Need opinions on storage for small VMware server

HDClown

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 30, 2004
Messages
223
This is for a business environment, using HP hardware and drives. So the pricing models below reflect that. Using off-the-shelf drives is not an option, nor is building my own storage array, so please do not suggest such at thing. I have budget constraints, but not to do the degree that I need to roll my own stuff. Warranty and support from an OEM on the entire system is requirement.

Server will be running ESX 4 with 4 VM's (DC, Exchange, SQL, IIS). Being used for a company starting up but needs to be able to scale over next 6 months. 10 users, SQL work is test/dev on 1-2gb sized tables (2-3 tables). SQL calculations are BASIC statistical analysis (mean, median, average, etc) The DC/Exchange will be production use, but the SQL/IIS will be purely development and testing.

My big question here is on using 7200rpm SATA drives for the VM images? HP offers SATA and SAS drives in 7200rpm. Using these drives mean less money spent for a lot more storage. I estimate I'll need < 300 gigs of storage to run the current environment. I'd like to have 1TB storage total, or as close to it as possible, as a minimum.

Server will likely be a DL180G6 built out for 8 drives, but it can go up to 14 drives in this chassis on affordable 3.5" LFF drives. This server was designated because of it's support for the lesser expensive 3.5" drives as well as it's good price range in general. This chassis can also be converted to support up to 25 2.5" LFF drives should it be necessary in the future.

For about $1500:
4x500gb 7200 SATA = 1TB RAID5, with hotspare, or 1TB RAID10

For about $1600
4x750gb 7200 SATA = 1.5TB RAID5, with hotspare or 1.5TB RAID10

For about $1700

3x300gb 10k SAS = 600gb RAID5, no hotspare
3x750gb 7200 SAS = 1.5TB RAID5, no hotspare
6x500gb 7200 SATA = 2.0TB RAID6, with hotspare or 1.5TB RAID10

I'm a big fan of hotspares for RAID5, but cost wise, it becomes hard to work in the budget using 10k or 7200rpm SAS drives

The recommendations so far from other server administrators has been that they would not have an issue using 7200rpm SATA drives, but they would only do it with a RAID10 setup. I'm looking for more input before I make the final decision.

Again, please keep in mind this is a "startup" box with low use, so the storage setup is being designed around that. As things expand, so should the budget, and using more customary 10k/15k SAS drives shouldn't be an issue like it will be today.
 
If your going to run 4 VM's on the one box, go with the SAS drives.
You didnt mention Exchange...already have 2003, 2007 or going with 2010?
 
I would do the 6x 500gb on RAID10

Disk contention is what is going to hurt this setup the most, and RAID 5 just adds complexity of parity calculation.
Having more spindles will increase your IO capacity, and 6x 500gb will have more IOs then 3x750gb's will.
With a R10 the VMs can read from all the disk so that will be the most beneficial I would think.
 
i had 2 vms: WHS and XP pro running on a RAID 5 5x750gb drives WD GP and it was really slow.... I wouldnt run vms on a RAID 5 setup, from my experience....

I would have individual disks for each with the datashares on a RAID 6 array and regualar backups of the vms.


then again I am not an expert, just giving advice from my experience
 
I run VM's on RAID5 arrays at both home and in the workplace, but it's all on quality controllers. At home, it's 4x750gb RAID5 on Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 disks and an Adaptec 5405 controller. The controller being key here most likely, as it's a dual core hardware controller and the array is pretty darn fast. In this case, I run some XP VM's and Linux and it's in VMware Workstation 6.5. Never had an I/O issue on the VM.

At work, I've run VM's on 4 disk RAID5 arrays on 10k rpm SCSI discs (Dell PE2850 servers and PERC4 controller), No issues here either, but we're talking SCSI drives at 10k RPM, so not a good comparison.

But, this post has also made me realize I am actively use an RAID5 across 7200rpm SATA discs without I/O issues either. The heaviest I/O VM is Exchange 2007 SP1 for about 50 users, around 30g mail store, but there is also light SQL 2008 use and daily use file storage for redirected profiles and shared stoeage, domain controller, IIS, and a few other things.. The storage subsystem is an Apple Xserve RAID. Array's are 6 disc RAID5 with 1 hotspare. 2 array's in the box, the VM's split across the different sets of arrays.

Now that I'm recalling this, I think I'll go with the 6x500gb setup in RAID10. RAID10 will reduce the I/O overhead of RAID5 while providing me even more redundancy. I've had those XserveRAID's running with 7200rpm SATA disks for almost 6 years straight, 24/7 runtime. Only had 1 drive fail to do, so the reliability of quality picked drives is good. I can only assume HP is getting enterprise grade SATA drives given the ridiculous mark-up they charge, so I would expect similar reliability. As my current setups have proven to not cause I/O issues, this RAID10 setup will certainly work for a small use environment.
 
Last edited:
My apology for not finding more about DL180G6, or in case you change your spec.

Very critical key check for HP Proliant is to confirm with your vendor that the server has Battery Backed Cache for the Smart Array Controller.

Usually HP Proliant Server will disable hard disk write cache by default. Even if you reset the disk write cache setting inside Windows, the driver will deactivate it immediately (assuming you are using fully supported official HP software support set, my experience is in Windows)

The disk write cache can be activated if proliant detects a supported Smart Array controller with Battery Backed Cache. The disk write cache does improve performance greatly.

Also, on some newer expensive Smart Array controllers, you need to pay additional software license to activate all controller features. If you have a need for the advanced features than you need to confirm with your vendor. I personally do not agree with such arrangement because I remember all the old and great SCSI-based Smart Array delivered with everything by default. Anyhow that's the new reality.
 
I will be using a P410 with 512 meg RAM and BBWC add-on (battery backed write cache). This is an upgrade from the included on-board controller The P410 is part of HP's newest controller line and it's fully featured as-is for the most part. The default card is 256meg no BBWC. So 512meg and BBWC are upgrade. The only software upgrade is an enable feature (SAAP) to enable RAID 6/60.
 
In that case it should be fine.

Just a slight update to be more accurate. The actual operational write cache is technically handled by the Proliant Smart Array Controller+onboard controller RAM therefore the need for battery-backed in case of power failure.

HP has very good SmartStart and Firmware Support CD/DVD. You should have the latest of everything when purchasing but can use the tools to verify and if needed upgrade all the controller + disk firmware to latest. (preferably done by your server vendor support upon delivery because I have seen cases of controller firmware needing update to address VMware support issue)
 
Anytime I deploy a new server, I always check for newest drivers/firmware. Since HP stuff is sold primarily through VARs, this stuff can be sitting on shelves for a while (although not extremely common). I don't even think these controllers let you enable write cache w/o the battery module present, as a safety feature.
 
Back
Top