Net Neutrality Explained on Video

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you thought that infographic we posted a while back on net neutrality did a good job explaining things, you'll love this video. I can think of a handful of people I need to send this link too already.
 
Too bad the people who don't know enough (yet have an opinion) probably wouldn't spend the time to watch this.
 
Too bad the people who don't know enough (yet have an opinion) probably wouldn't spend the time to watch this.

Too bad the people who don't know enough, yet take the opinions of the highest bidder, will be the ones to vote about this.
 
Great video, except for the last part which argues against laws protecting net neutrality. Their example was that laws would not let the companies protect against spam. This is not true. Legislation should be put in place to protect a non-prejudiced internet, while complying with laws that already exist. Spam is illegal, and blocking illegal content would not violate net neutrality.

1) All IP-based traffic should be treated equally, as long as said traffic complies with US law
2) Network providers should not be allowed to modify data on their network
3) Network providers cannot block connections to any IP, as long as the connection complies with US law

I would like them to take it a step further and put in full protection for network providers from content on their network. So if someone is transferring child porn, the ISP could not be held responsible. Instead, the government should go after the server hosting the content. There are things similar to this already, but this needs to be much better.

I think those things above should be done by Congress, and not the FCC. This should be an amendment to the US Constitution. There cannot be free speech without a free internet in the 21st century. Unfortunately Republicans incorrectly think net neutrality means regulating the internet, and the Democrats can't pass anything meaningful. Both are in the pockets of the ISPs and it doesn't look good for us.
 
Im sorry i guess im confused here, i guess the part i dont get is, isnt that why we pay for internet?
 
crashbox: it gets even more confusing if you know that all of the connections are either paid or negotiated to be settlement free. No network makes a habit out of routing packets from networks that they don't have an agreement with.

Overall, a pretty decent video, although I don't think there ever has been a "free flow" of packets. For one thing, agreements must be in place to get people to route your traffic, and often (but not in the case of settlement free interconnections), that involves a flow of money. For another, all of these connections have a bandwidth limit. Maybe there's a free flow on the Internet2 for .edu, but I thought the dorms were filling that up with torrent traffic too.
 
I think the biggest problem with this is that it really is a lose-lose situation. All the "tier 1" providers have been playing nice (to a degree) and everything has been good, if they decide to change they can, period. The other lose part is that people who don't want that need politicians to make laws that say they can't and that in itself opens up a whole new can of worms, there are more Mr Tubes people out there running our country, and you know they'll find a way to fuck things up even more so.

My problem was with netflix example at the end, netflix pays for its bandwidth to whatever Tier 1 it buys from, they themselves are not a Tier1 (AFAIK), so no bandwidth goes through them from other providers, they're all about outflowing of traffic, ditto with the WoW example.
 
Just as you have seen recently. If Comcast talks about limited bandwidth or MB transfered, people will vote with their feet and move to WorldNet, or Verizon, or what else is available to their area. We have tried a poor version of deregulation under Clinton where the Government (men with guns) forced Telco's to give free service to other companies and it squelched DSL expansion plans. We need to try a new kind of deregulation. Allow Verizon into AT&T, Bell South, etc areas, and vis versa, may the best provider win.

If provider A has new rules that hurt users, they will move service to provider B, or C. This is how the Cellphone market works. I had AT&T, but its service was poor and had no international service. I moved to T-Mobile which had GREAT international and good service where I live. Smart phones come out, I move to AT&T again, and now I've moved to Verizon. You should be able to change TV service, and Internet service just as easily.

The idea of net neutrality as it is practiced no honest person has a problem with, but the way government force limits users access to data, and forces Tier 1 and Tier 2 slowdowns is not proper or efficient. Every time I see someone advocate the Government (men with guns) forcing a private company to do or not to do, it gives me the willies.
 
Everyone is totalling missing the root problem. Providers need to add new capacity once in a while. More fiber, more/better routers, replace old slow transceivers with new faster ones. Focus needs to be on maximizing current infrastructure and steadily adding new infrastructure.
 
Just as you have seen recently. If Comcast talks about limited bandwidth or MB transfered, people will vote with their feet and move to WorldNet, or Verizon, or what else is available to their area. We have tried a poor version of deregulation under Clinton where the Government (men with guns) forced Telco's to give free service to other companies and it squelched DSL expansion plans. We need to try a new kind of deregulation. Allow Verizon into AT&T, Bell South, etc areas, and vis versa, may the best provider win.

