Netflix: Piracy Drops Wherever We Launch

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I'm not saying this is B.S. but I'd have to see some hard numbers to back up this claim. While I like what this guy is saying overall, I just find it hard to believe considering how long it takes Netflix to get new content.

One of the things is we get ISPs to publicise their connection speeds – and when we launch in a territory the Bittorrent traffic drops as the Netflix traffic grows. So I think people do want a great experience and they want access – people are mostly honest. The best way to combat piracy isn’t legislatively or criminally but by giving good options. One of the side effects of growth of content is an expectation to have access to it. You can’t use the internet as a marketing vehicle and then not as a delivery vehicle.
 
I'm not saying this is B.S. but I'd have to see some hard numbers to back up this claim. While I like what this guy is saying overall, I just find it hard to believe considering how long it takes Netflix to get new content.

Mostly it's because a lot of film studios are trying to fight against Netflix by refusing to extend previous deals. I guess they're trying to make their own BS service.
 
I'd guess that Netflix users, as a whole, aren't the ones that were using bit torrents anyway.

And agreed on the timing. A new release has long since been forgotten about by the sharers when that title finally hits Netflix....
 
I believe it.


I know people who used to torrent many years of seasons of television series for their binge watching pleasure.

Now they have Netflix for the first few years, and only have to download the most recent season that's not on Netflix yet :p

So, reduction? Yes! Elimination? Nooooo!
 
I say there is some truth as I used to torrent shows not available and now Netflix has them or they did. I think the decline of NETFLIX is their over all sucess right out of the gate now the studios see one more nail in the coffin for their distribution methods and want to prolong it as long as they can.
 
Why would Netflix be involved at all with combating piracy?
It gives people a legitimate and easy way of getting the content that they want on any device that they want, be it on the computer, their phone, their game console, or their TV.

Give people what they want and make it easy for them to get it and they won't have a reason to pirate. The reason why people pirate is because of all of these restrictions that have been put into place. Bought it for your PC? Can I use it on my phone? No. You have to buy it again. Bullshit.

The faster the studios realize that NetFlix can be their best friend the faster it's going to be better for us and the studios.

One video platform, one content delivery system, one payment, one login, one web site, one place to get everything! That's what people want!!!!

This crap about... "Oh, online video is great. Let's make our own service." doesn't work. People don't want to have to think about what online service currently hosts their favorite show, they want a single web site (ie. NetFlix) with a single login to view every TV show and movie that has ever been created. CONVENIENCE!
 
Zarathustra[H];1039850247 said:
I believe it.


I know people who used to torrent many years of seasons of television series for their binge watching pleasure.

Now they have Netflix for the first few years, and only have to download the most recent season that's not on Netflix yet :p

So, reduction? Yes! Elimination? Nooooo!

Totally agree. Netflix eliminates download of all old seasons of shows available on netflix.
Latest episodes of some shows like big bang theory, 2 and half men, conan, daily show, etc can be found on their websites next day. Fox shows like simpsons, bones are available after some days. But some people wont wait for these and will watch it streaming or download them.
 
The problem with that thinking, adithyag, is what if you want to catch up on older episodes? There's no legitimate outlet for that kind of viewing other than NetFlix.
 
nt and make it easy for them to get it and they won't have a reason to pirate. The reason why people pirate is because of all of these restrictions that have been put into place. Bought it for your PC? Can I use it on my phone? No. You have to buy it again. Bullshit.

I agree, but remember there are different types of pirates.

There are still those who just don't want to pay for something and instead download it.

These seem to mostly be teenagers and college students without a real steady income though.

As far as everyone else goes, if you can give them an easy and convenient distribution model at a reasonable price, like what Netflix provides, they will have less reason to pirate stuff.

This comic over at The Oatmeal does a good job of demonstrating this.

Unfortunately, what is probably going to happen is that every single dimwitted studio is going to want to get in on online distribution for themselves, and instead of a single, unified simple interface, like what we have in Netflix, it's going to be fragmented, habving to have multiple subscriptions to each studio's service, with different apps, and fees adding up from each one, resulting in people going back to piracy again.

