New card for system being built advice?

NathanP2007

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Dec 17, 2007
Messages
1,697
The purpose of the system will be to be a mid range system FOR WINDOWS 7, equal to what im using now (see specs in my signature) but intel instead of AMD....with the options of upgrading down the road to a quad core high end CPU.

What i cant figure out is what Vid-Card to buy or even be interested in. All i know is when i was building my current PC is the 8800GT was the best..and i paid 200 and its still doing great. Getting 50-60 Frames per minute in COD4 multi with everything cranked all the way up. It only struggled at highest resolution and settings on crysis and Sims 2.

My price range currently is nothing more than $130. Yes i know thats lowish, but it wont be my main PC...and if i want to il upgrade later maybe.

So whats the best and most reliable Vid-Card in that price range?
Btw i only have experience with nvidia so if you recommend anything other than that, please dont hold back with explaining why to go with that.
 
What res will you be playing at?
What PSU are you planning to use?
 
I'd go for this card:
$135 - XFX HD-485X-ZDFC Radeon HD 4850 1GB PCI-E Video Card

It's faster than the 8800GT and will be good enough for that res.
 
It's only a $5 difference w/o rebate, $25 difference w/rebate. If you've had extremely good luck with rebates, go for the "cheaper" XFX HD4850 512MB. But if your luck with rebates have been bad, go for the 1GB HD4850.

You don't have to do anything. The type of VRAM doesn't require you to do anything special.
 
K, so 1gig video card instead of 512 is worth the 25 buck difference in your experience?
 
imo, if you are going to $135 might as well upgrade to a 4870 (1gig) or a gtx260

that said, i play various games with a 4870 512mb @ 1920x1200 and have yet to really experience any real limitations of the memory in the games i play.
 
Got any links Risqu3? from what i see on newegg the 4870's are 200+ bucks and my price range is tops at like 140 i know its smart to buy way better even if its 60 bucks more..but i just cant right now. id actually perfer a damn decent card for 130 than a GREAT card for 200.
 

Wouldn't recommend this PSU. It's based off the FSP Episilon PSU design which has out of spec ripple, or voltage fluctuations, at high loads that can damage or kill your system. Granted, you may not reach such high loads but why pay for a PSU that can kill your system?

Also you can get the GTX 260 for $10 cheaper, backed by a better company and with lifetime warranty with free shipping:
$165 - BFG Tech BFGEGTX260896OCE GeForce GTX 260 896MB PCI-E Video Card
 
I just want to know the best GPU for 100-135 bucks best meaning the for what im paying im getting the best quality video out of the card...and reliability...iv never had a issue with my evga8800gt and its been nice that way
 
I just want to know the best GPU for 100-135 bucks best meaning the for what im paying im getting the best quality video out of the card...and reliability...iv never had a issue with my evga8800gt and its been nice that way

Why not just get another 8800GT? Those in SLI are going to beat any card for that price range.
 
My price range currently is nothing more than $130. Yes i know thats lowish, but it wont be my main PC...and if i want to il upgrade later maybe.

So whats the best and most reliable Vid-Card in that price range?
Btw i only have experience with nvidia so if you recommend anything other than that, please dont hold back with explaining why to go with that.

On the nVidia side, the 8800GT is exactly the same card as the 9800GT. The 9800GTX+ is a small step faster than the 8800GT, and was recently redesigned into the GTS 250. The GTX 260 comes in two versions; one with 192 processor cores and one with 216, and both are a full step up from the GTS 250.

On the ATi side, the 4830 is roughly equal to the 8800GT/9800GT. The 4850 is roughly equal to the 9800GTX+/GTS 250. The 4770 performs somewhere in that thin slice between the 4830 and 4850, and was intended to go for under $100 and be a great value, but is suffering serious supply problems. The 4870 1GB is roughly equal to the GTX 260 216, and the 4870 512MB is a bit slower.

