New Device In Development To Catch Texting Drivers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you are one of those people that still texts and drive, you'd better watch out, the police have a new tool in the works to catch you in the act.

A Virginia company is developing a radar gunlike device that would help police catch drivers as they text. The technology works by detecting the telltale radio frequencies that emit from a vehicle when someone inside is using a cellphone, said Malcolm McIntyre of ComSonics. Cable repairmen use similar means to find where a cable is damaged - from a rodent, for instance - by looking for frequencies leaking in a transmission, McIntyre said.
 
Wouldn't getting a phone call without actually picking up the phone would also give a positive reading on this? what about hands free cellphone talking?
 
So what happens if you're using your phone to stream music w/bluetooth, receiving a call/text (not necessarily answering it) or even using built in handfree like Sync to legally make calls/compose text messages? Will you get flagged as 'texting'?
 
This is bogus. What if I have a hands free system in the car that lets me compose texts? This will never work. Delete!
 
sounds like this would be targeted at people driving solo.

Everyone else brings up valid shortcomings but I think the police would just point it at a car they saw only one person in.

A lot of false positives later and we should have an interesting follow up article.
 
Not unless it is the end of the month and they need to fill the quota! ^^^^^
 
Pretty stupid. Why not just make the penalties for sending a text within a few minutes of a crash occurring exceptionally stringent?
 
Not unless it is the end of the month and they need to fill the quota! ^^^^^

This. They'll make the fines cheap enough that people will just pay to not have the hassle. Traffic tickets are based on a system of "guilty until you prove yourself innocent". The few that do challenge can be dropped, as the majority won't bother.
 
It'll never pass muster. The first case would be thrown out, and that would be the end of it.

Besides, I'm not so sure electronic surveillance is legal. Not that it seems to matter these days.
 
Wouldn't getting a phone call without actually picking up the phone would also give a positive reading on this? what about hands free cellphone talking?

yep, or your phone checking for email, or you playing pandora or whatever

Couldn't possibly catch people texting from the passenger seat.

yep

This. They'll make the fines cheap enough that people will just pay to not have the hassle. Traffic tickets are based on a system of "guilty until you prove yourself innocent". The few that do challenge can be dropped, as the majority won't bother.

just like red light camera tickets, it's all BS meant to fleece you
 
Good. I hate people who text and drive. Not only do they endanger the public, they hold up traffic. If you're a passenger to a person who texts and drives, do us all a favor and knock the shit out of them. ;)
 
I imagine the police will require visual confirmation before using the scanner, just like with radar guns. Police cant rely solely on a radar gun to ticket you for speeding, they have to actually see you speeding first, using their eyes and training to determine that you are likely speeding, and the gun is just for verification, as backwards as that seems.
 
yep, or your phone checking for email, or you playing pandora or whatever



yep



just like red light camera tickets, it's all BS meant to fleece you

Uh...if you get a red light ticket that's because YOU WENT THROUGH A FUCKING RED LIGHT. :rolleyes:

A texting detector is a lawsuit just waiting to happen.
 
I imagine the police will require visual confirmation before using the scanner, just like with radar guns. Police cant rely solely on a radar gun to ticket you for speeding, they have to actually see you speeding first, using their eyes and training to determine that you are likely speeding, and the gun is just for verification, as backwards as that seems.

lolwut??
 
Uh...if you get a red light ticket that's because YOU WENT THROUGH A FUCKING RED LIGHT. :rolleyes:

Depending on the State you can make a right turn without coming to a complete stop. The main issue for red light cameras is a majority of the money ends up going to companies likely outside region with the cameras. This hurts the local economy. To increase revenues further they also have a habit of reducing the yellow light time after an intersection has switched over to a red light camera. Most red lights with a camera actually end up with more accidents(at least in the short term), but it is consider worthwhile because it tends to reduce serious accidents.

If more of the money stayed in the local economy(normally at least half goes to private companies outside the area) and if the caution light time was constant versus being frequently reduced to increase revenue. They might be ok. The other issue is 90% of the tickets are normally for rolling right turns and likely caused by the reduced caution light interval.
 