If then know what's good for them, they will rally behind Netflix, even have them create a premium service that costs a little more per month than the $8.99 which is unrealistic if you expect to have all the latest content, and have everything in one easy place. That would really have a huge impact on piracy.
 
Totally agree. Netflix eliminates download of all old seasons of shows available on netflix.
Latest episodes of some shows like big bang theory, 2 and half men, conan, daily show, etc can be found on their websites next day. Fox shows like simpsons, bones are available after some days. But some people wont wait for these and will watch it streaming or download them.

I find it a nuisance to have to browse to each channels webpage and play the videos in their flash window.

I want something that integrates nicely into WMC or XBMC on my HTPC.

The quicker content owners learn that people want something easy, on their terms, that doesn't require them to hunt for stuff, and its all in one place under a unified interface, and that they then will pay for it, rather than pirating it, the better FOR THEM.

They are still stuck in the cable distribution model mindset, and quite frankly, consumers are no longer willing to put up with that. Unless they change their tune, it's only a matter of time until they are all gone.

Cars came, and suddenly there was no longer a Horse and Buggy market. Cable distribution is obsolete and needs to die.
 
I think ppl pirate cuz they want the content on their HD so it can be rewatched on demand, rather than requiring internet connection and streaming. I personally would never use Netflix even if it was free. It's the same thing as youtube if that was the case. All is gravy until you don't got internet.
 
I think ppl pirate cuz they want the content on their HD so it can be rewatched on demand, rather than requiring internet connection and streaming. I personally would never use Netflix even if it was free. It's the same thing as youtube if that was the case. All is gravy until you don't got internet.

You can tell when my internet is down because you see me curled into a fetal position constantly refreshing my phone or my browser :D

I think the vast majority of people are becoming much more interested and dependent on the always on internet connection and that the interest for offline entertainment will either take the form of temporary legal downloads (with a premium service level, like Spotify) or buffering on the online streaming services :cool:
 
Roll it up, let's hit the future button where NetFlix has contracted the rights to major motion picture producers so new movies are being offered on netflix at the same time as the theaters get them.

Would it kill the theaters, maybe, if so should they go away anyway, perhaps. Let Darwin figure it out. The RIAA and such are in this pickle to begin with cause they try to hold back Darwin instead of letting the model adapt to change.

When a new movie rolls out I want to see it just like the next guys. No way an I paying theater ticket prices and stupid money for a soda and popcorn so when will I see the movie?

A) When it released on Optical Media 6 months later ?

B) When is shows up on NetFlix or whatever 6 or more months later if.....?

C) The day before the theater with a downloaded torrent ?

These are our choices today, but what answer B was different?

B) On NetFlix, Amazon, or wherever the same day it hits theaters ? (I'd pay for that.)
 
Zarathustra[H];1039850289 said:
If then know what's good for them, they will rally behind Netflix, even have them create a premium service that costs a little more per month than the $8.99 which is unrealistic if you expect to have all the latest content, and have everything in one easy place. That would really have a huge impact on piracy.

you are missing one very important point.
they know exactly what they are doing in making things as difficult as possible to obtain from legally convenient sources. they know that piracy isnt quite the boogeyman its been made out to be. but it is their golden ticket to get new legislation that heavily favors them and increases their stranglehold on this.

this is why the only time you see any new services trotted out, they completely suck ass. they are designed to suck ass and fail.... which is why any time something comes along that doesnt suck ass... the media outlets do whatever they can to make it suck ass such as withholding content.
its the reason why the idea in your comment would be guaranteed to work and at the same time something that would never happen.
 
It gives people a legitimate and easy way of getting the content that they want on any device that they want, be it on the computer, their phone, their game console, or their TV.

Give people what they want and make it easy for them to get it and they won't have a reason to pirate. The reason why people pirate is because of all of these restrictions that have been put into place. Bought it for your PC? Can I use it on my phone? No. You have to buy it again. Bullshit.

The faster the studios realize that NetFlix can be their best friend the faster it's going to be better for us and the studios.

One video platform, one content delivery system, one payment, one login, one web site, one place to get everything! That's what people want!!!!