If provider A has new rules that hurt users, they will move service to provider B, or C. This is how the Cellphone market works. I had AT&T, but its service was poor and had no international service. I moved to T-Mobile which had GREAT international and good service where I live. Smart phones come out, I move to AT&T again, and now I've moved to Verizon. You should be able to change TV service, and Internet service just as easily.

The idea of net neutrality as it is practiced no honest person has a problem with, but the way government force limits users access to data, and forces Tier 1 and Tier 2 slowdowns is not proper or efficient. Every time I see someone advocate the Government (men with guns) forcing a private company to do or not to do, it gives me the willies.

Yes, yes, and yes. Actual open market competition can fix the vast majority of the crappy situations we're in.
 
This video reinforces plenty of incorrect and uneducated rhetoric i have seen on this "net neutrality" bullshit.

First, I want to say I am in favor of a non tiered internet.

The reason there is no tiering yet is because of the free market, and regulation will actually waste taxt payer dollars and add more fucking beurocracy to a bloated government in the USA and I'm sure elsewhere too. Considering how many fucking telcos there are out there if any one of them were to implement this kind of shit they know they would have backlashes all over the fucking place. THEY READ THE INTERNET TOO. That's what's keeping them from doing this, because we don't want it.

Fact of the matter is, the internet was not originally made for public consumption, it was made as a military communications network out of (if i remember properly) berkley. Companies just saw this great thing and tried making money off it, and it exploded, and that's why we have the internet in the first place, a free market.

Now some people might say "well what if they all do this". Well, that's called a monopoly, or a variety of other terms. And if all the providers do this kind of collaborative shit, you can get them in absolutely massive trouble. It's happened before in plenty of industries, and there are ways to deal with it. Net Neutrality regulation is NOT the best way to deal with it.

If you havn't been paying attention, telcos have rolled out tonnes and tonnes of infrastructure constantly to increase the bandwidth they can provide to their customers. While there are a lot of people in the USA still using dial-up, there are a LOT less than 10 years ago.

Companies strictly exist to make money, FROM YOU. If you don't like what they provide and take that money away, that concerns them. If they can't make money from you, then they're doing something wrong. And they need to either adapt, or die.

Get over this uninformed bullshit, regulated markets are actually what lead to a lack of competition. If you want to learn more about economic study I HIGHLY recommend you start by watching Milton Friedman's PBS Special: Free to Choose: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=2024617864923164175#
 
Great video, except for the last part which argues against laws protecting net neutrality. Their example was that laws would not let the companies protect against spam. This is not true. Legislation should be put in place to protect a non-prejudiced internet, while complying with laws that already exist. Spam is illegal, and blocking illegal content would not violate net neutrality.

1) All IP-based traffic should be treated equally, as long as said traffic complies with US law
2) Network providers should not be allowed to modify data on their network
3) Network providers cannot block connections to any IP, as long as the connection complies with US law

I would like them to take it a step further and put in full protection for network providers from content on their network. So if someone is transferring child porn, the ISP could not be held responsible. Instead, the government should go after the server hosting the content. There are things similar to this already, but this needs to be much better.

I think those things above should be done by Congress, and not the FCC. This should be an amendment to the US Constitution. There cannot be free speech without a free internet in the 21st century. Unfortunately Republicans incorrectly think net neutrality means regulating the internet, and the Democrats can't pass anything meaningful. Both are in the pockets of the ISPs and it doesn't look good for us.

Unfortunately, what constitutes SPAM by law is a moving target.
This is one of the basic issues when dealing with laws and technology that mutates at such a rapid pace.
In an effort to be comprehensive, many laws try too hard to be specific.
This generally makes finding loopholes in those laws easier.
Whether you're talking about SPAM, or quality of service or any number of Internet-related issues, laws tend to be spectacularly bad solutions.

It doesn't help that, as has been alluded, the vast majority of lawmakers aren't technically savvy enough, or altrusitic enough to be trusted for objectivity.
 
