New Tim Sweeny Interview - UE3 Fillrate Dependent

I'm not sure why everyone seems to HATE the R600 here!

I have had a HD 2900 XT for some time now and I LOVE IT. So much so that I ordered a 2nd one tonight for some Crossfire loving.

"1" 2900 is faster then BOTH of my X1900's and cost me less than 1/2 as much.

I can't see paying $800+ for a single card ever again. I did that with my X1900's and after 8 months they are dogs :p

I'm looking forward to UPS showing up tomorrow to see just what 2 of these cards can do.

Happy days!
 
I'm putting this in the video card forum for one important reason:

http://forums.epicgames.com/showthread.php?t=571019



Doesn't sound like good news for the R600 which has concentrated on geometry performance over texture/fillrate performance. The G80 has a fillrate advantage currently.

Hrmm....

Lots of other good info in the interview as well. No AA in DX9 due to using deffered shading :( But AA in DX10

great info, thanks for posting
 
I'm not sure why everyone seems to HATE the R600 here!

Because it's out 6 months after NV's cheaper part, has some nagging performance issues in certain games, consumes much more power, thus producing quite a bit of heat. At a recent LAN a friend and I swapped machines for some Supcom fun and we wound up reducing quite a bit of detail on the 2900XT just to get a playable framerate.

The only redeeming factor's improved drivers or better DX10/Next Gen engine performance...one of which may have been shot down today. :( Most of us are left hoping hoping ATI can whip up a nice respin on R600. :cool: Cause I'm not paying $1k for a G90.
 
The only redeeming factor's improved drivers or better DX10/Next Gen engine performance...one of which may have been shot down today. :( Most of us are left hoping hoping ATI can whip up a nice respin on R600. :cool: Cause I'm not paying $1k for a G90.

All I know is I paid far more for my X1900 XTX and X1900 Crossfire "each" when they 1st came out, and while the XTX is the "ultra" version and these XT's are not. So what. Right now I am running a single card and my frames went from 60 to 90 in Tiger Woods 07 with much cleaner looking graphics. I get about 300FPS in HL2 and again it looks better than my crossfire rig did in crossfire mode and gets me better frames.

All for about $650 LESS than I paid for my 1900 Crossfires. Does it run hot? Not really any hotter then my x1900's did. Is it loud? no. It will be even quieter when my waterblocks ship :p. Does it draw more power? Can't tell really, I see NO appreciable differences in case heat which means the fans must work :).

Are there downsides? I'm sure somewhere. The only 2 things that irked me so far as that damn extra 2 prongs for overclocking, and the fact that my XTX water blocks just don't cut it for this beast. So that means another 250 bucks for water blocks and if they change the PCB for the R700 then I'm totall ticked :(

I didn't get a tracking # so that means I was too late ordering today to get it tomorrow. but I'll have the 2nd one in on friday and I'll see what 2 of these monsters can do. Oh the joys of no external cable!@#@!@#@@!

I for one am GLAD they didn't release the XTX first lol. I hate paying more for the video cards than I did for the rest of the computer combined. [ok not quite but still].

Well ok there are some downsides
I can't use my XTX and HD in the same box [that totally p*ssed me off]
I have to buy new water blocks that aren't even shipping yet :( so 400+400+150+150 = is a LOT of cash for mid level cards

The upsides
1 is faster than both my X1900's
DX10 support. [Lost Planet DX10 Demo looks great!]
Internal Interconnect
Vista likes it :)
400 for a card that our performs $1100 worth of cards [my old Crossfires] is a damn good value

All in all I am not unhappy with my purchase and that is really the most important part.

Going from X850's to X1900's was a nice jump in performance, and going from the X1900's to the HD 2900's offer me about the same increase in performance. The games that I play look great, and I am getting great gaming experiences. So to me the 2900 is a great card and I recommend it to anyone who is looking for some great gaming without paying $1600 for 2 cards.
 
82303_main.jpg

yarly.jpg
 
OMG LOL to the above poster. Funniest thing I have seen in a long time. Definitely gotta save these owl pics. :D
 
The upsides
1 is faster than both my X1900's
DX10 support. [Lost Planet DX10 Demo looks great!]
Internal Interconnect
Vista likes it :)
400 for a card that our performs $1100 worth of cards [my old Crossfires] is a damn good value

All in all I am not unhappy with my purchase and that is really the most important part.

