new build - i7, am2+, or am3?

jblade

n00b
Joined
Mar 17, 2009
Messages
16
I need advice on a new system. Right now I’m using an Athlon XP 320 build from 5.5 years ago. So I assume that for my next computer I plan to keep my computer for 5-6 years as well. I definitely think that my system has hit a wall and it’s definitely time for an upgrade (if you think I should wait for something new is going to come out please notify me). I’ve seen several different threads about new computers but none doing a price difference as I have listed below. These are some of the configuration I’ve looked at.

i7 build that comes out to a total of 1120.92.
I picked the cheapest ASUS board due to newegg reviews.

Phenom ii x3 720 with am2+ board, with a total that comes out to 838.93
i7 difference = 286.99
Phenom ii x4 920 build that comes out to a total of 881.23
i7 difference = 239.69
Phenom ii x3 720 with am3 board, with a total that comes out to 876.94
i7 difference = 253.98
720 am2 difference = 43.01
Which AM3 board is better; MSI or Gigabyte

Intel Parts:
i7 920 + ASUS P6T Mobo + G.SKILL 6GB PC 1600

AM2+ Parts:
phenom ii x4 940 + ASUS M4A79 Deluxe = 344.99 combo deal
phenom ii x3 720 + ASUS M4A79 Deluxe = 296.99 combo deal

AM3+ Parts:
Phenom ii x3 720 + corsair xms3 4gb = 205 combo deal
Msi 790fx-gd70 = 179.99
Gigabyte ga-ma760fxt-ud5p = 179.99

General Parts:
Antec 761345-75080-6 80mm Case Fan - Retail (I have 2 of these in my cart)
Corsair 620HX and Samsung Spinpoint 1TB = 219.98 combo deal
Logitech Internet 350 (any other keyboard recommendations)
Sapphire HD 4780 Toxic Edition (I want a good cooling solution for gpu without modding)

Here is the basic questionnaire:
1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Gaming, basic media work, web browsing
2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
Around 1000
3) Where do you live?
Illinois, USA
4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
Everything except no case and monitor (listed above)
5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
Reusing an old case that probably has terrible airflow. I don’t know the model of and my mx510 mouse.
6) Will you be overclocking?
Minor if any - could use some heatsink ideas (not for i7 since it's already over the 1000 mark)
7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have?
Samsung 19’’ monitor and HP 22’’ monitor
8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
Within the next few months
9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
Crossfire or SLI so I can run dual GPUs later
10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license?
Yes, both business vista and xp pro

As you can I have a Corsair 620HX PSU (modular) in mind but I also have Corsair 750TX (non-modular) in mind. Is 620w too low for a system I am thinking about with 2 GPUs in crossfire/SLI? Also, I picked the sapphire 4870 toxic edition for a good cooling system without modding, would the powercolor 4850 be a better choice? Is the i7 worth the extra 200-250 dollars? What is the best AMD solution? Sorry for the long post and thanks in advance for your expert opinions!
 
No need for SLI/Crossfire with a 19" nor 22" mointor setup.

Markyip1 said:
Just some info on SLI / Crossfire: It's absolutely not worth considering if a) you're gaming at a resolution under 1920x1200 (as you'll see no performance benefit over a single card,) and b) if you plan to buy one card now and another later. SLI / Crossfire as an upgrade path is usually a very poor idea, as by the time you're ready to get that second card, a new single card solution will likely be available that will outperform two of your older cards in tandem. Furthermore, there really is no cost benefit to the SLI Upgrade Route, as any additional cost in getting the new card can be easily mitigated in most situations by selling the original. By avoiding an SLI / Crossfire solution when it will not be of benefit, you gain a cooler running, simpler to maintain system and more importantly, access to a much better (and broader) selection of motherboards.

With that said, and removing a dual GPU config in the future as a requirement, the HX 620W will be more than enough for your planned build.

I'd suggest going with Intel, since it performs best out of all your options, and also because you plan on keeping this system for a very long time. Getting the best performance available now will help with your plan.

Please post a picture of your case. If it has terrible airflow and is too small, then you'll need a new case and we can adjust your build to fit one into the budget.
 
I'd suggest going with Intel, since it performs best out of all your options, and also because you plan on keeping this system for a very long time. Getting the best performance available now will help with your plan.

+1 you will be better off with the intel, performance and support will be much better for longer than the AMD.
 
+1 you will be better off with the intel, performance and support will be much better for longer than the AMD.

Huh ? :confused: While I agree that an Intel will give better performance. How do you conclude that support will be better for longer than the AMD ?

Anytime I have had to deal with AMD on a support issue it has always been top notch.
 
I definitely like that little segment of crossfire/sli you pasted and completely agree with it now. Thank you for that advice! Now I can take each build and start looking for mobos that don't have two pcie 2.0 x16 slots. I think looking for a mobo with one pcie with x16 should reduce the cost of the mobo by a good amount.