Just as you have seen recently. If Comcast talks about limited bandwidth or MB transfered, people will vote with their feet and move to WorldNet, or Verizon, or what else is available to their area. We have tried a poor version of deregulation under Clinton where the Government (men with guns) forced Telco's to give free service to other companies and it squelched DSL expansion plans. We need to try a new kind of deregulation. Allow Verizon into AT&T, Bell South, etc areas, and vis versa, may the best provider win.

If provider A has new rules that hurt users, they will move service to provider B, or C. This is how the Cellphone market works. I had AT&T, but its service was poor and had no international service. I moved to T-Mobile which had GREAT international and good service where I live. Smart phones come out, I move to AT&T again, and now I've moved to Verizon. You should be able to change TV service, and Internet service just as easily.

The idea of net neutrality as it is practiced no honest person has a problem with, but the way government force limits users access to data, and forces Tier 1 and Tier 2 slowdowns is not proper or efficient. Every time I see someone advocate the Government (men with guns) forcing a private company to do or not to do, it gives me the willies.

Yes, yes, and yes. Actual open market competition can fix the vast majority of the crappy situations we're in.

I don't disagree with you, but you've left out a major part of the picture.

In many areas of the country, there is no competing provider.
In too many parts of the country, high-speed internet isn't even available.

There's no easy fix for this, since our country's size and the low population density in many regions makes it highly unprofitable for providers to service the area.

Laws mandating the provision of access are equally dangerous, since that goes against every tenet of the free market system.

Having that, one of the things that irritates me is this perception that everyone has to have high-speed internet or they will die!!
This is the mentality that is so easily exploited to add to an already bloated bureaucracy at every level of government.

While there are certainly a lot of things that are easier with a high-speed connection, the lack of it does not render life impossible.
Like so many other items beyond food, clothing and shelter, there might just be some things in life that you can't have until you can afford it.
 
spammers should pay a fee to send their crap, like the junk mail i get everyday from the post office.
 
How about service providers just letting their customer know if they are blocking/slowing down certain traffic, and letting the people decide who to buy from? I mean, it's almost like an additional service to have to filter through and slow down certain things, kinda like spam filtering. If it costs money to be prejudice, wouldn't they charge more, then lose customers?

How about just passing a law stating they are required to disclose exactly what they do with the traffic?
 
Great video, except for the last part which argues against laws protecting net neutrality. Their example was that laws would not let the companies protect against spam. This is not true. Legislation should be put in place to protect a non-prejudiced internet, while complying with laws that already exist. Spam is illegal, and blocking illegal content would not violate net neutrality.

1) All IP-based traffic should be treated equally, as long as said traffic complies with US law
2) Network providers should not be allowed to modify data on their network
3) Network providers cannot block connections to any IP, as long as the connection complies with US law

I would like them to take it a step further and put in full protection for network providers from content on their network. So if someone is transferring child porn, the ISP could not be held responsible. Instead, the government should go after the server hosting the content. There are things similar to this already, but this needs to be much better.

I think those things above should be done by Congress, and not the FCC. This should be an amendment to the US Constitution. There cannot be free speech without a free internet in the 21st century. Unfortunately Republicans incorrectly think net neutrality means regulating the internet, and the Democrats can't pass anything meaningful. Both are in the pockets of the ISPs and it doesn't look good for us.

I agree with you, with one caveat: "complies with US law"

I think if you try and apply US law to worldwide content you might open up a can of worms. Would you have the government mandate providers to filter content to accomplish this? Isn't that what China was (is?) doing that kicked up such a stink?
 
If you thought that infographic we posted a while back on net neutrality did a good job explaining things, you'll love this video. I can think of a handful of people I need to send this link too already.

There's some truth in that video. There's also a lot of misleading information. It's true that a company that sells cable/video has a vested interest in raising the cost for netflix to stream video.

It's complete and utter bullshit that they're going to slow down skype, which uses very little bandwidth.

What's more, he will raise my cost (and probably yours too), because pay/MB costs more than all you can eat.

More than anything, what I object to is that what he and most other NN zealouts (as opposed to those who want the FCC to nail the ISPs whenever they try to overstep), is that they'd argue that the best way for the internet to work is to putt a 4 way stop sign at every router. I don't know about you guys, but a busy 4 way stop sign is way WAY worse than a stop light. Stop lights are managed pipes, while 4 way stops are inefficient slow and aggravating.