Going from X850's to X1900's was a nice jump in performance, and going from the X1900's to the HD 2900's offer me about the same increase in performance. The games that I play look great, and I am getting great gaming experiences. So to me the 2900 is a great card and I recommend it to anyone who is looking for some great gaming without paying $1600 for 2 cards.

You do know that you can pay less for the same/better performance than the 2900 XT right ?
With a 8800 GTS 640 around, which is more or less the same in terms of performance, consumes less power, produces less heat, is silent and is cheaper, there's just no reason to buy a HD 2900 XT. And that's exactly why the 2900 XT is a failure.

It's your money and you buy what you want, but the fact remains that there is a better choice than the 2900 XT in the market and it's called 8800 GTS 640.
 
Justifying the R600 as a card that we should consider buying because it's better than the old AMD cards is a weak argument, the only time anyone should entertain this type of thinking is if for some reason they absolutly had to go with an AMD card and refused to use Nvidia for whatever reason (no such reason should really exist outside of trying to spite Nvidia for some reason)
 
Justifying the R600 as a card that we should consider buying because it's better than the old AMD cards is a weak argument, the only time anyone should entertain this type of thinking is if for some reason they absolutly had to go with an AMD card and refused to use Nvidia for whatever reason (no such reason should really exist outside of trying to spite Nvidia for some reason)

The only reason I have left is that I already have a Crossfire board and want two cards. However it's a 939 board and as such really needs upgrading anyway.
 
...1 is faster than both my X1900's...All in all I am not unhappy with my purchase and that is really the most important part.
Had this 6 months ago after replacing my LOUD X1900XT w/ a SILENT 8800GTX. But I'm glad you're able to justify the purchase in your head. :p
 
Considering these news about how well these new titles will run on older hardware and even though most of us, haven't seen it with our own eyes, it seems that upcoming titles are very well optimized. I remember that when games like FEAR or Oblivion came out, the current high-end cards, could barely handle them with just some of the settings set to high, at no more than 1600x1200. This time around, it seems to be the opposite, where the hardware is powerful enough to handle what's around the corner. Looks like a mix of amazing architectural design (G80) coupled with a highly optimized graphics engine.
This year certainly brings us great games, my most anticipated ones being Crysis and Bioshock. I want to play UT3 too, but I've not been very fond of Epic's latest decisions, so I don't think I'll buy it when it's out. Maybe later.
 
Justifying the R600 as a card that we should consider buying because it's better than the old AMD cards is a weak argument, the only time anyone should entertain this type of thinking is if for some reason they absolutly had to go with an AMD card and refused to use Nvidia for whatever reason (no such reason should really exist outside of trying to spite Nvidia for some reason)


This could be a 56+ page reason...

http://forums.nvidia.com/index.php?showtopic=25381&st=0

So far (knock on wood) I havent had any probles with my 8800gts....
 
Justifying the R600 as a card that we should consider buying because it's better than the old AMD cards is a weak argument

nothing personal but that is one of the dumbest things I have ever heard.

There is NO BETTER REASON to upgrade. What, we should only consider the upgrade if the freaking thing is slower?

Also I have no desire to replace my P5B-Deluxe Wi-Fi with another board just so so I can go SLI instead of Crossfire. I love this board, I love my cpu and I really like my 2900. Again I am SO pleased with it that I am buying a 2nd for this rig. I for one do not take everything Kyle says as gospel, I respect HardOCP and the staff's opinion on a great many things, but you guys take what they say as gospel and that is a shame. Kyle says the card sucks, so now you all do too. Without even trying one. Which is more spooky than anything else.

Anyway if it makes you sleep better at night, have fun with your Nvidia cards, and I'll have just as much fun with my ATI.


Craig
 
You do know that you can pay less for the same/better performance than the 2900 XT right ?
With a 8800 GTS 640 around, which is more or less the same in terms of performance, consumes less power, produces less heat, is silent and is cheaper, there's just no reason to buy a HD 2900 XT. And that's exactly why the 2900 XT is a failure.

It's your money and you buy what you want, but the fact remains that there is a better choice than the 2900 XT in the market and it's called 8800 GTS 640.

