need help!..AMD dual core or Intel dual core

arman01

Gawd
Joined
Feb 9, 2005
Messages
759
Hey guys, out of these two, which would be bettter overall

1) AMD Athlon X2 3800+ + Asus A8N-SLI Premium
2) Intel Pentium D 920 (presler) + nForce 4 SLI motherboard or 955x motherboard

??
 
Depends on how you plan on cooling that Intel. If you have water or better and plan on OCing it to the max you might get 4Ghz out of it which would be pretty nice.

If you're on air or are more limited in your OCing, you can't go wrong with the X2 3800+, it's a great chip.
 
If you're using air cooling, grab the 3800+ and use the factory heatpipe cooler or something like an XP120! Good luck :D
 
freeloader1969 said:
If you're using air cooling, grab the 3800+ and use the factory heatpipe cooler or something like an XP120! Good luck :D

3800+ doesn't come with the heatpipe cooler.
 
If you go Intel id stay away from an Nforce board. As far as air cooling an Intel, you'll be ok with air and a 920.
 
Well since you posted this in the AMD Processors section, I'm going with the 3800+/Opty 165. Definitely go with the 165 if you can find one. :D
 
Imo i think that u should go with the A64 x2. But if it's in your budget and u have the avalibility to get an Operton dual core i'd say go for it. Cuz those optys are killer overclockers. Plus i don't think that intel really has the support as the AMD chips nor are they as fast, in all the benchmarks i've seen the AMDs are faster.
 
PaHick said:
If you go Intel id stay away from an Nforce board. As far as air cooling an Intel, you'll be ok with air and a 920.

You could cool it on air, but would you get high enough of an OC to rival an AMD X2? That was my point earlier :).
 
Intel / AMD usually emotes an almost religious argument.....

The AMD's will pretty much eat the Intel's lunch in benchies, but there are those of us that still have "Intel inside" for a number of reasons.

Got to agree with PaHick - one of Intel's strengths is using them with an Intel chipset. I've heard a number of "interesting" things about the nVidia chipsets for the Intel CPU's. IMHO - if you go with the Intel part, stick with an Intel chipset.

Bottom line is either one is fast, stable and would give you a great machine. I'm hanging with my "old" Intel rig (sigged) and waiting for Gen2 dual cores.... :cool:

Good Luck - B.B.S.
 
smakkythecamel said:
Nintek.com.au have the 165's in stock, I ordered one myself today :)


me too
(actually i had an X2 3800+, but after you gave me the heads up i changed it to a 165 ) :)
 
BlindedByScience said:
Bottom line is either one is fast, stable and would give you a great machine. I'm hanging with my "old" Intel rig (sigged) and waiting for Gen2 dual cores.... :cool:

Good Luck - B.B.S.

You need to wait for the gen 3/4 cores from Intel. Gen2 is a stop gap on the way to the competitive product line.

AMD will rule the roost for at least another year. In 2007 when AMD goes quad, that will be another hurdle that Intel will have to jump.
 
so what's the big difference between the x2 3800 and the Opteron 165?
The Opteron 165 is stock clocked lower, but has twice the cache. In addition, it's stock voltage is lower. This means that if you up the voltage .05, you're practically guaranteed to meet the clock speed of a 3800 (and likely beat it even overclocked) and still drive double the cache.
 
Like axman said the Operton chips are WAY better overclockers than the x2's. Some people have been able to squeeze 3.0 GHz from the optys; the average is 2.6-2.7 tho personally I got mine to 2.8 before deciding to slow it down a bit because of high voltages to get it stable. Anyways the best bang for the buck for overclocking right now is the opty 165 by far. Best OCs and still around $300 bucks.

As for physical differences in the chips, the opertons are server chips and therefore under go more strenuous testing than the regular x2 chips, also they are made from the same silicon as the FX chips, and is why they are netting better overclocks than the A64 chips, also to like has been said they run on lower voltages too so you don't have to put as much juice to these chips to get it to OC well either, either way I’d go with AMD over Intel because the AMD chips are faster, but that’s why the opty is better than the x2....in short ><
 
Back
Top