New Gaming build (some questions)

Ratking496

n00b
Joined
Jun 12, 2011
Messages
7
Been outta the loop for quite awhile now and figured it was time to build a new gaming rig. I was hoping some of you guys could give me some advice on the parts i came up with and help me out on a couple of questions i have. I'm planning on ordering the parts this week.

ASUS P8P67 DELUXE (REV 3.0) Motherboard
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131701

Intel Core i5-2500K CPU
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115072

CORSAIR Vengeance 8GB (2 x 4GB) 240-Pin DDR3 1600 Memory
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820145345

CORSAIR HX Series CMPSU-850HX 850W Power Supply
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139011

Western Digital Caviar Black 1TB 7200 RPM 64MB Cache SATA 6.0Gb/s HDD
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136533

COOLER MASTER Hyper 212 Plus
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835103065

COOLER MASTER R4-BMBS-20PK-R0 Blade Master 120mm Case Fan
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835103069

LG CD/DVD Burner 24X Black SATA Model GH24NS70
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827136236

Arctic Silver AA-1.75G Thermal Compound
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835100014

(already ordered) Antec Three Hundred Illusion ATX Mid Tower Case
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811129066&Tpk=antec

I'm on a pretty tight budget unfortunately. I haven't bought anything yet except for the case. It wasn't exactly the case i wanted but i ordered it because it was on sale and seemed like a great deal. Also i'm gonna be reusing my current video card (8800GT 1G) for the time being and i'll be picking up a new nVidia card in a month or so when i have some more cash. Other future plans hopefully include an SSD drive and eventually 2 SSD's in raid 0. I don't have any plans to SLI.

I only have a few questions but any advice or different recommendations on my parts list would be greatly appreciated. Oh and please shout out if you see any incompatibilities on my list. I'd like to make sure i get everything i need (inc. all the little stuff) with my Newegg order since it's a pain finding anything local where i live.

QUESTIONS

1). First off i'm unfamiliar with this MB. I'm planning on using the hyper 212+ with the additional fan (push/pull) to achieve moderate o/c's on the 2500k, nothing too wild. Could i combine the 2 cpu fans with a PWM Y Cable and then plug into the cpu fan header on the Asus board? Which i assume will regulate them by cpu temps. If so, would this cable work?:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16812718001

2). The Antec Illusion case, to the best of my knowledge, has 2 front and 1 rear 120mm TriCool fans with 3-speed switch control. I believe these are them:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835209040&cm_re=antec_

The case also has 1 top 140mm Twocool fan with 2-speed switch control, which i believe is this one or something similar:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835209051

Is there way i can connect the case fans to the board CHA_FAN headers? If so, would i need some Y cable splitters? If so, would this be the ones:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16812200455&cm_re=Fan_Po

I noticed the 120mm fan description says "Fan-speed monitoring capability included (requires compatible motherboard)". Can this Asus board regulate the fan speeds for me as long as i flip the fan switches to high? I would like the 3 120mm fans to be regulated by the MB, i'm not too worried with the 140mm top fan.

3). Last question is about my PSU selection (CORSAIR 850HX). I'm not sure if it's the right one to get. I don't like to scrimp on the PSU but i also don't want to go overboard since i'm on a budget. Modular designs are very attractive for me especially since i'm going with a mid tower. Also i would rather have one that will be adequate for my future upgrades. The future will involve a higher end nVidia GPU (no plans for SLI) and some additional HDD's/SSD's). Is this PSU a good choice?

Any and all advice/recommendations are greatly appreciated! Been outta the loop far too long and really want to be sure before hitting the order button. TIA!
 
While I don't know enough about the motherboard to answer questions 1 & 2, I think you should be fine on question 3 (unless you plan on getting a GTX 590). 850W is more than enough for your system.
 
Actually, you could be paying too much money for that build because you've picked out or already ordered several parts that are relatively poor values (or put it this way, if you're on a tight budget, why did you pick out parts that are significantly overpriced for little practical gain and/or of lesser quality and/or performance than cheaper parts?). For example, the Antec Three Hundred Illusion is not worth anywhere close to its $70 price on the account of being seriously cramped rear to front (the P8P67 Deluxe barely fits that case at all, leaving precious little if any room at all whatsoever to accomodate internal SATA plugs, whose access get almost completely obstructed by the case's fixed, nonremovable hard drive cage brackets - and the P8P67 Deluxe, like many other P67 mobos, have all or most of their internal SATA ports located at the very front edge of the mobo, the exact same location where clearance is a severe problem).

