New performance build not only for gaming, asking for comments.

zenblu

n00b
Joined
May 3, 2007
Messages
41
Hello, I've decided to build something from ground up this time. Done LOTS of research, but I would really appreciate your comments and suggestions, as there are still things I'm not sure about. Thanks!

And there is a small twist: I'm not buying in the US, so there are some problems with the availability of some parts that I see are often recommended here.


1. Intended usage (most frequent first):
- heavy programming/development/multitasking with often two operating systems running simultaneously (main OS is Linux with Windows in a virtual machine and sometimes some other OSes as well).
- multimedia, video, music
- gaming on a 1920x1200 monitor. I want it to play current games and some upcoming ones like Starcraft 2 and Diablo3 in this resolution.
- graphics editing (2D and 3D), design

In general, I'm a heavy multitasker. The main OS will be Linux and Vista 64bit only for gaming (dual-boot).

The performance of graphics isn't the most important thing. This is not a gaming rig, although it will be used for gaming too. So I would rather welcome a better performance CPU/memory/harddisk-wise than a better GPU.


2. Budget:
Not very tight. Hard to express in dollars, but something around what you see below in parts. I can throw in even $500 or $1000 more, but only if I feel it'd be worth it. I don't want to cut corners, I want to be happy with my build.

Edit: I'm buying in Poland, prices here are higher than in the US. But I'll give you an estimate in US prices from Newegg:
The parts below are around ~$1300 in US prices. I'd say raising it to up to $1600 or heck, even $1800 would still be ok, as long as it makes good sense.


3. Remarks:
There are two parts to this build. The "staying for longer part" and the "to be replaced sooner than later". I will most probably be switching to Nehalem in 1-1.5 years or so, so I will be replacing CPU, MB and RAM (getting DDR3).

But I want to make an investment in things like case, PSU and other stuff that would last years

My general bias is towards quality rather than price, but I like good performance/price ratios, I don't like burning money needlessly.

I won't be starting with OC right away, but I guess some light OCing later won't hurt. Not to push the limits, just to improve performance while staying safe. I'm not planning water cooling.

Edit: after more and more reading, I see getting a Q6600 and OCing it to around 3GHz should be easy and safe. If so, I might be willing to do just that...


What I already have:
- LG-245WP 24'' LCD monitor



My current plans:

Asus P5Q-E
I like Asus, but I don't really need Premium/Deluxe boards. Besides obvious things like performance/stability etc., I'd like:

- the board to manage my chassis fans as much as possible (although I don't think I can get more than 3 chassis fan connectors)
- a decent number of SATA ports (6 is fine though) and possibly an eSATA port (although not that important)
- I don't really need the onboard audio nor plan to Crossfire
- I'm a Linux user so I won't be able to use Asus software for managing OCing, fans, temperatures etc.


Intel Core2 Duo E8400 (or 8500)
I might change to quad, but between 2 more cores and higher frequency, I rather choose the latter. It's a hard choice really... I guess I could do some safe OC on air cooling though...
Edit: starting to consider a Q6600 OCed to around 3GHz... Should be safe? I really want to it play safe!


CPU cooling
This is a problem... I can't get Xigmatek here... Any way to get something decent for under $50 (with light OCing in mind)?


DDR2 2x2048MB PC-800 Mushkin XP CL 4 4-4-12
This is difficult. First thing is, I see many people here recommend G.Skill but they are not available where I live. Second, maybe I should get PC-1000 ones? Don't really see a point though...
I was also considering OCZ 800 4-4-4-12.
I'd like to choose from among Corsair, GeIL, Mushkin, OCZ, PDP...


Asus Radeon 4870 512MB
I was considering 260 too, but I'll trust AMD with their new Linux compatibility this time. Any comments on the brand? I also have Gigabyte, Microstar, Palit, PowerColor and Sapphire available...


Asus Xonar DX
For good quality in music and movies.


Samsung SpinPoint F1 640 GB (ATA/300, 16MB, 7200, NCQ) HD642JJ
I want the best performance from the main hard disk. For storage I'll have other disks so the capacity is not that important. I was (and still am actually) considering the VelociRaptor... If it only was a bit cheaper though...


Sony / NEC (Optiarc) DVD+/-RW AD-7201S LightScribe
Subject to change, maybe for an LG?