Here are some pictures of the case I plan on reusing:
Couldn't find my digicam, so I used my cell phone.
I can't the my image to show up on the forum so I'm just going to provide links

http://elementlu.t35.com/pictures/DSC00104.jpg
http://elementlu.t35.com/pictures/DSC00105.jpg
http://elementlu.t35.com/pictures/DSC00107.jpg
http://elementlu.t35.com/pictures/DSC00108.jpg

As you can see there is only two 80mm fan slots, front and back
and the intake on the front is blocked by the usb ports/power switch
so what i had to do was tunnel the air that's what that opening is under the floppy drive

with the money i'm going to save on getting a cheaper mobo, i'm thinking getting the noctua heatsink that everyone talks about but i don't know if it can fit in the case. the mobo i have inside is the asus n7n8x deluxe regular atx
 
Huh ? :confused: While I agree that an Intel will give better performance. How do you conclude that support will be better for longer than the AMD ?

Ok maybe or maybe not better support, but longer yes just by popularity. Intel is outselling AMD by how much now with the current chipsets, all that volume will need long term support. Plus AMD is going to find it really hard to completely survive the resession that we are in.
 
Ok maybe or maybe not better support, but longer yes just by popularity. Intel is outselling AMD by how much now with the current chipsets, all that volume will need long term support. Plus AMD is going to find it really hard to completely survive the resession that we are in.

but amd's main strategy again intel is their lower priced chips which is exactly why i'm stuck in between i7 and am3. 200-250 is a big deal in the recession we are in right now, i think in a recession amd could see a little more business.

but back to talking about my build, i've done a lot more amd research than intel, can anyone find a better/cheaper i7 mobo than the one i have listed up there? i realize a lot of the combo deals have changed now so the figures up there are no longer valid.

this is the i7 mobo was thinking about
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131359
 
The P6T is great, I am happy with it. Gigabyte's UD3R looks good for a little less cash too.
 
but back to talking about my build, i've done a lot more amd research than intel, can anyone find a better/cheaper i7 mobo than the one i have listed up there? i realize a lot of the combo deals have changed now so the figures up there are no longer valid.

I recommend this combo:
Intel Core i7 920 CPU and Gigabyte GA-EX58-UD3R Intel X58 ATX Motherboard combo - $475

The UD3R is a very good overclocking but has the unfortunate problem of having only 4 DIMM slots. The Asus P6T mobo is a good choice as well. The Gigabyte UD4P mobo is another good choice:
Intel Core i7 920 CPU and Gigabyte GA-EX58-UD4P Intel X58 ATX Motherboard combo - $539
 
Yeah, I am going with the Gigabyte mobo as well. I am not overclocking or running SLI so there is no point for me to get anything more expensive than necessary.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128375

As for your debate, I too was going back and forth and am deciding to go with Core i7. I think the performance of the chip justifies the price difference, it's the Intel motherboard pricing that was turning me off.

I figure I will buy now and when the core i7 generation ends I will upgrade to the last compatible processor to give me a performance nudge until the next great thing comes down in price.
 
Does anyone have any advice if i need a new case or not? I can't find a ruler to measure it right now, but does anyone think if i get a noctua heatsink it won't fit in my case?

I've made two new wish lists and right now I'm looking at a difference of approx 224 dollars. I'm not sure if I have enough justification to choose i7 over am3 at that price. I'm not exactly sure what I need with 8 cores as well, I'm basically just picking because everyone says it is better for the long term investment.
 
The reason there are no cheap mobos for i7 is because the only chipset out right now is the enthusiast level chipset, X58... the most expensive and feature-rich of the chipsets.

Thats one outdated case with poor airflow, unless you use high speed 80mm fans, which are LOUD. If you were building a Core2 system, I'd say you can get away with it, but I'd recommend a new case for an i7 system. Are you near a Fry's? They have the Antec 300 for $44 in-store only. I'm not sure if a noctua would fit that case.

Also, are you near the microcenter in IL? If so, the i7.920 is only $230 there. ;)

If so, I think you can build an i7 for under $1k...
$230 - Intel Core i7 920 Nehalem 2.66GHz LGA 1366 130W Quad-Core Processor Model BX80601920 (In-Store pickup only)
$165 - HIS Hightech H487FN512P Radeon HD 4870 512MB
$190 - MSI X58 Pro LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard
$100 - Samsung Spinpoint F1 HD103UJ 1TB 7200RPM SATA300 32MB Cache
$98 - G.SKILL 6GB (3x2GB) DDR3-1600 F3-12800CL9T-6GBNQ 9-9-9-24 1.5V – 1.6V
$40 - XIGMATEK Dark Knight-S1283V 120mm CPU HSF w/ backplate included
$24 - ASUS 22X DVD Burner Black SATA Model DRW-22B1ST
$68 - BFG Tech LS SERIES LS-550 550W ATX12V 2.3 80 PLUS Certified (Free Shipping)
$44 - Antec Three Hundred Black Steel ATX Mid Tower (In-Store pickup only)
================
$960 + tax and shipping

Though, not sure how good that mobo is... I haven't read up on it yet. Also, I didn't check for combo deals... sorry, no time.
 