Speaking of the P8P67 Deluxe, it is way overkill for your use. You're really paying $60 to $70 extra just for a second Ethernet controller/port and a PLX PCI-e extender chip that can also cause problems with some expansion cards. (And that's not to mention that it actually costs $233, not $225, shipped.)

Third, that WD Black costs about $20 more than the 1TB Samsung F3 that we've been recommending and performs slightly faster (sequential-speed wise) than the Black (but keep in mind that the 2TB Black is of a different design from the 1TB and smaller Blacks).

Fourth, you don't need that Arctic Alumina: The Hyper 212 Plus HSF already comes with its own thermal compound that actually performs better than the Alumina.

And speaking of the Vengeance memory, the heat spreaders are tall enough to interfere with the proper installation of the Hyper 212 Plus HSF: The fan must be raised higher than its normal position, resulting in some reduction of the HSF's cooling performance.

And the HX850 does not cost $150. In fact, it actually costs $171 shipped, with a $15 prepaid rebate debit card that you are not guaranteed to even receive at all since many if not most of the legitimate rebate requests have been rejected (declined) by the rebate fulfillment companies.

And the Hyper 212 Plus HSF itself is definitely overpriced at Newegg: It is a good $30 HSF - but it is not worth the $40 price that Newegg sells it for. In fact, Newegg charges a significantly higher price than other resellers for that particular HSF.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the heads up Tricky, although i think the 590 will forever be outta my price range, lol.

E4g1e, i appreciate the advice, i really wanted to get some experienced feedback before ordering. I've only bought the case so far, nothing else, i picked it up for $55 total (shipping inc.). It was not my first choice but i figured the Antec 300 was a fairly popular case and it came equipped with 3x120mm & 1x140mm tricool fans. I just figured that was a great deal. I did however do some research on the case and as you say it is a cramped case. But i did see that many people were using it with these asus boards, so i just figured i could get it to work. I have no problem modding the case if i have to by dremeling, drilling, etc.. But i'm worried with what your saying, i very well might have screwed up snagging this on sale.

As for the MB, i picked Asus because i'm a fan of their boards, i've used them in my last few builds. I did some reading between the dlx vs the pro because of the $50 price difference. The majority of the dlx extras does not sway me but there is some features that i think are worth the extra $50, more power phases, onboard power/reset/clear CMOS buttons, debug LCD, better heatsinks & better audio. I normally don't use onboard audio but i thought i might give it a try before buying a new sound card. I do agree with you that this board is more than likely overkill for me but i just figured that it's a good move considering i have no plans of every changing this MB until i build my next full system. But i haven't ordered parts yet so everything is still up in the air for me atm.

I've always had great luck with WD drives and i'm unfamiliar with Samsung, but i'll take a look at the one you've recommended. My plans are to eventually go with a large enough SSD drive to handle OS, games, apps, etc.., while regulating the regular HDD to storage.

I won't get the Artic Silver thermal compound and i'll use the Cooler Master stuff. It's good to hear that it comes with superior compound, one thing less to worry about. As for the cooler itself, your right, it is pricier at the Egg although it's free shipping. I will check around on it.

I'm still on the fence with the memory, i was also looking at the G.Skill Ripjaw X. I've seen photos thats been posted of people using the Asus P8P67/ Hyper 212+ combo with the Vengeance sticks, it was fine using the 2nd and 4th slots, which i believe is the dual channel slots on this board? But using the first slot looked like it might require a little filing on the fan guard. But i'm just going by photos i saw. Could you recommend me some ram or tell me if you think these are a better pick:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820231445

As for the PSU, i'm aware of the shipping, rebate, etc.., i have it sitting in my Egg cart. I agree with what your saying regarding rebates, i really hate them. I've never been screwed outta one before but i've had to on occasion "remind" them that they were suppose to have issued me one. I just really hate keeping track of them. But the $15 rebate had no bearing on me picking this PSU. In fact i'm just not really sure what PSU to go with, i just know i want it to be a high quality, preferably modular, and future proof as to wattage. If you think this PSU is a bad choice or too costly it'd be great if you could recommend me something, i'm pretty clueless on this stuff.

Thank you very much guys!
 
All of the major manufacturers offer three- to five-year warranties for their boards, and even the cheap boards have enough features to make them good options for long-term use. I agree with E4g1e that you need to consider a cheaper board that still fits your needs. Since you're already running a tight budget, you shouldn't spend more than you need to on parts that you may or may not even use to the fullest.