And last but not least, case and PSU. I want them to stay with me for the next 8-10 years and I want them to be good.


Corsair CMPSU-750TXEU - 750W
PSU is easy. I want it to last and the price looks good compared to weaker ones.


But the case is more problematic.
- I'm absolutely anal about the layout inside my case, temperatures and airflow. I like when a case is well-designed. And prefer not having to use tools but it's not that important.
- I also want easy access to things, like be able to easily remove/add disks. I often change things.
- I like having many disks, but probably only 1 optical drive.
- I don't mind noise during peak usage, although I'd like it to get quiet when not used. And getting that to work automatically would be nice.
- I want a good looking case, although rather subdued than flashy. Some LEDs and windows are ok though.


I'm not completely convinced yet if I want to spend too much money on the case. But I want a good-quality, spacious, comfortable to work inside, well designed case. Looks go second. I'm open to suggestions, even more expensive ones (but reasonably).


So my idea was:
To get a CoolerMaster RC-690 and just stuff it with more fans. Something like 2 front intakes, 1-2 intakes on the side, 1 back outflow and 2 top outflow, maybe another one on the bottom. Then, connect 3 of them to the motherboard (probably the one in the back and two on the top, as they are near the CPU) for automatic management. Finally, get a 5.25'' panel/controller and connect the rest to it. Any comments on this?
What I like about the 690 is how well it's though-out, its looks, not having to use tools to install stuff, easy access to disks, cable management, vibration dampening. My only worry is probably the airflow.

Another idea was to get the NZXT Tempest and have the fans already there... But the organization inside isn't as good...

Well, I guess this is it. Thank you for reading and I hope for some advice!
 
Yeah you're gonna have to give us a budget for some boundaries.

Also you'll have to tell us where you're buying the parts from or where you are.

But your parts list looks fine so far. I recommend getting the WD 640GB drive instead since it's one of the fastest drives out now.

RAM wise, just go with the cheapest but decent quality DDR2 800 RAM you can find from Corsair, Patriot, Kingston, Mushkin, etc. Don't worry about the lower timings. You seriously won't notice the performance difference between CAS4 and CAS5.
 
Ok, I'll try to give an estimate of my budget.

I'll be buying in Poland. I'm buying from http://www.znak.pl or http://www.komputronik.pl, although those sites don't have an English version.

So I'll just try giving you a budget in US prices from Newegg.

CPU+MB+RAM+Disk+GPU+Sound+DVDRW+PSU listed above are around $1050 on Newegg (just for comparison - around $1465 when bought here in Poland).
Add to this HSF, case and cooling. Case is $85 on Newegg and around $100 here.

That would give an ~$1300 budget in US prices. I'd say raising it to up to $1600 or heck, even $1800 would still be ok, as long as it makes good sense.

I'm prepared to go higher, to around maybe $200 for the case, although as I said, if I see something really nice, I might consider even a bit more.
I'd prefer not to spend more than ~$50 on CPU cooling.


Edit: I assume you mean the 2-platter version of the WD disk, I haven't seen those here in Poland yet...
 
Looks good.

Add 6 Scythe SFF21E fans, a Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme (heatsink), and a CoolerMaster Cosmos 1000 and you're golden.

I'm about to do a caseswap right now because I'm in love with the cooling capacity and silence this combo has given me with a different rig I put together for a relative.

edit: I reccomend Samsung/LiteOn optical (SATA) drives, they've never failed me imo.
 
Thank you for the suggestions.
Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme is quite expensive though and still needs a fan... Any slightly cheaper options maybe? Or is this what should I pay for a good value/price HSF after all? Point is, I don't really care if it'd be louder.


CoolerMaster cases are simply great. I'm in love with them. I was looking at Antec cases, but they completely lack that well though-out design, toolless installation, disk bays, everything. The NZXT also lack this. I'm actually gravitating towards Cosmos S, looks nicer to me for the same price...
The question is, are there any other cases like CoolerMaster cases? So well designed inside? Just to see my options, although I'm almost sold...

About the LiteOn, I used to use them all the time... But I've heard they got much worse after Samsung acquired them... Is it true?


Edit: I see Thermaltake Armor is also very interesting inside. The thing I don't like though is that the PSU is not mounted on the bottom... I'm really sold to the idea...
And magically we went from a cheap CM 690 to Cosmos levels... I'm not too comfortable with it yet. And there is Antec 1200 on the way too...
 
