.
 
Happy Hopping said:
if the part glued to the GPU is the heat sink, what is the top part sticking out?
The card uses a heatpipe to connect two heatsinks, essentially, which helps with the cooling, like Ronco said.
The real benefit is, you might be able to position the second heatsink above your CPU, so when your CPU fan sucks air in to blow down onto your motherboard, it will suck air through the heatsink. This should help things stay a bit cooler.
 
Does this design really works? I mean, if a heat sink can do the job, why doesn't Nvidia come up w/ it when the 7800 come out? What if the heat sink doesn't dessipiate the heat fast enough?

EVGA is lifetime warranty, I notice asus is only 1 yr., if they have confident in their heatsink design, they should offer at least 5 yr.
 
Passive cooling would technically "work" on even a 7900GTX, but man that thing would have to be huge

Also, before the 7900s that ASUS passive 7800GT was pretty common on the virtual-shelf but many sites cleared out tons of 7800gts before the launch
 
Yeah... If anyone could keep this thread updated if they hear of anything else, that would be most appreciated. I think in light of what I know now I'll stick with the dual 6600's for the time being and wait for a bigger silent leap in performance.
 
Found this on the Arctic Cooling website:
Accelero S
04/2006
acceleros1.gif

The Accelero S1 is a High-End solution compatible with NVIDIA 7900 series specifically also for the GT versions.
For NVIDIA 7800 GS (AGP) the next High-End solution to launch is the Accelero S2. Whilst the Accelero S3 is compatible with ATI's X1300/X1600 series and NVIDIA's 7600 series. All patented passive designs ensure no noise and high cooling performance. The S series will be available starting June 2006
.
 
Ronco said:
It's another heatsink. It's the same arrangement as my 6600GT's but the heatpipe portion pivots.

124657288_e8793648da_o.jpg
124657287_4c082121ca_o.jpg
124657289_fc07dcea59_o.jpg


On my cards, the heatpipe suspends the rear-mounted sink. The rear sink 'floats' over the back of the card. On the Asus, that's now arranged so that the second heatsink can be mounted in a variety of ways.

I wish that wasn't vapourware. I haven't seen it anywhere for sale either. It seems like exactly what I want.

It isn't vapourware. I was building a computer for my friends sister and ordered the cheapest 6600gt I could find and was surprised when I took it out of the box to find it passively cooled.

http://www.centrecom.com.au/catalog...=14688&ccsid=0d52a4a1b21eaecc368e1cde5cefccbe

It's down to $253 AUD these days.
 
7600 GS is the same damn performance as a 6600 GT. It has more pixel pushing power, but less memory bandwidth.

If you want a significant upgrade from the 6600 GT SLI, you'll have to trade up to a 7900 GT.

Here's a tip: you can install a Zalman vf900-Cu on ANY video card and make it SILENT. On low mode you CANNOT HEAR the fan, and it STILL cools better than those loud stock heatsinks. For reference, my case is near silent.

If you limit yourself to passive cooling setups, you are going to limit your upgrade options. The 6600 GT (50w peak) is on the bleeding edge of passive cooling capability.
 
Back
Top