Unless your case cooling is really poor, you don't really need heatsinks on the RAM. I say that because RAM like the G.Skill Value Series would perform just as well as the "performance-based" Ripjaws RAM.

What video card do you plan on buying? Find a 650-750 watt modular PSU from Silverstone or XFX instead. (You could buy the HX650 instead of the HX850, but I believe that Silverstone and XFX sell cheaper modular PSUs.)
 
All of the major manufacturers offer three- to five-year warranties for their boards, and even the cheap boards have enough features to make them good options for long-term use. I agree with E4g1e that you need to consider a cheaper board that still fits your needs. Since you're already running a tight budget, you shouldn't spend more than you need to on parts that you may or may not even use to the fullest.

I completely agree with what you guys are saying, i'm just finding it hard to scrimp on the motherboard. Fact is i've only researched the Asus P67 & Z68 boards, i've always been partial to Asus and i'm unfamiliar with other brands. I just keep thinking that since i'll be stuck with this MB for the life of this build then $50 is not too much extra to spend. I think if i go with the pro i'll keep beating myself up over it later. I know, i'm being mental.

Unless your case cooling is really poor, you don't really need heatsinks on the RAM. I say that because RAM like the G.Skill Value Series would perform just as well as the "performance-based" Ripjaws RAM.

I'll take a look into some different modules, although i was thinking the ones i chose were pretty cheap anyway. I did notice some G.Skill CL9 1333 value ram but it was only $15 cheaper. I'll keep looking though.

What video card do you plan on buying? Find a 650-750 watt modular PSU from Silverstone or XFX instead. (You could buy the HX650 instead of the HX850, but I believe that Silverstone and XFX sell cheaper modular PSUs.)

I was going with the 850 to give myself some headroom but seeing what your saying i'm guessing now that was prolly overkill? I'll step it down to the 750. As for a video card, i haven't a clue atm, i will prolly grab one in a month or so, most likely a nvidia 500 series in the $250-$300 range, i guess. I'll need to do some reading on them.

Thanks tiraides!
 
Thanks for cluing me in on the F3's E4g1e, I read up on them and i think i'm gonna go with them instead of the WD black. I can grab them for $50 on the Egg. Quick question, does anyone know if these will work decent in raid or would the F3R drives be required? Because I'm thinking about going with 2 for raid0, then when i can eventually upgrade to SSD, i'll use the F3's maybe for raid1 storage.
 
Thanks for cluing me in on the F3's E4g1e, I read up on them and i think i'm gonna go with them instead of the WD black. I can grab them for $50 on the Egg. Quick question, does anyone know if these will work decent in raid or would the F3R drives be required? Because I'm thinking about going with 2 for raid0, then when i can eventually upgrade to SSD, i'll use the F3's maybe for raid1 storage.

The F3's will work just fine in RAID 0 or RAID 1. The F3R is required only if you're going to be using it in a RAID 5 or RAID 6 parity raid, especially with a hardware RAID card.
 
I completely agree with what you guys are saying, i'm just finding it hard to scrimp on the motherboard. Fact is i've only researched the Asus P67 & Z68 boards, i've always been partial to Asus and i'm unfamiliar with other brands. I just keep thinking that since i'll be stuck with this MB for the life of this build then $50 is not too much extra to spend. I think if i go with the pro i'll keep beating myself up over it later. I know, i'm being mental.
Yes you are being mental. Dude, past $150 you're already overspending on the motherboard. So you're not skrimping at all. Espcially considering that the P67 Pro is the Asus mobo with the most amount of issues for a socket LGA 1155 mobo. I;d reommend this mobo at the most:
$180 - MSI P67A-GD65 Intel P67 ATX Motherboard

I'll take a look into some different modules, although i was thinking the ones i chose were pretty cheap anyway. I did notice some G.Skill CL9 1333 value ram but it was only $15 cheaper. I'll keep looking though.
Yeah the Corsair set is cheap but still not a good buy.

I was going with the 850 to give myself some headroom but seeing what your saying i'm guessing now that was prolly overkill?

Pretty much unless you're going for a triple GPU setup or a dual extremely high-end GPU setup.

Oh even at $55, the Antec 300 is still not that great of a buy considering that the extra fan won't help with the poor cable management and space issues that the Antec 300 cases have. The Coolermaster HAF-912 would have been a better choice.
 
