New PC Build

Torn

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 21, 2004
Messages
433
I'm currently in the process of planning out a new system. The issue I'm running into is this; the age old debate of AMD vs Intel. Which is better for the money not only CPU wise, but mobo wise. Looking for best price to performance ratio, not necessarily cheaper-is-better. I've been hearing a lot about the Core 2 Duos being a bit better for the money than their AMD counterparts, but am unsure. Also, which chipsets would folks recommend for each? Thanks.
 
if you're starting from scratch, go with intel right now. what's your budget? what are your goals for the PC? I'm a big AMD fan, but right now, money is best spent on conroe versus the AM2 AMD platforms (which are essentially retrofit s939 bits in order to handle DDR2)

I just built my father a replacement PC, and for $800 (no monitor) he got a sweet E6400 system, DDR2 800 memory, and all high quality parts (no budget choices in the build). If you're into OC'ing, then the intel is even better. E6600's are getting into the mid 3.Xghz with air cooling and relatively small voltage bumps. a comparable X2 4800 will be similar stock (benchmarking wise) but will only OC to the high 2.X range, and will use more power, require bigger vCore bumps.

zv
 
The system in question is for my fiancee. It would be for online gaming (WoW, SWG) and internet. I'm hoping to come in below $700 if possible. I was going by the Sharky budget guide since we haven't seen an [H] budget guide in a long while and had it right around $650. Not sure about their recommended mobo though. Anyway, thanks for the feedback. Will stay on program with the Intel.
 
$700 is tight if you need monnitor, windows, kb/m, and all the pieces.

are you starting from complete scratch?

do you overclock?
 
Recycling monitor, cd (really want DVD, but may have to sacrifice), floppy, and Windows, so that cuts out a good chunk. $700 for just the core system; mobo, CPU, HDD, RAM, video, case/PSU (heard Antec Sonata II was a good combo).
 
Intel Core 2 Duo E6300 - $195.00
GIGABYTE GA-965P-S3 Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express - $108.99
G.Skill F2-6400CL5S-1GBNQ 1GB DDR2 800 RAM - $114.99
eVGA 256-P2-N615-TX GeForce 7600GT 256MB PCI-Express - $129.99
Seagate Barracuda 7200.9 160GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s - $57.99
XClio 450BL ATX 450W Power Supply - $37.99
COOLER MASTER Centurion 5 CAC-T05-UW ATX Case - $49.99
-----
Total: $694.94

Barely under $700 but it comes with everything you wanted. WOW isn't very graphically demanding so the 7600GT is more than enough to run WOW at high settings. This also comes with a Core 2 Duo proc, the E6300, but I'd wait a few more weeks if I were you. Intel is releasing some new Core 2 Duo procs which will drive down the costs of current Core 2 Duo procs.
 
That's essentially what i had built as a suggested system, only i broke the budget a bit with a more expensive video card and PSU.

i went with a 79xx series card, and an enermax PSU.
 
Well, things got pushed back a ways so the system has yet to be built. Anyone have any changes to suggest? I'm thinking that the E4300 possibly? Thanks for your suggestions.
 
Actually its a good thing that things have been pushed back a ways for you because now you can take advantage of some serious price drops. If you haven't heard, on April 22nd, Intel is slashing prices off its CPUs as well as releasing a new series of E6400 and E6300 CPUs with 4MB L2 Cache. In other words, better bang for your buck.

So if you're willing to wait till April 22nd to buy your CPU, you can get the following build:

Intel Core 2 Duo E6420 - $183
GIGABYTE GA-965P-S3 Socket T (LGA 775) Intel P965 Express - $105
G.SKILL F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ 2 x 1GB 240-Pin DDR2 800 RAM - $120
eVGA 256-P2-N615-TX GeForce 7600GT 256MB PCI-Express - $110
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 160GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s - $57
XCLIO STABLEPOWER 460W ATX Power Supply - $50
COOLER MASTER Centurion 5 ATX Mid-Tower - $50
----
Total: $675 PLus tax and shipping.

It's cheaper than the build list I made for you a few months ago but it's significantly better due to the faster CPU and 2 Gigs of RAM.
 
If you want a DVD drive, it'll be $10 more going off of Danny's build. Get the Centurion 534 from svc.com for $30 and add any sata DVD burner, which is usually around $30.
 
Amazing the difference only a couple of months has made. Waiting for the big drop on Sunday!
 
Yeah I know. I wish I had waited for a while to buy that G.Skill RAM. Paid $170 for it and now its about $110!
 
Yeah I know. I wish I had waited for a while to buy that G.Skill RAM. Paid $170 for it and now its about $110!

Heh, I built quite a few systems with that ram when it was $210, lol... but none of those "clients" have complained yet, lol. and if they do, they already know my answer...

Man, I need to find time to play with those ballistix I ordered, lol.

Anyhow, Tom, got any other questions? Oh, also, you might want to go for those Firestix at Directron.com for $120... they're hot and wont stay in stock long.
 
I think I've got a handle on it. This sounds like a great system build. Thanks for the input guys!
 
Uh oh another question. Looks like NewEgg has the 8500s in stock. Worth the money or stick with the 7600GT?
 
Stick with the 7600GT. The price to performance value of the Nvdia midrange video cards isn't that great. Get the 7600GT and upgrade to a DX10 when DX10 games actually come out and prices on DX10 cards actually drop.
 
ACK! Both XClios are out of stock! I was just about to order. Have to do it TONIGHT since I need it by next Wed. Any other options?

<edit>Well, the 500W version is only $10 more...guess that'll do 'er.
 
I went with the 500W Stablepower since that was the 460W one you recommended. Worth the money, I'm sure.

Yah, since the efficiency is listed as 80%, I'm guessing its a rebadged Enhance 5150GH, which is the same price on eWiz.com. I think the Stablepower line is all Enhance. The Goodpower and 450BL are CWT, with good cooling. The Greatpower line is CWT with better caps (like the Toughpower line of Thermaltake), or so I've read.
 
System is all put together and working beautifully. There was a minor issue since I am using an IDE CD-ROM for now and it emulates IDE with the SATA drives unless you tell it not to. Fixed in BIOS and all went smoothly!
 
Back
Top