New Rig? Or... Just don't bother

fellows

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
180
Alright... I've been putting of this post for almost 2 months. Instead I've been trolliong the forums looking for similar situations and answers to those questions.

Anyway, it goes like this.

I'm an employee in computer retail, and am thinking of getting the latest Q6700 bundle.

The only thing is, well here is my current rig

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1104944

Got here from [H] Forum, and I've been more than happy. The only thing is recent games are starting to really suffer, and I can't get anywhere close to the 1680x1050 resolution I'd like on my 22'' samsung. CSSource runs fine.


Bioshock runs at 800x600, Portal and HL Ep2 cause the x1800xt I have to overheat, and Call of Duty 4 runs at 800x600 at best.

This is without much Eye_candy turned on if I'm not mistaken.

Also I recently got a Westinghouse TX-42 and am using it as my main desktop monitor. I know 1920x1080 gaming is demanding but it seems the general consensus is that SLI/XFire isn't worth it unless both cards are bought at the same time. Especially since Nvidia may be releasing it's 8800GTX replacement around March.

So my questions are as follows.

With the QX9xxx series due out in a month or two should I just skip this years offering from Intel Retail Edge, or Is it worth upgrading now to a Q6700?

Technically I'm not saving a whole ton because Q6600's can be had for about the price of the bundle, and Vista Premium and the Intel mobo are useless to me. Also I would basically need a fair set of new components including RAM, Vid Card, an Mobo. Also I'd probably get another case, due to not much being salvageable from this current system besides the HD's

I know technology always changes, and it's impossible to keep up, but perhaps all I need is a new 8800gt? But on the other hand my x2 3800 might be an bottleneck. Since old DX9 cards are obsolete, should i maybe try to get one of those higher end ones on the cheap?

Also my RAM is only at ddr-400 speeds. Is there a significant performance increase with ddr2-800, or 1066 ram that I would be using on a Q6700

It seems that s939 is a dead platform, but other threads on here seem to think it's got life in it yet.

All in all I've had my computer for just about 1 year. Although it was not groundbreaking when I got it... at the time it seemed quite up there. Is it time for an upgrade?


So any advice would be appreciated.
 
I'd just keep what you have, get a new video card if you want (and another PSU if you need it, but probably not), and overclock the CPU a bit if necessary.

What does seem odd though is that the X1800XT you have is by no means bad, sounds to me like there's another issue if you honestly can't run those games you listed past 800x600. Could be dust bunnies in the card's HSF (happened to my old X800XL and it ended up running over 100C load lol). Do you have abnormally high room temperature or something? I guess it's also possible the card's busted somehow, but under normal circumstances you should be doing way better than that. Sorry I can't give out much advice, but you should definitely look into it before buying anything new IMO.
 
I'd just keep what you have, get a new video card if you want (and another PSU if you need it, but probably not), and overclock the CPU a bit if necessary.

What does seem odd though is that the X1800XT you have is by no means bad, sounds to me like there's another issue if you honestly can't run those games you listed past 800x600. Could be dust bunnies in the card's HSF (happened to my old X800XL and it ended up running over 100C load lol). Do you have abnormally high room temperature or something? I guess it's also possible the card's busted somehow, but under normal circumstances you should be doing way better than that. Sorry I can't give out much advice, but you should definitely look into it before buying anything new IMO.

Okay cool. Can you direct me in the best way to clean the Video Card. I usually just blast compressed air through the fan grills. I don't know if it is a case of dust bunnies, because CS Source runs fine, but it seems any newer type game like Half Life Ep2, which has newer graphics options causes the card to overhear (past 100 C) and crash.

Thanks Trombe, anyone else with some thoughts on upgrading?
 
For excellent gaming performance on the Westinghouse TX-42, you would probably need, at a minimum, a GeForce 8800GTX. For the 22 inch monitor, you can obtain good performance using either an 8800GT or a Radeon HD 3870, but you may not be able to play games with all of their features maxed out. Most of your problems seem to come from having an older card playing the latest games on a large monitor. Your rig is also a slight concern, seeing that the X2 3800+ is on the low end of the dual-core spectrum, but it might not be a major factor in your problems. If you could find a used X2 4800+ or FX-60 processor (which I've haven't seen in the FS forum here) -- or, if you're able to overclock the 3800+ (assuming that it hasn't been overclocked yet) -- that could extend the lifespan of your rig even further.