This crap about... "Oh, online video is great. Let's make our own service." doesn't work. People don't want to have to think about what online service currently hosts their favorite show, they want a single web site (ie. NetFlix) with a single login to view every TV show and movie that has ever been created. CONVENIENCE!
You got it.

Why do you think services like Spotify are so popular? Because for $10/month, I can have every song that was ever produced ANYWHERE. Pirating shit is inconvenient and time consuming - especially if you have OCD and must make sure everything tagged with proper meta data. $10/month is a DEAL compared to the time it would take to get everything that you want from illegitimate services.
 
If then know what's good for them, they will rally behind Netflix,

No, they just need to buy netflix and make it their own content distributor.

Man, I was paying like over $100 a month for DirectTV and it sucked so bad I cut it off. I have no services beyond cable-internet and my netflix account.

How much would I pay for first run movies at release via NetFlix without commercial content? $100 a month easy as long as the content is really there and the new movies play on release date.
 
No, they just need to buy netflix and make it their own content distributor.

Man, I was paying like over $100 a month for DirectTV and it sucked so bad I cut it off. I have no services beyond cable-internet and my netflix account.

How much would I pay for first run movies at release via NetFlix without commercial content? $100 a month easy as long as the content is really there and the new movies play on release date.
Wow. You'd have to watch more than 5 new movies every month to make that worth it.

Feel like that's a lot.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039850289 said:
I agree, but remember there are different types of pirates.

There are still those who just don't want to pay for something and instead download it.

These seem to mostly be teenagers and college students without a real steady income though.

As far as everyone else goes, if you can give them an easy and convenient distribution model at a reasonable price, like what Netflix provides, they will have less reason to pirate stuff.

This comic over at The Oatmeal does a good job of demonstrating this.

Unfortunately, what is probably going to happen is that every single dimwitted studio is going to want to get in on online distribution for themselves, and instead of a single, unified simple interface, like what we have in Netflix, it's going to be fragmented, habving to have multiple subscriptions to each studio's service, with different apps, and fees adding up from each one, resulting in people going back to piracy again.

If then know what's good for them, they will rally behind Netflix, even have them create a premium service that costs a little more per month than the $8.99 which is unrealistic if you expect to have all the latest content, and have everything in one easy place. That would really have a huge impact on piracy.

Very, very well said.

The studios still don't understand the reality we are marching into while they hold to the past. What they really need to accept is pushing Netflix or whatever ends up being the default choice... keeping the sub $10 price model for everything that isn't first-run, and having a more expensive tier if you want all the new TV shows and movies when they release.

But then the question becomes, "but even if they had a $20 or $30 tier for new content how will they make as much money as they do now?"

SIMPLE. Sell both tiers to between 500 MILLION and 1 BILLION PEOPLE WORLDWIDE. At those price tiers it can easily be done. They'll be SWIMMING in money if the only major fees they have is bandwidth and all the physical product shipping stops.

The idiots just aren't willing to make up for it with volume... they are living in the internet age and are too stupid to see they operate the one industry that has the single biggest opportunity for digital distribution compared to any other business in existence.
 
Very, very well said.

The studios still don't understand the reality we are marching into while they hold to the past. What they really need to accept is pushing Netflix or whatever ends up being the default choice... keeping the sub $10 price model for everything that isn't first-run, and having a more expensive tier if you want all the new TV shows and movies when they release.

But then the question becomes, "but even if they had a $20 or $30 tier for new content how will they make as much money as they do now?"

SIMPLE. Sell both tiers to between 500 MILLION and 1 BILLION PEOPLE WORLDWIDE. At those price tiers it can easily be done. They'll be SWIMMING in money if the only major fees they have is bandwidth and all the physical product shipping stops.

The idiots just aren't willing to make up for it with volume... they are living in the internet age and are too stupid to see they operate the one industry that has the single biggest opportunity for digital distribution compared to any other business in existence.
That's because every big music and TV executive out there is 80 years old and did nothing but rape, pillage, and plunder throughout their careers to get to the position where they are now. They rather hold onto an old "proven" model than explore a new one. There is also the "I want my money now!" mentality over the "I will get my money....eventually" - it's a big hurdle for any industry to make.

For now, they will continue going to all corners of the planet to pursue and take down any sort of illegal content distribution sites. Maybe in 10 years they will come to their senses.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039850247 said:
I believe it.