Last edited:
Yes you are being mental. Dude, past $150 you're already overspending on the motherboard. So you're not skrimping at all. Espcially considering that the P67 Pro is the Asus mobo with the most amount of issues for a socket LGA 1155 mobo. I;d reommend this mobo at the most:
$180 - MSI P67A-GD65 Intel P67 ATX Motherboard

That board looks really good but i think i'm kinda stuck on the Asus, i just hope everything goes smoothly with it and i don't live to regret it. But i do understand that i could easily save some money by choosing a different board, i just don't think i want to. I guess i'm not too worried about spending $40-50 more on the mainboard, while yes i'm on a budget i can always dig a little deeper for some stuff.

Yeah the Corsair set is cheap but still not a good buy.

I decided to change the ram a couple posts up to the G.Skill set, what is your thoughts on these?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820231445

I'm kinda against going with slower value ram for such a small cost savings, even though performance might be similar. I'll most likely be using this ram for along time, hopefully the life of this build.

Pretty much unless you're going for a triple GPU setup or a dual extremely high-end GPU setup.

I've taken the advice above and opted for the HX750 but i could also get the AX750 and after promo & rebate it comes to just $4 more. I really didn't want to mess with a rebate but i will if i need to. Do you think it would be a good move going with the AX750? HX750=$136 (after $10 mir/ shipping) or AX750=$140 (after promo/mir/shipping).

Oh even at $55, the Antec 300 is still not that great of a buy considering that the extra fan won't help with the poor cable management and space issues that the Antec 300 cases have. The Coolermaster HAF-912 would have been a better choice.

Yeah i know the 300 is a budget case and it was not the one i wanted but i already got it. I'm pretty good at routing cables, etc.. so i'm gonna give it a go. I do however think it was a good deal seeing how i doubt i could even buy the fans alone for what i paid total. I was considering that HAF case before i got this one, but it would have cost more. It does look like a good case with great cooling, although i'm not a fan of the looks. It seems to be setup for water cooling for those who want to go that route. If i remember correctly it only comes with 2 fans and costs $60. The 300 with 4 fans was $55. I'm not saying the HAF isn't a better case but it just would have cost more, so i just made a judgement call when i saw the 300 (with fans) on sale. Not saying it was the right move but it's kinda too late now.

Thanks Danny!
 
I decided to change the ram a couple posts up to the G.Skill set, what is your thoughts on these?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820231445

I'm kinda against going with slower value ram for such a small cost savings, even though performance might be similar. I'll most likely be using this ram for along time, hopefully the life of this build.
Well if you're gonna be paying $50+ more for a mobo with features that you don't need, might as well go full mental and go for the DDR3 1600 RAM.

I've taken the advice above and opted for the HX750 but i could also get the AX750 and after promo & rebate it comes to just $4 more. I really didn't want to mess with a rebate but i will if i need to. Do you think it would be a good move going with the AX750? HX750=$136 (after $10 mir/ shipping) or AX750=$140 (after promo/mir/shipping).

I don't ever factor in MIR. I'm not sure what promo code you're talking about in regards to the 750AX. Due to your eccentricities, you might as well go for the AX750 for the extra $24.

If all those changes are within budget, go for it. But as other will say, you're pretty much paying more money for nothing.
 
Well if you're gonna be paying $50+ more for a mobo with features that you don't need, might as well go full mental and go for the DDR3 1600 RAM.

Well i'm not saying that i "need" the extra features of the dlx board but it has many features i would like and benefit from. As for the memory, i just can't see using value ram just to save $15 or so. Although maybe that's just me.

I don't ever factor in MIR. I'm not sure what promo code you're talking about in regards to the 750AX. Due to your eccentricities, you might as well go for the AX750 for the extra $24.

The promo code came in a Newegg email i got yesterday. The AX750 will only cost me a grand total of $4 more with the slight additional hassle of a mir. I'm not too sure if paying $4 more for the AX model classifies me as being eccentric, but i'm assuming it's a smart move none the less, although maybe i'm wrong. I'm glad i was given the advice above 'bout not needing an 850w or i would have never seen this bargain.

If all those changes are within budget, go for it. But as other will say, you're pretty much paying more money for nothing.

Well thank for everyone's help, i think i have my build plan in order. As for the case, which i already received, i'm gonna give it a go and if all else fails i can swap cases with my current rigs modded Enermax.

Appreciate all the help.
 
Back
Top