Prices on newegg today:
9800GT $75 = 4830 $80 < 4770 $110 < 9800GTX+ $105 = GTS 250 $100 = 4850 $90 < 4870 512MB $150 = GTX 260 192 $145 < GTX 260 216 $155 = 4870 1GB $163
Disclaimers: Most of these prices are after mail-in rebate; I do not list HIS mail-in rebate prices because they are notorious for not honoring the rebate; I see on reading newegg reviews that MSI is also having trouble honoring rebates. Prices may change by $5 to $10 on a daily basis. Some of these prices are weekend-only deals and may be gone tomorrow. Wow, that was a lot of legal copy!

From what you've been saying, it sounds like you'll want the GTS 250. Looking more closely at the GTS 250 cards on newegg at the moment, the MSI is having rebate unreliability issues, and the Zotac needs an 8-pin PCI-E power connector instead of a 6-pin (huh?). So the cheapest one I'd look at is the eVGA GTS 250 for $120 after $10 mail-in rebate, with free shipping, that requires only one 6-pin PCI-E power connector; its only negative is that it has only a 2-year warranty instead of a lifetime warranty.

Since it's not your main PC, you could either save some cash and get the $75 9800GT, or put the $120 GTS 250 in your main computer and move the 8800GT to the new one.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Evil Sofa for that long detailed reply. Those are my fav type of replies haha.
Im curious your opinion on this card http://www.tigerdirect.com/applicat...?EdpNo=4410188&csid=ITD&body=MAIN#detailspecs
to versus that eVGA gts 250 i noticed they have the exact same specs and the same price (be4 rebate, like someone mentioned, rebates are sketchy sometimes.
And that 9800GTX has a lifetime warranty. What are your thoughts?
 
The 9800GTX+ on Tigerdirect does have a lifetime warranty, but after shipping it costs $132, needs two 6-pin PCI-E power connectors instead of one. I thought GTS 250s were shorter, but in this case they are the same length (9.5 inches). You can go either way here.

eVGA rebates are reliable; I've done 5 or 6 personally with no problems.

Zipzoomfly has the same GTS 250 as the newegg one, here, for $10 cheaper ($110 after mail-in rebate, free shipping, 2 year warranty).

Buy.com has a PNY 9800GTX+ for $94 and free shipping after a big $40 mail-in rebate, with a 3 year warranty.
 
Im curious which you think is the best deal? I cant help but picturing being pissed if the GPU died on the third year with only 2 year warranty...do you think lifetime vs 2 year is worth 30 bucks more?

And as far as the GTS's vs 9800GTX's.....is there a difference in anything bout them? They have the same memory and chip-set specs...but are their features different? Or is the difference that the 250 GTS is the newer version of the 9800GTX so its specs are the same but its technology is a bit newer? (aka more features..more compatible)
 
Im curious which you think is the best deal? I cant help but picturing being pissed if the GPU died on the third year with only 2 year warranty...do you think lifetime vs 2 year is worth 30 bucks more?

I'm afraid I'm going to have to say that only you can make that decision. Do you think you'll be upgrading anyway in 2011?

And as far as the GTS's vs 9800GTX's.....is there a difference in anything bout them? They have the same memory and chip-set specs...but are their features different? Or is the difference that the 250 GTS is the newer version of the 9800GTX so its specs are the same but its technology is a bit newer? (aka more features..more compatible)

The reference GTS 250's main difference was a new shorter board and power design; the clock speeds are the same but the power consumption has been reduced. The reference 9800GTX+ was 10.5" long and the reference GTS 250 is 9.5" long; eVGA was already using a 9.5" long board on the 9800GTX+. The reference 9800GTX+ used two 6-pin PCI-E power connectors while the reference GTS 250 uses only one, but some manufacturers seem to want to use two instead, and Galaxy is being really different by using one 8-pin; eVGA uses only one on both its 9800GTX+ and GTS 250. So, there is probably no difference at all between the eVGA 9800GTX+ and eVGA GTS 250.
 
Tack up another vote for the GTS 250. It seems to be perfect for what you need.
 
Back
Top