So, reduction? Yes! Elimination? Nooooo!

Elimination will never happen so long as studios try to maintain their stranglehold on the content. "The more you tighten your grip, the more systems will slip through your fingers." Many People don't like others having such power over them. Some is tolerated, but not to the scale Hollywood moguls are trying to do today. The more they try, the worse things will get, and the more profit they will lose. If they would just let it go and allow things to move to Hulu and Netflix, they'd make more profit and have less piracy.

They're just too stupid and greedy to see it.
 
I found this article from a few years back that explains the industry pretty well (I think, I am not an industry expert)...

http://abovethecrowd.com/2010/04/28/affiliate-fees-make-the-world-go-round/


My pirating has drastically been reduced since Netflix. There are a number of reasons including growing into larger income bracket/age. Though by far the largest is easy of access to content.

Yes netflix doesn't have a ton of great content but they have enough acceptable stuff to cut into a significant portion of my TV/Movie time. Since Netflix I really don't torrent/usenet any content but I did rent from Netflix and rip. Since NetFlix streaming, I rip about 75% of what I used to... I used to be one of those daily netflix mailers... receive and send back in 24 hours.

The industries both cable and content are fighting it... trying to figure stuff out. Content can't go straight to Netflix because their big cash cows will get pissed (aka cable). Cable doesn't want to eliminate their major business/revenue model.
 
It gives people a legitimate and easy way of getting the content that they want on any device that they want, be it on the computer, their phone, their game console, or their TV.
No, I get that their existence helps combat piracy, but they had a business model that delivers content over the internet easily and cheaply. They did not go into business to combat piracy like Norton did to combat viruses, combating piracy is simply a secondary effect of what they do.


So again I ask why do they need to combat piracy?
 
Zarathustra[H];1039850289 said:
I agree, but remember there are different types of pirates.

There are still those who just don't want to pay for something and instead download it.

These seem to mostly be teenagers and college students without a real steady income though.

As far as everyone else goes, if you can give them an easy and convenient distribution model at a reasonable price, like what Netflix provides, they will have less reason to pirate stuff.

This comic over at The Oatmeal does a good job of demonstrating this.

<SNIP>

Funny as hell. That's like a replay of my Sunday evenings....
 
Wow. You'd have to watch more than 5 new movies every month to make that worth it.

Feel like that's a lot.

Actually, given that a ticket is about $8 here if you forget the popcorn and coke, I would need to watch about 12 shows to "break even". So 3 a week, maybe I would, maybe I wouldn't, but at least when I did sit down to watch I would be watching what I want, when I want, and I could just enjoy it without any real hassles. That would be better then anything out there today that isn't much more expensive or potential risk of financial ruin.

I think it will happen, just not sure when.
 
Actually, given that a ticket is about $8 here if you forget the popcorn and coke, I would need to watch about 12 shows to "break even". So 3 a week, maybe I would, maybe I wouldn't, but at least when I did sit down to watch I would be watching what I want, when I want, and I could just enjoy it without any real hassles. That would be better then anything out there today that isn't much more expensive or potential risk of financial ruin.

I think it will happen, just not sure when.
I'm talking DVD/Blu Ray prices. Not theater
 
What? Ease of access to content leads to less piracy? Noooo, this would mean it is all the piraters fault!
 
I found this article from a few years back that explains the industry pretty well (I think, I am not an industry expert)...

Dandirk, the article is informative but it's not really addressing this issue. In effect, NetFlix, Hulu, etc are still paying the fees. The article was addressing Hulu's initial free content model for much of their content and it was proven to them by the content providers to be a bad move. Their change was a business decision. But that's not what some of us are talking about. We are talking about everyone still getting their slice of the pie, customers paying for content and being happier with the service provided, and the only real down side is the delivery methods would change, theaters would probably be hit hard but I think the only reason theaters exist at all is for high schoolers and younger to get out from under their parent's nose for awhile and for dates to have a safe meeting venue and maybe so mom and dad and get a break from the kids as well...... damn....... I should take my wife out, it's been too long :D
 
We are thinking of switching to Netflix as we have Cable and it keeps going out when anything we want to watch is showing. I am positive that its easier to find a torrent or other method of a show, than to watch a cable feed that isn't working. But I still want to watch some sports!
 
