Need specific advice on memory, mobo for an i7

JCDenton

Gawd
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
701
I just have a few questions that are pretty narrow but I'm hoping someone can answer:

1. Motherboard - I'm trying to decide between the Asus P6T and P6T deluxe. I'm kind of on a tight budget but I'd pay the extra $65 if it was really worth it. This is mainly a gaming system, and the primary things I care about are flexible GPU options and being able to tolerate a moderate overclock for a couple of years without the board dying. If overclocking/reliability will be pretty similar, I'll go with the cheaper one since I don't think I need the deluxe features.

I was also thinking about this Gigabyte but I don't know a lot about it.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128374

The price is right and the old gigabyte board i got when core 2 duo launched served me pretty well.


2. Memory - what speed should I expect it to run at? is the DDR3 2000 useless because nobody runs it that high? I need to know the fastest memory speed that would actually be practical to use. The reason for this is that with the mods I run, Oblivion is actually memory bottlenecked. At the bottlenecked parts, I had a 1:1 speed increase when I upgraded my DDR2 from 800 to 1066, but they still run crappy. I'd pay extra for the RAM to smooth this out because I play oblivion a lot, but again, I'm on a tight budget so I don't want to buy something faster than I can actually use.

3. Cooling - are the brackets the same from 775 to the new socket? Can I just pop my Arctic freezer 7 pro onto the new mobo?
 
1) OC'ing should be better on the deluxe with the 16+2 phase power (non-deluxe has 8+2), but how high do you plan on OC'ing? The Gigabyte would be between the deluxe and the non-deluxe with its 12+2 phase power.

2) Again, how high do you plan on OC'ing? DDR3-1600 would be good enough for a 4Ghz OC on the i7.920, but 1333 can still get you to 3.8Ghz.

3) Nope, sorry. You'll also need a much better cooler than the AC F7Pro for an i7. ;) The crowd faves are the TRUE120 1366, Noctua NH-U12P SE1366, and Cooler Master V8.
 
Thanks friend. I've been looking into this for a few hours and I've ruled out the P6T deluxe since it doesn't support triple SLI, is $60+ more, and the other boards apparently hold their own against it OC-wise.

Seriously clueless about the standard P6T vs the gigabyte EX58-UD4P though. I did notice the difference in power phasing but I'm not educated enough to judge the importance. Another key difference I found is that the P6T has dual holes so you can mount either a 775 or a 1366 cooler. Maybe I'm just overthinking it and these are just two very similar boards, but I'm edgy because of the HELL my msi boards have put me through over the last year and I want to pick a winner.

I was hoping to get into the 3.6-3.8 range for now, then when I have some more money to blow later, upgrade from the stock cooler or my AF7 and test the limits of the proc. So I'd like to have a bit of leeway on the mem.

The people at Fry's spent a long time digging around to find me a 920 from one of the best batches so I'm hoping I have a good overclocker at low volts.
 
No real need for Tri-SLI, so don't hold that against it.

I don't think you can go wrong with either the Gigabyte or Asus. I do not, however, think your AC F7Pro is up to the task of cooling the i7, despite the mounting holes on the Asus (apparently they copied that feature from foxconn... nifty feature nonetheless). However, I welcome you to prove me wrong. :D (which would make you choose the asus, lol)

Fry's? is it on sale for $230 again? it is! nice! oh, not a bad price on the UD4P either.
 
I think I may go with the asus. I found a newegg code posted in another thread that knocks $15 off the price (EMCLNLP44) so now it would be $220 and no rebate to deal with, vs. 260 with a $20 mir. The one thing that has me still wanting the gigabyte is this info about the copper/durable tech but I'm not sure if it's just marketing BS or if it would help the board last:

http://www.techspot.com/review/136-gigabyte-ex58-ud4p/page3.html

And yeah, fry's had them for $229 but today was the last day. I RAN down there when I discovered it. They were also including a $10 gas card, making it effectively $219+tax. Not bad considering I got one from the 3841A batch.
 
The extra bit of copper helps a little so it's not totally marketing BS. I mean the current Gigabyte P45 UD series are overclocking way better than the older Gigabyte non-UD series P45 motherboard. Then again that could also be due to the heatpipe cooling the UD P45 now have...
 
Back
Top