Net Neutrality Fight Far From Over

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Can someone tell me why this has to be explained? Honestly, I don't think anyone considers the net neutrality fight "over."

Unfortunately, the only thing that Federal Communications Commission and congressional officials, along with representatives from industry and public interest groups, could agree on was that the fight over the FCC's controversial new "open Internet" regulations is far from over.
 
Reading into the article, it appearss Google (and possibly Verizon) are content with the FCC's latest draft.
 
With the hyper partisan B.S. currently underway I don't see net neutrality making any headway. Add in that most congress-critters are ignorant on tech issues and you just have a mess in the making.
 
With the hyper partisan B.S. currently underway I don't see net neutrality making any headway.

It's quite simple actually. It's not about what net neutrality will do for the net, it's what net neutrality does to businesses. Having talked with others and being completely shocked they'd be against this, I finally figured out they simply have their mind set that A) this is the government regulating a particular infrastructure and B) this is the government telling a company how to operate. And there are quite a few people out there that simply dislike the government saying what anyone can do... unless its something they agree with, like being a pro-lifer then it's ok for the government to say what you can't do :D
 
It's quite simple actually. It's not about what net neutrality will do for the net, it's what net neutrality does to businesses. Having talked with others and being completely shocked they'd be against this, I finally figured out they simply have their mind set that A) this is the government regulating a particular infrastructure and B) this is the government telling a company how to operate. And there are quite a few people out there that simply dislike the government saying what anyone can do... unless its something they agree with, like being a pro-lifer then it's ok for the government to say what you can't do :D

I prefer to put it that businesses want to be able to piss on you call it rain. Then sell the run-off to your local grocery store as "orange juice". If private citizens have a code of conduct to follow why wouldn't businesses?
 
All I have to say is either said of the debate wins, we still loose in the long run. People really don't seem to understand that the net neutrality bills still give power over web content into the hands of the Gov't. Still better then carrier exclusive content and throttling, but it will come back to bite us all one of these days just like the Department of Commerce controlling domain names popping up out of no where end of last year to bite some sites in the ass. I hope that the p2p domain project works out, I wasn't a huge fan of web 2.0, this is the dawn of web 3.0 and we are still struggling to see who will control it.
 
Which begs the question, what has deregulation done for you lately?

How did the deregulation of the banking industry - specifically housing and mortgages- help you out in 2007? Tell me how the deregulation of cable has made your services cheaper, more efficient, and increased your local options over the past 15 years? Hey guys on the gulf coast- how's that oil drilling industry deregulation working out for your beaches?

It's a stigma word. Like "Red" used to be. Oh no, the government wants to take steps to protect us from organizations that are just after a quick buck at our expense.

Net Neutrality is about a large number of different issues that aren't entirely all related, and a lot of people who do more passionate speeches than actual thinking use the defense of one aspect to attack another- and companies like Google and Verizon are smart enough to lobby with the skill and subtlety to get what they want without anybody else really noticing.

My biggest concern? The internet has removed one of the biggest barriers to entry for musicians. Even 10 years ago, if you were a moderately talented musician, to get your music out you have to buy into the system and essentially sign a slave-labor contract with a publisher. Go look around on google for some of those contracts. They are absolutely disgusting. Today you can go online and go viral if you're good enough. There is a very real concern- especially given how the RIAA is trying to play gatekeeper- that the rules that were just approved will essentially technically block those artists out, and required them to- once again- go back to big publishers to try to get their work out.

My biggest personal worry? My cable provider (they're the only game in town) getting into a temper tantrum because I watch the daily show on thedailyshow.com instead of paying them an additional $60 a month.

So let me instead introduce an awesome idea: separate content DELIVERY from content PRODUCTION. Give us a nice fat wireless pipe with low latency, but don't at all get involved with the route of transmission. I would be perfectly okay with respectable quality of service limiting to ease congestion if I could be assured that it was the type of content being streamlined of limited (voice communication versus video buffering versus World of Warcraft updating itself via bittorrent). Give me gas, let me choose my own car and my own route to and from where I want to go.

And while you're at it, update the laws regarding the transmission of data and communication to at least take into consideration modern technologies. Chances of this happening? All I have to say is "The internet is a collection of tubes".

Wishful thinking? Probably.
 
Which begs the question, what has deregulation done for you lately?
.......
Wishful thinking? Probably.

We're actually moving close to this in Maine. We have a company called Maine Fiber Co. That is wiring the state with a nice fiber backbone. They will sell bandwidth to anyone that wants it, and they don't do anything but provide the connection. They are a state sponsored, but private company.
 
Back
Top