Need Recommendations: Core i7 Build for $1200

ROCKETR

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
820
A friend is wanting me to build him a new computer for $1200. He would really like to get an i7 CPU to somewhat "future-proof" his system. He is ready to buy the hardware as soon as possible. I honestly have not been keeping up entirely in the know on what parts are best so that's why I came to you guys for help. :)

1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming, Photoshop, Web-browsing, Office work, General-use
2) What's your budget? $1200 with a little bit of breathing room for shipping, etc
3) Where do you live? Florida, USA
4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, Motherboard, Graphics Card, Optical Drive, Hard Drive (he can get by with 1TB he tells me), RAM, PSU, Case(essentially everything besides a monitor, mouse, and keyboard)
5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? None internally
6) Will you be overclocking? Possibly but not planning on it right away
7) What size monitor do you have and/or plan to have? 19" right now
8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC? As soon as possible
9) What features do you need in a motherboard? eSATA and Firewire would be nice. No plan to SLi or Crossfire for now
10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? Windows 7 RC

He gave me this link to look at, http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4689367&Sku=B69-1075. I'm not all that crazy about the power supply or hard drive in that kit. Also on the motherboard, TigerDirect doesn't specify what version of the P6T it is.

One last thing. My friend would like to buy from a place that allows him to be tax exempt (he's building this for his non-profit organization job and he has a tax exempt number). He already has an account at TigerDirect, but I always preferred buying from NewEgg anyways.

Thanks for your time!
 
His non-profit org pays him to game?!? wow... nice gig. I don't think the egg charges tax to FL. ;)
 
His non-profit org pays him to game?!? wow... nice gig. I don't think the egg charges tax to FL. ;)

Haha, he's paying for this with his own money but he will be using it for his job mainly. However, it's a part-time job so he can game after work. :p

As for the taxes, I live here in Florida as well and I paid taxes the last time I bought off the 'egg. :(
 
Thats news to me. I just put in a Miami zip code and no tax was charged. :p Where did you have the parts delivered?
 
To Tallahassee, the capital of Florida. :p I just put in my zip code and there was tax charged. :(
 
I suggest you move to miami. lol, j/k. Thats weird. oh wellz. Try Amazon for most of the parts, as well as directron, zipzoomfly, and provantage.
 
-Recommendations-

Thanks for the recommendations, shiro! I definitely like that motherboard as I have an EVGA board myself. That case is a stellar pick. I have never seen that one before.

I suggest you move to miami. lol, j/k. Thats weird. oh wellz. Try Amazon for most of the parts, as well as directron, zipzoomfly, and provantage.

Haha, I would if I could, my good sir. Thanks for the heads-up on the other sites. I'll take a look before we finalize the purchase. Still working on some part ideas.
 
Holy Cow! Nice Case.. I love it.. I'm so buying it :D

I watched the video and pretty much has everything I want/need.

Great thread BTW... I'm exactly looking at the same budget.

Grabbing popcorn ...
 
Last edited:
Alright so here's what I came up with. How does all of this look?

CPU: Intel Core i7 920 - $279

Motherboard: EVGA X58 SLi LE - $214 (AMR)

RAM: OCZ Gold 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) - $89 (AMR)

GPU: EVGA GeForce GTX 260 Core 216 Superclocked Edition 896MB - $159 (AMR)

Case: COOLER MASTER Storm Scout - $99

HDD: Western Digital Caviar Black WD1001FALS 1TB 7200 RPM - $99

PSU: CORSAIR CMPSU-750TX 750W - $99 (AMR)

DVD: SAMSUNG Black 22X DVD Burner Black SATA Model SH-S223B - OEM - $27

Subtotal: $1,150.92
(After Mail-In Rebates): $1070.92

My friend is a bit of an nVidia fanboy. Would anyone recommend a HD4890 or something over this GTX260 Core 216? It may take some 'splaining to do, but if the value for performance/price is better then I would rather go for that. :p

For the motherboard, I was reading that the ASUS P6T is great from the review that Kyle gave it. Would it be a better buy than this EVGA for about $30 more?