The question is, how do they intend to compete when they just refuse to support instant streaming like Netflix, but you can torrent a show or movie in minutes?

It's more convenient to torrent ANYTHING rather than waiting for it to air and trying to get it with your DVR box.

The studio's NEED to get together with Netflix and get some decent quality and especially 5.1 AUDIO on everything for crying out loud. Stereo? We have 7.1 available in the living room and watching 90% of the stuff in stereo is insulting.
 
I'll say from my personal experience, Netflix cut my piracy by half almost overnight, and it's been declining steadily ever since.

It's partially from a moral standpoint that it really is wrong to just take the content, but it's now finally possible to find pretty much everything from a legitimate source. Sure, there are still some obscure shows from the 80s and early 90s that can't be found anywhere, but pretty much everything being made today has a way that you can watch it legally within a reasonable time frame.
 
No, they just need to buy netflix and make it their own content distributor.

Man, I was paying like over $100 a month for DirectTV and it sucked so bad I cut it off. I have no services beyond cable-internet and my netflix account.

How much would I pay for first run movies at release via NetFlix without commercial content? $100 a month easy as long as the content is really there and the new movies play on release date.

$100 a month would be well worth it. A family of four would optimally spend at least 1.5x as much just to see ONE movie at the theater.


Wow. You'd have to watch more than 5 new movies every month to make that worth it.

Feel like that's a lot.

I would beat Reed Hastings with my wallet to make it happen.
 
Dandirk, the article is informative but it's not really addressing this issue. In effect, NetFlix, Hulu, etc are still paying the fees. The article was addressing Hulu's initial free content model for much of their content and it was proven to them by the content providers to be a bad move. Their change was a business decision. But that's not what some of us are talking about. We are talking about everyone still getting their slice of the pie, customers paying for content and being happier with the service provided, and the only real down side is the delivery methods would change, theaters would probably be hit hard but I think the only reason theaters exist at all is for high schoolers and younger to get out from under their parent's nose for awhile and for dates to have a safe meeting venue and maybe so mom and dad and get a break from the kids as well...... damn....... I should take my wife out, it's been too long :D

The link was merely informational... a reason why companies are not signing whole sale to netflix/hulu...

The current model pays big money in fat yearly checks... reducing those checks significantly by signing up to Netflix just like the Hulu example is not enticing to the content providers...

The Oparah example was also telling... amazing a single show can split off and create a whole new channel...

That article also alluded to the price we would probably pay per channel ($0.25-2). Which I think is very relevant to manage expectations cause the content providers aren't going to take a loss when replacing an income model. Also remember most these channels also have commercials so the price would be more on a netflix model.

I am with some here, that would gladly play cable/sat prices + more for more content on netflix. Though I think they are asking a bit much for new release movies for that price. Heck I would pay $80 a month for 1-2 year old content (lets say 90% that is available)... just for the commercial free/on-demand/mobile aspect. That is tons of value right there.
 
I will also add there is a HUGE chance that a la carte and Netflix models could seriously hurt the differsity of programming.

The benefit of bundling tons of channels is it allows content providers to offer successful and non-successful content that might fill the needs of niche.

Now this could continue with the Netflix model but more likely the less popular would die to falling revenue and more crappy "popular" reality shows would completely take over.

Then again this is already happening with the current model:)
 
I will also add there is a HUGE chance that a la carte and Netflix models could seriously hurt the differsity of programming.

The benefit of bundling tons of channels is it allows content providers to offer successful and non-successful content that might fill the needs of niche.

Now this could continue with the Netflix model but more likely the less popular would die to falling revenue and more crappy "popular" reality shows would completely take over.

Then again this is already happening with the current model:)

Depends how innovative they get ... if they expand their pricing models you could introduce low priced subscriptions to stream a specific show (3-10 dollar range) ... and maybe apply the streaming fee to ownership for people that want to download the shows from iTunes or Amazon ;)
 
I stopped once Redbox came around and started giving me free rental codes. :D
 
Back
Top