No its not, GTS 640 equal or better? LOL! HD2900XT sits comfortable between GTS640 and GTX in performance, and drivers are still early, who knows how far it can go

The only reasons to get a GTS over a XT is heat and noise
 
Uh, go read the [H]'s review on the R600, now if you still want to go to the INq, THG, and Anatech for canned benchmarks you go right ahead.:rolleyes:
 
UT3 is supposed to be released sometime around September I believe, won't the 8800 refreshes be out around then too? Also isn't it possible the first dx10 games will pretty much stomp current dx10 cards? Wasn't it the same with dx9? I don't imagine until AMD/ATI and Nvidia come out with their next cards will we see acceptable performance in dx10. I guess only time will tell.


Yes, there is a forum post on Beyond3D, the next card from nvidia will be G90. Early indications say this card will be out Q4 this year (I'm thinking November) and be as powerful if not more so than SLI'd 8800GTX's (speculation, although highly likely). :D

http://forum.beyond3d.com/showthread.php?t=41512

OT: This should be a great card to take advantage of the UT3 engine!
 
No its not, GTS 640 equal or better? LOL! HD2900XT sits comfortable between GTS640 and GTX in performance, and drivers are still early, who knows how far it can go

The only reasons to get a GTS over a XT is heat and noise

So, one month after all the reviews showed what I said above and even people that bought the card, confirmed the results of reviews/evalutations, you still think that the "HD2900XT sits comfortable between GTS640 and GTX in performance" ?

Really, I never saw such a big case of denial before...

Anyway on topic:

A single 8800 card will be more than enough to run UT3 with all the eye candy on. It seems to me, that for the first time in a long time, hardware is powerful enough to handle games in the near future, which, as I mentioned before, is a combo between game engine optimizations and amazing architectural design (in the form of G80).
If G92 is really as powerful as rumored, it probably won't be "really" needed for a while and will only be useful for those that want (need?) 200 fps @ 2560x1600, with all the eye candy on.
 
You are new to the internet right?

damn... Damn! You totally beat me to it.

Anyways, I've got opinions on this issue, but I refuse to comment on ANYTHING until results are available. Speculation gets you nowhere in such a new field... :)
 
Uh, go read the [H]'s review on the R600, now if you still want to go to the INq, THG, and Anatech for canned benchmarks you go right ahead.:rolleyes:

All those other Review do the same as [H] let see the same result.
The Difference is they show more settings.
And then the HD2900XT on avarage get more around in between GTS640 -GTX
With exception that it dive below R580+ and sometime go beyond GTX.
[H] is like a filtered review of how they think it's ment to be played.
If you are a 16xAF and AA junky this is the review for you.
That result are aslo aviable in those other reviews

Ofcourse there are Test setup differences and a lot of games have many settings so it's obvious that result can differ a bit more or less.

As for U3 being fillrate depending.
What will Crysis be. Because that the game I'am waiting for. Unreal3 acualy not maybe a total conversion Mod.
If Crysis wil be more Geometry depending. It evens out. I wonder.

because I look at 10 reviews 2900xT is oke. And have room to grow.

after 6 month nV is pushing 8800 still further with better performance drivers. So wich better is not to say after a month. ATI have a much larger Driver task upfront then nV they are further down the road and still going.

If ATI got it in place wenn Crysis is out I'am happy.
 
(no such reason should really exist outside of trying to spite Nvidia for some reason)

Would being screwed by them not once but twice count as a good reason?

1) They took over 3dfx and instantly dropped driver support for 3dfx cards.

2) They took over ULi and instantly dropped driver support for ULi chipsets

Both took place at transitions of Windows operationg systems. 3dfx cards never received any Win2K drivers or WinXP drivers. ULi chipsets will never recieve any working Vista drivers.

Thanks, but no thanks, but I am stuck with looking forward to buying a 8800GTS anyways.
 
Would being screwed by them not once but twice count as a good reason?

1) They took over 3dfx and instantly dropped driver support for 3dfx cards.

2) They took over ULi and instantly dropped driver support for ULi chipsets

Both took place at transitions of Windows operationg systems. 3dfx cards never received any Win2K drivers or WinXP drivers. ULi chipsets will never recieve any working Vista drivers.

Thanks, but no thanks, but I am stuck with looking forward to buying a 8800GTS anyways.

wow! i never thought of that.... good reasons!
 
Back
Top