Also, I read rave reviews on the Seagate Barracuda 1.5TB yet I have seen many people on [H]ardForum say that there are problems with these drives. Would the WD Caviar be better in this case?

Lastly, I love modular PSU's and I was curious if it was worth the money to lose a bit of power yet gain the advantage of having modular cables with this Corsair HX620W.
 
MSI 4890 for $165AR http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=10010282&ps=homain2

But on a NINETEEN inch monitor!? Get a 4850.

If you want to show off the internals (and if you are that gold ram is pretty hideous) then get modular.

The 1.5TB is a purely storage HD. Have one and no problems.

What does the P6T offer over the EVGA that you need? Cuz' they're not that different.

He told me he plans on upgrading his monitor in the future so I wanted to get the best bang for the buck.

With that case, there isn't much you can see other than the red fans inside. :p

Other than a FireWire port on the back panel (which isn't that big of a deal since there's a FireWire header on the EVGA), I can't see anything that's different really on the ASUS. I had just read better reviews for it.
 
What does "in the future" mean? Like.. a year? 6 months? 1 month? Absolutely zero point in using an uber card if he's not going to be switching monitors soon.
 
Which monitor is your friend considering? With new video cards on the horizon, it's best to time the new (high-end) video card purchase for along the same time as the monitor purchase.

The 7200.11 1.5TB HDD was the one that started the whole "Seagate firmware issues" mess. Though the problem has been fixed, many people still avoid it like the plague. The 7200.12 generation doesn't have that problem, however; Western Digital (IIRC) also have a couple of 1.5TB HDDs to consider.

You better be reading those reviews from a hardware review site like us here or AnandTech. NewEgg (as well as other retailers) is a crapshoot at best because most of its reviewers can't make a detailed, accurate review to save their lives.
 
I believe he was looking at a 24" (possibly 22" but I think he would like a 24") monitor so 1920x1200/1080 resolution gaming.

Okay thanks for the heads-up. It doesn't look like they have a 1.5TB model out for the 7200.12 versions. Would anyone recommend the Seagate over the Western Digital or they're both pretty good? I've had hard drives from both companies for years, but again, I honestly haven't kept up with things as of late.

Oh trust me, I am. I find it extremely difficult to trust a review from a retailer. I only go to the trusted sources. ;) I probably spend too much time on researching products whenever I am down to buy something, lol.
 
I wouldn't suggest those larger drives for OS cause their are design for power saving.
 
I wouldn't suggest those larger drives for OS cause their are design for power saving.

I completely agree on not having larger drives for the OS, but I'm not sure I follow what you are talking about when you say "their are design for power saving".

If it were my build and a bit higher budget, I would get a small, fast drive for my boot drive and then install most of my other software on a secondary drive while having a third for storage. It's helped me out a lot in the past when dealing with large video files if you don't put all of the stress on one drive.
 
They spin slower and larger cache.

I'm no expert by any means, but I wouldn't say that's always the case though. From what I have read and seen, most of the latest TB drives are not too far behind the fastest hard drives (not talking SSDs here) on the market. I've heard that 1.5TB Seagate was close to the Velociraptor in some scores.

As far the new monitor goes, he said about two months after a couple paychecks he'll have more than enough. Also he would be planning on a 24" monitor. So is the GTX260 a good buy right now or can we do better?
 
I'd wait for the new GPUs. Pickup a spare card off CL or the FS/T forums for $20 and use it in the meantime.

I have been saying the same as I am holding out too, but he is a stubborn one and wants to go with a GTX260 it seems rather than wait.

Does the build that I posted a little bit back look good? I have since added the WD Caviar Black 640GB for OS and whatnot to go along with the 1TB. Any other comments or suggestions?
 
Well we built the computer last weekend. Here are some pictures.

DSC_0274.jpg


DSC_0266.jpg


Here are the final specifications of the computer.