Do any of you guys actually read these articles before you run off at the keyboard?


A text message, phone call and data transfer emit different frequencies that can be distinguished by the device ComSonics is working on, according to McIntyre. That would prove particularly useful for law enforcement in states such as Virginia, where texting behind the wheel is banned but talking on the phone is legal for adult drivers.

He said the device is "close to production" but still has several hurdles to clear, including legislative approval and adoption by law enforcement.
 
Uh...if you get a red light ticket that's because YOU WENT THROUGH A FUCKING RED LIGHT. :rolleyes:

A texting detector is a lawsuit just waiting to happen.

Yea... and some times it sends tickets to the wrong person.

I got a red light ticket because the car in front of me with a similar car blew the red light and somehow they got my plate instead.

It was a real hassle to get it thrown out, I contested it through mail, sent evidence that my car is a different model than the one in the video that blew the light.

I still ended up in court. The judge then had an officer show up to my house to inspect my car and confirm that my car is not the one on the footage.
Only THEN was the ticket thrown out.

I missed 2 days of work. I was better off just paying the ticket.
Anyways... just wanted to vent that out.

But yea, unless there's more to how this "Texting while Driving" detector will work, it's just not going to end up well.
 
Do any of you guys actually read these articles before you run off at the keyboard?

While I'm sure some people just go off the headlines, your quote didn't clear up the confusion. As several people mentioned, what if you receive a text while driving or compose a text with your vehicle, hands free?

There is a large potential for false positives with this device it seems
 
Do any of you guys actually read these articles before you run off at the keyboard?

cell phones dont "emit different frequencies" depending on text/data/voice in the modern world

with everything going to LTE it's all data, regardless of what it is

unless they are illegally decrypting the control channels, that would be neat, no way anyone could abuse that!
 
While I'm sure some people just go off the headlines, your quote didn't clear up the confusion. As several people mentioned, what if you receive a text while driving or compose a text with your vehicle, hands free?

There is a large potential for false positives with this device it seems

Then read my second quote in the same post :D
 
cell phones dont "emit different frequencies" depending on text/data/voice in the modern world

with everything going to LTE it's all data, regardless of what it is

I didn't write the article, I posted what it says and they say they can identify the difference between text traffic and regular calls or other data.
 
If they can address all od the shortcomings discussed here, I am all for it.
 
cell phones dont "emit different frequencies" depending on text/data/voice in the modern world

with everything going to LTE it's all data, regardless of what it is

unless they are illegally decrypting the control channels, that would be neat, no way anyone could abuse that!

It wouldn't surprise me if they were all ready.
 
sounds like this would be targeted at people driving solo.

Everyone else brings up valid shortcomings but I think the police would just point it at a car they saw only one person in.

A lot of false positives later and we should have an interesting follow up article.

I don't see how that'd work. If you receive a text, it uses the same radio as when you send one. Sure they can pull you over and ask to see your phone, but by then you could easily delete the texts. Are the police seriously going to subpoena phone records every time they pull someone over? If not, then this doesn't sound like it'll work.
 
Yea... and some times it sends tickets to the wrong person.

I got a red light ticket because the car in front of me with a similar car blew the red light and somehow they got my plate instead.

It was a real hassle to get it thrown out, I contested it through mail, sent evidence that my car is a different model than the one in the video that blew the light.

I still ended up in court. The judge then had an officer show up to my house to inspect my car and confirm that my car is not the one on the footage.
Only THEN was the ticket thrown out.

I missed 2 days of work. I was better off just paying the ticket.
Anyways... just wanted to vent that out.

Ick.

Around my area traffic cameras are a nuisance, but not all that big a hassle.

The cameras around here are required to take multiple pictures -- one of the car as it crosses into the intersection with the color of the light visible in the picture, another with the license plate clearly visible, and a third from the front with the driver visible.

They are required to void the ticket if the person being ticketed (i.e. the registered owner) does not match the driver in the picture because it's too hard to prove who was driving in this instance.