Managing torrent traffic makes sense (though not the way that comcast did it a few years ago). If it takes a little longer to downloader a Linux Distro, then so be it. Better to slow it down than to have an important phone call break up or video go to hell.

If ISP1 sends about as much data to ISP2 as ISP2 sends to ISP1, then they pay nothing. If not, then ISP2 may ask for money from ISP1.

AFAIK, that is actually how it works to this day.

I don't trust the ISPs as far as I can spit, but the most vocal NN speakers/writers are almost as bad. Both are guilty of lies and/or lies by omission.
 
It's complete and utter bullshit that they're going to slow down skype, which uses very little bandwidth.

Bandwidth isn't the issue really. You said it yourself. It's competition, and the providers DON'T want that. That's the reason they would tamper with something like Skype. Bandwidth if we aren't talking about torrents really is quite plentiful for most types of internet activity.

Take a look at Vonage. Before Verizon pulled it's head out it's butt they were doing all sorts of things to Vonage even though as you say bandwidth for a simple audio stream of phone quality is ridiculously low. Net Neutrality (aside from torrents) is about free access to bandwidth so that all players, you , me , small businesses all have equal access to bandwidth, it isn't about preventing some world catastrophe of bandwidth. Most developed countries have been enjoying 4G LTE and land line bandwidth much higher than we currently experience for at least a year or two. Companies go after NN to limit competition. Nothing more nothing less.
 
Managing torrent traffic makes sense (though not the way that comcast did it a few years ago). If it takes a little longer to downloader a Linux Distro, then so be it. Better to slow it down than to have an important phone call break up or video go to hell.
Actually fuck that "important phone call" if I'm paying for a 10Mbps service, I better get 10Mbps from everything on my providers side of things, now if the other side is bottle necked then whatever. But I don't want *MY* provider slowing down Netflix, InstaPorn, a"linux distro" or anything else because it needs to conserve bandwidth.
 
Bandwidth isn't the issue really. You said it yourself. It's competition, and the providers DON'T want that. That's the reason they would tamper with something like Skype. Bandwidth if we aren't talking about torrents really is quite plentiful for most types of internet activity.

Take a look at Vonage. Before Verizon pulled it's head out it's butt they were doing all sorts of things to Vonage even though as you say bandwidth for a simple audio stream of phone quality is ridiculously low. Net Neutrality (aside from torrents) is about free access to bandwidth so that all players, you , me , small businesses all have equal access to bandwidth, it isn't about preventing some world catastrophe of bandwidth. Most developed countries have been enjoying 4G LTE and land line bandwidth much higher than we currently experience for at least a year or two. Companies go after NN to limit competition. Nothing more nothing less.

Dude, the NN crowd is against managing traffic in anyway shape or form. If they managed streets, we'd only have 4 way stop signs. If you were dying and the ambulance was rushing you to the hospital, you could not jump in front of anyone, because your life isn't worth any more than the guy who's going to get a pack of smokes.

I'm with you in theory, but every time I read something by the NN groups, they are hard core against network management, and sorry, but that's fucking dumb. And the reality is that when we get 4G, the pipe will become saturated.

If VZ was fucking with Vonage, then the FCC should have come down on them hard. But if VZ wants to say that IP telephony is a bit more important than downloading a file, then I'm OK with that, and I do not have any IP Telephone service. It's not going to be noticeable to me or anyone else.
 
Actually fuck that "important phone call" if I'm paying for a 10Mbps service, I better get 10Mbps from everything on my providers side of things, now if the other side is bottle necked then whatever. But I don't want *MY* provider slowing down Netflix, InstaPorn, a"linux distro" or anything else because it needs to conserve bandwidth.

Then you should get a commercial account that guarantees 10Mbps service. If you have a consumer account, you're not guaranteed shit. But then your 10Mbps consumer service probably costs 1/10 (or less) of what a t1 costs, with it's girlie 1.5Mbps connection.

Better yet, get a T3....or a few T3s.

With that said, ISPs should be required to state a minimum and average level of service, not just the max. up to 10Mbps....great how often is that? Is it all the time, only after midnight?

I hold no love for ISPs, I can promise you you're being overcharged for your 10Mbps connection (unless it's around $30/month), but just because they're assholes doesn't mean I think that railing against network management is good.
 