CPU: Intel Core i7 920 - $279

Motherboard: EVGA X58 SLi LE - $214 (AMR)

RAM: OCZ Gold 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) - $89 (AMR)

GPU: EVGA GeForce GTX 260 Core 216 Superclocked Edition 896MB - $159 (AMR)

Case: COOLER MASTER Storm Scout - $99

HDD: Western Digital Caviar Black WD6401AALS 640GB 7200 RPM

HDD: Western Digital Caviar Black WD1001FALS 1TB 7200 RPM - $99

PSU: CORSAIR CMPSU-750TX 750W - $99 (AMR)

DVD: SAMSUNG Black 22X DVD Burner Black SATA Model SH-S223B - OEM - $27

We decided to go with the stock heatsink for now since he won't be doing any overclocking for the time being. Plus it is added cost. :p

Thanks for everyone who gave suggestions. We appreciate it. :) He's loving his new rockin' PC!
 
now if you did some cable management it would be perfect.

1. take out that bracket for usb and firewire onless he needs the firewire.

2. run the cpu power connector under the video card.

3. zip tie down the atx connector on those holes you see on side of motherboard.

4. draw up the extra front i/o cables and zip tie on back side of the case.
 
Last edited:
Haha, he's paying for this with his own money but he will be using it for his job mainly. However, it's a part-time job so he can game after work. :p

As for the taxes, I live here in Florida as well and I paid taxes the last time I bought off the 'egg. :(

I live in Florida (Boynton Beach) and the only time I have ever paid them taxes was when I had something directly shipped to CA.

I would contact their online chat and discuss this.

Have you lived in or shipped to either CA or NJ, I know they have bases in those two states therefore they need to charge tax when shipping to those two states, not sure about living in CA then shipping to a non Egg inhabited state.

Also, the Tiger link list seems very pedestrian, in that there doesn't seem to be any good deals, just average everywhere deals.

Edit.

I see he got some MIRs, that's better!. Glad he likes his PC.
 
now if you did some cable management it would be perfect.

1. take out that bracket for usb and firewire onless he needs the firewire.

2. run the cpu power connector under the video card.

3. zip tie down the atx connector on those holes you see on side of motherboard.

4. draw up the extra front i/o cables and zip tie on back side of the case.

1. Yep, he needs the Firewire so that's why we added it.

2. The power connector was too large to fit under the video card and the case is too cramped. :(

3. I'll try to look at it again, but if I recall we tried zip tying it to the side but the case door wouldn't get on because again the graphics card cramped up the case. :(

4. All of the front headers were used (besides the AC97 header) and we were only able to zip tie them to the side of the hard drive mounting bay.

Thanks for the tips though. They are much appreciated. Even though I have a good bit of experience building PCs, cable management is an art form that I have just started to work on. :p

I live in Florida (Boynton Beach) and the only time I have ever paid them taxes was when I had something directly shipped to CA.

Yeah, I sent enginurd a private message about this. They added it to my cart, but it wasn't charged when I went to pay for it so you guys are correct.
 
Yeah, I sent enginurd a private message about this. They added it to my cart, but it wasn't charged when I went to pay for it so you guys are correct.

Yeah must've been a glitch or something. The only states that get charged tax for Newegg purchases are NJ, TN and CA as Newegg has warehouses in those three states. That unless Newegg expanded to FL or something?:eek:
 
wd 640gb series ftwwwww

I live in Ft.Lauderdale (45 mins north of Miami)
Newegg doesn't tax me :eek:
Amazon doesn't tax me

Tiger taxes me :( (they mainly stink anyway, no offense to tiger fans)

I hope newegg never comes to Florida...they should come to Georgia for fast delivery - but not Florida, oh no no no.
 
...

I hope newegg never comes to Florida...they should come to Georgia for fast delivery - but not Florida, oh no no no.

They probably won't seeing as it takes about a day shipping for the packages to just get out of South Florida. Also their sorting/shipping center in TN would cover whatever we would cover.

I thought of something interesting though. NJ has no sales tax right? So at least their residents don't have to worry. The Egg should just shift all locations to tax free states and ship from there as even the in-state residents would benefit. (for as long as the fed doesn't put out an internet tax, which they eventually will have to.):mad:

The other idea was to move to P.R. how cool would it be to work for a national company based out of P.R.? Shipping would suck of course, but I am guessing they could just have corp head and call centers there.
 
Back
Top