New Build - DVD/SATA/ACHI Issues

willow

Weaksauce
Joined
Nov 27, 2004
Messages
77
I just built a new system on an ASUS P5Q Deluxe motherboard. I have 2 SATA hard drives & one SATA optical drive: SH-S223F. BIOS is set to ACHI.

Vista Home Premium installed fine, but Windows isnt't usually able to recognize discs that I put in. It reconizes the drive fine, but again, often not the disc itself.

I then tried to install XP Pro, when it start to load it blue screens. If I go in to the BIOS & change it to IDE, all is fine. & yes, I have the F6 drivers.

So I've read enough to know that some optical drives don't play nice with ACHI. I'd really like to leave the BIOS set to ACHI, as I've read it DOES improve hard disc performance. Some options I have are:

1)Switch the SATA optical drive for an IDE.
2) Buy a PCI SATA card.
3) Change the SATA BIOS to IDE.

However, I'm hoping there's a SATA DVD burner that plays nice with ACHI. Is there a diferent brand I can get & use the onboard SATA ports & ACHI?
 
I don't know that MB, but according to the Asus specs, it has two controllers, an Intel ICH10R and a Silicon Image® Sil5723. The latter runs the IDE port as well as providing two SATA ports.

Try putting the hard drives on the Intel controller and the optical drive on the Silicon Image controller. Then set the Intel controller to AHCI (or RAID if you think you might use RAID in the future - RAID should include AHCI; check the manual). Set the Silicon Image controller to IDE.
 
Thanks, but the SI ports are strictly for hard drives, (per the owners mauual).
 
Thanks, but the SI ports are strictly for hard drives, (per the owners mauual).

Well then can't you use the SI ports for the hard drive(s), and the Intel ports for the optical drive? Then set the SI ports to AHCI and the Intel ports to IDE
 
The problem could be the DVD drive itself. I need some more information first. Did you end up installing XP on that system, and if so, does the DVD drive read all your discs in XP using IDE mode?

I ask because I have a DVD burner that has a somewhat similar problem. I've had the drive in two or three different systems now using IDE mode and AHCI. I've also used the drive in XP, Vista and openSUSE. The drive will show up in each OS but it will not read all the media I have. Most of the problems I've had is with burned media although it's had trouble with DVD movies and a couple of pressed data DVDs. I'm not 100% sure about CDs because I don't really use them much.

In my case, I was hoping a firmware update would solve my problems but it didn't. More than likely my drive is just defective but since it's in a secondary system I rarely use it and never got around to RMAing it.

 
Thanks, but the SI ports are strictly for hard drives, (per the owners mauual).

That sucks - they've done it all backwards compared to Gigabyte. It would appear you're forced to use all your Intel ports in IDE mode and only have two SI ports in AHCI/RAID mode if you use a SATA optical device.
.
 
I have recently been informed, on the [H] MB forum, that the P5Q documentation is questionable. He was able to put the DVD device on the Intel controller in AHCI mode with no problems. His was also a Samsung DVD.
 
I ended up replacing the Samsung SH-S223F with a SH-S203B. All is well now. Apparently the 223 has conflicts that the 203 does not. Anyway, the 203 is running fine in ACHI.
 
Back
Top