If you want to upgrade now, right now, you kinda have to choose between one (the quad-core processor) or the other (the dual card setup). Nvidia has the high end covered, and you'll need at least one 8800GTX (hence, SLI) to get adequate performance on the Westinghouse HDTV. (I've never had to use a dual card setup, so I'm not going to mislead you by elaborating further.) However, people have reportedly been having stability issues with the Core 2 Quads and boards with the 680i SLI chipset (though I don't know about the 650i's or any of the CrossFire motherboards...).

As for the processor, many people have overclocked their Q6600s to the point where they've reached or exceeded the Q6700's speeds. IMO, paying over $200 more for a 266MHz speed increase is not worth it, especially if you're able to push the cheaper CPU to those levels. I don't know what deals are part of Intel's Retail Edge bundle, but if you're not interested in them, then I'd suggest that you wait for the incoming Penryn quad-cores. But don't get the QX9xxx CPUs -- Extreme Edition processors (what the QX's are) are generally overpriced for their performance levels.

A good piece of advice about upgrading is to wait until you can't hold out any longer... and I believe that most of your problems lie in the possibility of you needing a better video card.
 
Wow. Thanks for all the replies guys.

Yeah I realized that besides the 0.2ghz the q6600, and q6700 are about the same.

But the Intel Bundle price is only like 30 more dollars.

You get a q6700, low end intel mobo, and a full version of Vista Premium for around $250.
I'm wondering if I should order it anyway, and then sell it, but I'd probably just break above even. I made a similar mistake last year with the e6300 bundle that is, now, just collecting dust. Although it came with Vista Ultimate so I guess it paid for itself.

So the consensus seems to be that my x1800xt is simply old. Just so I get this straight, though, even though the market value for my CPU is like $60-70, it will not be a bottleneck for a 8800gt? or something similar?

Any advice on the best way to clean my Vid Card in case it's simply a build up of dirt and debris? All I use is compressed air.

Also, I have a Scythe Ninja Rev. B lying around that I was gonna use with the Quad Setup, but maybe I'll try installing it on the x2 3800, and see if I can O/C it.
 
$250 for the Intel bundle?!? In that case, get the bundle, and sell the cheap Intel mobo and (if you still don't want it then) the copy of Vista Home Premum.

The bigger bottleneck in your case would be the video card. The 3800+ may or may not be a factor in your problems, but definitely not with your issue of the X1800XT overheating. And while you're cleaning it, make sure that you are able to get the dust/debris from between the fins of the heatsink (you may not be able to see them with the cover on top... use the canned air where the heat gets pushed out to). Basically you need at a minimum an 8800GTX, especially if you decide to stick with the Westinghouse as your main monitor. (If you decide to use both monitors at the same time, you may want an 8800 Ultra; SLI will disable the secondary monitor while playing games.)

The easiest way of fixing the processor issue it to overclock the 3800+. (Make sure that you have a good 120mm fan, like the Scythe S-FLEX, for the Ninja.) At this point of time, the only processors you should get (should you decide to upgrade the CPU) are the 4800+, the FX-60, or the Opteron 185 -- that is, if you can find one of them used. Otherwise, you might want to start saving up for a new rig.
 
I concur with Tiraides. $250 for that bundle is pretty good.
 
Ohh Yeah The Price is great, but I'm thinking on whether it would be worth doing...
As stated, I would need new ram, new mobo, case, etc.

So I'm debating on whether I should go ahead and purchase it. After shipping, Canadian taxes and duty It would probably be closer to $280.

Also trying to sell that Intel Mobo might be impossible (I hear it's not very good) and then the OEM version of Vista Premium, and the Q6700 would probably not sell for much more than the Q6600 since the latter is a great overclocker on it's own right.

I think I'm convinced to just keep my current system, but maybe getting the bundle and trading for a 8800gt might not be a bad idea.
 
Back
Top