Also, you can only be fined if the front fender of the vehicle crosses the white line of the intersection AFTER the light turns red. As long as your vehicle is even 1" beyond the line in the picture while the light is still yellow, they can't ticket you.

You can pretty much contest any of them by mail just by submitting a picture of your car, your photo ID, etc -- and basically everyone I've ever heard of contesting them has never had an issue. Even if you simply don't pay it, the tickets are not allowed to count as moving violations or traffic infractions. They are only allowed to be handled as incurred debts -- i.e. the worst that can happen if you don't pay is that they turn the debt over to a bill collector. They aren't allowed to effect your driving record, license, etc. in any way. So, worst case, around here about all that can happen is you get a ding on your credit score.
 
Ick.

Around my area traffic cameras are a nuisance, but not all that big a hassle.

The cameras around here are required to take multiple pictures -- one of the car as it crosses into the intersection with the color of the light visible in the picture, another with the license plate clearly visible, and a third from the front with the driver visible.

They are required to void the ticket if the person being ticketed (i.e. the registered owner) does not match the driver in the picture because it's too hard to prove who was driving in this instance.

Also, you can only be fined if the front fender of the vehicle crosses the white line of the intersection AFTER the light turns red. As long as your vehicle is even 1" beyond the line in the picture while the light is still yellow, they can't ticket you.

You can pretty much contest any of them by mail just by submitting a picture of your car, your photo ID, etc -- and basically everyone I've ever heard of contesting them has never had an issue. Even if you simply don't pay it, the tickets are not allowed to count as moving violations or traffic infractions. They are only allowed to be handled as incurred debts -- i.e. the worst that can happen if you don't pay is that they turn the debt over to a bill collector. They aren't allowed to effect your driving record, license, etc. in any way. So, worst case, around here about all that can happen is you get a ding on your credit score.

Yea because a "ding" on your credit score doesn't cost you much more down the road. :rolleyes:
 
Hmm... there's a high tech device that will disable a vehicle's electronic computer. Your car's electronics network may be sophisticated, but as the amount of data it handles increases over time, it will have to be upgraded. Most likely, cars will adopt an Ethernet-based system such as VEEDIMS. VEEDIMS assigns each vehicle component an IP address so that centralized and remote computers can pass around huge amounts of information. Attach a cellular connection and data can be beamed to the cloud for analysis. Better yet, you can text "Disable" to ANY future vehicle including law enforcement vehicles. :cool:
 
what if I lend my car to someone? the owner of the car gets the ticket, not the driver... or automated tolling systems that mis-read plates or think your car is a semi-truck

http://articles.sun-sentinel.com/20...ss-axles-20130316_1_toll-plazas-axles-sunpass

crazy because this happened to me

I got a ticket in the mail from Miami, FL saying I went through a toll without paying it.

I live in IL. I also don't drive a mini-van (which was the vehicle in the black and white printed photo I received in the mail)

it's fucking sad honestly
 
This idea is unacceptable, though that won't stop law enforcement from using it.

They cannot tell me if I'm texting or not, and it's legal to use my phone for many things while driving. It's not even acceptable to imply that using your cell phone in the car is always unsafe. But of course law enforcement doesn't agree that there should be high degrees of logic behind the things they do. They just want simple, nearly-guaranteed revenues from fines.
 
Of course it is being developed by a company out of Virginia. The state where you can end up serving time in jail for speeding.
 
Doesn't a text message take just a split second to send? I don't see how they can possibly identify which car happened to send a text unless you are the only car on the road.
 
Pretty stupid. Why not just make the penalties for sending a text within a few minutes of a crash occurring exceptionally stringent?

It'd be awfully hard to prove without reasonable doubt that they hadn't stopped or used an automated piece of software. Or voice recog.
 
It'd be awfully hard to prove without reasonable doubt that they hadn't stopped or used an automated piece of software. Or voice recog.

No matter how they make the laws, with the minimal oversight our mili.... err-police get, they will just abuse any technology they are given. Even if laws were well-written (they are, of course, horribly written by stupid people voted for by stupid people) they won't save us from a lack of police oversight and accountability.
 
Back
Top