Then you should get a commercial account that guarantees 10Mbps service. If you have a consumer account, you're not guaranteed shit. But then your 10Mbps consumer service probably costs 1/10 (or less) of what a t1 costs, with it's girlie 1.5Mbps connection.
I'm not talking about guaranteed speeds vs throttled speeds, I mean me trying to download a netflix movie (or whatever) and getting throttled on that, conveniently proven by the fact that if I use something on their service at the same time it zips through at an unthrottled speed. Total bandwidth available should be amount of bandwidth to use on ANYTHING, not just my ISPs preferred service.

I hold no love for ISPs, I can promise you you're being overcharged for your 10Mbps connection (unless it's around $30/month), but just because they're assholes doesn't mean I think that railing against network management is good.

I know i'm being over charged, I wish I had 10Mbps, it's actually less than 3Mbps, and it is for $30/month.
 
I agree with you, with one caveat: "complies with US law"

I think if you try and apply US law to worldwide content you might open up a can of worms. Would you have the government mandate providers to filter content to accomplish this? Isn't that what China was (is?) doing that kicked up such a stink?

Sorry, my post was only referring to the US. Each country would obviously need to have their own net neutrality laws in place. This is just something that we can put into place here (sorry for not stating that).
 
Im sorry i guess im confused here, i guess the part i dont get is, isnt that why we pay for internet?
This video was about the best explanation I've seen for net neutrality, except for its omission of this one fact. Comcast/Verizon/Cox/TimeWarner/etc are already paid by their customers for internet access. This crucial fact is somehow ignored in all the discussions regarding traffic passing through the ISP's network. They want to be paid for the extra traffic....except that the customer is already paying for it..
 
I don't disagree with you, but you've left out a major part of the picture.

In many areas of the country, there is no competing provider.
In too many parts of the country, high-speed internet isn't even available.

There's no easy fix for this, since our country's size and the low population density in many regions makes it highly unprofitable for providers to service the area.

Laws mandating the provision of access are equally dangerous, since that goes against every tenet of the free market system.

Disagree. Areas with limited highspeed connections (like my relatives home in northern Arkansas) still have options, and that is where wireless comes in. You can get a wireless 3g or 4g router that gives you broadband that way ( I set it up and it works fine, not as fast as my connection with FIOS, but good enough), and in their area they have a microwave provider. If you live way out, you will always have limited options, and most people who live there, like it because of the isolation. People who don't like that will move to where they are comfortable. People in this country are mobile, and it is very common for people to move to where they want to live, or where work is, or where something else they want is. Personally, I know several people who live in the area they are, because of FIOS.

Also I agree it's not needed to live, but to live better it is. You can buy more for less, and get more information on high dollar purchases with it.
 
Why is there concern about Tier 1 providers becoming non-neutral (which they might already be because no one gets to see the deals they are making) when the lower tiers are already non-neutral? Being non-neutral (that is not being transit free) is, besides size which is an ambiguous classification, one of the defining characteristics of being a non-tier 1 provider isn't it?
 
I'm not talking about guaranteed speeds vs throttled speeds, I mean me trying to download a netflix movie (or whatever) and getting throttled on that, conveniently proven by the fact that if I use something on their service at the same time it zips through at an unthrottled speed. Total bandwidth available should be amount of bandwidth to use on ANYTHING, not just my ISPs preferred service.



I know i'm being over charged, I wish I had 10Mbps, it's actually less than 3Mbps, and it is for $30/month.

Throttling you because you're not using their video service is worth fighting over. Throttling a download, because dropping the rate by 100Kb allows a couple of phone calls to work that otherwise would not. These networks are not designed for people to saturate their slice of the pipe all the time.

If everyone used their phone all the time, you'd quickly find that you'd be without service. In the land line days, you'd get a fast busy (which was pretty common anytime there was an emergency or tickets for a major event went on sale.

If you'd prefer, however, the NN folk are perfectly happy for your prices to double or triple, so long as we stand on the principle that an Ambulance doesn't deserve to jump ahead of other traffic.

All that said, if you want good service, get municipal FTTH in your area. That $30.00 for is roughly what it costs to get a symmetric 10Mbps connection in Lafayette LA. And they built the network in roughly 2 - 2.5 years.
 
Back
Top