Well... I'd like to bump this a bit because I would still like to ask for your opinion particularly on following things:

- considering the above, which memory maker would you recommend (from Corsair, GeIL, Mushkin, OCZ, PDP). I'll be buying 2x2GB DDR800 and I want CL4 and rather good performance memory (a bit more expensive than mainstream), but with sensible price/performance ratio nevertheless

- a good but not too expensive heatsink + fan for the CPU with which I would not be afraid of tearing a hole in my motherboard (i.e. not too heavy). And something I can get here in Poland (something from Arctic, Akasa, OCZ, Scythe, Thermaltake, Asus, CoolMaster, Thermalright, Zalman...). I've been thinking about Scythe Mugen SCINF-1000, but if I could make it a bit, say 25-40%, cheaper, it'd be great).

- which Radeon 4870 do you recommend? I can choose between Asus, Gigabyte, Microstar, Palit, PowerColor and Sapphire...

- and one more thing, I see people choosing Asus P5Q Pro over P5Q-E, I don't really understand the difference in slots between them (Asus website is not very clear about this). Could anybody explain it to me? Anything else on this topic?

and I'll be going with Q6600 and WD 640GB after all
 
- You won't notice the difference between CL4 and CL5 in real world gameplay or apps. Unless you love synthetic benchmarks, don't pay the premium for lower latency RAM. So just buy the cheapest DDR2 800 RAM from any of those RAM manufacturers and you'll be set.

- Go for the Thermalright Ultima 90 or OCZ Vendetta II. Both are available on the two sites you linked to.

- I'd go for the cheapest non-Sapphire HD4870 card there is.

- Key differences between the P5Q-E and P5Q Pro:
  • The P5Q-E supports up to 16GB of RAM whereas the P5Q Pro supports up to 8GB of RAM.
  • The P5Q-E has a second LAN port whereas the Pro does not.
  • Better northbridge cooling with the P5Q-E

That's pretty much the major differences. You can see a feature comparison here:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...mpareItemList=N82E16813131299,N82E16813131296


Oh and PSU wise, go with a Corsair, Seasonic, PC Power & Cooling, or Thermaltake Toughpower PSU.
 
About the LiteOn, I used to use them all the time... But I've heard they got much worse after Samsung acquired them... Is it true?

False; Lite-On is still an independent company (based out of, IIRC, Taiwan; Samsung is a Korean entity). Lite-On still makes reliable optical drives, but Samsung's drives are much quieter (yet perform just as well).

CoolerMaster cases are simply great. I'm in love with them. I was looking at Antec cases, but they completely lack that well though-out design, toolless installation, disk bays, everything. The NZXT also lack this. I'm actually gravitating towards Cosmos S, looks nicer to me for the same price...
The question is, are there any other cases like CoolerMaster cases? So well designed inside? Just to see my options, although I'm almost sold...

Edit: I see Thermaltake Armor is also very interesting inside. The thing I don't like though is that the PSU is not mounted on the bottom... I'm really sold to the idea...
And magically we went from a cheap CM 690 to Cosmos levels... I'm not too comfortable with it yet. And there is Antec 1200 on the way too...

The Cooler Master Stacker and Cosmos series comprise its main full tower cases. The RC-690 and RC-590 are good inexpensive cases that offer plenty of room (compared to "generic" mid-tower cases) but they're not tool-less. The appeal of the Antec Twelve Hundred is its cooling capabilities, but you could also get similar features on the smaller Three Hundred and Nine Hundred cases.

You simply need to figure out what you want and what you could afford. The RC-590/690 offers a nice compromise between space, features, and cost.
 
Thanks for the suggestions!

I'll either get a Vendetta II or simply settle with the stock HSF until (if) I decide to OC. My case will be probably loud anyway (I'm aiming at CM HAF-932, I don't know if I'll be able to get it here in Europe soon enough though). And I wouldn't be able to use it with Nehalem anyway...

I have one more question about the GPU though: I've noticed some sweet (pricewise at least) 4870 OCs: Asus TOP (at 815MHz) and Sapphire at 850MHz. Everybody discourages buying Sapphire, but what about that Asus? I've seen some reviews, but the results vary... What do you guys think (not having to OC the card myself is a definite plus for me)?
 
Back
Top