Nice build. If the MSI is iffy, the gigabyte UD3R is a good option for only a little more.
 
Thanks so much for building that system out for me!
Fry's and Microcenter is probably an hour away from where I live but it's probably worth the savings i would get! If i buy the chip from microcenter online, there will be no tax charge? I know fry's charges tax when you make an online purchase.

$165 - HIS Hightech H487FN512P Radeon HD 4870 512MB

when looking for a 4870 card, is 512 usually preferred? if anyone has anything input on that toxic card i selected, that would be appreciated.

$40 - XIGMATEK Dark Knight-S1283V 120mm CPU HSF w/ backplate included

I was thinking since i'll be spending so much on a i7, i'll stick with the stock heatsink. is that not recommended?

$24 - ASUS 22X DVD Burner Black SATA Model DRW-22B1ST

are sata dvd burners much better than ata dvd burners?
 
I believe MC will still charge tax.

For a 19" monitor, the 512MB should be fine. If you don't think so, get the 1GB or see Danny's post below.

The stock HSF may get loud, and you can't OC much with it. The Xigmatek is more quiet while cooling much better than the stock HSF, also allowing you to OC.

There is no performance difference between SATA and IDE DVD Burners. However, cable management is easier with a SATA drive, and case airflow is better, too.
 
when looking for a 4870 card, is 512 usually preferred? if anyone has anything input on that toxic card i selected, that would be appreciated.

these days everybody recommends the 1GB.

I was thinking since i'll be spending so much on a i7, i'll stick with the stock heatsink. is that not recommended?

Depends if you are going to OC or not. If you want to OC get the dark knight

are sata dvd burners much better than ata dvd burners?

IDE is a dying breed.
 
when looking for a 4870 card, is 512 usually preferred? if anyone has anything input on that toxic card i selected, that would be appreciated.

512MB is the bare minimum. However if you can afford the 1GB, then go for it. As for the Sapphire HD4870 1GB Toxic, in that price range, I'd rather get an Nvidia GTX260 since A) their performance is virtually the same as the HD4870 1GB and B) the eVGA, BFG and XFX GTX260 cards have a lifetime warranty. So I recommend getting the GTX260 if you can fit it into your budget:
BFG Tech BFGEGTX260MC896OCE GeForce GTX 260 896MB PCI-E Video Card - $180

I was thinking since i'll be spending so much on a i7, i'll stick with the stock heatsink. is that not recommended?
Stock cooling will be good enough for stock speeds. However if you overclock, then definitely get that Xigmatek HSF.

are sata dvd burners much better than ata dvd burners?

IN terms of performance, not really. In terms of air flow and cable management, SATA DVD burners are far superior than IDE DVD burners.
 
Thats one outdated case with poor airflow, unless you use high speed 80mm fans, which are LOUD. If you were building a Core2 system, I'd say you can get away with it, but I'd recommend a new case for an i7 system.

you say i can get away with this on a core2 system... do you think the same could apply to a am2+/am3 system?
 
512MB is the bare minimum. However if you can afford the 1GB, then go for it. As for the Sapphire HD4870 1GB Toxic, in that price range, I'd rather get an Nvidia GTX260 since A) their performance is virtually the same as the HD4870 1GB and B) the eVGA, BFG and XFX GTX260 cards have a lifetime warranty. So I recommend getting the GTX260 if you can fit it into your budget:
BFG Tech BFGEGTX260MC896OCE GeForce GTX 260 896MB PCI-E Video Card - $180

So your saying that the 260(216) has about the same power as the 4870? Even though they use different gddr (3 vs 5)? If so, i think I'll go with the 260! As for the case problem, I read that it comes with two 120mm fans with the case. Do you guys recommend that I install more than that?

I'll consider getting a new sata dvd burner than... i don't know what i'm going to do with all my old IDE drives, i practically have a box full of them. my goal now is to spend at least over 999 at newegg so i can get no interest for 12 months with credit services. so i think i might just buy all my parts from newegg except for the antec 300 case.

I have to step out for a bit so i won't be able to ask questions for awhile, thanks for all the advice everyone
 
So your saying that the 260(216) has about the same power as the 4870? Even though they use different gddr (3 vs 5)? If so, i think I'll go with the 260! As for the case problem, I read that it comes with two 120mm fans with the case. Do you guys recommend that I install more than that?

