New Captcha System Uses Empathy for Human Response

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
It was bound to happen sooner or later: a politically correct reply to a Captcha question could replace the standard format. The new system is designed by a group named Civil Rights Defenders and if you guessed they are a human rights group, you win a prize.

Civil Rights Defenders, the Swedish-based group that developed the tool, hopes the Civil Rights Captcha will help sites block spiders and bots, while letting humans in — and hopefully educating the humans at the same time.
 
Seems a little silly.

1. A human isn't a set of emotions or feelings. Some people are assholes, but still human. THough I suppose it might keep some assholes out...but then again assholes lie. :D

2. People can only be shocked by stuff so many times. The more you expose people to the suffering of others, the less they will care eventually. They will care the first few times, but it just becomes normal and then just background noise. It's like swearing. It just becomes grey after a while.
 
In other news Foxconn corporate users were unable to login to their computers today so production on the iPhone 5 had to be halted.
 
Don't believe this will end up getting implemented. I see far too many problems. I don't need to be forced to be politically correct, especially when most of it is just Crap for people who are to sensitive.
 
This violates the rights of sociopaths everywhere.

Isn't there the expression 'One mans sociopath is another man's freedom fighter?' But seriously, 50 years ago that same question would have had a different set of answers.

I consider this example in context of the target website bringing some rye humor. But in context with the the incessant preaching and imposed world views I see everywhere its a turn off. In other words if I came across a preachy PC captcha in my day to day surfing, I'd take that website off my destinations.
 
Great, now even captcha's are going to be shoving politically correct bullshit down our throats. It's not like we don't get enough of that on tv, radio, movies, music, school, work...I guess everywhere is what I'm saying.
 
Great, another form of captcha I will not be able to use.
 
Great, now even captcha's are going to be shoving politically correct bullshit down our throats. It's not like we don't get enough of that on tv, radio, movies, music, school, work...I guess everywhere is what I'm saying.

If this is what you are picking up all the time, maybe it's time to consider adjusting your antenna. ;)
 
I wonder if Anonymous' Operation Ren... yeah that one, would work with this! :D
 
Some Captchas are awesome. This is a real one I had to solve not too long ago.

344zg61.jpg
 
CAPTCHA is already impossible to solve as it is, they need to relax a bit. Some websites I can go through 20 of them before one of them is even close to legible. It's a lot of hassle to determine robots.
 
CAPTCHA is already impossible to solve as it is, they need to relax a bit. Some websites I can go through 20 of them before one of them is even close to legible. It's a lot of hassle to determine robots.
Robots actually have an easier time with captchas than humans do.
 
hopefully educating the humans at the same time.

how does it educate, we all have different opinions so to claim it educates is BS, it someone is fascinated than that is their choice.....and a captcha is not going to change that.
 
The Captcha system is the wrost shit in history. I failed to get log in after dozens of attempts that would mean I'm a bot? I no longer log on to those sites anymore. Less and less used.
 
OK guys I'm getting a vibe from some of the people who are posting that there is something wrong with this statement:

The Vice Minister of Defense in Albania, Ekrem Spahui, thinks gays should be beat up with a stick. How does that make you feel?

Terrible.

If you think there's something wrong with this I'd like to know why.
 
I want a captcha system that can feel my rage and show empathy towards giving me a goddamn word I can actually type in and not spend 10 minutes unable to tell if it's a "U" or two "L's" or an O being a 0 and so on and so forth.


The captcha system is one of the worst things to ever come and be embraced by the Internet. I'd rather tell with spammers than such a crap system that already can be broken by Black Hats who have $1000 to purchase a constantly updated system to bypass them.
 
Not sure whether testing humans for empathy will come up with many results... unless they are defending their country, anyway... seems a lot of people don't give a fuck about humans but they sure as hell love their countries.
 
Bad news for replicants...

You’re in a desert walking along in the sand when all of the sudden you look down, and you see a tortoise, Tony, it’s crawling toward you. You reach down, you flip the tortoise over on its back, Tony. The tortoise lays on its back, its belly baking in the hot sun, beating its legs trying to turn itself over, but it can’t, not without your help. But you’re not helping. Why is that?
 

+1, Whoever thinks it's a good idea to tell people how to feel is a fascist moron. There's way too much grey area for bleeding heart libs to go around telling people what's right and wrong.

"Serial rapist tries to attack woman in alley. She shoots him to death with her concealed carry handgun. How does this make you feel?"

(A) "Sad" (B) "Depressed" (C) "Shocked"

Guess what. My answer isn't listed.
 
Robots actually have an easier time with captchas than humans do.
All the sites that we have captchas on disagree with you. Additionally, it depends on the captcha you use. Some are very easy to solve and will still nearly eliminate spam.

The idea of this captcha is interesting, but has two key problems:
1 - I can't use it on a client site simply because of the content. If the questions were neutral in nature then I could use it.
2 - There are only 3 options. 1 in 3 is still a high rate for spammers.
 
This is like a lot of the way laws are passed... it only makes it harder on those that work in the system and not outside of it. I think we should find the people making these bots... well, insert non-PC solution here _______
 
All the sites that we have captchas on disagree with you. Additionally, it depends on the captcha you use. Some are very easy to solve and will still nearly eliminate spam.

The idea of this captcha is interesting, but has two key problems:
1 - I can't use it on a client site simply because of the content. If the questions were neutral in nature then I could use it.
2 - There are only 3 options. 1 in 3 is still a high rate for spammers.

Even the new video captcha system "NuCaptcha" can be beaten by computers with a 90%+ accuracy...which is probably more luck than humans would have. There are plenty of articles and blog postings on the internet about the other various Captcha services being broken by computer with comparable if not greater ease than humans have.
 
how does it educate, we all have different opinions so to claim it educates is BS, it someone is fascinated than that is their choice.....and a captcha is not going to change that.

Indoctrinate

I came here to respond to the top post with this ^. It's another group claiming they have the final answer on morality and "educating" you about how to be enlightened just like they are.
 
OK guys I'm getting a vibe from some of the people who are posting that there is something wrong with this statement:
If you think there's something wrong with this I'd like to know why.

1. It's politically loaded.

2. It forces the re-evaluation of a thought to coincide with an emotion that a (potentially) disparate group believes and thus is an attempt to promote groupthink.

3. Similarly, it flies in the face of the fundamental idea of freedom. Freedom of thought, speech, expression.

Also, I have a very different feeling when I read that statement. Anger. Both at the subject and at the captcha itself for the reasons above.
 
fuck captcha and double fuck empathetic captcha

most of us internet pricks will never get into anything anymore since we are all desensitized asshats.

still, spend this time and effort upgrading to just handle the occasional flowthrough of bots or something... i'm sick of being punished for being a person at a keyboard.
 
Back
Top