The two fans should be enough. And yes the GTX260 is about the same as the HD4870 1GB. See for yourself:
http://hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTYyNiwsLGhlbnRodXNpYXN0
http://hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTYzMSwsLGhlbnRodXNpYXN0
 
you say i can get away with this on a core2 system... do you think the same could apply to a am2+/am3 system?
No, they run hotter than Core2s, IIRC.
... As for the case problem, I read that it comes with two 120mm fans with the case. Do you guys recommend that I install more than that?
I'd recommend one or two more fans, placed in the front of the case as intake. Go for some Yate Loon 120mm low or medium speed from jab-tech.com.
sad the antec case now says 59.99 at frys :( ...
... my goal now is to spend at least over 999 at newegg so i can get no interest for 12 months with credit services. ...

Sometimes you have to act fast. Oh wellz, now it'll be easier to reach your goal at newegg. :eek:
 
any difference between the
asus gtx 260
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814121257&Tpk=asus gtx 260

bfg tech 260
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814143155

they have the same specs but asus is alot more expensive

also, does everyone agree on the XIGMATEK Dark Knight-S1283V 120mm heatsink is the way to go? there's no size problems with it in the antec 300 is there? I'm definitely thinking about over clocking the i7, but not a whole lot. I was reading the [H] posts on over clocking the i7 and I'm definitely not thinking of going anywhere near 3.8 GHz. Also do most of you do folding@home? I am most definitely looking forward to contributing when I get this system.
 
Get the BFG card, as it is cheaper and it offers a limited lifetime warranty (provided you register your card first).

The Xigmatek HDT-S1283V is a good choice for overclocking. If you want it, get it.

Folding@Home? That's up to you.
 
about $2

I don't know if anybody has shown a benefit to lower timings on the i7 yet. I haven't seen it.
 
i guess i'll be going with the silverish looking ones...
although i kind of like the looks of the red ones more, the silverish ones looks like it has better/bigger heat spreaders...

i see a lot of egg reviews saying they run this at pc1333.
problems with pc1600?

i'll be placing my order this week for sure
(have to make sure i got this extra part-time job)

i hope going with the gigabyte mobo won't disappoint me
i'm looking at a total of 1200 right now
 
They are both great ram. I agree for practically the same price you might as well go with the better timings and heat spreaders.
 
i realize i don't have to go the gigabyte board because i am no longer getting the combo deal with the i7 920 because i'm buying the 920 at microcenter...

therefore i can go with a evga, asus, gigabyte, or msi board... is it unanimous that p6t is the best?
 
If you're overclocking, go with the red DDR3 1600 kit. Its lower voltage matters more than the tighter timings of the other set -- you'll end up with a greater overclocking threshold.

When it comes to the overall performance of the boards, YMMV. Some people have problems with the same boards that others are constantly praising. With that said, I wouldn't call the P6T better or worse than the other boards. Choose one with the features that you feel that you need and you shouldn't run into any problems.
 
I'd got for a board with 6 slots instead of the gigabyte. 2 years from now you can double the memory for dirt cheap and keep your system chugging for another 2-3
 
ty for everyone's help - i ended up buying my computer parts + some addition extra stuff to meet my 1000 goal at newegg for the 12 months no interest...

newegg stuff ~ approx 804 dollars before rebate
XIGMATEK Dark Knight-S1283V 120mm Long Life Bearing CPU Cooler
Antec Three Hundred Black Computer Case
BFG Tech GeForce GTX 260 BFGEGTX260MC896OCE Video Card
Logitech Black Internet 350 USB Keyboard
EVGA 132-BL-E758-TR ATX Intel Motherboard
LG 22X DVD±R DVD Burner with LightScribe Black SATA Model GH22LS30
SAMSUNG Spinpoint F1 1TB 3.5" SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive
CORSAIR CMPSU-620HX 620W Power Supply

microcenter stuff ~ approx 247 dollars
Intel Corporation Intel® Boxed Core® i7 Processor 920

jab-tech stuff ~ 15 dollars
2x late yoon 120mm fans

amazon stuff ~ approx 42 dollars after rebate
OCZ XMP Ready Series 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) Triple Channel Kit Desktop Memory - Retail

all for a approx cost of 1058 after rebate price and /w shipping
i picked the evga board dude to newegg offering standard warranty on that board versus 30 day limited warranty on asus and gigabtye. even though right now i'm still debating if i should call in and switch the evga board for the asus pt6 deluxe v2 board for 40 more dollars (20 dollars mail in rebate) or 10 dollars less for the pt6 regular board, but i'm most likely going to stick with my choices
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
sucks... right after i ordered
GIGABYTE GA-EX58-UD4P LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail
ASUS P6T LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail
went down 10 dollars in price
tried calling this morning to change my build but they said it is too late already
i don't think it is worth canceling the whole order to save 10 bucks
 
Back
Top